Nor'east Ski WWeekend (Basics) - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Those on my sketch list today were barks, cubs, and capri. Didn't want to vote barks and cubs was coming off as noob as the day progressed. Capri contributed her "dartboard" vote and then some math and comments that were not analytical in anyway, just commentary on things like avatars and people's profile pictures. So she was around for at least a couple of times, but did not post anything of substance.
Just for the record, this was in the sign up thread.
Should I venture into NKA? Should I try to figure out whether capri is a wolf or whether the wolves are trying to throw suspicion on her? :thinking:
Wouldn't surprise me. I'm a pretty easy sketch target. Or could be they wanted to kill her for another reason.
 
Wouldn't surprise me. I'm a pretty easy sketch target. Or could be they wanted to kill her for another reason.

Why do you think you're an easy sketch target?

Also whenever I try to do NKA I get stuck in a WIFOM loop but I was kind of expecting a Barks attempt because of the pr reveal.
 
Why do you think you're an easy sketch target?

Also whenever I try to do NKA I get stuck in a WIFOM loop but I was kind of expecting a Barks attempt because of the pr reveal.
Eh, woofs don't know if there is a protector so I'm not too worried about the lack of barks attempt just yet

But yeah NKA can be frustrating
 
D2 Everyone's Frozen but Still Have to Work Tally


0/21

Deadline 10pm est (~13 hours)

2e67b016751149802cfc912a4b9c5a13.gif
 
Wolf leans
Capri - play feels off - bad math felt unnecessary and this ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ likely NAI but I dont like it
Coffee - feels like she’s manufacturing sketch based on previous play, but claiming to be analyzing this game.
Barks - don’t necessarily believe him but, willing wait here

General feels
AM/Dolphin feels w/w or v/v feels doesn’t seem w/v - Dolphin lightly defending AM’s posts read weird
Ziggy/Genny feels v/v
Ziggy - responses seem genuine (also Ziggy please don’t take this game too personal - I’m averaging 2.2 days alive
yetEYfypRFRw1GdywxvTPXJyK51IoE43mVtYncGCGxc__qRWXfWimCTAFVph778yv3S5HI6zAyFLE6Zf_NHXVxlcG3Aumgu4kZTt1wZDcJ49OF0pXD78uk10Wtm5pl5ybKEnw3md
)
Genny - giving advice, wanted to protect the claim - could also be WIFOM,

Not sure - everyone else
 
I'm pretty sure that is just actual info about the mountain. Should be easy to look up, which I will try to do at some point if I have time. I just caught up on 5 pages of thread.

Lynch zigs

Some of her posts were a bit sketch yesterday, though I was feeling better about her by the end of the day. I just want to get a lynch vote in early in case my day goes to $hit again.

I'm feeling pretty good about AM at the moment. I'm also want to look into people that stayed on barks yesterday, all things considered.
 
Wolf leans
Capri - play feels off - bad math felt unnecessary and this ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ likely NAI but I dont like it
Coffee - feels like she’s manufacturing sketch based on previous play, but claiming to be analyzing this game.
Barks - don’t necessarily believe him but, willing wait here

General feels
AM/Dolphin feels w/w or v/v feels doesn’t seem w/v - Dolphin lightly defending AM’s posts read weird
Ziggy/Genny feels v/v
Ziggy - responses seem genuine (also Ziggy please don’t take this game too personal - I’m averaging 2.2 days alive
yetEYfypRFRw1GdywxvTPXJyK51IoE43mVtYncGCGxc__qRWXfWimCTAFVph778yv3S5HI6zAyFLE6Zf_NHXVxlcG3Aumgu4kZTt1wZDcJ49OF0pXD78uk10Wtm5pl5ybKEnw3md
)
Genny - giving advice, wanted to protect the claim - could also be WIFOM,

Not sure - everyone else
Dont you think it's fair to analyze those staying on a claimed PR as a viable counter? Doesn't mean it's right but doesn't mean it's wrong. Snowy was also up and I haven't played with her enough to comment on playstyle so I was looking at who made sense to me at the time which was you.

Fwiw, I have caught wolves before that react this way... Not casting shade on someone until they mention your name.. It's like a wolf getting all jumpy/sweaty
 
I have reasons but I also have an anatomy test in an hour so not really willing to expend loads on energy on this atm.

Her willingness to jump off the barks vote and criticize those who didn't, willingness to follow the leader with her own vote, including only voting for me when genny mentioned I was sketchy. Could be a mini freak out, could be wolfy, who knows.
 
I have reasons but I also have an anatomy test in an hour so not really willing to expend loads on energy on this atm.

Her willingness to jump off the barks vote and criticize those who didn't, willingness to follow the leader with her own vote, including only voting for me when genny mentioned I was sketchy. Could be a mini freak out, could be wolfy, who knows.

What do you mean by follow the leader?
 
What do you mean by follow the leader?
She pulled her vote off barks to coffee, claiming she saw cubs as village yet she actually put him in the lead by doing so. Voting for coffee for sporty's reasons (which I don't remember being that strong). Then following you to snowy. Then voting for me when genny suggested it. Didn't seem to have her own ideas, just went with what other people were doing. She also questioned me about my barks vote and when I said why I was still voting there, she said she agreed.
 
She pulled her vote off barks to coffee, claiming she saw cubs as village yet she actually put him in the lead by doing so. Voting for coffee for sporty's reasons (which I don't remember being that strong). Then following you to snowy. Then voting for me when genny suggested it. Didn't seem to have her own ideas, just went with what other people were doing. She also questioned me about my barks vote and when I said why I was still voting there, she said she agreed.

What are your thoughts on Snowy, Coffee?, and genny right now?
 
Why do you think you're an easy sketch target?
Because I am. I get mislynched a lot. Frankly if at least a quarter of living players aren't sketched out by me by ~D3 it's a miracle.
Capri - play feels off - bad math felt unnecessary and this ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ likely NAI but I dont like it
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
What are your thoughts on Snowy, Coffee?, and genny right now?
I would have to go back and look honestly and I just don't have time to do that. I don't really find it sketchy snowy stayed on the vote because as a wolf, it would really just draw unwanted attention. Genny seems village, I think. Unsure about coffee, would have to go back
 
I will say I don't have time to do that atm
 
Then why did you move off yesterday?
I'm willing to give him a chance, to see if he uses it for good or if hes a wolf pr
Dont you think it's fair to analyze those staying on a claimed PR as a viable counter? Doesn't mean it's right but doesn't mean it's wrong. Snowy was also up and I haven't played with her enough to comment on playstyle so I was looking at who made sense to me at the time which was you.

Fwiw, I have caught wolves before that react this way... Not casting shade on someone until they mention your name.. It's like a wolf getting all jumpy/sweaty
It is fair but imo you choosing me and saying its a pressure vote an hour before lynch close bc I have played and should know to post more was a reach.

As proven here, im an easy lynch target, AM and dolphin looked into me as soon as you placed your vote on me - fortunately they didnt agree.

I do get defensive when my name is up bc 1 vote turns to 3 then theres a whole bandwagon (counterwagon?) and I have not figured out a way to save myself from a lynch
 
Dubz? Skim? MJ? genny?
Dubz has been playing a while but mostly since I was away. She used to always be seen as a villager, and now claims to be some wolf expert? I have no clu,e

No idea who skim is.

MJ was chaos no matter what his role. He seems to have mellowed out in his old age.

Genny seems to have matured a lot as a player. Don’t get a wolfy sense.

All 3 of those are 2nd generation prevet players. I am the only gen 1 here.

And I don’t know where all these acronyms came from. Can’t follow. pR? Wifom? Nka? A few others as well. This really makes me feel old.
 
I do get defensive when my name is up bc 1 vote turns to 3 then theres a whole bandwagon (counterwagon?) and I have not figured out a way to save myself from a lynch

The best way to prevent any bandwagon is just being active and communicating with others often. Don't be afraid to come out of the background. It helps us get a feel for you better.
 
Because I am. I get mislynched a lot. Frankly if at least a quarter of living players aren't sketched out by me by ~D3 it's a miracle.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Attach48531_20190130_103526.gif


Any quality content to add? Reads/feels today?
 
Dubz has been playing a while but mostly since I was away. She used to always be seen as a villager, and now claims to be some wolf expert? I have no clu,e

No idea who skim is.

MJ was chaos no matter what his role. He seems to have mellowed out in his old age.

Genny seems to have matured a lot as a player. Don’t get a wolfy sense.

All 3 of those are 2nd generation prevet players. I am the only gen 1 here.

And I don’t know where all these acronyms came from. Can’t follow. pR? Wifom? Nka? A few others as well. This really makes me feel old.

Skim is Jil. I'm not sure how the generation thing works but I just meant people you're somewhat familiar with.

I started using acronyms then everyone else did. They're newish for here, I suppose.

PR: Power role
WIFOM: Wine in Front of Me
NKA: Night Kill Analysis
 
Eh, woofs don't know if there is a protector so I'm not too worried about the lack of barks attempt just yet

But yeah NKA can be frustrating

Yeah similar thing happened when I claimed pr last game so I'm just going to file it back to look at later.

I'm feeling neutral about Capri and not convinced yet, same with zigs. I need to go back and reread posts from last night when I get a break from work.

My current theory is wolf on either/both barks lynch (especially after pr claim) or someone who jumped on the Cubs bandwagon.
 
I have reasons but I also have an anatomy test in an hour so not really willing to expend loads on energy on this atm.

Her willingness to jump off the barks vote and criticize those who didn't, willingness to follow the leader with her own vote, including only voting for me when genny mentioned I was sketchy. Could be a mini freak out, could be wolfy, who knows.
She pulled her vote off barks to coffee, claiming she saw cubs as village yet she actually put him in the lead by doing so. Voting for coffee for sporty's reasons (which I don't remember being that strong). Then following you to snowy. Then voting for me when genny suggested it. Didn't seem to have her own ideas, just went with what other people were doing. She also questioned me about my barks vote and when I said why I was still voting there, she said she agreed.
So I should have voted for people who had zero votes? How would that have helped barks or cubs?

Edit: I did agree with you about barks (half of your reasoning - I think I said later, I felt she was manufacturing sketch about MSU), but that was before the pr claim. And I voted for you before I saw genny's comment.
 
Dubz has been playing a while but mostly since I was away. She used to always be seen as a villager, and now claims to be some wolf expert? I have no clu,e

No idea who skim is.

MJ was chaos no matter what his role. He seems to have mellowed out in his old age.

Genny seems to have matured a lot as a player. Don’t get a wolfy sense.

All 3 of those are 2nd generation prevet players. I am the only gen 1 here.

And I don’t know where all these acronyms came from. Can’t follow. pR? Wifom? Nka? A few others as well. This really makes me feel old.
All these young whippersnappers showed up and they were scared of my wolfing ways, so now my #alwaysvillage persona is dead. Still, I'm pretty sure we played together for almost three years 🙁
 
Lynch Capri

I’ll keep my vote here because despite people trying to get some reads from her, she s not really offered any more information.
And that stupid shrug emoji.
I’m starting to feel like you, AM, about that emoji.

Wolfy vibes also from zig, coffee, and snowy (no particular order). Nothing too strong on any of them and TBH I haven’t been able to closely look at specific interactions between them either, but based on the tone of their posts.
-zig: usually gets defensive, but this seems overly defensive for her, and super quickly.
-coffee: felt like a lot of overexplaining to me. I don’t really remember her doing this much explanation in other games when she’s village and I feel like she was pretty explanatory in HalloWWeen as a wolf. I could be wrong. Again, I haven’t done an ISO or looked at past games and this is based on my own (often faulty) brains recollections.
-snowy: didn’t follow her logic of less hedgy as village=less hedgy as wolf=harder to read? I feel like last game you were lynched for being hedgy as a wolf and it gave you away. Why should being less hedgy now and acknowledging that it could be your tell make us think you are village?

I know that my analyses lack quotes and ISO info. I wanted to get reads on here because I know I was pretty silent yesterday, but I landed at 10pm pacific time last night, spent the night st the airport because I and have a drs appointment in an hour in DTLA (and I live an hour from both the airport and downtown, so decided to just stay in LA proper overnight... might be oversharing but wanted to let you guys know why this is really a super quick catch up) so I’m really just trying to catch up and contribute a little before then. I don’t have my laptop on me right now so I’m on my phone, but when I get back to my apt And can catch up and multi quote for real I promise to contribute more in depth stuff
 
And I don’t know where all these acronyms came from. Can’t follow. pR? Wifom? Nka? A few others as well. This really makes me feel old.
******************
From the Dog Show spectator PM:
WIFOM is you getting into the head of a player and trying to determine why they did what they did whether it be a night action, night kill choice, or lynch vote

at least that's how I think of it
Let's talk about WIFOM - MafiaWiki
WIFOM - MafiaWiki
Everything Is WIFOM - MafiaWiki
The tldr version:
WIFOM - Mafia Universe Wiki
Wine In Front Of Me (WIFOM)
The urban dictionary version
Urban Dictionary: WIFOM
Wine In Front Of Me - SA Mafia Wiki
Nickname Guide

Modators

WildZoo - dubz, wubz, subs, WZ
Trilt - trout
vetmedhead - vmh, meathead, meats

Manatees
...for most of you its your first, maybe second game. Pfft. You'll get nicknames WHEN YOU EARN THEM.

Matthew9Thirtyfive - M935 (this is an executive decision, because nobody wants to type all that)
SkiOtter - Ski, SkiSki, Otter

Grasshoppers
sheltermed - shelter, s&m, sm
muttmanager - mutts
killerleaf - killer
Dandelion8 - dandelion

Padawans
Stagg737 - Stagg, Staggikarp
dolphin106258 - dolphin, dolph
CoffeeQuestionMark - Coffee?, Cofeve (or something like that), koffee

Manators

Melchizedek - Mel, CheezyD, Cheezy, Cheez, Cheez-It
Karabiner13 - Kara, Karabou, KB, Karab, Bou, karabeans
Animal Midwife - AM
SportPonies - Sporty, Sport Sport, SportySpice, SP (if you're LAME)
PippyPony - Pippy, Pip, Pipperoo, Pipperoni, Pipsqueak, Pip Pip Hooray
finnickthedog - finn, finny
genny - Gen, En, EN, N, pengen
allieh8607 - allieh, allie
Coopah - Coop
kcoughli - kc, kcough
SARdoghandler - SAR, SARdines
MixedAnimals77 - mixy, Sir Mixalot
Skimble - Skim, Skil, Skilary
Crayola227 - Cray, CrayCray, Crayons
capri1722 - capri

WW Terminology
*may be updated with suggestions - manators please offer suggestions in our chat if you have them, so we don't clog up the thread.*

Waffle
- A delicious breakfast food. Also, the act of switching your vote. If lots of votes are switching around the same time, especially towards the end of the day, we call that a wafflefest

LyLo
- Lynch (correctly) or Lose. This is the point of no return for the village. If anything other than a wolf is lynched during LyLo, village loses the game.

WIFOM - Wine in Front of Me, taken from the poison scene in The Princess Bride. The circular reasoning that results from trying to determine the choices of someone who knows their actions would be analyzed. Probably overused.

Village(r) Code - A terrible way to determine someone's affiliation based on the style/format of their role PM, due to the assumption that wolf PMs will be different from villager PMs. Don't do it.

Sketchy - If you look up sketchy in the dictionary you will see pictures of many of our illustrious manators, along with this modator (depending on who you ask). Synonymous include wolfy, shady, suspect, suspicious, and highly lynchable.

Bandwagon - A buildup of votes on one player, usually one that quickly reaches the majority of votes

Parity - When wolf numbers equal village numbers. This is how wolves win the game.

Vanilla - a player with no special abilities. Can refer to a villager - sometimes called a vanillager - or a wolf, who in that case would have no abilities other than killing. Can also refer to a type of game where no special abilities exist.

Soft clear - When a player determines that, in their opinion, another player is not a wolf based on interactions, analysis, or whatever else and NOT through trustworthy mod-given information

Pocket - something mysteriously missing from a lot of women's clothing. Also the act of getting another player to trust you, typically by some form of sneaky emotional manipulation

Bus/Bussing - when a wolf backstabs another to gain the trust of the village

Tunneling - player A continues to go after player B day after day, perhaps in spite of evidence that player B is village

Scum - a catchall for the informed minority, usually the murderous ones. Someone the village needs to lynch.

Mod Flair - refers to artistic/creative license taken by the mods in writeups and individual players results. It is common for players to attempt to determine whether a particular portion of these writings is relevant to the game or simply mods having fun.

NAI - Not Affiliation Indicative. Usually refers to some aspect of a player's play that does not point to whether they are wolf or village. It simply...is.

Meta - Wolf meta. Village meta. Meta meta meta. This simply refers to various aspects of a player's playstyle, through time, in multiple games, and in different roles. You may not see it used as much in this game since many of you are new and do not yet have an established meta.

Idiot Savant - Also known as "Who are you, STL?" The act of correctly lynching a wolf, but for all the wrong reasons. Logic need not apply.

Rojo - One of the great old ones, his name has now the common term used to describe the act of accidentally posting something on the thread that was meant for PM, usually when a wolf posts something that was meant for wolf chat.
******************
 
Stupid question...

What is hedgy?
 
My reasons on you were more along the route of saying -blank blank and me are all soft cleared for being a woof last time. The whole not so subtle - trust me right off the bat. I'm village bc I say I'm village, ya know? Just to clarify. And I can also dig up the quote that says this if it helps.

As for everything else that has happened recently... imma have to hop on my laptop to address that so I can multi-quote

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

How do you feel about this now that Cubs flipped village? What made you think wolf instead of noob?

Actually, I changed my mind. I don't really have anything that I could multi quote that hasn't already been discussed. (And I'm feeling lazy)

I will just state some early feelings. Honestly, I am not getting wolfy feels from ziggy though. Maybe its because I haven't seen zig wolf (I don't think I have), but I do seem to start some games semi-trusting her so I may need to think on that.

Barks can be sketchy sometimes. I don't like that she contradicted herself about the whole- don't do an easy lynch, have reasons... nobody has reasons on me so I'm a lazy lynch vote. @Barkley you were interested in MSU earlier. I see that you've changed that for self-prez. So, who would you like to lynch if you could vote willy nilly?

A lot of people I'd like to hear more from. But its day one, so I'm sure more people will start showing up soon... at least I hope! Anyways, I'm gonna be away for a bit since I'm going out to dinner. I'm hungry.... but I for one am not eating waffles tonight :laugh:

I don't like this. It sounds like you hopped on the Cubs lynch, didn't want to explain because you were lazy and then you make a subtle comment about not changing your vote.

Lynch moosey

For now. I want to hear from her again though.



 
Top