I was rejected too. Yikes maybe they saw that my worse grade was in a religion class, and them being a Jesuit school, ran for the hills! I'm not intolerant, I just made a mistake plugging the online test into my calendar and missed it by a day, so received half credit! It was sophomore year and I learned from that, otherwise I would have gotten an A in the class.
I doubt that's it, but I guess I will be calling. When you called to set up the appointment did you just say "I was rejected and I was wondering if you give out individual feedback"? Or is there a more formal process?