Kaplan Qbank - First impressions, after completing all the cardio questions (10% of total Qs):
I was prejudiced against Kaplan, due to all the negative buzz going around regarding the quality of the questions and the focus on minutiae. The only reason I decided to use it was to increase my total Q count, because of the positive correlation with the actual score.
I was pleasantly surprised to find out that this is not the case:
- The structure of the questions resembles a lot the NBMEs
- I found 0 new concepts being tested (but keep in mind I did some subjects from Kaplan early in my prep) - instead it was concepts I already encountered but in a twisted way, which is exactly what the USMLE is about.
- Descriptions of diseases are characteristic but way more subtle, compared to Rx which looks like a buzzwordfest next to Kaplan.
- Physio-heavy with very creative questions regarding that subject. No arrow, diagram or cardiac loop question is gonna scare you after solving these (including a CO/VR-RAP diagram with 10 options). Rx physio is almost non-existant compared to this and even made me wonder what was all that fuss about it, if we don't see it in questions.
- A lot of multimedia questions involving stethoscopes - which again Rx lacks. Instead of describing the murmur or the S3 you 're gonna have to hear it youself and often enough you can't get to the answer based on the Q text only, unless you listen to the actual murmur. Again, great practice for the real thing.
- Explanations are great, describing why each answer is wrong instead of just saying what each choice is and there is a solid consistency to that across all questions, compared to Rx, which shows a great variability between good and inadequate explanations.
On the downside:
- The Rx dashboard and interface are superior and much more user friendly.
- Pharm seems quite underrepresented, mostly in favor of physio.
The difficulty of the Qs is greater, but that is not reflected on the percentages people get. Questions that would get a 60% in Rx, get an 80% in Kaplan. I assume this is because most people use it later in their prep.
I wouldn't recommend it for a beginner since it will be a quite demotivating experience. Rx's drawback of using too many buzzword questions, isn't necessarily a bad thing for someone who just finished doing their first FA pass and helps solidifying associations for basic concepts. Kaplan goes one step further but that means that you need a stronger background to get into Kaplan's mindset.
I'd recommend it for anyone who can afford the time of solving other Qbanks besides UW. A lot of people recommend doing a second pass of UW but I am against that. When doing Rx, I could remember questions I did two months ago when I skimmed through my incorrects once. And the data seems to suggest, the more different questions you do, the better. Also, great for anyone feeling weak in physio.