StardeWW 2: Ginger Island - GAME THREAD

[lucy.]

I don’t feel good enough about Santy to be comfortable voting with him, don’t want to end on a 3-way tie, and don’t like that vote movement timing by mighty.

Unvote Santy
Vote mighty

santy spewed town again

vis is getting bus cred

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[lucy.]

Yes

can you elaborate

 

[Animal Midwife]

can you elaborate

No

 

[WildZoo]

But explain pls

Me: looking for more perspective/thoughts from one of the blocc to help sort my neutral reads

Also me:

 

[lucy.]

LMAO stoat flipped 3p

 

[lucy.]

No

is it sufficient to clear them?

 

[Animal Midwife]

is it sufficient to clear them?

Yes

 

[lucy.]

Yes

are you sure?

me scumreading the same slot on two players without knowing that they were actually one slot is a very bad look for them

 

[Animal Midwife]

are you sure?

me scumreading the same slot on two players without knowing that they were actually one slot is a very bad look for them

You also thought mighty was village and don't know who the mayor is.

 

[lucy.]

You also thought mighty was village and don't know who the mayor is.

i based it off one page and i correct scumread stoat and vis this game

 

[lucy.]

one message*

 

[Animal Midwife]

i based it off one page and i correct scumread stoat and vis this game

1. stoat wasn't scum.
2. You were the literal last person to scumread Vis. So I strongly suspect it's restrospective analysis for that one.

Also, you seem to be village reading several people who are in the POE right now.

 

[lucy.]

1. stoat wasn't scum.
2. You were the literal last person to scumread Vis. So I strongly suspect it's restrospective analysis for that one.

Also, you seem to be village reading several people who are in the POE right now.

1) wasn't town
2) i literally didn't read any of those reads, i know you can't trust this as it's mafia but for post game remember that i'm honest here

 

[lucy.]

meh

 

[lucy.]

Unvote Lawpy

Vote Alley

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unvote Lawpy

Vote Alley

Did you finish catching up?

 

[NateTheLesser]

My usual spreadsheet bizniss. Bookmark this post, I'll update it as long as I'm alive.

Day 1 Votes​

Waterfall​

EOD Wagons​

Potentially juicy VCA, since two wolves were in danger for most of the day. More thoughts tomorrow, but I think Zenge/Dubz/AM/samac are cleared off of it, which is helpful. Also looks good for Stagg, both from their votes and the fact that both mighty and Vis either voted there or supported the idea near EOD.

On the flipside, it looks worst for alley/Santy/Lawpy. So that's who I'll be looking at more closely. Santy's votes were bad but he had some interactions with Vis that didn't seem partnery to me, so I need to weigh that.

 

[lucy.]

 

[lucy.]

Did you finish catching up?

yeah

 

[lucy.]

i think reading page 4-42 is inefficient with 2 mafia dead

 

[NateTheLesser]

Yes

Is the "mech" just their vote for mighty + bussing meta?

 

[Animal Midwife]

yeah

What is your POE?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Is the "mech" just their vote for mighty + bussing meta?

No

 

[lucy.]

Lawpy/alley

santy can be clear but these two have 1 wolf in them

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lawpy/alley

santy can be clear but these two have 1 wolf in them

This is way too narrow. There are at least two wolves alive. I need to see a bigger POE from you.

 

[samac]

lawpy/coopah/stoat is my current poe

This feels intentionally disconnected.

 

[samac]

stoat town i assume

Why would you assume this when you just had her in Poe

 

[lucy.]

Why would you assume this when you just had her in Poe

bc i know 2 mafia flipped, being vis/mighty and they told me that stoat was dead, logical assumption was town

 

[samac]

Potentially juicy VCA, since two wolves were in danger for most of the day. More thoughts tomorrow, but I think Zenge/Dubz/AM/samac are cleared off of it, which is helpful. Also looks good for Stagg, both from their votes and the fact that both mighty and Vis either voted there or supported the idea near EOD.

On the flipside, it looks worst for alley/Santy/Lawpy. So that's who I'll be looking at more closely. Santy's votes were bad but he had some interactions with Vis that didn't seem partnery to me, so I need to weigh that.

When dubz moved to Visc is when it got real juicy

 

[lucy.]

This feels intentionally disconnected.

i haven't read 40 pages of the game broski

 

[samac]

Why the sith gif

 

[lucy.]

This is way too narrow. There are at least two wolves alive. I need to see a bigger POE from you.

let me look at pl

 

[lucy.]

Why the sith gif

gifs are fun to send

 

[samac]

i haven't read 40 pages of the game broski

If you know we flipped 2 wolves you should know stoat is 3P since that flip was with a wolf flip.

 

[Animal Midwife]

let me look at pl

What more is there to see? You're caught up.

 

[samac]

i think reading page 4-42 is inefficient with 2 mafia dead

Why

 

[lucy.]

If you know we flipped 2 wolves you should know stoat is 3P since that flip was with a wolf flip.

when i first looked at flip i didn't see the second spoiler, i only saw that flip on a reread

 

[lucy.]

What more is there to see? You're caught up.

i'm not juggling all players mentally in this game yet, zenge/wildzoo/nate can be outer poe

 

[lucy.]

Why

all i need to do is sheep people more focused on this game and town will win, no use to high effort when it looks like a town win

 

[Animal Midwife]

i'm not juggling all players mentally in this game yet, zenge/wildzoo/nate can be outer poe

So you're POEing consensus villagers and clearing consensus POE?

 

[lucy.]

On the flipside, it looks worst for alley/Santy/Lawp

see this is what happens when people play more and flip wolves, there's a shortlist consensus on individuals and people are cleared, such as who nate cleared

So you're POEing consensus villagers and clearing consensus POE?

i believe what you're talking about is critical and original thought, it is up to you to decide if my perspective is towny and real or fake and wolfy

 

[lucy.]

critical thinking* ****

 

[Animal Midwife]

see this is what happens when people play more and flip wolves, there's a shortlist consensus on individuals and people are cleared, such as who nate cleared

The people Nate cleared are in your POE. So I don't understand this comparison.

i believe what you're talking about is critical and original thought, it is up to you to decide if my perspective is towny and real or fake and wolfy

You're already in my POE. I was just hoping you'd self-clear rather than try to misyeet the clears.

 

[lucy.]

The people Nate cleared are in your POE. So I don't understand this comparison.

You're already in my POE. I was just hoping you'd self-clear rather than try to misyeet the clears.

it's simple, i am missing context and i don't have a good perspective of the game

others do and they will change my reads for good

 

[lucy.]

i'm vt so i can't realllly avoid getting mischopped here

 

[lucy.]

rn i'm voting for alley and i think santy is town

 

[Animal Midwife]

it's simple, i am missing context and i don't have a good perspective of the game

others do and they will change my reads for good

You're not missing context though. You've been here since D0 and all the context was and is still there. We set up the consensus POE fiscal today (which you have read) so I don't understand why your reads are counter to it.

 

[lucy.]

god actually

 

[Animal Midwife]

i'm vt so i can't realllly avoid getting mischopped here

Ability means nothing. Your posts do.

 

[lucy.]

I was just hoping you'd self-clear rather than try to misyeet the clears.

this is am extremely bad take