- Joined
- Dec 7, 2014
- Messages
- 2,480
- Reaction score
- 3,112
I'm going to optimistically assume it's a 3p and not a cult :')
What if Greedy was Ethan lolWe still don't know what Ethan found out from N2 either.
No ma'am. It can be anyone at this point.you put my pretty name back up in the town list tsk tsk.
I think if there were 9 townies at the beginning there would be more than 2 mafia.so is this the lineup we think town had:
9 total town (originally not including any converted into a cult)
• 1 Town Doctor
• 1 Town BG
• 1 Town Tom Cruise
• 1 Town Tracker
• 4 Vanilla Town
• 1 Town Miller
does this seem plausible?
soo..8 town?? 4 scum?.I think if there were 9 townies at the beginning there would be more than 2 mafia.
I mean literally anyone. I originally put SAR in town because of her yeeting fruit and immediately hopping on 3p hunting... but that doesn't mean she's not 3p and leading us astray.No ma'am. It can be anyone at this point.
damn. and i was really starting to get along with you too. sighNo ma'am. It can be anyone at this point.
Oh nvm I mathed wrong. 9 townies would mean 3 mafia which is balanced to me.soo..8 town?? 4 scum?.
I'm going to optimistically assume it's a 3p and not a cult :')
If you’re assuming it’s a 3p, idk how you could categorize anyone into towny vs. not at this point since in theory everyone left had the same motivation to eliminate the wolves.Towny:
PSV, SAR, me
Help?!?!
genny, vampy, zenge, mkg
Yeah I hope it's not literally three 3p's left.
No3 third parties
3 mafia
6 town
Okay I'll trust it
Bestie why you gotta go there 🙁so…i’m just gonna come out and say it..i think chic fake claimed.
Like 50:50 village:non-village is very lopsided.Okay I'll trust it
because i have been collecting information all day.Bestie why you gotta go there 🙁
I mean there could if there are three factions.because i have been collecting information all day.
and majority of people agreed that there cannot be both a tracker and a watcher.
and yet….
its still unbalanced.I mean there could if there are three factions.
If this ends up being true I'll eat my socks.Btw to everyone saying mkg is soft cleared village, I don’t think she is. She is soft cleared *not-scum*. I agree with the possibility of a 3p and she could be a 3p PR instead of village. Now to be fair, I have never seen a 3p bodyguard (it would likely have to be a 3p group who knows each other….. like a cult?!) but idk anything can happen on SDN.
No 😔zenge. have you received extra messages at all?
Okay but what if....?Ok hear me out… Genny? /s
IVE SUSSES GENNYYYY AND YOU GUYS MADE ME OUT TO BE CRAZYYY BC OF THE CLEM D1 VOTEEEEOkay but what if....?
What's unfortunate?that’s so unfortunate
THIS WAS BEFORE THE 3P SHENANIGANS WERE REAL 😭IVE SUSSES GENNYYYY AND YOU GUYS MADE ME OUT TO BE CRAZYYY BC OF THE CLEM D1 VOTEEEE
zenge doesnt know if anyone cuddled himWhat's unfortunate?
oh snapSpeaking of which, who was telling me to hush about the possibility of 3p on D1? 🤔
Oh. I thought you were implying you cuddled him.zenge doesnt know if anyone cuddled him
Did a search and the answer is no one. I remembered wrongly.Speaking of which, who was telling me to hush about the possibility of 3p on D1? 🤔
I thought she was implying Ethan might reach out with a PM and share the Ethan only intel to relay to the thread without revealing EthanOh. I thought you were implying you cuddled him.
Innocent Child would like to have a word with youAnd as mentioned before, any role can be any affiliation...
Oh. Well, I guess it's good I asked. Because of the implication.I thought she was implying Ethan might reach out with a PM and share the Ethan only intel to relay to the thread without revealing Ethan
Almost any role can have any affiliation...Innocent Child would like to have a word with you
I mean you must have remembered something.Did a search and the answer is no one. I remembered wrongly.
i am sat.WAIT A MINUTE.
WaitsWAIT A MINUTE.
Is SAR “believing” there is a 3p due to flavor more likely to come from scum trying to figure out the game makeup while also pushing town to a higher paranoia level or from town being really proactive?
Edited: typo
if it was a scum thought, i feel like she'd keep that in wolf chat. if a large portion of the group doesn't know sdn's affinity for chaos/3p roles, i don't think a wolf would draw attention to it like that. better to 3p hunt under the guise of scum hunting.
This strikes me as a game where wolves would have cover roles (confirmed) and a bodyguard may not be inherently village if there is a 3p or cult out there
(Or if a game is designed by me)
But I don't disagree that a roleblocker likely indicates village does have some powerful balances, and a body guard would fit that
Actually I guess if we’re entertaining possible 3p worlds I’m not sure we’d have a 3 player scum team. Greedy can sanity check my math/mech though. We have 12 players. I think if we had 3p or multi ball it would be 9 v 2 v 1 or at most 8 v 2 v 2. So I’m doubting any scum team is actually more than 2 if we truly believe 3p or similar could be possible. If no 3p though, I do think we’d probably have 3 scum.
We've definitely previously had games with 2 maf and 1 malicious 3p so it's theoretically a possible setup, but again without further writeup hints, 2 kills indicating an SK, or someone flipping 3p I'm going to focus on mafia since we know they exist. Seems like a small game for something like a cult + mafia team.
It’s a mix of things. He just doesn’t feel like he has a town desire to solve. I think I’m remembering too much of day 2 of the last game where he was all fire and very towny and this just feels like the complete opposite but I don’t really remember his presence day 1 because all my rereads of day 1 were not live so less prevalent in my memory. I can see this kind of play coming from a 3p to stay under the radar.
Yeah we've had neutral on this site before as well who just need to survive and can win with either side, so a 3p isn't necessarily anti-town. If we're thinking 3p in this game based on opening writeup I kinda lean a neutral/survivor wincon but that's highly speculative. I probably won't stress unless 2+ mafia die and the game is still going.
Unless mkg is 3p, I don’t see how I can believe mkg as bad at this point.
Maybe there are just 3 scum and we’re looking too much into 3p. If the remaining 2 are a janitor and some other PR that targeted me, that could work. I just still don’t get why target greedy.
Also want to draw attention to this from the writeup. Really believe we're in a 3p world here and it doesn't sound like a benevolent entity.