What happens to people that lie during the application process?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
It depends on the lie. Some are far worse than others, obviously.

I agree with pretty much everyone here that lying about stats and EC and similar things (credentials) is wrong and shouldn't be done. There are certain fibs however that don't matter (minor ones). For example:

Of all the interviews I attended, I knew one of the schools is more rural family-medicine-oriented. I have completely zero intentions of ever doing family medicine in some back-country town. No way. Yet, when they asked, I stated that I had considered it as an option. I knew that if I told them straight-up that I want to do private practice I would have been possibly looked down upon in not fitting their mission statement. So I fibbed. Had I attended their school, I would have had the same end goal anyway. But that's obviously a more innocuous lie. God forbid we're not ALL altruistic machines who lead lives of sacrifice and giving up everything for others. Don't get me wrong, I want to help people and am passionate about the "good" aspects of medicine, but in the end it's a job like any other and I want to be happy in my life too.

I see nothing wrong with what you did. They got the answer they deserved - you said you considered it as an option - not too sure how much better an answer one can give to that question. No med school can expect any applicant to commit to future residency or career options as a condition of acceptance.

And I bet if you look at their match list, not everyone graduating from that school is going into rural primary care...maybe a higher percentage than most schools - but I bet it is still a small number...
 
It depends on the lie. Some are far worse than others, obviously.

I agree with pretty much everyone here that lying about stats and EC and similar things (credentials) is wrong and shouldn't be done. There are certain fibs however that don't matter (minor ones). For example:

Of all the interviews I attended, I knew one of the schools is more rural family-medicine-oriented. I have completely zero intentions of ever doing family medicine in some back-country town. No way. Yet, when they asked, I stated that I had considered it as an option. I knew that if I told them straight-up that I want to do private practice I would have been possibly looked down upon in not fitting their mission statement. So I fibbed. Had I attended their school, I would have had the same end goal anyway. But that's obviously a more innocuous lie. God forbid we're not ALL altruistic machines who lead lives of sacrifice and giving up everything for others. Don't get me wrong, I want to help people and am passionate about the "good" aspects of medicine, but in the end it's a job like any other and I want to be happy in my life too.

(...waiting patiently for cpants to rip you apart for your incredibly "unethical" views and behavior)
:corny:
 
By the way, you sir, are no Einstein. You are just another pre-med trying to game the system. There are plenty of honest people that get rejected each year. They deserve your spot.
Honestly, do you really want to go there? It's as if I told you in this discussion that people like you will just become tools who lack tolerance and realism who would never cut it in the field of medicine, and that it's doctors like you who end up developing drug and family abuse problems because you are so out of touch with reality. And thus, you should just drop out now and let people who can handle what medicine is really like in.. I'm not sure anymore if you are trying to offend me or trying to make a valid point.

There is a big difference between estimating the number of hours you spent and doubling the number of hours you spent or making up activities. Estimation is acceptable and actually desired by schools. If you estimate that you worked 3 hours per week in a lab, but neglect to say that you didn't work the week of Christmas and you were sick one week in October, this is not lying. Lying is saying I worked 400 hours when you only worked 200 hours, an example you gave in a previous post. Lying is saying you have clinical/shadowing/volunteer experience when you really did nothing.

No sir, lying is when you say something that is contrary to the truth. If you even "estimated" in your favor, then you have lied. What I find interesting is that on one hand you say embossing your app is lying and is bad, but then you go on to justify cases where embossing your app is not lying. I'm beginning to see less and less difference between what you are saying now from what I suggested before which is that everyone lies, the difference is on how much you lie; but just because someone has not been truthful in their application, it wouldn't bother me one bit if they can become good doctors.

I think your posts have proven that your primary goal is not to become a good doctor, but to get into medical school at all costs. If you wanted to become a good doctor, you would actually be interested in spending time learning from other doctors and helping people, instead of just making it up.

I think your posts have proven that you like to very easily assume that you understand what other people's views are without actually reading into what the other person is saying. I would much appreciated if you would read my posts where I say again where I say what my bottomline belief is and see if it at all correlates what you have constructed in your mind.

Also, you seem to have a very limited idea of what a "good doctor" is. A good doctor is one that wants to help people, but in no way can you say that someone doesn't want to help people if that person fudges numbers on an application. You seem to think what a person puts on the application can act as a door into someone's soul in knowing what kind of doctor that person will be. That sounds pretty ignorant.

And I would like to ask, what is YOUR definition of what a good doctor is? I think you need to recognize that there are MANY ways and definitions to a "good doctor." For example, I believe that one definition of a good doctor is someone who can stand for 12 hours in the surgery room reconstructing someone's face because he's got the skills that no one else does. I think a good doctor can be the guy who spent hundreds of hours in lab discovering that cure for cancer that he later sells for millions of dollars. I think a good doctor can be the guy who just lobbied a billion dollars to construct that new spinal reconstruction center because he knows how to sell his staff and his hospital. You think I give a care if any of these people only spent 100 hours in the community center serving soup to homeless people instead of the 200 hours he put on his application? Heck no.

*EDIT*

Wait, let me ask you, would YOU care in those cases?

Actually, don't answer, I can probably guess what your answer is based on what you said before. Although you can certainly post it if you want to. But your answer and mine, that's where our positions differ.
 
^ (s)he has changed thier opinion in regards to lying throughout this thead. First they said that lying is lying no matter what. Now they changing their mind and saying its ok if you leave out certain things like "the week you took off in christmas".

From Cpants very first post in this thread (s)he has done nothing but throw emotional and somewhat lieble remarks around. Its honestly been entertaining as I am not sure if they are 100% serious with his/her statments.
 
^ (s)he has changed thier opinion in regards to lying throughout this thead. First they said that lying is lying no matter what. Now they changing their mind and saying its ok if you leave out certain things like "the week you took off in christmas".

From Cpants very first post in this thread (s)he has done nothing but throw emotional and somewhat lieble remarks around. Its honestly been entertaining as I am not sure if they are 100% serious with his/her statments.

hm... i'm guessing that arrow wasn't pointed at my post but the couple of posts before me? 🙂
 
No. No it's not. The admission process is ridiculous and some people just don't have time to jump through the idiotic hoops. If his grades and MCAT scores were good and he has the desire the "friend" will do just fine.

It's like taking a lab with organic chemistry as a pre-med. Do you think everybody does the lab perfectly? No. Most rational people realize that a rinky-dink lab class taught by a Chinese graduate student ranks a 0.0 on the 10 point scale of importance and just make up the data to put on their lab report.

It's just a hoop. Better to use some cunning to circumvent it.
what?? someone else thinks that most of the application stuff are just idiotic hoops to jump through? I'm amazed. Usually I have a bunch of people yelling at me when I say that.
 
And to answer the question of what happens to people that lie during the application process...

Absolutely nothing 🙂. They can live by their lack of honesty. Do you want to?
 
What happens to people that lie during the app cycle?

Firing squad.

Seriously. I've seen it.
 
what?? someone else thinks that most of the application stuff are just idiotic hoops to jump through? I'm amazed. Usually I have a bunch of people yelling at me when I say that.

yeah you aren't the only one, but plenty of people on this thread have also yelled at the people who recognize this.
 
Top