WW Child's Play; a noob game

[hazelmoo]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I will always be wary of Kam, but I think our top priority is finding out who was helping trilt.

I wonder if the other wolves knew what trilt was doing. Or if they were like, "OMG WTF IS HE DOING?". If they knew what he was doing, and they knew that he would be able to use his ant farm to NOT die, then they would have been for lynching him as well so that they didn't give anything away. I think this was their plan, to trick us into thinking teepster was a wolf so that we would kill them and the wolves wouldn't waste one of their kills.

 

[Donut.vett]

I wonder if the other wolves knew what trilt was doing. Or if they were like, "OMG WTF IS HE DOING?". If they knew what he was doing, and they knew that he would be able to use his ant farm to NOT die, then they would have been for lynching him as well so that they didn't give anything away. I think this was their plan, to trick us into thinking teepster was a wolf so that we would kill them and the wolves wouldn't waste one of their kills.

I'm pretty sure they all knew what trilt had planned. Yea but not lynching trilt the 1st day meant 1 more villager died in the process (me).

 

[hazelmoo]

I'm pretty sure they all knew what trilt had planned. Yea but not lynching trilt the 1st day meant 1 more villager died in the process (me).

I think we should trust teepster for now. I don't think 2 wolves would be given the ability to PM villagers. Since trilt had this ability, teepster CAN'T be a wolf because they have the ability too. I think teepster was fooled just like the rest of us.

 

[hazelmoo]

It is still possible that Kam is a wolf and they were silenced by a villager... But which villager has that power??

 

[hazelmoo]

The only people I am sure are not wolves are me and SF 🙁 This is so hard...

 

[finnickthedog]

*************
Do you always feel like somebody's watching you?
Because I was... while I got my nails did. 😛
I got addicted to checking this thread... and apparently habits don't break when you die.
Still rooting for you guys. Best of luck.
**************

 

[Lupin21]

Official Day 5 Lynching Tally

Caiter (2); Teep, STD
Rocky (1); Ppup,
Deva (3); hmoo, Sfef, Rocky
Teep ();
Swineherder ();

6/14 voting DEADLINE IS ~9:30PM EST

 

[Filly Bay]

Still others grinned at the one-sided fight. They thrived off the animosity and were pleased when the crowd dispersed, leaving a tattered and beaten body. Clouds drew over the village, and not one child felt at ease with what they had done. A single crow watched from its perch as the night took over from the day.

(First, I know PinkPuppy, its "too soon"...🙁)
BUT I was reading back over the Night/day summaries. Maybe I'm reading too much into this but Lupin specifically said there were no children who felt good about killing Tiny Tim. Caiter & Trilt both voted to lynch Chordata. Guess what players aren't children here? Krampus and Jacob Grimm.

At this point, whether they are being truthful or not, I have a role name in my spreadsheet for every player left. We are all children/teenager protagonists except one.

 

[hazelmoo]

(First, I know PinkPuppy, its "too soon"...🙁)
BUT I was reading back over the Night/day summaries. Maybe I'm reading too much into this but Lupin specifically said there were no children who felt good about killing Tiny Tim. Caiter & Trilt both voted to lynch Chordata. Guess what players aren't children here? Krampus and Jacob Grimm.

At this point, whether they are being truthful or not, I have a role name in my spreadsheet for every player left. We are all children/teenager protagonists except one.

Unless someone is a dirty, rotten liar.

 

[hazelmoo]

I'm fine with lynching Caiter if y'all want.. I just don't know what to do at this point 🙁

 

[Filly Bay]

Here’s another interesting thing I’ve found by combing through some of the first pages:

One girl crept along trying to figure out the true identity of one of her fellow children. She espied Little Red Riding Hood hiding in a barn, and heard her lamenting the loss of her newly found friend from another world, Tiny Tim. She heard how they had been able to PM with each other, and how they could have decided together how to ask insightful questions. Then she saw Little Red Riding Hood leave a message for the mods in her basket, and she wondered what the mods would answer, because although she couldn't read the message, it seemed like a good idea to get more info.

While she was spying on Little Red Riding Hood, and waiting for the answer to her question, this girl sensed a dark shape suddenly emerging, and all her bravado she had suddenly vanished, and in its place was a deep dark fear. She closed her eyes and hid as best she could, hoping that she was not noticed. After what seemed like days of waiting, the sun started to dawn, and she felt safe to get up. When she did, she noticed that Little Red Riding Hood's basket was gone, and the question unanswered. Little Red Riding Hood was not gone though, she was still there lying there like this:

That's right. Little Red Riding Hood was dead. All this girl could think of was the only death possible for the girl, death by wolves! She ran home and was not sure what to think of this crazy world anymore.

It's clear that there was ANOTHER seer than seered LRRH that night (She hid from the wolves so she has to be a villager), and Caiter claimed to seer Dorothy:

I actually looked at you last night Alohacat, because I wondered if there was anything to the link pp posted. There isn't, and you're Dorthy. I won't post what you're abilities are, I dont want to out if you don't want to reveal it yourself.


Kcough, yep I know. But it's going to be the only way for you guys to believe me at this point. So I had to take the risk.

This is another reason why I think we should lynch Caiter today, since it's highly unlikely that there are two villager seers, and instead it's more likely there's one villager seer (the one that seered LRRH), and the wolf seer (Caiter). It may not seem like a big deal but if we aren't careful their wolf seer will find our who the villager seer is and then we are even more blind than before.

 

[KCgophervet]

Here’s another interesting thing I’ve found by combing through some of the first pages:



It's clear that there was ANOTHER seer than seered LRRH that night (She hid from the wolves so she has to be a villager), and Caiter claimed to seer Dorothy:



This is another reason why I think we should lynch Caiter today, since it's highly unlikely that there are two villager seers, and instead it's more likely there's one villager seer (the one that seered LRRH), and the wolf seer (Caiter). It may not seem like a big deal but if we aren't careful their wolf seer will find our who the villager seer is and then we are even more blind than before.

I like this logic. It makes sense to me. I also trust you mostly because you voted to lynch Hayley before anyone else did... I also no longer trust my own instincts.

For now,

Lynch Caiter

 

[hazelmoo]

Unlynch dev
Lynch Caiter

 

[KCgophervet]

Here’s another interesting thing I’ve found by combing through some of the first pages:



It's clear that there was ANOTHER seer than seered LRRH that night (She hid from the wolves so she has to be a villager), and Caiter claimed to seer Dorothy:



This is another reason why I think we should lynch Caiter today, since it's highly unlikely that there are two villager seers, and instead it's more likely there's one villager seer (the one that seered LRRH), and the wolf seer (Caiter). It may not seem like a big deal but if we aren't careful their wolf seer will find our who the villager seer is and then we are even more blind than before.

Okay, rereading it it sounds like there was a little girl spying on LRRH... which could be Nancy Drew? Honestly I'm not 100% sure what the difference is between seering and spying/sleuthing...

 

[Filly Bay]

Okay, rereading it it sounds like there was a little girl spying on LRRH... which could be Nancy Drew? Honestly I'm not 100% sure what the difference is between seering and spying/sleuthing...

Also, I will say that I cannot look into specific roles/titles. I have to go by sleuthing alone.

The writeup said the girl found LRRH'd identity (role) AND found out about the asking the mods a question (ability).

Dev already said she can't do that.

 

[Mouse2106]

I can't stop reading! No time to waste.

LYNCH CAITER.

 

[Filly Bay]

If you're still not sure, this can easily be solved by asking @Devastating. Were you the girl in this write-up?

 

[Donut.vett]

This is a game of numbers we don't want a 1:1 ratio or the wolves win. With 13 players left that means theres only 11 villagers and 2 kills a night would put us in a dangerous situation in 4-5 days (3 if we keep lynching villagers).

 

[Donut.vett]

If you're still not sure, this can easily be solved by asking @Devastating. Were you the girl in this write-up?

Dev could also lie. Idk but dev hasn't told us any new info she acquired from to her sleuthing.

 

[Filly Bay]

If Dev is lying about being a villager (which I don't think she is) then there isn't a question because there's no Nancy Drew/Sleuthing.

 

[Lupin21]

Official Day 5 Lynching Tally

Caiter (5); Teep, STD, Kcough, hmoo, Mouse
Rocky (1); Ppup,
Deva (2); , Sfef, Rocky
Teep ();
Swineherder ();

8/14 voting DEADLINE IS ~9:30PM EST

 

[Donut.vett]

If Dev is lying about being a villager (which I don't think she is) then there isn't a question because there's no Nancy Drew/Sleuthing.

okay I semi-believe the sleuthing ability, but just because she has that ability doesn't me she's not a wolf.
I would hope she would use her ability to give us a little more insight into who she suspects are wolves.

 

[Filly Bay]

okay I semi-believe the sleuthing ability, but just because she has that ability doesn't me she's not a wolf.
I would hope she would use her ability to give us a little more insight into who she suspects are wolves.

Well if she has the ability AND shes a wolf then she's not the girl in the story I posted above. Which brings us back to Caiter lying.

But if she (dev) is a villager, she has no reason to lie and should be able to tell if that was her (which is not likely given that she said she can't see role/ability).

 

[hazelmoo]

@Devastating, you have lots 'o 'spainin to do...

 

[Donut.vett]

Well if she has the ability AND shes a wolf then she's not the girl in the story I posted above. Which brings us back to Caiter lying.

But if she (dev) is a villager, she has no reason to lie and should be able to tell if that was her (which is not likely given that she said she can't see role/ability).

Yea I see your point. I always thought catier was a possible wolf. I don't see a valid reason why they would keep her around so long.

 

[Donut.vett]

I also fear for my life tonight. should I bring someone back incase they decide to kill me tonight?

 

[Donut.vett]

The person would have there abilities but they could be useful to us (if only for 2 days). and If i do die at least the villager numbers will still be the same so the rest of you can have an extra day to catch a wolf.

 

[Donut.vett]

The person would have there abilities but they could be useful to us (if only for 2 days). and If i do die at least the villager numbers will still be the same so the rest of you can have an extra day to catch a wolf.

*wouldn't
*their

 

[DVMDream]

The person would have there abilities but they could be useful to us (if only for 2 days). and If i do die at least the villager numbers will still be the same so the rest of you can have an extra day to catch a wolf.

*their

 

[Donut.vett]

Part of the reason our thread is so long is because of all my spelling mistakes (sorry all of SDN) Lol

 

[DVMDream]

*wouldn't
*their

Damn, I got ninja'd by a newb.

 

[pp9]

I'm seriously losing track of this game 🙁 Too lost

 

[KCgophervet]

I also fear for my life tonight. should I bring someone back incase they decide to kill me tonight?

Yes definitely. We need as many villagers as we can get. What is your full role description if you don't mind? I know you've already posted it but just to remind me?

 

[hazelmoo]

I need to go back and read everyone's abilities to see who would be most useful. If anyone has the power to protect someone, they should protect SF tonight.

 

[Donut.vett]

Max- A very creative boy, you get into trouble with your “wild” ways, but luckily can escape to a place where you are King of the Wild Things. This means that you can once in the game bring back a player, however they will take on the form of a Wild Thing (no return of powers). You will be able PM with said person as well. They will only live two days before returning to the land of the dead.

 

[hazelmoo]

Ohhhh so they won't have their abilities! I say go ahead and bring someone back tonight just in case. Someone who may know something we don't.

 

[Donut.vett]

I need to go back and read everyone's abilities to see who would be most useful. If anyone has the power to protect someone, they should protect SF tonight.

Yea I agree I was going to save my ability to bring back a seer to gives us more info. But if I wait and I do die my ability is wasted. I don't know what to do.

 

[hazelmoo]

Yea I agree I was going to save my ability to bring back a seer to gives us more info. But if I wait and I do die my ability is wasted. I don't know what to do.

But I thought that they won't have their abilities back according to your description? You might want to check with your mentor.

 

[Donut.vett]

Ohhhh so they won't have their abilities! I say go ahead and bring someone back tonight just in case. Someone who may know something we don't.

Yea I'm open for ideas! I was thinking one of the more recently deceased because they had more time to interact with us. either PBC or FinDog.
(Sorry older deadies I wish I could bring you all back!!!)

 

[Filly Bay]

Yea I'm open for ideas! I was thinking one of the more recently deceased because they had more time to interact with us. either PBC or FinDog.
(Sorry older deadies I wish I could bring you all back!!!)

Um, did you already forget that PBC was CHAOS??

 

[hazelmoo]

I'm scared PBC will create more mischief than help us. But they should be able to tell us more about people's abilities... Idk.

 

[Donut.vett]

But I thought that they won't have their abilities back according to your description? You might want to check with your mentor.

They won't but what if the seer feared divulging info before but after they were dead there was no risk.

 

[Filly Bay]

Even if PBC couldn't wreck more havoc, they wouldn't count towards the villagers numbers!!!!

 

[Donut.vett]

Um, did you already forget that PBC was CHAOS??

But they won't have that ability anymore! they would be a regular villager. I think chaos would be able to provide valuable insight becaue PBC would be on the villagers side now.

 

[Filly Bay]

But they won't have that ability anymore! they would be a regular villager. I think chaos would be able to provide valuable insight becaue PBC would be on the villagers side now.

I'd ask your mentor, but I'm pretty certain taking away Peter Pan's abilities would not just make him a villager. He is still the role of chaos.

 

[Donut.vett]

Even if PBC couldn't wreck more havoc, they wouldn't count towards the villagers numbers!!!!

It wouldn't? I thought PBC was a villager with a naughty side not a wolf.

 

[Teepster87]

Yea I'm open for ideas! I was thinking one of the more recently deceased because they had more time to interact with us. either PBC or FinDog.
(Sorry older deadies I wish I could bring you all back!!!)

Lady has said that she has still been keeping up as well. It would be nice to have fin back to tell us if he used both his attempted kills

 

[hazelmoo]

But they won't have that ability anymore! they would be a regular villager. I think chaos would be able to provide valuable insight becaue PBC would be on the villagers side now.

This is true.. I think they could tell us more about people's abilities since they could steal them. Also, the wolves would have no reason to kill you since you already used your power to bring someone back.

 

[Filly Bay]

It wouldn't? I thought PBC was a villager with a naughty side not a wolf.

There are wolves, chaos, and villagers. PBC was chaos. Your role description says nothing about making them a villager.

 

[Filly Bay]

I just don't think its a good idea to risk it. I would be a much safer bet to bring back a known villager.