WWicked WWild HalloWWeen Interest/ Sign ups/Game thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Official D3 lynch tally
Mutts (4)-mel, sporty, grebes, dolphin
Jboo (2)-SAR, AM
SAR (1)-shelter
Shelter (2)-genny, jboo
Sporty (1)-mutt
Grebes (1)-dandy
11/12
Lynch close in ~2 hours
@muttmanager you're in the lead

I've laid my best offense, based on the info I get, on the table.
 
lynch jboo

based on her most recent few posts. reading things more in depth now to try and get some other feels.
 
If shes a wolf with abilities, it wouod make sense to lynch the wolf with none since both were suspects.

Maybe her item did save someone last night, I haven't seen proof. I didn't realize we wouldn't know when/if items were used in the write-ups

So are you sticking with your sporty vote, knowing what you know now? That 1)we aren't notified about items in the write-up and 2)if someone does have an item they're not going to come right out and admit it?
 
So are you sticking with your sporty vote, knowing what you know now? That 1)we aren't notified about items in the write-up and 2)if someone does have an item they're not going to come right out and admit it?
Doesnt matter but sticking with my most wolfy.

Unlynch Sport, Lynch Dandy

In order from least to most likely? Because if there are actually 4 wolves in this game, we were screwed from the start.
In that order. Sport is the least wolfy to me right now.
 
I will say that this whole "people are voting for me so they must be wolves" attitude that Mutts is putting on screams noob-village, but don't know if its worth switching a lynch at this point. I'm looking at SAR if anyone else is willing to vote that way.
 
I will say that this whole "people are voting for me so they must be wolves" attitude that Mutts is putting on screams noob-village, but don't know if its worth switching a lynch at this point. I'm looking at SAR if anyone else is willing to vote that way.

why
 
@muttmanager So you must believe that there are at least two villagers on your lynch, yes?
You mean up to be lynched with me. I don't know. I think people are voting based off how they think people play and not necessarily based on this game. Which puts me at a disadvantage since I dont know anyone
 
Interactions with coffee? D1 and I can see a world in which she followed me onto the SP vote yesterday in an attempt to save Coffee, but with SP role revealing, she couldn't stay on that vote without getting flak so she bussed her partner.
 
You mean up to be lynched with me. I don't know. I think people are voting based off how they think people play and not necessarily based on this game. Which puts me at a disadvantage since I dont know anyone

No, I mean two villagers lynching you currently.
 
Interactions with coffee? D1 and I can see a world in which she followed me onto the SP vote yesterday in an attempt to save Coffee, but with SP role revealing, she couldn't stay on that vote without getting flak so she bussed her partner.
The last bit also crossed my mind as well.

Interaction with coffee is why mutts was and still is on my wolfy list, so I don’t really care to move off of that all that much. HOWEVER, I think your evaluation of SAR is fair and certainly worth looking into more as well
 
Interactions with coffee? D1 and I can see a world in which she followed me onto the SP vote yesterday in an attempt to save Coffee, but with SP role revealing, she couldn't stay on that vote without getting flak so she bussed her partner.

Lol. If you actually think I'm that smart when scrambling at lynch close, I'm flattered

Sorry I've been MIA. My therio exam spanked me hard and I've been pouting, tbh
 
I'm comfortable hanging where my vote is at for now, though I have to do a more thorough re-read.

For those tossing my name, it would be very dumb of me to loudly joke vote a fellow wolf on D1 knowing it would probably stand out. I get burned enough for my first post apparently being sketchy af, I'd rather just move on from that tradition
 
Final Official D3 lynch tally
Mutts (4)-mel, sporty, grebes, dolphin
Jboo (3)-SAR, AM, genny
SAR (1)-shelter
Shelter (2)-genny, jboo
Grebes (1)-dandy
Dandy (1)-mutts
12/12
 
D3
After a safe night the villagers were out for blood. After finding coffee? Guilty they thought for sure muttmanager must be the one they seek. The one to blame for the deaths. Alas! Pushed into the well without his broom.

Dead is @muttmanager a vanillager whom got upgraded to talk to the dead but was never able to use it. A witch


It is now N3
1. @grebes4lyfe
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @Dandelion18
4. @dolphin106258
5. @johnnaboo
8. @allieh8607
9. @genny
10. @sheltermed
13. @Melchizedek
14. @SportPonies
15. @SARdoghandler

Graveyard
@JaysmmmBT
@Stagg737
@CoffeeQuestionMark
@muttmanager
 
Last edited:
What do you think about the non-noob players outside of Sporty?
I already said I felt a lot of weird feels about SAR it’s almost reminded me of the Lurking Beloww game where I defended SAR not sounding wolfy and then SAR turned out to be a wolf. But of course I was village in that scenario so on the one hand it puts SAR village-y but SAR is more experienced than me so could’ve totally done it on purpose. And I still never got a response from jboo for my question. @johnnaboo
You and Mel I have in neutral-ish. And Genny and Allie are ?? Am I forgetting any non-noobs
 
D3
After a safe night the villagers were out for blood. After finding coffee? Guilty they thought for sure muttmanager must be the one they seek. The one to blame for the deaths. Alas! Pushed into the well without his broom.

Dead is @muttmanager a vanillager whom got upgraded to talk to the dead but was never able to use it

It is now N3
1. @grebes4lyfe
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @Dandelion18
4. @dolphin106258
5. @johnnaboo
8. @allieh8607
9. @genny
10. @sheltermed
13. @Melchizedek
14. @SportPonies
15. @SARdoghandler

Graveyard
@JaysmmmBT
@Stagg737
@CoffeeQuestionMark
@muttmanager


**********************
Every single one of you is now officially on my s*** list.

Lynch everybody
**********************
 
I already said I felt a lot of weird feels about SAR it’s almost reminded me of the Lurking Beloww game where I defended SAR not sounding wolfy and then SAR turned out to be a wolf. But of course I was village in that scenario so on the one hand it puts SAR village-y but SAR is more experienced than me so could’ve totally done it on purpose. And I still never got a response from jboo for my question. @johnnaboo
You and Mel I have in neutral-ish. And Genny and Allie are ?? Am I forgetting any non-noobs

I need you need some of these people moved into village category. Even more important is figuring out where to place the "??".
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
Stagg (1) - Mel
AM (1) - Sporty
Mel (2) - jboo, mutt
dolphin () -
mutt (2) - Stagg, grebes
Coffee? (2) - Jays*, AM
SAR (1) - dolphin
Jays* (3) - Dandy, genny, coffee?
Dandy (1) - SAR

13/15
Missing: allie, shelter

*didn't flip any alignment

Day 2 Lynch Tally

dolphin () -
Coffee? (4) - AM, genny, Sporty, SAR
mutt (1) - grebes
Dandy (1) - mutt
Sporty (3) - Mel, coffee?, Jboo
Allie (1) - Shelter
Genny (1) - Dandy

11/13
Missing: allie, dolphin

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Mutts (4)
- mel, sporty, grebes, dolphin
Jboo (3) - SAR, AM, allie
SAR (1) - shelter
Shelter (2) - genny, jboo
Sporty () -
Grebes (1) - dandy
Dandy (1) - mutt
12/12
 
I need you need some of these people moved into village category. Even more important is figuring out where to place the "??".
If I stopped thinking so hard and just went off of straight up feelings.
Village—AM, Sporty, Grebes
Could go either way(top of list is most wolfy to least)—Jboo, Shelter, Allie, genny
Most wolfy atm—SAR, dandy, Mel
 
D3
After a safe night the villagers were out for blood. After finding coffee? Guilty they thought for sure muttmanager must be the one they seek. The one to blame for the deaths. Alas! Pushed into the well without his broom.

Dead is @muttmanager a vanillager whom got upgraded to talk to the dead but was never able to use it. A witch


It is now N3
1. @grebes4lyfe
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @Dandelion18
4. @dolphin106258
5. @johnnaboo
8. @allieh8607
9. @genny
10. @sheltermed
13. @Melchizedek
14. @SportPonies
15. @SARdoghandler

Graveyard
@JaysmmmBT
@Stagg737
@CoffeeQuestionMark
@muttmanager
*************
Plot twist: I told you so.

**************
 
Okay, but I'm feeling twitchy and kind of want to lynch everyone who didn't answer the questions so I'm trying to think.
 
If I stopped thinking so hard and just went off of straight up feelings.
Village—AM, Sporty, Grebes
Could go either way(top of list is most wolfy to least)—Jboo, Shelter, Allie, genny
Most wolfy atm—SAR, dandy, Mel

Why is grebes village?
 
Okay, but I'm feeling twitchy and kind of want to lynch everyone who didn't answer the questions so I'm trying to think.
****
It’s probably because you didn’t ask 20
FDA7FBBA-E4E0-4D05-8289-A3B243B0A681.gif

****
 
Why is grebes village?
Bc that’s what my gut is telling me, my theory that I posted is something I’ve been thinking about. But I know my first game I probably did and said stupid things that made me look sketch. So I’m not inclined to just believe my theory bc of that.
 
If I stopped thinking so hard and just went off of straight up feelings.
Village—AM, Sporty, Grebes
Could go either way(top of list is most wolfy to least)—Jboo, Shelter, Allie, genny
Most wolfy atm—SAR, dandy, Mel

Where is Sporty?
 
I already said I felt a lot of weird feels about SAR it’s almost reminded me of the Lurking Beloww game where I defended SAR not sounding wolfy and then SAR turned out to be a wolf. But of course I was village in that scenario so on the one hand it puts SAR village-y but SAR is more experienced than me so could’ve totally done it on purpose. And I still never got a response from jboo for my question. @johnnaboo

You and Mel I have in neutral-ish. And Genny and Allie are ?? Am I forgetting any non-noobs
My b
I am really trying to not think you’re sketch in every game bc I think the last time i was way off. And I completely understand the busy-ness of life, but are you just throwing up me and allie in the sketch category bc we aren’t on to say anything to the contrary? Also you can give reasoning for us but none for why you voted Sporty (unless i missed it?) Don’t like it. :eyebrow:
I addressed the Sporty part. And I typically like to pressure those who are less active to contribute more, especially early on. Done that for a while now. Does it do anything? Sometimes. Have I caught a wolf because they haven’t been posting a lot? Yep.
 
My b

I addressed the Sporty part. And I typically like to pressure those who are less active to contribute more, especially early on. Done that for a while now. Does it do anything? Sometimes. Have I caught a wolf because they haven’t been posting a lot? Yep.
But you didn’t actually tag so how is that pressure, if someone is really avoiding the thread bc they’re a wolf why wouldn’t you tag them to prove that’s what you’re doing. Just throwing names of inactive people out there isn’t that helpful, it just seemed like an easy way to have something else to write about besides writing a blank lynch vote. Which is basically what it was bc at the time there was no reasoning for Sporty if I’m recalling correctly.

Maybe it’s an overall personal preference thing, idk. But I still don’t like it.
 
Top