WWicked WWild HalloWWeen Interest/ Sign ups/Game thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Stagg737 said:
********
Lynch Coffee?'s skeleton
********
Click to expand...
******
aeNWNQp_460s.jpg
?? :naughty:
******
 
dolphin106258 said:
If I stopped thinking so hard and just went off of straight up feelings.
Village—AM, Sporty, Grebes
Could go either way(top of list is most wolfy to least)—Jboo, Shelter, Allie, genny
Most wolfy atm—SAR, dandy, Mel
Click to expand...

Can I ask why Mel and Dandy are in the most wolfy category?
 
Melchizedek said:
....What the hell? Are you even thinking about what this list means?
Click to expand...
Calm down, I have had weird vibes off of things you’ve said and I was establishing a list, I would’ve rather left you off completely bc I don’t like attaching wolf to someone like you who just seems to get it attached and others go off of it. But AM was wanting my thoughts on non noob players specifically and wanted me to not have people in neutral to idk and that’s bc I was thinking too much. So I gave her a list of just feelings. Leaving you off would’ve drawn attention and then I would’ve had to explain. :lame:
 
Animal Midwife said:
Can I ask why Mel and Dandy are in the most wolfy category?
Click to expand...
Mel it’s just some feelings off of his posts. Dandy it’s partly my theory, partly I just think one noob is a wolf, and dandy seems like the most likely candidate to me. Especially with mutts not being a wolf. Plus I do agree with Mel that dandy could’ve gone and broken the tie towards the wolf, but didn’t and chose to pick a random player. However for me I know when I played I didn’t want to be a last minute vote onto a lynch candidate unless I felt that way. But I also didn’t want to do it as a wolf bc attention. Soooo idk. But I’m not sure if I’m ready to lynch based on that. I’m thinking.
 
dolphin106258 said:
Mel it’s just some feelings off of his posts. Dandy it’s partly my theory, partly I just think one noob is a wolf, and dandy seems like the most likely candidate to me. Especially with mutts not being a wolf. Plus I do agree with Mel that dandy could’ve gone and broken the tie towards the wolf, but didn’t and chose to pick a random player. However for me I know when I played I didn’t want to be a last minute vote onto a lynch candidate unless I felt that way. But I also didn’t want to do it as a wolf bc attention. Soooo idk. But I’m not sure if I’m ready to lynch based on that. I’m thinking.
Click to expand...

Which posts of Mel's? Why does one noob have to be a wolf?
 
Melchizedek said:
....What the hell? Are you even thinking about what this list means?
Click to expand...
dolphin106258 said:
Mel it’s just some feelings off of his posts. Dandy it’s partly my theory, partly I just think one noob is a wolf, and dandy seems like the most likely candidate to me. Especially with mutts not being a wolf. Plus I do agree with Mel that dandy could’ve gone and broken the tie towards the wolf, but didn’t and chose to pick a random player. However for me I know when I played I didn’t want to be a last minute vote onto a lynch candidate unless I felt that way. But I also didn’t want to do it as a wolf bc attention. Soooo idk. But I’m not sure if I’m ready to lynch based on that. I’m thinking.
Click to expand...
This is why I’m confused about your list, assuming there’s two wolves left, no combination of me, SAR, or Dandy makes sense.
Both SAR and I have been eyeing Dandy and keeping her in the conversation. So Dandy + Me or Dandy + SAR doesn’t make sense.
I’m vocally getting more and more suspicious of SAR (see thoughts last night) so Me + SAR doesn’t make sense.
If you’re just thinking in the first order situation where any of the three of us could be wolves individually, then I can understand that, but you’re more experienced than that so I was expected a little more in terms of how your individual suspects would work in context of them being a pack.

ETA: It especially doesn’t make sense if you’re agreeing with me about how Dandy’s actions could look


ETA: My wolf list is Dandy, Dolphin, Grebes, and SAR most woofy to neutral but creeping me out.
 
Last edited:
Melchizedek said:
This is why I’m confused about your list, assuming there’s two wolves left, no combination of me, SAR, or Dandy makes sense.
Both SAR and I have been eyeing Dandy and keeping her in the conversation. So Dandy + Me or Dandy + SAR doesn’t make sense.
I’m vocally getting more and more suspicious of SAR (see thoughts last night) so Me + SAR doesn’t make sense.
If you’re just thinking in the first order situation where any of the three of us could be wolves individually, then I can understand that, but you’re more experienced than that so I was expected a little more in terms of how your individual suspects would work in context of them being a pack.

ETA: It especially doesn’t make sense if you’re agreeing with me about how Dandy’s actions could look


ETA: My wolf list is Dandy, Dolphin, Grebes, and SAR most woofy to neutral but creeping me out.
Click to expand...
I was literally giving a list of my feelings if you want something about how any of them work in conjunction then I could give you that. When I think about feelings I don’t think in anyway how they could work together as a pack. Nor did I say in anyway that they were listed as a group. But if you and SAR are questioning dandy and my theory/thoughts about Dandy are incorrect (as in village) then it wouldn’t be far fetched that one of you could be wolves. Also you’re saying being vocal of someone who could also be a wolf means that you aren’t a wolf. And I’m pretty sure that’s not how anyone has told me to clear a person or put them in village camp.
I definitely have much stronger feelings, and reasons for SAR or Dandy to be a wolf than you. But I didn’t want to hold anything back from the list or lie. That doesn’t help the village.

Also, you put me on your list of wolf suspects now bc of my list or what?
 
dolphin106258 said:
Also, you put me on your list of wolf suspects now bc of my list or what?
Click to expand...
I get that it was a gut reaction list, but it also looks like a list that a wolf threw out under pressure because they were asked to give reads on the fly. The list is the people I haven't gotten a good village read on (minus Jboo and Allie, there just isn't enough from them to say more than null).
 
Animal Midwife said:
Which posts of Mel's? Why does one noob have to be a wolf?
Click to expand...
I’ll have to pull them later, I’m at class all day without my computer. And it just seemed logical that a basics game would probably involve a noob wolf especially with as many as we had in this game to start with. 4/15 almost a third, I’m not saying that idea is controlling my suspects to where I wouldn’t put a veteran up if I genuinely felt they were more wolfy. I was just thinking of it as a possibility.
 
Melchizedek said:
I get that it was a gut reaction list, but it also looks like a list that a wolf threw out under pressure because they were asked to give reads on the fly. The list is the people I haven't gotten a good village read on (minus Jboo and Allie, there just isn't enough from them to say more than null).
Click to expand...
I had already given thoughts, but AM didn’t seem like it was complete enough so asked for me to figure out the neutral folks, I could’ve just responded with that’s all I feel/know right now. But I gave extra info, didn’t feel pressure to, nor did I really have to. There were other ways I could’ve handled AM than throwing out a gut reaction list.
 
Also @Melchizedek how are you calling out SAR and becoming more suspicious but have them at the bottom of your list in the neutral creeping you out portion?

I get you’re saying you think by talking about SAR that clears you from being a part of a pack with SAR. But genuinely why wouldn’t SAR be higher if you’re becoming more suspicious?
 
dolphin106258 said:
Also @Melchizedek how are you calling out SAR and becoming more suspicious but have them at the bottom of your list in the neutral creeping you out portion?

I get you’re saying you think by talking about SAR that clears you from being a part of a pack with SAR. But genuinely why wouldn’t SAR be higher if you’re becoming more suspicious?
Click to expand...
Sorry Mel the first part of that question sounded hella snarky/rude, I didn’t mean it that way. I prefer my sarcasm to have meaning and purpose.
 
N3
What an eventful night! For once it wasnt raining and the moon full many of our players decided to go out to a haunted corn maze last night. Running about a few players seemed perpetually lost in the maze. Dolphin began to feel helpless like shed never get out. She ran into sporty who felt sure she had found the way. As dolphin was almost out of the corn maze someone jumped out at her chopping down the corn in front of her and threatening her with a chain saw. Sporty trailed behind her. "Go dolphin!" Sporty yelled as she pushed her out the exit.

Still alive is dolphin. Trapped forever in the haunted maze with no way out is @SportPonies a skeleton vanillager upgraded to item maker

It is now D4
1. @grebes4lyfe
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @Dandelion18
4. @dolphin106258
5. @johnnaboo
8. @allieh8607
9. @genny
10. @sheltermed
13. @Melchizedek
15. @SARdoghandler

Graveyard
@JaysmmmBT
@Stagg737
@CoffeeQuestionMark
@muttmanager
@SportPonies
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
Stagg (1) - Mel
AM (1) - Sporty
Mel (2) - jboo, mutt
dolphin () -
mutt (2) - Stagg, grebes
Coffee? (2) - Jays*, AM
SAR (1) - dolphin
Jays* (3) - Dandy, genny, coffee?
Dandy (1) - SAR

13/15
Missing: allie, shelter

*didn't flip any alignment

Day 2 Lynch Tally
dolphin () -
Coffee? (4) - AM, genny, Sporty, SAR
mutt (1) - grebes
Dandy (1) - mutt
Sporty (3) - Mel, coffee?, Jboo
Allie (1) - Shelter
Genny (1) - Dandy

11/13
Missing: allie, dolphin

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Mutts (4) - mel, sporty, grebes, dolphin
Jboo (3) - SAR, AM, allie
SAR (1) - shelter
Shelter (2) - genny, jboo
Sporty () -
Grebes (1) - dandy
Dandy (1) - mutt
12/12
 
dolphin106258 said:
I’ll have to pull them later, I’m at class all day without my computer. And it just seemed logical that a basics game would probably involve a noob wolf especially with as many as we had in this game to start with. 4/15 almost a third, I’m not saying that idea is controlling my suspects to where I wouldn’t put a veteran up if I genuinely felt they were more wolfy. I was just thinking of it as a possibility.
Click to expand...

Wolves are RNG though. If lack of experience increases the chances of being a wolf, then you'd be a safe bet to lynch. If you're truly sure that a noob is a wolf, then there must be reasons for why almost every veteran is village. Grebes also shouldn't be a village read by this assumption. So you have to ask yourself whether grebes has to be moved to the wolf category or if looking for a noob wolf is going down a rabbit hole.
 
Yeah, I'm going to stick on Genny for now. Assuming we have ~3 wolves, I'd expect one other than Coffee to be involved in the Coffee v Sporty that ran down on D1. Genny jumped on coffee when we had a lot of flak on Mutts and Coffee wasn't a clear favourite, but could still be a good "but I pushed Coffee" place for a wolf to hang out. I'm reading AM as village so that only leaves Genny - assuming my thoughts about where wolves fell D2 pans out. It's also possible that 2 wolves hung out on Sporty, though less likely in my mind, so I'm still suspicious of jboo's voting record too.

Feeling pretty strong village on Dandy based on how the end of D2 panned out.
 
SARdoghandler said:
Yeah, I'm going to stick on Genny for now. Assuming we have ~3 wolves, I'd expect one other than Coffee to be involved in the Coffee v Sporty that ran down on D1. Genny jumped on coffee when we had a lot of flak on Mutts and Coffee wasn't a clear favourite, but could still be a good "but I pushed Coffee" place for a wolf to hang out. I'm reading AM as village so that only leaves Genny - assuming my thoughts about where wolves fell D2 pans out. It's also possible that 2 wolves hung out on Sporty, though less likely in my mind, so I'm still suspicious of jboo's voting record too.

Feeling pretty strong village on Dandy based on how the end of D2 panned out.
Click to expand...
You really don’t know my wolf play if you think I would do that. I usually have a crappy enough vote record as a villager that I can skate by with a crappy voting record as a wolf too.
 
SARdoghandler said:
Do we think the write-up mentioning both Dolphin and Sporty being threatened means anything, or just flavour?
Click to expand...
Ninja’d
Thinking is it possible there was a double kill and Sporty gave Dolphin a protection item or something?
 
SARdoghandler said:
Do we think the write-up mentioning both Dolphin and Sporty being threatened means anything, or just flavour?
Click to expand...

I think it's probably noteworthy. Given that I played with these mods before, I know they like to talk about attack attempts.
 
genny said:
You really don’t know my wolf play if you think I would do that. I usually have a crappy enough vote record as a villager that I can skate by with a crappy voting record as a wolf too.
Click to expand...

No, I don't really know anyone's play. There is not enough room in my brain for that. I try to remember play styles, but usually just go for whatever in the game pings me. And unfortunately, your vote record has pinged me. I'm equally good with a jboo lynch though if we want to go that direction today
 
Dandelion18 said:
I'm still working out how to think through Coffee's old posts, to be honest. She mentioned shelter, sporty, and grebes as her "top suspects." I've been going back and forth all day on whether it would be smarter for a wolf to mention all villagers in a suspicion list or to include a wolf in the mix. It seems like it would be smarter to mention at least one wolf on their so that if they go down before you do it gives you credibility. And if you go down before any of the people you mentioned, you didn't just clear 3 villagers. I'm not a hundred percent sure where I fall on the argument, but for now I'm tentatively lynching grebes.
Click to expand...
Had enough time to ruminate?


Lynch Dandy
 
Animal Midwife said:
why
Click to expand...

looking back at his voting record sketched me out. his vote for sporty and not coffee on D2, and then onto the mutts bandwagon D3.
got super defensive when dolphin called him out for being wolfy yesterday.
and also is always asking people for their reasons but doesn't seem to ever provide any of his own....
idk all of these together read wolf to me
 
grebes4lyfe said:
looking back at his voting record sketched me out. his vote for sporty and not coffee on D2, and then onto the mutts bandwagon D3.
got super defensive when dolphin called him out for being wolfy yesterday.
and also is always asking people for their reasons but doesn't seem to ever provide any of his own....
idk all of these together read wolf to me
Click to expand...

Who do you think could be teamed with Mel? Who do you have as villagers?
 
Animal Midwife said:
Who do you think could be teamed with Mel? Who do you have as villagers?
Click to expand...

also feeling like dandy could be wolfy, but not really sure how to reconcile mel's lynch vote with that. i guess i'll see how the votes go today and if there's any waffling because I think that would say a lot.
getting gut village vibes from shelter and genny, but mostly just because nothing they've done as struck me as particularly wolfy so I have no reason to believe they're not village.
I'm still just trying to read everyone else so I don't really have any other solid leanings one way or the other.
 
grebes4lyfe said:
also feeling like dandy could be wolfy, but not really sure how to reconcile mel's lynch vote with that. i guess i'll see how the votes go today and if there's any waffling because I think that would say a lot.
getting gut village vibes from shelter and genny, but mostly just because nothing they've done as struck me as particularly wolfy so I have no reason to believe they're not village.
I'm still just trying to read everyone else so I don't really have any other solid leanings one way or the other.
Click to expand...

What do you consider wolfy?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

supershorty
Here It GGOATS Again (GGOATS ThWWee) - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED
2
Replies
68
Views
3K
SARdoghandler
SARdoghandler
WildZoo
Supernatural WW Shenanigans Part 5 Sign Ups [OPEN] - Game Start Sept 12th (tentative)
Replies
48
Views
527
samac
samac
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
16K
supershorty
supershorty
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
54K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top