Addressing PE

  • Thread starter Thread starter AnatomyGrey12
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Still I bet by July or August they’ll be like never mind we’re canceling it because eventually they do everything big brother NBME does.
... And for the 3rd years like myself with PE scheduled in late June... forced to take it and see ya later $$ and time? I almost want to cancel and roll the dice with it getting canceled outright - though I've already paid and who knows if I'd get that money back.
 
I would love for NBME to fact check that email. its makings making some bold claims on why NBME cancelled CS.
This is not the first time the NBOME has said "X is why Z is happening" and it been straight up not true based on the words of the other organization's announcement. It has happened several times now.
 
Guys so I have meeting scheduled with Dr. Gimpel soon... I'll let you guys know what he says.

The only thing I can see him fighting me back on is OMM part of the PE. I need good defense on that.


FYI tho: So unless you plan on practicing in these states (Pennsylvania, Florida, West Virginia, Michigan and Oklahoma)....you can take Step 1, 2 and 3 and get your license to practice. As long as you complete all your DO school's requirements AND do a ACGME residency (ie all the prgms now).
 
Guys so I have meeting scheduled with Dr. Gimpel soon... I'll let you guys know what he says.

The only thing I can see him fighting me back on is OMM part of the PE. I need good defense on that.


FYI tho: So unless you plan on practicing in these states (Pennsylvania, Florida, West Virginia, Michigan and Oklahoma)....you can take Step 1, 2 and 3 and get your license to practice. As long as you complete all your DO school's requirements AND do a ACGME residency (ie all the prgms now).
OMM is evaluated during m1 and m2 and during OMM rotations. This is more rigorous and valid than being judged on doing OMM on about 3 fake patients during PE. Therefore OMM is adequately assessed during actual med school and the PE is redundant.
 
OMM is evaluated during m1 and m2 and during OMM rotations. This is more rigorous than doing OMM on about 3 fake patients during PE. Therefore OMM is adequately assessed during actual med school and the PE is redundant.
Yeah buts its not standardized across the schools like Level 1, 2 and 3 are. I just need a good defense so I don't look like a ******* in front of him.
 
So for those of you who have requested refunds are you currently just waiting to see if it goes away before you have to take level 3? Unfortunately, I plan on being in one of the states where taking the USMLE series won't work for getting a license so I plan to stick it out with the NBOME. Currently, I am registered to take PE in April but would really like my money back. My only fear is the mess this would cause of having to take it during residency and the lack of available testing dates? Thoughts?
I requested a refund because I didn’t have a test date, was cancelled 5-7 times (no exaggeration) since April 2020, and they had my money for over a year and a half. If I had an April date, or even the chance to sign up in April-June before residency, I wouldn’t have gotten the refund. But they blocked those months from the sign-up calendar and wouldn’t even explain why.

if I were you with an April date I would keep it.
 
Guys so I have meeting scheduled with Dr. Gimpel soon... I'll let you guys know what he says.

The only thing I can see him fighting me back on is OMM part of the PE. I need good defense on that.


FYI tho: So unless you plan on practicing in these states (Pennsylvania, Florida, West Virginia, Michigan and Oklahoma)....you can take Step 1, 2 and 3 and get your license to practice. As long as you complete all your DO school's requirements AND do a ACGME residency (ie all the prgms now).
OMM gets tested across the entire DO school experience from pre-clinical to clinical.

I would argue physical OMM is not something that can be standardized. The standardized part is tested in the written exams. And every school does OSCEs where OMM is a good part of it. You either trust your licensed OMM docs to teach it or you don’t. It’s completely redundant to do it on 3 fake patients that you aren’t even allowed to do more than one OMM technique on.
 
... And for the 3rd years like myself with PE scheduled in late June... forced to take it and see ya later $$ and time? I almost want to cancel and roll the dice with it getting canceled outright - though I've already paid and who knows if I'd get that money back.
I’m late July and I’m now debating doing the same thing. Funny how it seems we might be punished for trying to be responsible because the NBOME just sucks that much.
 
OMM gets tested across the entire DO school experience from pre-clinical to clinical.

I would argue physical OMM is not something that can be standardized. The standardized part is tested in the written exams. And every school does OSCEs where OMM is a good part of it. You either trust your licensed OMM docs to teach it or you don’t. It’s completely redundant to do it on 3 fake patients that you aren’t even allowed to do more than one OMM technique on.

I would argue physical OMM is not something that can be standardized. --> boom I like that. Let'se see.
 
I would argue physical OMM is not something that can be standardized. --> boom I like that. Let'se see.
Your OMM faculty have probably even said this 100 times during M1 and M2. Mine definitely did. That's how they defend the variation and lack of consistency in any OMM teaching and physical exam finding. The whole osteopathic world is literally built on a house of cards due to them spending all day speaking from both sides of their mouths every chance they get. It's unreal.
 
Yeah buts its not standardized across the schools like Level 1, 2 and 3 are. I just need a good defense so I don't look like a ******* in front of him.
@Deecee2DO hit the nail on the head. Mention that the OMM faculty justification for no OMM research is that it is an art and can't be standardized so how can they say that and then expect a standardized test on the practice of it... on 3 fake patients.
 
The NBOME is a cheap copy of the NBME. The NBOME’s continued existence is fueled by the greed of executives who want to profit off of a “DO difference” that doesn’t exist in the real world.

I would argue physical OMM is not something that can be standardized. --> boom I like that. Let'se see.

How about the fact that a majority of DO physicians don’t use OMM and are still fully capable of practicing medicine and treating patients effectively. OMM is a non-essential skill for practicing medicine, and so it shouldn’t serve as a bar that keeps student doctors from graduating and serving patients. Not knowing how to do OMM doesn’t make you an incompetent physician or a danger to the public—and if Dr. Gimpel thinks it does, then he should try bringing it up to the thousands of practicing DOs across the country who couldn’t diagnose a sacral dysfunction to save their lives.
 
But like I said....

Unless you plan on practicing in these 5 states (Pennsylvania, Florida, West Virginia, Michigan and Oklahoma)....you can take Step 1, 2 and 3 and get your license to practice. As long as you complete all your DO school's requirements AND do a ACGME residency (ie all the prgms now).

Cool. Do you know of any DO schools that don’t require COMLEX levels 1 and 2?
 
I emailed him about why PE is still a requirement in order to take Lvl 3... since CS was no longer a requirement for Step 3. And he responded saying he wanted to do a web meeting with me

🤷​

oh lord. what year are you? honestly dude/dudette i would not go through with this meeting unless you are graduated/about to graduate. he holds too much power over med students and has proven to be very vindictive. ii would hate to see him file a professionalism complaint or something else to screw you over based on this meeting. tread very verrrrry carefully.
 
oh lord. what year are you? honestly dude/dudette i would not go through with this meeting unless you are graduated/about to graduate. he holds too much power over med students and has proven to be very vindictive. ii would hate to see him file a professionalism complaint or something else to screw you over based on this meeting. tread very verrrrry carefully.
@Noisewater-TDX knows lol
 
wait. what happened to him/her?

I scared

1611699279069.png
 
I emailed him about why PE is still a requirement in order to take Lvl 3... since CS was no longer a requirement for Step 3. And he responded saying he wanted to do a web meeting with me

🤷​


You totes need to ask him to provide their logistics on how they can accommodate both the 2021 class and 2022 class and watch him go:
 

Attachments

  • agentdodgingbullets.gif
    agentdodgingbullets.gif
    1.2 MB · Views: 89
Cancel it. One of my friends just called them and asked for a refund, he said the lady was very frazzled. I suspect people are canceling in droves right now. Pile on.
Yup one of my classmates canceled as well. The lady begged her not to cancel saying "there will be tons of dates opening in April shortly" LOL
 
If the NBOME holds their ground we need to lobby to have those remaining states change their licensing laws. If we can be licensed in every state with the USMLE series we will not only kill the PE but kill Level 3 at the same time. Most of us are already taking USMLE 1 and 2. This would also put real pressure on the NBOME. I think if they saw states fix their laws they would cave instantly and cancel it in order to keep us from skipping level 3.
 
Last edited:
If NBOME is so hell-bent on a skills exam, then they need to decentralize it. Let students take it at their schools. Turn OSCEs into THE exam, and accept a schools certification of skills as a replacement for the PE.
This has been talked about by clinical skills faculty at my school for 4 years now. They even proposed it to the NBOME.
 
If the NBOME holds their ground we need to lobby to have those remaining states change their licensing laws. If we can be licensed in every state with the USMLE series we will not only kill the PE but kill Level 3 at the same time. Most of us are already taking USMLE 1 and 2 already. This would also put real pressure on the NBOME. I think if they saw states fix their laws they would cave instantly and cancel it in order to keep us from skipping level 3.
I'm pretty sure NBOME will hire lobbyists to make sure those 5 states DON'T change laws.
 
Last edited:
If NBOME is so hell-bent on a skills exam, then they need to decentralize it. Let students take it at their schools. Turn OSCEs into THE exam, and accept a schools certification of skills as a replacement for the PE.
This is completely logical. Only one problem the NBOME loses money. If it were truly about protecting the public then they never would have even thought to have us travel during the pandemic. Gimpel is shameful in his lies that it is to "protect the public." It's to line your own pocket and everyone knows it.
 
I mean, if no one says anything to him, how do we know he is not surrounded by yes-men who approve all his ideas. It is risky to reach out to him, but also perhaps necessary.
I would normally agree with you, but this man is not above ruining peoples careers out of spite. We are not in a power structure where students concerns are given priority.
 
I’m late July and I’m now debating doing the same thing. Funny how it seems we might be punished for trying to be responsible because the NBOME just sucks that much.
I'm in July and I would be so pissed if I took it and it was cancelled right after. I want to practice in FL so don't have the balls to just try and not take it, but now I may consider cancelling my current date and just snagging one in December after interviews. Although my school sent out an email last week that our deadline for taking PE has been extended to end of September because they realize people are having scheduling issues...like lol people do you even realize there are no dates until December
 
I'm in July and I would be so pissed if I took it and it was cancelled right after. I want to practice in FL so don't have the balls to just try and not take it, but now I may consider cancelling my current date and just snagging one in December after interviews.
This is what I'm pondering: if there is really any benefit to keeping my summer test date. If I take PE I risk failing and being totally screwed for interviews and the match. If I cancel it I'll be fine since PDs won't care, seeing as they'll no longer be tracking if MD students have CS done. My school hasn't waived it as a graduation requirement but come autumn they really won't have a choice. Many of my classmates are currently stuck with September and October test dates and it's not like they can keep half of us from graduating.

I'm starting to lean towards canceling for the above reasons and the reason you stated.
 
This is what I'm pondering: if there is really any benefit to keeping my summer test date. If I take it I risk failing and being totally screwed for interviews and the match. If I cancel it I'll be fine since PDs won't care, seeing as they'll no longer be tracking if MD students have CS done. My school hasn't waived it as a graduation requirement but come autumn they really won't have a choice. Many of my classmates are currently stuck with September and October test dates and it's not like they can keep half of us from graduating.

I'm starting to lean towards canceling for the above reasons and the reason you stated.
At this point everyone with a summer date should just cancel, in the case they actually end up resuming testing(highly doubt it actually happens) you won’t have to worry about it till later, there’s no way they can test everyone in such a short period of time.
 
This is what I'm pondering: if there is really any benefit to keeping my summer test date. If I take PE I risk failing and being totally screwed for interviews and the match. If I cancel it I'll be fine since PDs won't care, seeing as they'll no longer be tracking if MD students have CS done. My school hasn't waived it as a graduation requirement but come autumn they really won't have a choice. Many of my classmates are currently stuck with September and October test dates and it's not like they can keep half of us from graduating.

I'm starting to lean towards canceling for the above reasons and the reason you stated.
Cancel. The sooner the better. And call them to do it.
 
I'm in July and I would be so pissed if I took it and it was cancelled right after. I want to practice in FL so don't have the balls to just try and not take it, but now I may consider cancelling my current date and just snagging one in December after interviews. Although my school sent out an email last week that our deadline for taking PE has been extended to end of September because they realize people are having scheduling issues...like lol people do you even realize there are no dates until December
My school is giving us until Dec 31 to take PE so I’m seriously considering canceling and grabbing a December date. I’m not about to have this stupid exam ruin my life if god forbid I should fail. PDs literally won’t care since MDs don’t have it anymore so I really want to try and wait them out and take it at the very last second if need be.
 
This is what I'm pondering: if there is really any benefit to keeping my summer test date. If I take PE I risk failing and being totally screwed for interviews and the match. If I cancel it I'll be fine since PDs won't care, seeing as they'll no longer be tracking if MD students have CS done. My school hasn't waived it as a graduation requirement but come autumn they really won't have a choice. Many of my classmates are currently stuck with September and October test dates and it's not like they can keep half of us from graduating.

I'm starting to lean towards canceling for the above reasons and the reason you stated.
Im leaning the same as you but my concern is getting in trouble with my school. I assume they know when we are registered for things and I'm afraid I'll get in trouble for cancelling a date and then registering for one after their "deadline".
 
My school is giving us until Dec 31 to take PE so I’m seriously considering canceling and grabbing a December date. I’m not about to have this stupid exam ruin my life if god forbid I should fail. PDs literally won’t care since MDs don’t have it anymore so I really want to try and wait them out and take it at the very last second if need be.
If your school's deadline is Dec I would definitely reschedule.
 
Would you feel the PE will at least continue for 1 or 2 more classes, given that they just announced opening a Fresno test center? If they cancel now, the investment would be gone...
 
I
Would you feel the PE will at least continue for 1 or 2 more classes, given that they just announced opening a Fresno test center? If they cancel now, the investment would be gone...
i mean if they can even figure how to test thousands of residents who are class of 2021.
 
Top