FTF's Worst Idea Yet (Game Over)

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
alissa14 said:
I do agree with your analysis. I have a hard time believing Pippy would choose vanilla townie over a not-so-awful mafia role. Perhaps she was offered something better and even more sinister? I think it’s very possible for her to pick something 3P over mafia though

thoughts on MsP? I think MsP is kinda in the same boat as puppy in regards to she likes, or at least doesn’t mind being scum.
Click to expand...

do we know Pippy picked a vanilla role?

Crayola227 said:
Not exactly. Pick well and the chances go down.
Click to expand...

Pick? bro its Rng . its a 50 percent chance I randomly kill myself irrespective of who I chose

Zenge142 said:
I don’t care for this. She’s saying Bob voting for Chaos is opportunistic but it’s literally the first vote on Chaos.

I also don’t like that she’s attacking Bob for voting for Chaos when Chaos is voting for her. It feels like she’s trying to curry favor with the person voting to yeet her.

Yeet Cray
Click to expand...

Feels like you dont see why voting me is oppurtunistic.

See , If you are town , are susp about my claim and also want to actually wolf hunt , you should be better off ignoring me for a couple days , focusing on other people before actually doing something about me. Its a fricking suicidal role after all.

I think Cray is town , I like her takes

also townleaning JusPaws , her posts comes across as purely looking for info w/o any ulterior motives

vote BobisLaw

dont mind switching to alissa either
 
Vote: Bob

Strongest pings I’ve got so far, aside from alissa who seems to regardless of affiliation always get everyone’s radar pinging wildly day 1
 
Crayola227 said:
I still don't understand why werewolves can't be lovers, but town/village and mafia can. Is it just one of those just because things?
Click to expand...
Yes. Some rules have to exist or people run around with their head cut off saying "b-but it might also be wolves, mafia, sk, survivor, cultists, etc..."

Sometimes it's nice to know what affiliation someone mechanically cannot be instead of continuous mechanical torture.
 
Chaostrodon said:
do we know Pippy picked a vanilla role?



Pick? bro its Rng . its a 50 percent chance I randomly kill myself irrespective of who I chose



Feels like you dont see why voting me is oppurtunistic.

See , If you are town , are susp about my claim and also want to actually wolf hunt , you should be better off ignoring me for a couple days , focusing on other people before actually doing something about me. Its a fricking suicidal role after all.

I think Cray is town , I like her takes

also townleaning JusPaws , her posts comes across as purely looking for info w/o any ulterior motives

vote BobisLaw

dont mind switching to alissa either
Click to expand...
Oh, so it isn't that you protect them, and when they die only have a 50/50 of dying with them? Because in that case being good about your night action choices picking ppl not likely to be targeted for NK would help you alive.

Can you explain again how your ability works?
 
Crayola227 said:
Oh, so it isn't that you protect them, and when they die only have a 50/50 of dying with them? Because in that case being good about your night action choices picking ppl not likely to be targeted for NK would help you alive.

Can you explain again how your ability works?
Click to expand...

Compulsive bodyguard means , I will have to compulsively bodyguard someone every night. So if they are killed I die instead

also a 50 percent faith vig , which means there is a chance I use my vig on my targets. But soft. I am also bodyguarding my target.

Which means there is a 50 percent chance I try to kill my target and since Im bodyguarding them , I die protecting my target from myself
 
Aprilthearab said:
Hmm... That's fair. I've not played with Paws before so I don't have her meta handy. Her posts, regardless of what Pippy thinks of them, do kind of feel icky to me though and I feel okay on this vote.
Click to expand...
Do you have anyone else you’re wolfing reading?
 
Chaostrodon said:
Compulsive bodyguard means , I will have to compulsively bodyguard someone every night. So if they are killed I die instead

also a 50 percent faith vig , which means there is a chance I use my vig on my targets. But soft. I am also bodyguarding my target.

Which means there is a 50 percent chance I try to kill my target and since Im bodyguarding them , I die protecting my target from myself
Click to expand...
I literally can't. I read this like 5 times and I can't process it.
 
Chaostrodon said:
Compulsive bodyguard means , I will have to compulsively bodyguard someone every night. So if they are killed I die instead

also a 50 percent faith vig , which means there is a chance I use my vig on my targets. But soft. I am also bodyguarding my target.

Which means there is a 50 percent chance I try to kill my target and since Im bodyguarding them , I die protecting my target from myself
Click to expand...

So you get why I was looking for a doc

If I could find a doc , the role becomes powerful . Bc if we keep targetting each other , neither of us would die
 
Viscernable said:
Huh, this is interesting. Bob played with and then talked with us in dead chat about cray for a long time during England.
Click to expand...
Good point! I should know Cray, but honestly I don't track he/she on internet too well b/c it seems mostly irrelevant. By all means def watch me close. I wouldn't throw sus at cray b/c of my slip, that was just me being me. (Now I'll be said to be trying to protect my packmate-lol)
 
If you look at my discard, I got rid of reverse CPR doc. In retrospect, I should have kept it. I got rid of it b/c I didn't like the idea of killing someone else that was village. I have an issue where I always like to be the good guy. I am curious to how I will handle being a wolf, but won't find out this game. Sorry! lol

Besides, when I misgender I like to misgender blatantly like I did with MsP. (I still can't believe she didn't jump on me too. lol)
 
Aprilthearab said:
Not any big wolfy vibes. Pippy, Dubz, and Bob are currently in my "I have no hecking clue what they are and I would not be at all surprised if woof" category
Click to expand...
That is what put Chaos at the top of my list. If I am going to kill an innocent, at least it is an innocent that was going to die anyway. Someone else said, "yeet someone wolfy". But no one looks wolfy yet. So, I say yeet a possible villager who has said they will die anyway.
The only one I thought was wolfy was pippy. And I didn't want to think that since she modded the last game. And now I am glad I didn't b/c it looks like she isn't (or she is putting on a good act). I think everything is a guess right now. So I choose the short-timer. The thing that bothers me is that I figured more ppl would've jumped on (and given me reason to sus them).

But if I was playing as a wolf, I wouldn't vote chaos. He is going to die anyway, so why waste my time with him.

The way he revealed straight out of the gate still strikes me as odd. The way he encouraged doc to reveal (with subtle hint....yeah, no one else will pick up on that).
 
JustPaws said:
So what do you think of the WZ/Pip back and forth? Have you played with them in the same game before?
Click to expand...
I've said what I think of the WZ/Pippy interactions, which is a whole lot of me walking in circles:
Aprilthearab said:
I'm inclined to read the Paws/Pippy interactions as w/v with Paws being the wolf, or maybe w/w with Paws and Pippy in different factions. I'm kind of siding with Pippy about Paws here. But Dubz is saying she feels like Pippy is getting twisty with words and I'm not sure if I should trust her read given that I am bad at reading Pippy and I assume Dubz is better and also just more experienced and knows Pippy better than I do. Or if maybe Dubz is also wolfy, maybe even with Paws, and shouldn't be trusted with her Pippy read.
Click to expand...
Yes I have, but my memory is crap so I don't recall how I felt about them when they were playing together in previous games
 
BobLoblaw78 said:
That is what put Chaos at the top of my list. If I am going to kill an innocent, at least it is an innocent that was going to die anyway. Someone else said, "yeet someone wolfy". But no one looks wolfy yet. So, I say yeet a possible villager who has said they will die anyway.
The only one I thought was wolfy was pippy. And I didn't want to think that since she modded the last game. And now I am glad I didn't b/c it looks like she isn't (or she is putting on a good act). I think everything is a guess right now. So I choose the short-timer. The thing that bothers me is that I figured more ppl would've jumped on (and given me reason to sus them).

But if I was playing as a wolf, I wouldn't vote chaos. He is going to die anyway, so why waste my time with him.

The way he revealed straight out of the gate still strikes me as odd. The way he encouraged doc to reveal (with subtle hint....yeah, no one else will pick up on that).
Click to expand...
As I've said before though, it's a waste of a vote if they're going to die anyway. Might at least try to target a wolf rather than a person who has a higher probability of being village. If they die on their own, okay, then we didn't waste a vote. If they don't die, then we can reconsider.

I wouldn't be so quick to place trust in Pippy when you haven't seen her play before
 
BobLoblaw78 said:
The only one I thought was wolfy was pippy. And I didn't want to think that since she modded the last game. And now I am glad I didn't b/c it looks like she isn't (or she is putting on a good act).
Click to expand...
What changed your mind here?

I discarded what seems like a good wolfy role; my mistake. As AM pointed out, that tells you/everyone nothing about the role I kept.
 
Okay, I'm going to clear up chaos's claim because it's driving me nuts.

He's saying every time he protects, he has a 50% chance to kill himself instead of protecting anyone. The ability must be used nightly.
 
Is this right? Flushy's format looks weird and I feel more comfortable this way.

sunshine (1) - AM
Cray (2) - chaos, Zenge
Ms P (0) -
alissa (2) - cray, MsP
Chaos (1) - bob
paws (2) - april, sunshine
pip (1) - Dubz
Dubz (1) - Pippy
vis (1) - paws
bob (1) - vis
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
50K
vampyrica
vampyrica
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
86K
samac
samac
Top