Game Thread: Meats's Reading List: WWhat I Read in 2019

[PippyPony]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Why are you wolf reading dubz?

Honestly a lot of it is feels surrounding her reads. Up until today I have disagreed with most of her reads and I feel like her early game pushes were insubstantial somehow.

Plus she can be as grumpy about this as she wants, but I really did not like the comment about how wolves would have known doggo wasn't a power role and then claimed she got that from a retrospective hunt for power role hints. I forget what game it was, but at one point a long time ago, she slipped up on a tiny timeline thing just like that (something to do with noticing something about Jil?) and it was the only indication she was a wolf. It got dropped, she won.

 

[PippyPony]

@mizchiefmanaged you can talk now, so defend yourself. I'm not doing it anymore 😛

I'm glad you have learned from experience 😉

 

[Coopah]

I don't know how we can be sure about whether he would've subbed or not since he was awol for 24+ hours. Regardless, my point is he's not cutthroat for miz. I don't see how "yes, she's a wolf but I won't say anything to anyone" and "nah I'm going to not go after her because it'll make her happy" are any different.

Ok agree to disagree

 

[Coopah]

I'm glad you have learned from experience 😉

I'm not sure what you mean by this?

 

[PippyPony]

Second question, why are you village reading Ms P? I can see a neutral but honestly she hasn't given anyone enough to accurately read her. I don't really see how holding her vote makes sense villager or wolf. Is that the only thing you're going on?

I have her on the low end of village -- most of her posts made me lean her village, her early vote on D1 + her focus on kill targets took away a couple of those village points.

I think she has posted a decent amount of content though so I'm not sure where people are getting this thing about not enough having to go off of.

 

[PippyPony]

I'm not sure what you mean by this?

I am teasing you about the time you decided to defend Miz vs letting her defend herself

 

[kaydubs]

Official I Can Stop Reading Whenever I Want, Okay?! Tally

MsP (4) - SAR, dolph, alissa, Barks
BC (2) - jmoose, Pippy
miz (1) - Dubz

7/14 voting
Missing: all the rest of y'all

Spoiler

Lynch deadline 7:00 PM PST/8:00 PM MST/9:00 PM CST/10:00 PM EST

 

[Animal Midwife]

I have her on the low end of village -- most of her posts made me lean her village, her early vote on D1 + her focus on kill targets took away a couple of those village points.

I think she has posted a decent amount of content though so I'm not sure where people are getting this thing about not enough having to go off of.

I have no problem with her post amount. It's her reads I want answers for especially if she plans to continue voting <60 minutes to EOD.

 

[PippyPony]

I have no problem with her post amount. It's her reads I want answers for especially if she plans to continue voting <60 minutes to EOD.

Earlier in the game people jumped on her for voting early lol

 

[Animal Midwife]

Earlier in the game people jumped on her for voting early lol

I didn't though because that's NAI, at worst, as always. It only matters to me for how long they sat on said early vote and for what reasons. I can't help it if others are wrong about what pro-village behavior is smh

 

[Coopah]

Well let's have some fun eh? Since Jboo isn't viable yet and this will give me info

Lynch BC

 

[genny]

lynch barks

 

[genny]

I would like us to not lynch ms p today. I will change my vote to save her if I have to.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I would like us to not lynch ms p today. I will change my vote to save her if I have to.

How do you feel about BC?

 

[PippyPony]

I would like us to not lynch ms p today. I will change my vote to save her if I have to.

Ehhhh

I don't necessarily disagree, but can I ask why so strong? (Not like, specifics, just generally)

 

[BigCats]

This false dichotomy of lynch bandwagons is kind of irritating. I just ISO'd MsP and, guess what, she sounds completely village. I'm not sure whose post exactly influenced me to rethink that but I'm annoyed at myself for allowing myself to be swayed by others' opinions. Back to my actual wolfy candidates.

lynch jboo

 

[Coopah]

@Ms Procrastinator I'd still love an answer to your thoughts on BC given that abilities do not correlate with affiliation.

 

[BigCats]

Johnnaboo (wolf-leaning/neutral)— I have been getting sketch vibes from her but I have been trying to ignore these feelings somewhat since I was assuming I was being influenced by her consistent lynch voting me. I’m waiting for more concrete evidence to confirm.

BC (wolf leaning/neutral)— she hasn’t done anything suspicious but I'm putting her here since I don't want to forget that when she was a wolf in the noob game, she was able to slip by us. Rather not make the same mistake again by trusting her. Gonna be on the safer side and say she is wolf leaning/neutral.

miz - (wolf-leaning/neutral) Much more toward the neutral than the wolf-leaning on the scale. Unsure how I feel about miz, as someone of course close to Nav, pushing for a Nav vote. Nav would be the ideal person to read miz and miz would be the ideal person to read Nav I would assume (sorry I contributed in some degree to the lynch; by the time I was on there was little possibility of changing the tide; additionally, I was unsure my feelings on MsP).

I think I tried asking @mizchiefmanaged for her read on BC yesterday when she was silenced so I would like to revisit this question assuming that she is not silenced today.

alissa (Neutral) - I’ve read her as frustrated villager for D1/D2. Need to ISO to see if she leans some other way for me.

MsP (???) - I don’t think I’ve played with her as villager only as wolf. She does seem different than how I remember her playing as a wolf but that doesn’t mean much.

Pippy (Neutral)

dolphin (neutral) - was annoyed that people were saying they don’t talk enough D1 which I read as slightly villager. I expect wolves to get scared from players calling them out for such things and just talking more to satisfy.


SAR (neutral)

Barkley (Neutral) - she seems nice in PM lol we shared pictures of roosters which of course is the best way to figure out if someone is a wolf.

WildZoo (Neutral)

Coopah (Neutral)

AM (neutral/village-leaning) - she seems the same as how she was in Basics when she was village.

- genny (village): general feel and comments seem village to me and especially that she spoke about the NK choices being on brand for what she would do seems like a strange post if you are a wolf.

So, when I voted to lynch jboo the other day with the caveat that yes, I was aware they'd already said they had no internet but that they were posting several times so I thought it was still a fair vote, I got called out for being "hedgy", but no one's going to remark on this at all? We've had what, four days of play so far, and yet Wondering only has three hedgy wolf reads and only one actual village read? (And, not to harp on it, but saying I'm a potential wolf read because I was a wolf before is just plain lazy. Lynch me for valid reasoning, sure. But it's such a cop-out to say that I must lean wolf because of a role I was RNGed in a prior game.) Interesting use of selective listening going on here.

 

[BigCats]

Well let's have some fun eh? Since Jboo isn't viable yet and this will give me info

Lynch BC

You could always try to make it viable. Pretty weak to just bandwagon onto my lynch while simultaneously saying you'd like to lynch someone else. You were blasting jboo last night for telling you that they wanted to join the Nav lynch but were just going to stay with their vote, and here you are doing the same thing.

 

[PippyPony]

I have to say, I don't have Barks as all that wolfy but activity seems to pick up a bit when she is put on the board

 

[Coopah]

You could always try to make it viable. Pretty weak to just bandwagon onto my lynch while simultaneously saying you'd like to lynch someone else. You were blasting jboo last night for telling you that they wanted to join the Nav lynch but were just going to stay with their vote, and here you are doing the same thing.

Lol no I've already voiced my suspicions of you, and I'm not afraid of looking sketchy. Good aggressive defense though I like it!

 

[genny]

How do you feel about BC?

I am not opposed to a BC lynch. But part of me feels like it would be great for wolves if they could get the villager with 2 votes lynched instead of having to NK. So I’m not really in any rush to lynch BC just in case she is a villager.

 

[genny]

Ehhhh

I don't necessarily disagree, but can I ask why so strong? (Not like, specifics, just generally)

I want people to consider others, so I have to say it strongly. A shrug isn’t really going to move any votes.

 

[PippyPony]

I want people to consider others, so I have to say it strongly. A shrug isn’t really going to move any votes.

Ok, I just want to make sure it's not based on some kind of role thing, because if it is, then I have multiple problems with that and will likely switch to either you or her.

 

[PippyPony]

...I don't know why I thought threatening to switch to you or the person you're saying not to lynch would get you to change your answer lol

Can I be a wolfy book instead? Like that one in Harry Potter that chomps people unless you pet it first

 

[BigCats]

Dude this is like the 3rd day in a row you have sheeped my vote and it's starting to get creepy.

Uh, are you sure you're remembering correctly? Because the day before this post, you were camping out on WZ Island, population 1, which you migrated to from the Peninsula of Miz, also population 1.

 

[PippyPony]

Uh, are you sure you're remembering correctly? Because the day before this post, you were camping out on WZ Island, population 1, which you migrated to from the Peninsula of Miz, also population 1.

I was talking about previous days, and not just votes.

 

[BigCats]

I was talking about previous days, and not just votes.

Wow interesting how exactly 0 of that is reflected in your post

 

[BigCats]

Ok, I just want to make sure it's not based on some kind of role thing, because if it is, then I have multiple problems with that and will likely switch to either you or her.

Anyone else hear that sound? That's the sound of a wolf sniffing for PRs.

 

[PippyPony]

Anyone else hear that sound? That's the sound of a wolf sniffing for PRs.

I am an equal opportunity sniffer

 

[kaydubs]

Official I Can Stop Reading Whenever I Want, Okay?! Tally

MsP (4) - SAR, dolph, alissa, Barks
BC (3) - jmoose, Pippy, Coops
miz (1) - Dubz
Barks (1) - genny
jmoose (2) - BC

10/14 voting
Missing: all the rest of y'all

Spoiler

Lynch deadline 7:00 PM PST/8:00 PM MST/9:00 PM CST/10:00 PM EST

 

[Coopah]

I have to say, I don't have Barks as all that wolfy but activity seems to pick up a bit when she is put on the board

Are you implying one vote brings out the wolfy pals to distract? That seems a bit far fetched

 

[PippyPony]

No but seriously there are reasons why I have concerns with genny's statement if it is based on role claim stuff instead of on something like post content, not least of which is that I feel like roles are an easy thing to try and hide behind this game

 

[PippyPony]

Are you implying one vote brings out the wolfy pals to distract? That seems a bit far fetched

I dunno, kittykittymeowmeow got spicier right afterwards

 

[Coopah]

No but seriously there are reasons why I have concerns with genny's statement if it is based on role claim stuff instead of on something like post content, not least of which is that I feel like roles are an easy thing to try and hide behind this game

Why? Would you like to explain for the rest of us instead of just ominously hinting?

 

[PippyPony]

Why? Would you like to explain for the rest of us instead of just ominously hinting?

Not really

 

[PippyPony]

Donde esta la biblioteca mizchiefmanaged

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Donde esta la biblioteca mizchiefmanaged

You glitching today pips?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Hi guys I’m crazy busy today I’m so sorry I’m not an absolutely terrible lynch but you’re not getting a wolf. I’ll be on while I can but it might be a while.

Really pissed at village Nav for pulling this ****.

 

[PippyPony]

You glitching today pips?

I'm not putting that in a spoiler, it's too good. Meats can deal

 

[PippyPony]

And oh looky that, not even tagged

 

[PippyPony]

Really pissed at village Nav for pulling this ****.

Yes I can imagine that is frustrating lol

 

[Coopah]

And oh looky that, not even tagged

Nah but I did PM her. She said basically the same thing to me

 

[Coopah]

Ok I'm bored again. Yo BC is your defense just going to go after all the people on your lynch as wolfy?

On another note, besides jboo do you have anyone else as top wolf suspect and why? Can you put together potential packs. If jboo flips village what does that do to the rest of your reads?

 

[Barkley13]

You glitching today pips?

You got any defense today?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Why have I come back to Spanish!Pippy and not reads!MsP

 

[Coopah]

You glitching today pips?

I've asked about 3 million times please ANSWER ME

 

[Coopah]

Also who's silenced today?

 

[PippyPony]

Also who's silenced today?

Probably no one because night was cancelled

 

[Animal Midwife]

Also, not a big fan of chocolate, but celebrating my sister's birthday and Oreo cake is hella awesome.