Hunger Games Redux WW sign ups

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
Lupin21 said:
You may have missed a rather telling post by Rogert...
Click to expand...

Other than the claim to have rezzed SnS?

That is a great story. But it seems kinda short. Is there more?

I've been told not to tell too much. And that open communication is critical. So many conflicting messages. If I know that at least one of four is a wolf, should I share all the names, or not? Please advise the noob mayor what to do with intel that he has?
 
Okay, reasoning this out...

It would be ballsy to claim to have been responsible for the resurrection if one wasn't, since someone else could counterclaim.

The resurrection might not have been any tribute's doing, but a gift from the modgods.

Unlynch Rogert, Lynch WZ for feels, for pointing at Rogert, and because reasons.
 
Promethean said:
Other than the claim to have rezzed SnS?

That is a great story. But it seems kinda short. Is there more?

I've been told not to tell too much. And that open communication is critical. So many conflicting messages. If I know that at least one of four is a wolf, should I share all the names, or not? Please advise the noob mayor what to do with intel that he has?
Click to expand...
It is just that at least in most games...actually, I think every game I have played, rezzing people is a village only power. Also, if he was attempting a fib, he would be called on it as soon as the person who did bring back SnS checked in. So I don't see how the wolf card would be flipped with him. Possible in some alternate universe I suppose, but highly unlikely.

Also, I think I misunderstood your original comment. If you are saying you have a list and one of them is a wolf, then I would go ahead and share it as it gives those with abilities a narrowed list to use actions on. We can try and sort it out even further probably depending on what people know about each of those players.
 
sorasea said:
Welcome back, SnS!! 🙂

Do you know anything about your resurrection?


He's been piquing my interest, too, but why so sure? Do you have anything solid beyond feels?
Click to expand...
Nope.

And ok
Unlynch rogert lynch romo
 
Promethean said:
Other than the claim to have rezzed SnS?

That is a great story. But it seems kinda short. Is there more?

I've been told not to tell too much. And that open communication is critical. So many conflicting messages. If I know that at least one of four is a wolf, should I share all the names, or not? Please advise the noob mayor what to do with intel that he has?
Click to expand...

Resurrection is usually a villager ability. Though wolves have been given that power before, it is much more common for a villager to possess that capability.

If you have information that points to a possible wolf, yes that would be good to share.
 
Lupin21 said:
It is just that at least in most games...actually, I think every game I have played, rezzing people is a village only power. Also, if he was attempting a fib, he would be called on it as soon as the person who did bring back SnS checked in. So I don't see how the wolf card would be flipped with him. Possible in some alternate universe I suppose, but highly unlikely.

Also, I think I misunderstood your original comment. If you are saying you have a list and one of them is a wolf, then I would go ahead and share it as it gives those with abilities a narrowed list to use actions on. We can try and sort it out even further probably depending on what people know about each of those players.
Click to expand...
Actually this might be one of those things that if someone has the ability to check in with you, closed door dealing might be better. Eh, I don't know. Others can chime in with their thoughts.
 
Promethean said:
Other than the claim to have rezzed SnS?

That is a great story. But it seems kinda short. Is there more?

I've been told not to tell too much. And that open communication is critical. So many conflicting messages. If I know that at least one of four is a wolf, should I share all the names, or not? Please advise the noob mayor what to do with intel that he has?
Click to expand...
Another vote for sharing the wolf info

Promethean said:
Okay, reasoning this out...

It would be ballsy to claim to have been responsible for the resurrection if one wasn't, since someone else could counterclaim.

The resurrection might not have been any tribute's doing, but a gift from the modgods.

Unlynch Rogert, Lynch WZ for feels, for pointing at Rogert, and because reasons.
Click to expand...
I wasn't the only person suspicious of Rogert...and also, I'm a villager. As has been pointed out. Multiple times.
 
Wildzoo
MadJack
Rogert
that_redhead

One of those is a wolf. At least one. The information isn't specific as to whether more than one might be.
 
Time to find out if someone in MadZoo is a gigantic doodyface liar.

unlynch Romo, lynch trh
 
I should also add that I was able to pick the list. It wasn't random.

I needed to cast a wide enough net to find at least one, but not so wide that it would be useless info.

I chose two that I felt relatively safe with, one that I wasn't sure about, and one that I have already cast aspersions toward.
 
I like the cut of your jib Rogert!

Oooo.. ooo.. am I allowed to maybe be right about my district mate now? Vindication, is that you on the horizon? How I have sought after thee!

Unlynch wz, lynch TRH
 
Promethean said:
Wildzoo
MadJack
Rogert
that_redhead

One of those is a wolf. At least one. The information isn't specific as to whether more than one might be.
Click to expand...

Well you can take me and MJ off the list. I won't reveal his role without his permission, but I'm Boggs, military leader for Distric 13, vanilla villager. He is also a villager per the role info he gave me, which was Day 1 and I think was very believable. So there ya go.

lynch trh
 
I'm sticking with this vote, btw. Sorry for being a little waffley. I just... I really think this is the right one.
 
...wait a minute. Promo is convinced that TRH is a wolf, because of her silence? Even though we explained a very legit reason why she could be a silent villager?
Rogert said:
Time to find out if someone in MadZoo is a gigantic doodyface liar.

unlynch Romo, lynch trh
Click to expand...
And you're suspicious of someone in Madzoo, so you vote to lynch someone not in Madzoo.
I must be missing something here.
unlynch whomever, lynch Rogert
 
Gwenevre said:
...wait a minute. Promo is convinced that TRH is a wolf, because of her silence? Even though we explained a very legit reason why she could be a silent villager?

And you're suspicious of someone in Madzoo, so you vote to lynch someone not in Madzoo.
I must be missing something here.
unlynch whomever, lynch Rogert
Click to expand...
I'm not suspicious of MadZoo. Well, I am, but only in the sense that I suspicious of everyone in WW. MJ and WZ are both vouching for each other. If trh turns out to not be a wolf, we know one of them is lying.
 
Gwenevre said:
...wait a minute. Promo is convinced that TRH is a wolf, because of her silence? Even though we explained a very legit reason why she could be a silent villager?

And you're suspicious of someone in Madzoo, so you vote to lynch someone not in Madzoo.
I must be missing something here.
unlynch whomever, lynch Rogert
Click to expand...
Read the thread. He was given a list of 4 possible wolves so we are voting from it
 
Thanks for the new variant of my name, btw. I like "Promo" so much more than "ProMeth." I know that no one gets to pick their own nicknames, but I am pretty AntiMeth, actually.

It isn't just silence that made me question TRH. It was silence in the setting of a conversation which had begun and was abruptly shut down with no explanation at all. It seemed off.

So, I included TRH on my differential.
 
That makes more sense. I must have missed where Promo obtained or made his list.
I still have more feels for Rogert than TRH, so my vote stays.
 
Lynch TRH.

I role revealed to WZ literally a couple minutes into the game, before we knew anything about roles, that there were so many vanillas, etc. Figured I had nothing to lose since I have no ability to begin with.
 
Promethean said:
Thanks for the new variant of my name, btw. I like "Promo" so much more than "ProMeth." I know that no one gets to pick their own nicknames, but I am pretty AntiMeth, actually.

It isn't just silence that made me question TRH. It was silence in the setting of a conversation which had begun and was abruptly shut down with no explanation at all. It seemed off.

So, I included TRH on my differential.
Click to expand...
TP disliked being bestowed the initials that describe toilet paper, I had to deal with being MJ and an endless slew of Michael Jackson references, you get to deal with being Prometh. It's just how things work, unless you're LIS, who can also go by LeTitsNow, because alternate punctuation.
 
Mad Jack said:
TP disliked being bestowed the initials that describe toilet paper, I had to deal with being MJ and an endless slew of Michael Jackson references, you get to deal with being Prometh. It's just how things work, unless you're LIS, who can also go by LeTitsNow, because alternate punctuation.
Click to expand...

I get that. It is why I didn't complain about being ProMeth. I understand the rule, that you may name yourself, but your friends rename you as the please, no exceptions.

I was commenting with gratitude for the new variant, not even hope that the one I didn't like would go away.
 
I'll go with lynch Rogert although pretty sure I'm not getting out of this one.

Although Promo would be my most suspicious person for jumping all over me repeatedly, I don't think he began the game as a wolf.
 
Unlynch TRH.

Lynch Rog.

Not sure if I buy it, but I'm going back to bed for now so whatever, I'll see how I feel about it in an hour.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
16K
supershorty
supershorty
WildZoo
Supernatural WW Shenanigans Part 5 Sign Ups [OPEN] - Game Start Sept 12th (tentative)
Replies
16
Views
85
samac
samac
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
kaydubs
WW sign ups April 2024
Replies
47
Views
2K
kaydubs
kaydubs
JaggedJimmyJay
  • Poll Poll
pWWants are people too [WW sign-ups]
Replies
33
Views
2K
kaydubs
kaydubs
Top