Ladies and Gentlemen... a Noob WW Game Thread!

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
serher said:
Any ideas as to why those two villagers were targeted last night? Clearly killerleaf had an especially valuable ability, but I'm not sure why the wolves would have known that...?
Click to expand...
there potentially could be a wolf seer of some sort that found out N1
 
Bottle of Bear said:
Unless there's a wolf seer who found her before she found them.
Click to expand...

ninja.

Assuming there is a reason there's been an animal each night, we only know a few of them. That means each individual animal player has a high probability of being targeted.
 
Since the first day, I have placed myself in grave danger by sharing my thoughts with my fellow performers.

Despite being the target of a frightful paralyzing attack two nights ago, I have continued to make every effort possible to caution my fellow villagers to remain vigilant.

Since that fateful night, I, too dearly fear for my own safety.
 
Yeah, just to play devil's advocate, I also don't think it makes much sense for a wolf to be openly accusing 3-4 people (unless they were in deep trouble, like hyge was yesterday). So you just puzzle me DrS lol
 
serher said:
Yeah, just to play devil's advocate, I also don't think it makes much sense for a wolf to be openly accusing 3-4 people (unless they were in deep trouble, like hyge was yesterday). So you just puzzle me DrS lol
Click to expand...

I agree with you. To me, it wouldn't make that much sense for a wolf to be this openly confusing/cryptic..but maybe that's the point? Hiding in plain sight? Since none of us can figure out what she means, we won't bother lynching her because we can't tell if shes a villager or a wolf?
 
kittenmittens524 said:
I agree with you. To me, it wouldn't make that much sense for a wolf to be this openly confusing/cryptic..but maybe that's the point? Hiding in plain sight? Since none of us can figure out what she means, we won't bother lynching her because we can't tell if shes a villager or a wolf?
Click to expand...

Seems plausible. I'm totally confused about Doctor-S. Does anyone know if there can be (or often is) more than one chaos?
 
TrashPanda said:
Seems plausible. I'm totally confused about Doctor-S. Does anyone know if there can be (or often is) more than one chaos?
Click to expand...

I was thinking that as well..or maybe a character that isn't allowed to speak directly? sort of how cdoconn had to communicate through images, maybe Dr. S has to communicate through these ridiculous riddles :bang:
 
Doctor-S said:
You have often wanted to kill me in the past and so have your nefarious cronies - that is, SAR and kittenmittens.
Click to expand...
giphy.gif

When in doubt, always go back to The Holy Grail
 
maybe anyone with a role could say what their role is without revealing if they have an ability? that way we all know who is who for the most part, but it wouldn't make anyone more of a target for the wolves if they don't know if you have an ability
 
kittenmittens524 said:
maybe anyone with a role could say what their role is without revealing if they have an ability? that way we all know who is who for the most part, but it wouldn't make anyone more of a target for the wolves if they don't know if you have an ability
Click to expand...

unless you can tell from the role if someone has an ability..I'm not actually sure about that
 
serher said:
I see what you are going for kittenmittens, but I would refrain from that before we figure out why one animal and one human has been killed both nights.
Click to expand...

oh right, you're right. I keep forgetting that we have figured out almost nothing lol
 
kittenmittens524 said:
I was thinking that as well..or maybe a character that isn't allowed to speak directly? sort of how cdoconn had to communicate through images, maybe Dr. S has to communicate through these ridiculous riddles :bang:
Click to expand...

That's an interesting thought. She described an attack (or attempted attack) that wasn't in the write-up. Maybe that's a riddle somehow? Or a dream?
 
kittenmittens524 said:
oh right, you're right. I keep forgetting that we have figured out almost nothing lol
Click to expand...
how are you forgetting that we have nothing really figured out? are you trying to keep up with us not knowing anything? do you know more than us? wolves are the informed minority in this game.
for this statement alone, I'm going with
lynch kittenmittens
 
TrashPanda said:
That's an interesting thought. She described an attack (or attempted attack) that wasn't in the write-up. Maybe that's a riddle somehow? Or a dream?
Click to expand...

Well since it was the first night, items that are sent out by people with abilities aren't used until the second night right? SO no one could have done anything to protect her
 
raf2769 said:
how are you forgetting that we have nothing really figured out? are you trying to keep up with us not knowing anything? do you know more than us? wolves are the informed minority in this game.
for this statement alone, I'm going with
lynch kittenmittens
Click to expand...

It was just a statement of frustration, that everything in this game just leads to more questions. We still have questions from the write up from the first night about Dr. S that we haven't made any progress on, and the write up this morning was really vague
 
kittenmittens524 said:
Well since it was the first night, items that are sent out by people with abilities aren't used until the second night right? SO no one could have done anything to protect her
Click to expand...
I don't think people with abilities send items to others, I think they just show up from what I understand. And I think that whoever protected her could've done so on the first night. I'm pretty sure items and abilities are two separate things.
 
SkiOtter said:
I don't think people with abilities send items to others, I think they just show up from what I understand. And I think that whoever protected her could've done so on the first night. I'm pretty sure items and abilities are two separate things.
Click to expand...

oh okay, I see what you're saying. So a person with an ability could choose a person at random to protect each night?
 
That's the point of the game, an uninformed majority (village) against an informed minority (wolves). The point of being village is to have nothing figured out and to work at figuring things out. For those of us working to figure things out, it's hard to "forget" that we have nothing figured out.
 
kittenmittens524 said:
Well since it was the first night, items that are sent out by people with abilities aren't used until the second night right? SO no one could have done anything to protect her
Click to expand...

So do you think she's just lying?

Speaking of lying...

We don't know who to trust, but we do know who not to trust- hyge. The first day she voted to lynch jmo, but then yesterday said she doubted she was a wolf.

Here's hyge's predictions:

hygebeorht said:
Whoops meant to do the @'s but forgot so here's my "edit" (since we can't edit)

People I currently doubt are wolves: @SnowshoeDog143 , @Karabiner13 , @sheltemed (sorry about your doggie :c), @raf2769 , @SARdoghandler, @jmo1012, @wallydo. I may be wrong but I'm not likely to vote for any of them either at this point.
Click to expand...

I highly doubt they're all wolves, but as Chaos, hyge would have tried to convince us that wolves are villagers and vice versa.
 
serher said:
Yeah, just to play devil's advocate, I also don't think it makes much sense for a wolf to be openly accusing 3-4 people (unless they were in deep trouble, like hyge was yesterday). So you just puzzle me DrS lol
Click to expand...

Not saying this is the case here but in the Child's Play Noob WW game, there was a wolf seer that role revealed as a seer early on. They said they were a villager and were believed. Far down the road suspicions were raised and the villagers finally lynched her and she was a wolf.

kittenmittens524 said:
maybe anyone with a role could say what their role is without revealing if they have an ability? that way we all know who is who for the most part, but it wouldn't make anyone more of a target for the wolves if they don't know if you have an ability
Click to expand...

definitely not a good idea as raf said. Statements like these look like a wolf fishing for information
 
TrashPanda said:
So do you think she's just lying?

Speaking of lying...

We don't know who to trust, but we do know who not to trust- hyge. The first day she voted to lynch jmo, but then yesterday said she doubted she was a wolf.

Here's hyge's predictions:



I highly doubt they're all wolves, but as Chaos, hyge would have tried to convince us that wolves are villagers and vice versa.
Click to expand...

I did, but SkiOtter clarified, I was confusing items and abilities, so now I am just back to brainstorming who could've protected her.
 
Karabiner13 said:
Not saying this is the case here but in the Child's Play Noob WW game, there was a wolf seer that role revealed as a seer early on. They said they were a villager and were believed. Far down the road suspicions were raised and the villagers finally lynched her and she was a wolf.



definitely not a good idea as raf said. Statements like these look like a wolf fishing for information
Click to expand...

I just thought that if there was a doubling up of identities, or someone had a role that didn't sound convincing it could allude to who was a wolf. Since no one would be saying what their abilities are, it wouldn't make them more of a target for wolves
 
TrashPanda said:
So do you think she's just lying?

Speaking of lying...

We don't know who to trust, but we do know who not to trust- hyge. The first day she voted to lynch jmo, but then yesterday said she doubted she was a wolf.

Here's hyge's predictions:



I highly doubt they're all wolves, but as Chaos, hyge would have tried to convince us that wolves are villagers and vice versa.
Click to expand...

from my experience, wolves and chaos don't actually know who each other are. I'm wondering if that was a list hyge made of just random people. The wolves would be searching to kill chaos just like villagers would be, and chaos doesn't really care who wins (unless they have a win condition) and they just try to make it to the end. At that point, hyge was up for lynch but still had plenty of time to turn the lynch a different way. It's possible she was just making a random list to gain credibility and look like a villager.
 
kittenmittens524 said:
oh okay, I see what you're saying. So a person with an ability could choose a person at random to protect each night?
Click to expand...
If they had a protector ability I believe yes. (Though, that could potentially be what paralyzed her after N1)
Cdoconn's ability was to pm someone nightly, which she was able to do night 1. So depends on the ability what they can do with it.
 
:meh::meh::meh::meh::meh:
kittenmittens524 said:
maybe anyone with a role could say what their role is without revealing if they have an ability? that way we all know who is who for the most part, but it wouldn't make anyone more of a target for the wolves if they don't know if you have an ability
Click to expand...
This one's trying to break the game
:nono::nono::nono::nono::nono::nono:
 
raf2769 said:
from my experience, wolves and chaos don't actually know who each other are. I'm wondering if that was a list hyge made of just random people. The wolves would be searching to kill chaos just like villagers would be, and chaos doesn't really care who wins (unless they have a win condition) and they just try to make it to the end. At that point, hyge was up for lynch but still had plenty of time to turn the lynch a different way. It's possible she was just making a random list to gain credibility and look like a villager.
Click to expand...

That's a good point. I agree the wolves would want to kill chaos too, but keeping chaos would probably help them at this point as there are more villagers than wolves. (Hyge would be more likely to turn a villager vote against a villager than a wolf vote against a wolf.) Then again, like you said, the wolves probably didn't know hyge was chaos until she basically admitted it last night.

SkiOtter said:
If they had a protector ability I believe yes. (Though, that could potentially be what paralyzed her after N1)
Cdoconn's ability was to pm someone nightly, which she was able to do night 1. So depends on the ability what they can do with it.
Click to expand...

So the protector ability could have also paralyzed her? I know Doctor-S said she was attacked by one individual and saved by another, but maybe she was just incapacitated by one so she couldn't act and no one could act on her.
 
TrashPanda said:
Seems plausible. I'm totally confused about Doctor-S. Does anyone know if there can be (or often is) more than one chaos?
Click to expand...

Trilt said:
The juggler was always a little weird, but staring at balls for hours and hours, practicing your very individual art will sort of... do that to you.
​
But just never seemed to "click" with everyone else, much to his chagrin.
Click to expand...

I asked my mentor about chaos roles. They said that if it's not an individual and it is a chaos team, it is usually 2 people. However, the write-up makes me think there is only 1 chaos role in this game
 
Karabiner13 said:
I asked my mentor about chaos roles. They said that if it's not an individual and it is a chaos team, it is usually 2 people. However, the write-up makes me think there is only 1 chaos role in this game
Click to expand...

Huh. Interesting. "Very individual art" does seem to imply that. Either that or there's only one juggler, which doesn't seem like information worth mentioning. Ok, hopefully there was only one chaos and now there's none!
 
Doctor-S said:
- I am still seeking the truth; and I did a lot of methodical thinking last night: WHO-WHO-WHO are the killers?

- It has always been a trait of mine to ask questions and to seek the truth (by sifting through chaos and paranoia and analyzing the facts).

- For that reason, I know it would be unwise to cast my first lynch vote impulsively (and possibly lose a valuable villager).

- Instead, it is logical to assume the killer wolves want the villagers to become panic, paranoid, run amok, and react impulsively.

- Here is my advice to my fellow villagers: do not react impulsively. Choose carefully.

- In case anyone is curious, I do not have four paws. In fact, I have NO paws at all; and I do NOT have any sharp cuspids.

- So far, I believe @Karabiner13 , @LyraGardenia, @mmmdreamerz, @kittenmittens524, @raf2769, @wallydo, @hygebeorht are probably "villagers" at this time.
Click to expand...

okay if you take this comment and the rural description from this morning in tandem, Dr. S could be an owl right? because the explanation from this morning talked about the woods and the only wise circus creature that says "who" would be an owl. So maybe something from this morning has to do with Dr. S, and maybe the paralysis? cause the write up discussed how calm and quiet it was.
 
TrashPanda said:
So the protector ability could have also paralyzed her? I know Doctor-S said she was attacked by one individual and saved by another, but maybe she was just incapacitated by one so she couldn't act and no one could act on her.
Click to expand...

I don't know for sure if that's what paralyzed her, probably not, but it's a thought. Potentially someone thought she had a night ability and wanted to stop her from using it, not sure.
 
I know, I know, it's not WW without some gender confusion! lol

editted because I forgot the word not the first time...
 
Are the ANY men in the vet forums?? I've always had male vets, but is the gender balance this skewed it vet schools?
 
raf2769 said:
(I'm a she!)
Click to expand...

(Sorry, raf does sound rather mannish)

Gonna vote to lynch DocS.
I highly doubt she's a wolf but she could be chaos based on her posts which in the beginning sounded like she was an important villager but have since become more of a ranting style which is why I don't feel comfortable defending her.
I feel like kitten is a villager taking heat for a simple noob mistake so I'm not going to throw my vote her way unless it becomes obvious she's something else
 
So I feel like a DrS lynch will at least answer some people's questions. And then based on the results of that lynch maybe we can start talking about other things other than DrS. I still lean towards her being village, which is why I won't vote for her, but I do understand everyone else wanting to lynch her.
 
kittenmittens524 said:
maybe anyone with a role could say what their role is without revealing if they have an ability? that way we all know who is who for the most part, but it wouldn't make anyone more of a target for the wolves if they don't know if you have an ability
Click to expand...

Hmm kittens I am thinking about changing my lynch vote over this comment..

I don't think DrS is a wolf. She might be a chaos, but if she is, there is a better chance she's going to be on our side vs the wolves right now as the wolves are killing us two at a time and we haven't killed any of them. She talks in riddles and seems to be giving away her role which makes me think she wouldn't be a wolf (too different and always getting threatened to be lynched - wolves more would want to blend in) I really think we should go for a wolf this time and if DrS is a chaos (which someone already said there's a good chance hyge was the only one "lonely") then she will be fine with that because chaotics don't care about who we lynch as long as they stay alive. So if anyone has anymore theories on who would be a wolf that would be great.
 
raf2769 said:
So I feel like a DrS lynch will at least answer some people's questions. And then based on the results of that lynch maybe we can start talking about other things other than DrS. I still lean towards her being village, which is why I won't vote for her, but I do understand everyone else wanting to lynch her.
Click to expand...

I'm torn, honestly. Raf, I have internally agreed with much of your strategizing this game. However, Dr. S is really throwing a bit of a wrench into plans for those looking for wolves and for that, once and for all (JK, I could waffle)... I vote...

Lynch DrS
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
2
Replies
86
Views
721
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
170
Views
11K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
Top