Ladies and Gentlemen... a Noob WW Game Thread!

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
serher said:
I have a weird feeling that DrS might be neutral. Anybody else thought about that? (apologies if this has already been discussed and I missed it; I will search the posts later) But that also wouldn't explain why wolves have tried to kill her. Unless they are unsure of her status as well. Or if the wolves seered her the first night and saw she was neutral, that might be why they haven't gone after her since.
Click to expand...

Interesting thought. I might agree with this actually. I forgot about neutrals.
 
At the great and wise Trilt's behest, I'm gonna throw this out there.

lynch SAR

Please, SAR, defend yourself and convince me otherwise.
 
hurtem&healem said:
At the great and wise Trilt's behest, I'm gonna throw this out there.

lynch SAR

Please, SAR, defend yourself and convince me otherwise.
Click to expand...

In what way would you like a defense? Role and ability reveal? Is there any other defense that I could offer that wod be believable? Just wanting to make sure that you do want another villager to out themselves.

Sent from my LG G4
 
Officialish Lynch Tally
Dr-S (4) - Panda, Lyra, Coopah, SARDog
Mmmdream (1) - Snowy
SARDog (3) - Karabou, Serher, H&H

8/17 accounted for.

Deadline 9PM EST; ~1.5 hours remaining.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
I don't have time or the will to find the quote but jmo said "wait! I would know if I was a wolf right?"
Click to expand...

Ah, yes, I remember. And we thought maybe she was pretending to know so little (or I did) but she came back to say she really had no idea. Ok, thanks for that.
 
wallydo said:
Why is everyone going for SAR other than lack of game solving?
Click to expand...

Also curious about this. Remember how we lynched AM last night...?

I don't think it's an awful reason, but I think there are other names to add to the list of non-game-solvers.
 
TrashPanda said:
A lot of us have questions about you, and if you're answer them instead of repeating yourself, that might help keep us all alive. So if you have any information, this would be a good time to share it.
Click to expand...
TrashPanda, I would like to remind you that you voted to lynch a villager (LetItSnow).

LIS was a GOOD villager.

So your vote has already caused us to lose a GOOD villager. [see Post #561]
 
SARdoghandler said:
I also think this is interesting. Sticking with my vote though as even if she is a neutral, it means she's not a villager
Click to expand...

Hmm why would you vote against her if you think shes neutral? That's like a waste of a wolf vote? Neutrals don't try to confuse people like chaos does (correct me if I'm wrong not terribly sure the difference between neutrals and chaos)
 
SARdoghandler said:
In what way would you like a defense? Role and ability reveal? Is there any other defense that I could offer that wod be believable? Just wanting to make sure that you do want another villager to out themselves.

Sent from my LG G4
Click to expand...

You could defend yourself by trying to convince people that someone else deserves to be lynched
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Hmm why would you vote against her if you think shes neutral? That's like a waste of a wolf vote? Neutrals don't try to confuse people like chaos does (correct me if I'm wrong not terribly sure the difference between neutrals and chaos)
Click to expand...

I agree with that too, why are you keeping your vote?
 
kittenmittens524 said:
You could defend yourself by trying to convince people that someone else deserves to be lynched
Click to expand...

I've been pretty clearly pro-lynch of Dr-S the past two days. Beyond that, I am not convinced of anyone's wolfiness. So this becomes rather diffucult as I'd rather not just throw a different villager under the bus to save myself

And re: possible neutral being a bad vote. I disagree. I find her posts only sow further confusion so believe it would be a good choice to try and figure out what is actually going on
 
kittenmittens524 said:
You could defend yourself by trying to convince people that someone else deserves to be lynched
Click to expand...

I would also be interested in why you are not a wolf.. you seem to have everything against DrS and not much more. Who else do YOU think is a wolf?
 
SARdoghandler said:
In what way would you like a defense? Role and ability reveal? Is there any other defense that I could offer that wod be believable? Just wanting to make sure that you do want another villager to out themselves.

Sent from my LG G4
Click to expand...
No, I obviously don't want you to reveal your role or ability. Idk, apparently this is how the game works. Read Trilt's post, and my mentor has told me the same multiple times.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
I would also be interested in why you are not a wolf.. you seem to have everything against DrS and not much more. Who else do YOU think is a wolf?
Click to expand...

I don't know. My gut still thinks that Dr-S is sketchy. Also have been on record for doubting BoB in the past. Like I said before, I don't want to throw another villager under the bus accidentally. But lynching me will be a villager. I can prove it through revealing what I have done for villagers so far in the game, but I'll hold that for now unless I'm about to be lynched
 
SARdoghandler said:
Lynching me will just get another villager gone. I guarantee I am a villager. If necessary, I can tell you all my role. But then I'll likely be killed overnight anyway
Click to expand...
serher said:
I will if people continue voting for you. But also, it's probably not game changing information and might put a target on my back.
Click to expand...
SARdoghandler said:
In what way would you like a defense? Role and ability reveal? Is there any other defense that I could offer that wod be believable? Just wanting to make sure that you do want another villager to out themselves.

Sent from my LG G4
Click to expand...

Slow your roles.

I'm not big on guarantees but I believe SAR. She hasn't done much to help solve but she also hasn't tried to lead us away.

I'm hesitant to use my vote on DocS because I don't believe she's wolf but raf suspected her enough to use one of her two assassin moves.
 
TrashPanda said:
You're incorrect. LIS was mod-killed.
Click to expand...

SARdoghandler said:
I don't know. My gut still thinks that Dr-S is sketchy. Also have been on record for doubting BoB in the past. Like I said before, I don't want to throw another villager under the bus accidentally. But lynching me will be a villager. I can prove it through revealing what I have done for villagers so far in the game, but I'll hold that for now unless I'm about to be lynched
Click to expand...

@SARdoghandler - I think these would be my exact words if I were in your position. It doesn't seem right to throw another potential villager under the cause just because you have to point a figure at somebody.

@TrashPanda - very good catch. It is because of this that I retract my statement from previously and tonight I choose to ...

Lynch Dr. S
 
wallydo said:
Hmm, yes, he was. Not very nice Dr. S.
Click to expand...
TrashPanda cast a vote to lynch LIS.

LIS (3) - kittenmittens, killerleaf, TrashPanda [i.e., see Post #561]

Later, the mods simply chose to eliminate LIS from the thread -- but NOT before TrashPanda had already cast a vote to lynch LIS and LIS was a harmless villager.
 
Officialish Lynch Tally
Dr-S (5) - Panda, Lyra, Coopah, SARDog, Wally
Mmmdream (1) - Snowy
SARDog (3) - Karabou, Serher, H&H

9/17 accounted for.

Deadline 9PM EST; 1 hour remaining.
 
wallydo said:
@SARdoghandler - I think these would be my exact words if I were in your position. It doesn't seem right to throw another potential villager under the cause just because you have to point a figure at somebody.

@TrashPanda - very good catch. It is because of this that I retract my statement from previously and tonight I choose to ...

Lynch Dr. S
Click to expand...
Once again ... and I repeat:

TrashPanda cast a vote to lynch LIS.

LIS (3) - kittenmittens, killerleaf, TrashPanda [i.e., see Post #561]

Later, the mods simply chose to eliminate LIS from the thread -- but NOT before TrashPanda had already cast a vote to lynch LIS ... and LIS was a harmless villager.
 
:bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored:
cbf8feafd0119c6ec8be823ccc72d23237edaf6dab037378850a2e5dd991ea3f.jpg

:bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored::bored:
 
Okay to create conversation: anyone have reasons to think Panda is/isn't a wolf. I have my suspions (I feel like I have to many suspions though) but I can't really find anything that stands out about her either way. We have to consider everyone so any evidence?
 
Guys sorry I will be back in about 15 minutes. I need to drive home (I know stupid reason). I will catch up then.
 
Dreams I thought mainly agreed with people and rehashed stuff. But someone can review her posts and see because she said she was being helpful and now I feel guilty for lynching her without much to go on. Also she tried to start up the I'm going to vote for the person who has talked least and I though AM did a good job at seeming not wolfy. But that is also a typical nookie action to want to do. I'm waffling now but I don't know who to. Dr's isn't guilty imo and SAR I'm not sure about but seemed legit.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Okay to create conversation: anyone have reasons to think Panda is/isn't a wolf. I have my suspions (I feel like I have to many suspions though) but I can't really find anything that stands out about her either way. We have to consider everyone so any evidence?
Click to expand...

Well according to DocS she voted for LIS. But so did kitten and killer and they turned out to be other villagers
 
TrashPanda said:
This sounds a lot like Chaos....
Click to expand...

TrashPanda said:
Can someone explain, quickly? Seems bad and I agree it would probably benefit wolves but I don't really know either.
Click to expand...

Panda did get us onto Hyge. She didn't end up voting for Hyge in the end. I'm wondering if it's due to the last minute scramble onto Hyge and this question of Panda's that went unanswered. Still sifting through
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Dreams I thought mainly agreed with people and rehashed stuff. But someone can review her posts and see because she said she was being helpful and now I feel guilty for lynching her without much to go on. Also she tried to start up the I'm going to vote for the person who has talked least and I though AM did a good job at seeming not wolfy. But that is also a typical nookie action to want to do. I'm waffling now but I don't know who to. Dr's isn't guilty imo and SAR I'm not sure about but seemed legit.
Click to expand...

If I had the energy, I would go through and quote all my posts where I presented a new idea/insight but I have about zero energy at this point and I feel super behind in this thread LOL.

Voting for AM yesterday was simply because she posted the least and I felt like we didn't have someone solid to vote for (as many people said). Obviously, it didn't work out but I was just trying to find some ground to start on.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Dreams I thought mainly agreed with people and rehashed stuff. But someone can review her posts and see because she said she was being helpful and now I feel guilty for lynching her without much to go on. Also she tried to start up the I'm going to vote for the person who has talked least and I though AM did a good job at seeming not wolfy. But that is also a typical nookie action to want to do. I'm waffling now but I don't know who to. Dr's isn't guilty imo and SAR I'm not sure about but seemed legit.
Click to expand...

No hard feelings. It's a game and we are all grasping for straws (even non-existent ones lol).
 
Bottle of Bear said:
Well according to DocS she voted for LIS. But so did kitten and killer and they turned out to be other villagers
Click to expand...

Yes dumb reason, but what if this whole riddle thing DrS has is she can't tell the entire truth so if someone looks suspicious and she wants to say they do she has to give a stupid reason.
 
Officialish Lynch Tally
Dr-S (5) - Panda, Lyra, Coopah, SARDog, Wally
Mmmdream (1) - Snowy
SARDog (3) - Karabou, Serher, H&H

9/17 accounted for.

Deadline 9PM EST; ~40min remaining.
 
Karabiner13 said:
Panda did get us onto Hyge. She didn't end up voting for Hyge in the end. I'm wondering if it's due to the last minute scramble onto Hyge and this question of Panda's that went unanswered. Still sifting through
Click to expand...

Yeah. I thought hyge was a wolf because of the juggler in the write-up, but was then thought that didn't fit. If you go back, you'll see I was the whole reason why. I feel I've been open about all my reasons and votes. I pointed out hyge was suspicious, then I questioned if she was chaos, and then she was lynched and I was right 🙂

SnowshoeDog143 said:
Yes dumb reason, but what if this whole riddle thing DrS has is she can't tell the entire truth so if someone looks suspicious and she wants to say they do she has to give a stupid reason.
Click to expand...

Not a bad theory, but she's thrown out dumb reasons for lots of people, including several confirmed villagers.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
159
Views
10K
samac
samac
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top