Ladies and Gentlemen... a Noob WW Game Thread!

[deleted806434]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Are you a wolf? And if you aren't a wolf, who is? ;-)

But yes, that is interesting. It would be going against my gut to lynch SAR. H&H voted to lynch SAR the night be lynched BoB (or at least that was from a lynch total near the end of the night). To me, I feel as though that would mean she ISN'T a wolf, right?

Hahahaha omg no and I wish I had that answer as well

That's true, but it seems like wolves like to get votes for their fellow wolves on their voting record (just to use as evidence late down the road)... so it's so hard to tell!!!

 

[TrashPanda]

I also have not interacted overnight with TP unless he is one that has been paralyzing me, which I do not think is the case.

I haven't paralyzed anyone. I think snowshoe saw me with a protection item and assumed it was from you, but it was actually from someone else.

 

[deleted806434]

I still feel like there is a wolf that hasn't been questioned that hard yet. Hrmmm.

 

[TrashPanda]

I'm leaving work now and will be back on a little before lynch close. Hoping there won't be another scramble!

 

[TrashPanda]

I still feel like there is a wolf that hasn't been questioned that hard yet. Hrmmm.

I agree. I'm leaving work now, running an errand, and coming back for lynch-time.

Both BoB and H&H had a decent number of comments but didn't explain themselves or their thought processes well. I'd like to hear from others who have been quiet or had similar types of comments.

 

[deleted806434]

lol don't we all hope that

 

[mmmdreamerz]

WW is not compatible with real life haha. I'm so behind lol

 

[mmmdreamerz]

Here are more thoughts, as I'm reading the threads:

1. On Day 4, BOB was lynched and BOB was Wolf No. 1. [see Post #1968]

2. On Day 5, SAR said there were "2 remaining wolves." [see SAR's Post #2210 below]

3. On Day 5, HH was lynched and HH was Wolf No. 2. [see Post #2349]

So, I'm wondering ...

@SARdoghandler , why did you say there were "2 remaining wolves" at that time in this game?

Reason: With the exception of BOB (Wolf No. 1), we had not lynched any more wolves yet.

In other words, SAR's statement about "2 remaining wolves" was posted before HH was lynched by the villagers.

Do you have any explanation ... just curious?

This is interesting...and a little suspicious...

 

[Doctor-S]

I had been talking about HH more in pm than I had on this thread.

Like @LyraGardenia has already pointed out in Post #2543, I was also curious about serher's comment "talking about HH more in pm."

Does this mean serher was PM'ed by someone?

 

[Doctor-S]

RIP SkiOtter. 🙁 I'm not sure who I suspect at this point, but I still feel like we shouldn't overlook @sheltermed.

Do you have an example? I expressed suspicions of both BoB and h&h early on, and voted to lynch them both even before we had anything solid to go on and everyone else jumped on the bandwagon. I know I was suspicious of you earlier, but I've since changed my mind.

Understood ... just wanted to hear from you since the thread was so quiet earlier today.

 

[deleted806434]

Like @LyraGardenia has already pointed out in Post #2543, I was also curious about serher's comment "talking about HH more in pm."

Does this mean serher was PM'ed by someone?

We've had three people that have been killed with the ability to pm someone. There are probably a LOT of people who are being pm'd by other people. In fact cdoconn revealed that they pm'd you the first evening. So what's the big concern?

 

[mmmdreamerz]

Four wolves left meaning we had 5 to start with? That seems highly stacked for a noob game.

My vote stands for now

Okay, yesterday right after h&h said something about how many wolves were left, SAR posted this and it did not sit right with me...it just seemed like she was too eager to dismiss this number of wolves... Maybe it's nothing, but I figured I should at least bring this up because it was kinda like a gut feeling, ya know?

Obviously, I could be very wrong...anyone else feel like they are always treading on this line of being helpful and possibly sounding "wolf-y?" WW is hard lol

Anyone else have any thoughts?

 

[SARdoghandler]

****
WAIT is that what SAR stands for?????? Search and rescue??
****

Yes. I and my dog are a certified search and rescue team. That's why I often try and put lynch votes in earlier - there's always a niggling fear that I might get a call out.

Re: suspicions against me, give me a minute. Have to go back and see what I said - but I think it's probably because I've played a crap ton of games of mafia online (a slightly different version of the same game) and there's always 3 mafia members (i.e. wolves) so I've been thinking there are 3 wolves total. I probably just said it because I was on my phone and scramble typing and didn't hedge my bets. But like I said, gonna go look again at that post. brb

 

[kaydubs]

Yes. I and my dog are a certified search and rescue team. That's why I often try and put lynch votes in earlier - there's always a niggling fear that I might get a call out.

Very cool!!

 

[kaydubs]

Lynch Tally (D6):
Mmmm (1) - SAR
Lyra (1) - Snowy
S&M ()
KB (2) - kmittens, Lyra


4/12 accounted for
Deadline 9pm EST (~1.25h away)

 

[SARdoghandler]

Okay, went back to look at the post in question and the above explanation still stands. I'm so used to playing games with 3 'bad guys' that I defaulted. And with H&H on the chopping block and only serher defending him, it seemed to make logical sense to me at the time.

 

[Doctor-S]

We've had three people that have been killed with the ability to pm someone. There are probably a LOT of people who are being pm'd by other people. In fact cdoconn revealed that they pm'd you the first evening. So what's the big concern?

I did not know a lot of people have the power to PM. I guess they get to PM in a WW game.

 

[deleted806434]

That explanation works for me. I guess I just found it interesting that you called me suspicious for saying the same exact thing you did lol

 

[deleted806434]

my last post was in response to SAR for clarification

 

[SARdoghandler]

That explanation works for me. I guess I just found it interesting that you called me suspicious for saying the same exact thing you did lol

Only because I think I'm the only one who plays Mafia for fun haha. If you play it too, let me know! (Partially because it explains it - though I think you hinted at 4 wolves which doesn't line up to mafia - and partially because I love playing with other people haha)

 

[deleted806434]

I did not know a lot of people have the power to PM. I guess they get to PM in a WW game.

I don't know how many people have the power, I was just going off of the villagers that have died. So I am assuming more people are chatting with each other as well, that's all.

 

[deleted806434]

Thoughts on Karabou?

 

[Doctor-S]

I don't know how many people have the power, I was just going off of the villagers that have died. So I am assuming more people are chatting with each other as well, that's all.

Okay, thanks for this information.

 

[Karabiner13]

Thoughts on Karabou?

let me know what questions I can answer

 

[SARdoghandler]

Karabou hinted yesterday that she might have a guess at my role/ability. If that were true, and Karabou were a wolf, I would expect to be deaded by now. That's my basis for thinking Karabou might be a villager - but admittedly it's pretty weak.

 

[deleted806434]

let me know what questions I can answer

I will indeed. The problem is I don't have many at the moment. I just thought it was weird that you were pretty randomly selected by two people...

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Well my clinic is going to be pretty busy for the next hour so I hope the last min scrambling goes well and we catch a wolf. I see SAR and triple m are discussing each others wolfiness which I'm interested in but since I won't be able to read their defenses I will stick to my vote for Lyra tonight.

 

[SkiOtter]

Yes. I and my dog are a certified search and rescue team.

***
That's cool! I never really thought about figuring out the acronym but I figured it stood for something haha
***

 

[wallydo]

I always call SAR Search and Rescue in my head. I think her username makes me associate her as a positive character too. Not ideal for playing WW, I realize. Haha.

I don't really have anything on Kbou.

Also, I'm sorry I just don't have the debate raging in me tonight. I'm exhausted and feeling a possible migraine sneaking up.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

I guess with not a whole lot to go with tonight, I'm gonna go with my gut...it may very well be wrong but there's just some things that have been said/ how they've been said that give me pause? Ugh. Idk.

I'm open to waffling, I guess, if someone has something better...

lynch SAR

 

[kittenmittens524]

alright guys, we've got 45 minutes until the lynch we gotta try and spark up some conversation. don't be afraid to just lynch someone that you're suspicious of, we need to start conversations

 

[Doctor-S]

Karabou hinted yesterday that she might have a guess at my role/ability. If that were true, and Karabou were a wolf, I would expect to be deaded by now. That's my basis for thinking Karabou might be a villager - but admittedly it's pretty weak.

@Karabiner13, can you say more about SAR's comment?

 

[mmmdreamerz]

alright guys, we've got 45 minutes until the lynch we gotta try and spark up some conversation. don't be afraid to just lynch someone that you're suspicious of, we need to start conversations

THIS. I am always so nervous about casting lynch votes because I feel like people will then come after me...scary stuff lol

 

[SARdoghandler]

I always call SAR Search and Rescue in my head. I think her username makes me associate her as a positive character too. Not ideal for playing WW, I realize. Haha.

I don't really have anything on Kbou.

Also, I'm sorry I just don't have the debate raging in me tonight. I'm exhausted and feeling a possible migraine sneaking up.

Hahaha. Regardless, I appreciate it wally. Someone remind me when this is all over and I'll pull up the working picture of my K9 and I. =)

 

[Karabiner13]

@Karabiner13, can you say more about SAR's comment?

Based on the timing of when her defense came up and other events that happened that day I think I know her ability. As a villager I definitely want this ability around

 

[kittenmittens524]

THIS. I am always so nervous about casting lynch votes because I feel like people will then come after me...scary stuff lol

it happened to me once, its not that scary i promise lol we just all need to start talking until we come to some sort of conclusion

 

[kittenmittens524]

I'm gonna go on gut instinct then and

unlynch Karabean

lynch serher

 

[wallydo]

THIS. I am always so nervous about casting lynch votes because I feel like people will then come after me...scary stuff lol

And the next day will be awful if we accidentally lynch a villager.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

it happened to me once, its not that scary i promise lol we just all need to start talking until we come to some sort of conclusion

You are right...

 

[deleted806434]

I just left for 20 minutes and thought I was going to come back to chaos... no one has even voted since I left!!! Arhgghghhg. Better to get votes out their now so we can get some real defense, not just a role reveal

 

[mmmdreamerz]

And the next day will be awful if we accidentally lynch a villager.

YESSSSSSS

 

[Doctor-S]

On another note (and in addition to the "two wolves remaining" comment that I made earlier):

When I told everyone I had been incapacitated by paralyzing liquid, BOB (Wolf No. 1) and SAR tried very hard to discredit me, and they (along with HH, Wolf No. 2) wanted everyone to lynch me. BOB, HH and SAR often voted to lynch me and encouraged others to lynch me.

LIS and SkiOtter knew that I am a villager, and said so on this thread. So, I am suspicious of SAR at this time who repeatedly tried to discredit me.

Lynch SAR

 

[wallydo]

I didn't want to be first. And I'm terribly sorry if I'm wrong, but I'm going to agree with kittens.

Lynch serher

 

[Trilt]

Lynch Tally (D6):
Mmmm (1) - SAR
Lyra (1) - Snowy
S&M ()
KB (1) - Lyra
SAR (2) - mmmdream, Dr-S
Serher (2) - KM, Wally

7/12 accounted for. Check your votes.
Deadline 9pm EST (~40min away)

 

[deleted806434]

GUYS REALLY. I have been defending myself to questions the entire day and NOW you put in two votes against me?!?!? LOL WHY

 

[deleted806434]

lynch SAR

I don't have solid evidence and I am sorry for that. I'm going off of feelings and the fact that you were the first person to target me yesterday.

Self-preservation at the moment.

 

[kaydubs]

Ties??????

 

[deleted806434]

What questions can I address for those voting for me? You really don't want to vote me. I'm a villager and have been strategizing for the village the ENTIRE game.

 

[kaydubs]

🙁 no tie.....

 

[SARdoghandler]

Dr-S, I already explained earlier I voted for you because I thought you were acting pretty sketchy. You're still acting odd, but I'm more sure you're a villager now. And I haven't voted for you since that came to light.

I'm going to go with Wally and kmittz. Still mildly suspicious of mmmdreamz but for now

unlynch mmmdreamz

lynch serher