- Joined
- Mar 24, 2017
- Messages
- 45
- Reaction score
- 86
What is the allure of top-tier med schools as opposed to mid-tier/state schools?
I've been doing a lot of thinking lately, especially in regards to my strange notion of having to go to the best possible medical school. I had it in my head that I needed to be at some top-tier medical school in order to get into a superb residency program afterward. Then, once realizing that this sounded both stupid and uninformed, I began to do some digging and asking around. I came to the conclusion that Step-1 scores and Research are what separate superior candidates from the rest when applying to residency programs (of course, LoRs and clinical rotations grades are also extremely important, but let's set that aside for a second because this based on your relationships formed during medical school for the former, and your own ability to do well during the clinical rotations for the later). Technically, medical school curriculums should help prep you for the Step-1, but they aren't the only factor in Step-1 success, right? We have prep materials aside from our med school curriculum and each student has their own level of intellect that would supposedly shine through in their Step-1 score, given proper preparation, right? If that's the case, then how much would it matter if someone goes to a mid-tier/state school versus a top-tier school (in terms of doing well on the Step-1)?
As for Research, I definitely understand that top-tier medical schools have superior research opportunities that are most likely more varied and "better" to some degree. But, why wouldn't a strong mid-tier/state school that has a good amount of research opportunities and distinction programs still give applicants a fighting chance for top residency programs? Not to mention the money some people save going to a state school, and the benefits of being close to home (if you end up going to a medical school in your home state).
What I'm trying to ask is, are my assumptions correct? Can a student with superb talent go to a state school, even a low-tier med school and still come out on top as a superior residency candidate? If so, is this a good thing that I've come to this realization, or am I overthinking it and trying to rationalize my situation as not being a strong applicant for top schools?
Thank you in advance!
I've been doing a lot of thinking lately, especially in regards to my strange notion of having to go to the best possible medical school. I had it in my head that I needed to be at some top-tier medical school in order to get into a superb residency program afterward. Then, once realizing that this sounded both stupid and uninformed, I began to do some digging and asking around. I came to the conclusion that Step-1 scores and Research are what separate superior candidates from the rest when applying to residency programs (of course, LoRs and clinical rotations grades are also extremely important, but let's set that aside for a second because this based on your relationships formed during medical school for the former, and your own ability to do well during the clinical rotations for the later). Technically, medical school curriculums should help prep you for the Step-1, but they aren't the only factor in Step-1 success, right? We have prep materials aside from our med school curriculum and each student has their own level of intellect that would supposedly shine through in their Step-1 score, given proper preparation, right? If that's the case, then how much would it matter if someone goes to a mid-tier/state school versus a top-tier school (in terms of doing well on the Step-1)?
As for Research, I definitely understand that top-tier medical schools have superior research opportunities that are most likely more varied and "better" to some degree. But, why wouldn't a strong mid-tier/state school that has a good amount of research opportunities and distinction programs still give applicants a fighting chance for top residency programs? Not to mention the money some people save going to a state school, and the benefits of being close to home (if you end up going to a medical school in your home state).
What I'm trying to ask is, are my assumptions correct? Can a student with superb talent go to a state school, even a low-tier med school and still come out on top as a superior residency candidate? If so, is this a good thing that I've come to this realization, or am I overthinking it and trying to rationalize my situation as not being a strong applicant for top schools?
Thank you in advance!