Lurking Beloww: Sea Monsters Sign Ups and Game Thread

[genny]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Unless you’re asking because you want to kill me tonight...

 

[PippyPony]

On another note, people put so much trash in the ocean, guys. It's a real shame.

 

[PippyPony]

Unless you’re asking because you want to kill me tonight...

I wouldn't, unless there was good reason to mutiny 😉

 

[Animal Midwife]

I wouldn't, unless there was good reason to mutiny 😉

If I ever were to convert you, would you accept?

 

[PippyPony]

If I ever were to convert you, would you accept?

If it was early enough, sure. My dislike of being converted stems from the fact that the only times it has happened, it's been into unwinnable situations in late game lol

But a delicious mid-game conversion? Sign me up

 

[genny]

Oh that reminds me, in case I die: I was knocked unconscious, and was told I couldn’t do anything tonight. Just in case there are any future block message questions that I’m not around to answer.

 

[PippyPony]

Oh that reminds me, in case I die: I was knocked unconscious, and was told I couldn’t do anything tonight.

Well that's not very nice of someone to do

Hope that doesn't happen to me 😛

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

I have not posted reads thus far, and considering you say you haven't read half my posts, I'm curious as to where you think you saw them

Well I read your posts when I read the thread, I didn't read them all when I was going through and iso'ing people. And so far who you have lynched, been wary of, agreed with, etc are very similar to what I've been thinking. It's just your overall demeanor that is weird. But not enough to make me want to lynch you rn.

That wasn't a question.



I'm actually not that hard to read and it's a common misconception. I have very blatant wolf tells.

now that I think about it.. idk if I've played a game where you have been a wolf. At least not very many.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Well that's not very nice of someone to do

Hope that doesn't happen to me 😛

This type of thing. Could be innocent joking. Could be wolfy taunting.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

On another note, people put so much trash in the ocean, guys. It's a real shame.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Has @StartingoverVet checked in yet today?

Also forgot Allie was playing, hello there

Thanks for the love.. but I did I check in and vote

 

[WildZoo]

Contingency lynch bj
Because I feel like it

 

[Skimble]

People were sounding like there was a delayed blocker which was probably wolfy. I get why coffee was nervous to reveal. I would have kept my vote on her with that reveal if I had been around.

genny was hit by the delayed blocker and DVMD was instantly blocked. Cof? admitted to blocking DVMD, to which she confirmed. I agree with genny that the delayed block sounds more like a wolf block and that makes the normal block more likely village. This is part of why I didn’t understand people staying on the cof? vote. How would her revealing she was a normal blocker, make you want to stay on her vote?

 

[kaydubs]

....uh, night closed?

Yah, sure...

 

[StartingoverVet]

Fwiw, even if I were around, I would have kept my vote for coffee. A blocker is more wolfy than villagers imo (and mostly true in my games), and even if not, it is a bad role for the village to maintain.

 

[StartingoverVet]

genny was hit by the delayed blocker and DVMD was instantly blocked. Cof? admitted to blocking DVMD, to which she confirmed. I agree with genny that the delayed block sounds more like a wolf block and that makes the normal block more likely village. This is part of why I didn’t understand people staying on the cof? vote. How would her revealing she was a normal blocker, make you want to stay on her vote?

That is what you would do as a wolf...give as much truth as possible. It sure why delayed is wolfy in your mind.

 

[PippyPony]

Fwiw, even if I were around, I would have kept my vote for coffee. A blocker is more wolfy than villagers imo (and mostly true in my games), and even if not, it is a bad role for the village to maintain.

This may be a difference in games now vs when you played a lot -- blockers are very commonly village now and have a lot of utility imo

 

[StartingoverVet]

This may be a difference in games now vs when you played a lot -- blockers are very commonly village now and have a lot of utility imo

Maybe when you get to the level of blocking I used to receive, you would change your mind? Mostly they block the village from important stuff, but that is more true in a high role game, where odds are more likely you hit a villager...in a game like this the wolf-villager role balance is closer so not as bad.

Still happy with my vote, just would have been a lot happier if we got a wolf.

 

[PippyPony]

This type of thing. Could be innocent joking. Could be wolfy taunting.

But what if it is neither

 

[kaydubs]

Good Morning, passengers!

We will be resurfacing shortly. Prepare for 25 degree bubble.
Secure all belongings. Sound the bell.​

The Nautilus broke through the surface of the water with gusto and, once the hatches were opened, the view was a sight to behold. A sunrise at sea is one of the most beautiful things a person can witness.

A boatswain sounded out his daily report, "There is nothing in sight!"

Excerpt from Prof. Aronnax's Journal– And in truth, the ocean was deserted. Not a sail on the horizon. The tips of any land had disappeared during the night. The sea, absorbing every color of the prism except its blue rays, reflected the latter in every direction and sported a wonderful indigo tint. The undulating waves regularly took on the appearance of watered silk with wide stripes.

The air supply was renewed, some of the crew took to a little fishing. Soon though, a body floated by, turning the sea red around it, interrupting the gorgeous blues. The crew and passengers worked together to bring the body onboard. It had wings, tentacles on what we thought was it's head, but roughly human shaped overall. What a loss. The head and wings were swiftly chopped off and preserved. The rest of the body was dumped.

Dead is @WildZoo , Cthulhu.

ADJUST PMs ACCORDINGLY.

CAST YOUR LYNCH VOTES!!!! Deadline at 10pm Eastern.

Green Horns
1. @SARdoghandler
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @SnowshoeDog143
4. @DVMDream
6. @allieh8607
7. @bryndiana.jones
8. @Stagg737
9. @kcoughli
10. @Skimble
11. @genny
13. @dolphin106258
14. @PippyPony
15. @johnnaboo
18. @StartingoverVet

Laid to Rest
12. capri1722 - Giant squid
17. Melchizedek - Candiru
5. CoffeeQuestionMark - Scylla and Charybdis
16. WildZoo - Cthulhu

 

[PippyPony]

Lmao

I had a feeling when she said her role was not RNG.

RIP Cthulhu

 

[PippyPony]

Some thoughts...

Have genny at a decently village lean, but all the same, didn't really like this string of posts:

SAR's mayor vote yesterday made me think of someone with a guilty conscience. I'm hoping it's wolf-guilt, and not just general life-guilt, so that's why I'm voting there. I could also vote for Pippy or Dolphin. I think AM and Coffee sound village so far.

Dolphin hasn't said much. I always suspect my PM partners.

Lynch genny

People can call it retaliatory but I'm just really not liking the aggressive tone in her posts.

🙄 Now I feel really good about my lynch vote.

I'm interested in what the 1st mate's job is, because here she says it is "typical"...

Nope. Not even close to what I said. It's a typical mayoral duty.

...but then was concerned about a tie meaning double death:

I am not in favor of a tie. I think they will both die in that case.

In my experience, mayor duty is most commonly something like tie breaker. That's not to say it couldn't be something else, but was just something I wanted to note.

-----

This rubbed me the wrong way. Also the follow up about the mod PM makes me think she’s in wolf chat.

This was basically jboo's only contribution to the thread yesterday. Rubs me the wrong way 😉
-----

Thanks for reminding me. Lynch genny.

For real though, SAR’s 1st post today pinged all kinds of feels.

Unlynch bj

Lynch SAR

Did it? Can you elaborate on this please? Because it kiiiinda looks like you waited until the SAR lynch started to pick up steam, and then jumped ship from Bryndi.
--------

To expand on those reads you've commented on: Dvmd may not have said much, but her D1/D2 contributions in this game are like 800% higher than usual (which for the past few games has been drop a lynch vote and peace, which I get because life). Of what she has said, I'm reading village. Most of my feels work that way, and one post is enough to trigger feels. That's what got me tunneling on you last game. As for coffee, I so far (excepting one tinfoil incident) can read her 100% reliably. If others disagree with me on her behaviour today then that's on them but I'm not going to sheep others opinions on a player when they differ from mine. Also it should be noted that Coffee making sense to me some today initially had my eyebrows up, which I think is the opposite here of what you are implying. Coffee and I tend to be extreme tinfoiling buddies and she can be a bit of a rabid villager so if her comments don't seem at least a little erratic (ilu coffee) then I start to doubt her villageness. She's had enough of her regular meta posts today to calm me down again and leave me relatively happy with putting her at village lean

Unless she's playing the long game and started pocketing me two games ago...

Don't like the last sentence in this post, though. Weird feels.
-----

LYnch Coffee?

Really not liking her reasoning today. Also looking at SAR for pushing at the mayor so early on as I assume someone will look into her soon enough. Didn't like some of kc's thoughts, but retalitory lynching usually seems more village then wolfy.

Also agree with pippy. (Always slightly distrustful of pips, but am feeling okay so far with her)

Snowy likes to pocket me as a wolf these days because she's figured out that it usually works. So seeing her say multiple times that she agrees with me -- when I have been admittedly pretty wacko and all over the place -- does not make me want to put Snowy in a village bucket.

Well now I definitely want to keep my coffee vote

Really? Because this looked a little opportunistic to me.

-----

unlynch coffee

Y tho.
-------

Hmm, makes more sense now but I'm still keeping my eye on it.

This was a very weird comment from DVMD imo, although I have her at a mostly village lean after yesterday, I think. But, red flag on this one, and the fact that she was throwing shade at Coffee for the role reveal without voting for her.
--------

Edited to add dividers because this ended up kinda long.

 

[PippyPony]

And, amongst all that, on and off weird feels from KC.

@kcoughli you get morning sickness?

 

[PippyPony]

Anyone else notice that we're 2 for 2 on night kills on people who can PM with jboo and SOV? Strange.

I am kind of operating under the assumption that SOV was brought in as a vanillager, though.

Is today the day when @Crayola227 is supposed to join? Is that even happening? @kaydubs @katashark

 

[PippyPony]

For now,

Lynch bryndi

In memoriam ex monstrum

 

[Animal Midwife]

Hey, I was attacked.

It's one of those games.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch Snowy

 

[PippyPony]

Surprised there would be so much double death if no rezzes. I was expecting to see Capri or Cheezit kicking around here today.

 

[PippyPony]

Oh by the by, I found a fun article that appears to have a good number of game roles on it:

https://www.tor.com/2012/08/13/sea-monsters-a-z/

I strongly doubt role names are indicative of affiliation, but found this to be an entertaining compilation all the same.

 

[Animal Midwife]

btw, in case people have realized how severe the double kill are on things, tomorrow could be lylo

 

[PippyPony]

btw, in case people have realized how severe the double kill are on things, tomorrow could be lylo

It won't be

 

[Animal Midwife]

It won't be

How do you figure?

 

[PippyPony]

How do you figure?

Let's focus on lynching a wolf today, and then it won't be 😉

 

[PippyPony]

Has anyone else been delay blocked?

 

[kaydubs]

Is today the day when @Crayola227 is supposed to join? Is that even happening? @kaydubs @katashark

Possibly? Remains to be seen.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Y tho.

As the day progressed she seemed more and more village to me

 

[KCgophervet]

And, amongst all that, on and off weird feels from KC.

@kcoughli you get morning sickness?

Is this a non game related pregnancy question or...?

If yes the answer is my morning sickness always was worse in the afternoon/evening but luckily I'm past the nausea stage yay. Now just evening heartburn and random lower abdomen pain. Currently sitting at the Dr office waiting for appointment.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Let's focus on lynching a wolf today, and then it won't be 😉

Why not focus on both?

 

[bryndiana.jones]

I'm off to the first day of class! I won't be around as much as you want, but I will be around as much as you deserve😉

 

[PippyPony]

Is this a non game related pregnancy question or...?

If yes the answer is my morning sickness always was worse in the afternoon/evening but luckily I'm past the nausea stage yay. Now just evening heartburn and random lower abdomen pain. Currently sitting at the Dr office waiting for appointment.

Both? I'm debating whether I should pick a fight with you now or later.

 

[PippyPony]

Why not focus on both?

😕 Both what?

Nevermind, don't answer that.

 

[KCgophervet]

If am was attacked and dubs was killed, does that mean double kills every night? Cuz yikes

 

[KCgophervet]

Both? I'm debating whether I should pick a fight with you now or later.

Later please, appointment starting

 

[PippyPony]

I'm off to the first day of class! I won't be around as much as you want, but I will be around as much as you deserve😉

Have fun!

Since this will be fruitless until this evening,

Unlynch bryndi

 

[PippyPony]

Snowy or jboo, snowy or jboo...

Lynch jbizzle

 

[Animal Midwife]

I will say this is my first game with limited flips, so I'm just trying to figure it out.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

genny was hit by the delayed blocker and DVMD was instantly blocked. Cof? admitted to blocking DVMD, to which she confirmed. I agree with genny that the delayed block sounds more like a wolf block and that makes the normal block more likely village. This is part of why I didn’t understand people staying on the cof? vote. How would her revealing she was a normal blocker, make you want to stay on her vote?

Well I forgot about her saying she blocked DVmd. Yeah that wasn't the delayed blocked so who knows maybe I would have changed...

 

[PippyPony]

I will say this is my first game with limited flips, so I'm just trying to figure it out.

Well, how about this:

Anyone know anything about the people who died?

It appears they are not coming back, so if they provided role info or reads in PM, time to dish.

And along those lines, I still want to know if someone was delay blocked for tonight.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

@PippyPony maybe I just cant figure you out this game which is annoying because I usually read you well.

So AM and kc were attacked?

 

[PippyPony]

Well I forgot about her saying she blocked DVmd. Yeah that wasn't the delayed blocked so who knows maybe I would have changed...

You forgot that whole conversation about blocking? The one that you were participating in?

😵