Milkshake - Game Thread

[Kota1000]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Well I did find one post D1 that may be a claim, but not really. If it is, I don’t like how barks is pushing the doggo lynch. I did notice the barks was the one to start the doggo lynch D1 as well for “funsies” as they say. I’m moving barks to my wolfy pile, doggo more village-neutral.

lynch Barks

I want to iso Coopah as well when I get a chance, I’m on my phone and won’t be home for a while so idk if I want to try and iso on my phone.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (2) - Coop, Kota

2/7
lynch close in ~7 hours

 

[Coopah]

Since it might be missed if people don't wanna read my wall of a post above but how does others read this (posted 1 min before lynch close)?

Reads as a I expected this.

Also you really need to answer my question about that soft claim. Right freaking now

 

[Coopah]

Unlynch barks

 

[WonderingStudent]

Well I did find one post D1 that may be a claim, but not really. If it is, I don’t like how barks is pushing the doggo lynch.

*face palm* but we don't know if our interpretation of *hinting* is correct. Doggo's posts haven't been screaming village this game and at this point we gotta rethink what we've been assuming about D1.

Let's run some scenarios just to understand how much time we have so villagers can understand were we are at.
7 players alive currently.

Worst Case scenario:
Day 5:
Lynch a villager + NK Night 5 (25% chance of NK JOAT)

Tomorrow: Lylo
5 players alive (2 wolves : 3 villagers)

Welp. I expect lots of discussion and reads from everyone today.

@Coopah think you were asking about timelines earlier

I don’t think it’s a good idea to lynch me, but y’all do whatever you want to I guess

@Coopah At this point we already talked about what we interpreted it as hinting so slightly useless to not just put it here I guess. It isn't like it was that overt but at least I wasn't the only one to think this when I read it.

 

[Barkley13]

Well I did find one post D1 that may be a claim, but not really. If it is, I don’t like how barks is pushing the doggo lynch. I did notice the barks was the one to start the doggo lynch D1 as well for “funsies” as they say. I’m moving barks to my wolfy pile, doggo more village-neutral.

lynch Barks

I want to iso Coopah as well when I get a chance, I’m on my phone and won’t be home for a while so idk if I want to try and iso on my phone.

“But not really” except multiple people thought it was and two of them are now dead over the person who claimed

yeah ok

 

[WonderingStudent]

Wondering’s complaining about revealing too much is giving me sketch feels... idk what to think about them though. Like why wouldn’t you want to make sure all village understands something?

Because wolves have been known to miss things on the thread that villagers pick up on. By putting too much info on here so plainly, wolves are going to understand it too.

 

[WonderingStudent]

@Doggo Labs your input at the moment + current reads would be much appreciated.

 

[Kota1000]

Because wolves have been known to miss things on the thread that villagers pick up on. By putting too much info on here so plainly, wolves are going to understand it too.

Honestly that’s kind of dumb... anyone who’s played WW more then a few times should be able to pick up on hints wolf or not, unless they’re playing as a wolf that is just skimming and not really paying attention

 

[WonderingStudent]

Honestly that’s kind of dumb... anyone who’s played WW more then a few times should be able to pick up on hints wolf or not, unless they’re playing as a wolf that is just skimming and not really paying attention

then you will be thoroughly surprised in future games....

 

[Barkley13]

Honestly that’s kind of dumb... anyone who’s played WW more then a few times should be able to pick up on hints wolf or not, unless they’re playing as a wolf that is just skimming and not really paying attention

????
You and coop both missed that hint though?

 

[Kota1000]

“But not really” except multiple people thought it was and two of them are now dead over the person who claimed

yeah ok

But if they though doggo was a JOAT then why would doggo!wolf kill them? Those people would be less likely to lynch them.

Although, I do see your implications if doggo is a wolf it would make sense why they aren’t dead yet, although if not then you potentially outed them today, so I’m still feeling sketch about you

 

[Kota1000]

????
You and coop both missed that hint though?

Well I don’t think things through that much, I’m not very good at interpreting things apparently l, I take things how they are unless something is pointed out as differently

 

[Barkley13]

But if they though doggo was a JOAT then why would doggo!wolf kill them? Those people would be less likely to lynch them.

Uh because they were questioning why doggo is still alive.

 

[Kota1000]

Anyway I just meant that I don’t think missing a hint or misinterpreting something is really affiliation indicative

 

[Coopah]

????
You and coop both missed that hint though?

Cause that's not a hint. I am a JOAT and I know who the other one is.

 

[Kota1000]

Uh because they were questioning why doggo is still alive.

Huh, I guess that makes sense. I still don’t know though, I’ve gotta think on that

 

[Coopah]

Cause that's not a hint. I am a JOAT and I know who the other one is.

Since genny so kindly requested we reveal today

 

[Kota1000]

Cause that's not a hint. I am a JOAT and I know who the other one is.

If you are a JOAT, how do you know who the other is? I thought only wolves could talk in message

 

[Coopah]

Uh because they were questioning why doggo is still alive.

Eh that seems like a stretch

 

[Coopah]

If you are a JOAT, how do you know who the other is? I thought only wolves could talk in message

... night results

 

[Kota1000]

... night results

Okay then. Well I guess I’ll stick with my barks lynch for now, and your definitely going to my village pile, so that leaves doggo, barks and genny as my possible suspects. But I don’t see doggo and barks as a team, and I’m more suspecting barks after today

 

[Coopah]

Okay then. Well I guess I’ll stick with my barks lynch for now, and your definitely going to my village pile, so that leaves doggo, barks and genny as my possible suspects. But I don’t see doggo and barks as a team, and I’m more suspecting barks after today

Why?

 

[Coopah]

Lynch Kota

 

[Kota1000]

Why?

Why what?

 

[Coopah]

Why what?

Why are you more suspecting of barks?

 

[Kota1000]

Why are you more suspecting of barks?

Then doggo? Because i find it odd that barks is pushing doggie lynch so much when yesterday they weren’t very susceptive of them, but today they are. Also, upon a quick phone iso they don’t seem to have had a lot of good reads. Lastly, they were the one that started the doggo lynch D1 and I think it really escalated unnecessarily and it may have been a distraction.

I’m still susceptive of genny, but barks posts today seem more sketch. Although genny hasn’t been as active today

 

[Coopah]

Then doggo? Because i find it odd that barks is pushing doggie lynch so much when yesterday they weren’t very susceptive of them, but today they are. Also, upon a quick phone iso they don’t seem to have had a lot of good reads. Lastly, they were the one that started the doggo lynch D1 and I think it really escalated unnecessarily and it may have been a distraction.

I’m still susceptive of genny, but barks posts today seem more sketch. Although genny hasn’t been as active today

Well I don't think anyone's reads have been great this game. Villagers are wrong more often than wolves about affiliation.

We've already discussed that barks dropped the doggo lynch after D1 and is just bringing it back up now. So what exactly is making you feel she's sketch?

 

[Kota1000]

Well I don't think anyone's reads have been great this game. Villagers are wrong more often than wolves about affiliation.

We've already discussed that barks dropped the doggo lynch after D1 and is just bringing it back up now. So what exactly is making you feel she's sketch?

It’s her posts from today, and I don’t think she’s put a lot of effort in wolf hunting the last few days. When I get on my computer I can find examples

 

[alissa14]

Popping in during a short and I mean short break. I’m KINDA caught up on thread but not enough for reads or analysis and I haven’t eaten since this morning and I’m hangry. Food is more important than you guys sorry not sorry.

 

[alissa14]

Thoughts:
Will be ISOing Kota, Doggo, and Barks today.
While I felt good about doggo jnitially as village neutral, their flip flop of votes yesterday made me uneasy. Kota I feel is just all wrong. I’m confused why she’s still on the genny train when genny is an outed JOAT but okay. Barks I had suspicions for yesterday but their interactions with me seemed okay so I didn’t end up lynching there. We’re down to the nitty gritty at this point and we can’t screw up this lynch.. I’m probably leaning more towards Kota and Barks over Doggo though If I’m gonna be honest.

 

[alissa14]

@Coopah has your night kill theory/tinfoil changed at all after today’s reveal?

 

[alissa14]

Oh also it should go without saying, but I have Coop, genny, and wonder as solid village

 

[alissa14]

I have about 10 minutes until the next feeding so if anyone has questions for me ask away!

 

[WonderingStudent]

@alissa14 genny never said she was the JOAT

 

[alissa14]

@alissa14 genny never said she was the JOAT

Did I miss something? I’m sorry I thought coopah outed both of them. I’ve been skimming

 

[Barkley13]

Idk guys I just feel like doggo hasn't had very many original reads

Spoiler: ECHO Echo echo echo

First, sunny is very quiet, which is unusual for them I think.

Sunni: seems very quiet, which is very different from her normal play

_______________________________________________________________________________________

I am actually wondering about Sunni being a wolf as there's a huge tone shift from her standard village play

Lynch Sunni
Posting has been off to me and not making sense, I know genny pointed out stuff I was catching as I was reading

_______________________________________________________________________________________
Honestly can't even pick just one quote about paws acting different because of the exclamation points but here's doggo's read after all that discussion

Paws: I was pretty sure she was wolf the whole last game, but ended up village. Now I’m sensing a play style shift, that’s why she’s up rhere

_______________________________________________________________________________________

I’m feeling better about Paws. They seem more invested in wolf hunting based on the questions they are asking and some of their explanations.

Today I am feeling slightly better about paws.

_____________________________________________________________________________

I'm also wondering why sunbodi is lurking and not answering paws question

I'm also getting lurky feels from her too

I'm going to vote her because of the evasiveness of her posts. She's been asked questions and has not answered them, but I do get wanting to balance life better too

Lynch Sunni

__________________________________________________________________________________________

Where is [Sunbodi] today?

Wondering if @Sunbodi is going to come on today or not

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

I think that sporty and paws while both high on my sketch radar are w/v

Sport: I'm thinking when her and paws were up for lynch/tied for lynch the other day that one or both of them was wolf. Now we know that paws is village, I'm thinking sport could be on of the wolfs.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Kota has felt off to me pretty much this entire game and a lot of posts she has made have given me sketchy feels.

Noob wolf needs whatever village cred she can get since this is a tough crowd. Noob wolf votes strong wolf, tying it up. If strong wolf flips, noob wolf gains a lot of village cred.

Kota: has been going up my sketch list. Ive disagreed with a lot of what shes been saying. Lynch choices seem easily swayed by others. and IMO has come off/ sounded/ acted different than her previous village games. I think she skated by D1 with her SAR vote to claim village cred

 

[alissa14]

Since genny so kindly requested we reveal today

Sorry @WonderingStudent I thought that the “we” meant that her and genny were the JOATs

 

[Barkley13]

Cause that's not a hint. I am a JOAT and I know who the other one is.

I think it was a hint. Doesn't mean it was right or not but def feel like it was enough for wolves to have been interested in killing her over others

 

[WonderingStudent]

So you never came back.
Lynch doggo as pressure

Let's put some pressure

lynch doggo

 

[Barkley13]

Idk guys I just feel like doggo hasn't had very many original reads

Spoiler: ECHO Echo echo echo

_______________________________________________________________________________________


_______________________________________________________________________________________
Honestly can't even pick just one quote about paws acting different because of the exclamation points but here's doggo's read after all that discussion

_______________________________________________________________________________________



_____________________________________________________________________________



__________________________________________________________________________________________


_____________________________________________________________________________________________


_____________________________________________________________________________________________

It's obviously Kota, who is flip-flopping wherever the wind is blowing whenever a viable lynch appears. You're not the tiniest bit sketched out that she joined you on my lynch?

Oh add this one to literally right before the very last quote

 

[Barkley13]

Also, upon a quick phone iso they don’t seem to have had a lot of good reads.

Oh we can talk about reads if you want

Spoiler: Reads

Maybe, I’m gonna go through and reread. But I will vote. It’s not really final, I want to go back and reread

lynch Dubz

So looking back at D1, since SAR flipped wolf, two things that really bothered me were BC and sort of coopah’s lynch patterns.

Thank you! Do you think your going to vote for Bc?

I have suspicions about them as well, especially considering the quick move off SAR and onto Doggo

Lynch Bc

BC has initially lynched SAR but then unlynched her and lynched suni. They then said they didn’t feel comfortable about the SAR lynch and felt that SAR had a good level of suspicion to make BC feel good about them.
Today, BC started out on a short rant regarding failure to lynch SAR, which is fine, but it seems a little too loud with the caps and punctuation. She did give rather good reads regarding other people and their interaction with SAR yesterday, but it also had a lot of punctuation and just sort of blabbed it all out in one long paragraph.

unlynch BC
Lynch Paws

I am feeling better about the Paw's Lynch now. I know I said I was leaning more village on them earlier; however, I feel like they have been rather shallow in their posts recently and they haven't provided a whole lot of substantial evidence to their defense, and rather have been trying to redirect the focus to others, i.e. doggo. Also their mention about who else they should vote for rather then themselves seems very odd. Additionally, I don't like the fact that they only have enough suspicion on Sporty to vote their, and they aren't changing the Lynch despite it being pointed out that sporty will probably be mod killed anyways

I’m feeling better about Paws. They seem more invested in wolf hunting based on the questions they are asking and some of their explanations.

unlynch paws
Lynch 3m
I’m moving to 3m because I don’t think they’ve provided a lot of substantial content today, and I am a little concerned about the WZ 3m interaction yesterday. Also 3m didn’t seem suspect of SAR either

Ill start off the day with my list of villager -> more wolfy
Coopah
Doggo
Alissa
Barks
Sporty
Genny
BC
Paws

I want to ISO Genny, BC and Paws today before I give more in-depth reads.

I had paws as village, but after rereading and things other people pointed out, I moved her back to my wolfy pile this morning, I still need to do an ISO. I felt that later in D2 she had a lot better questioning method that made her seem more village, but after 3m flipped village, I want to reevaluate her so I put her in my wolfy pile again.

As far as 3m, I had her leaning village after D1. Then after a whole other day and reading her posts (or lack of), I was a little suspect of them. I also decided to Lynch her because she hadn't voted or mentioned anything about SAR being suspect D1.

unlynch genny
Lynch paws

Genny is still on my radar, but since no one agrees, I’m going with my 2nd wolfy suspect. I don’t agree with the suni lynch, so I’d rather try and sway it elsewhere

I think I am going to move sporty into wolfy territory.

unlynch genny
Lynch Bc

I’m feeling better about a BC lynch at the moment. Their replies and initial posts today seem very defensive, and I don’t like how they’ve been explaining things from the perspective of a wolf, I don’t remember them doing this before, so it’s a little suspect. Also, they’ve been pushing hard for a JOAT revel, which I don’t agree with because it would potentially help the wolves more then village.

I still have suspects on genny and sporty, but BC is leading right now.

Lastly, they were the one that started the doggo lynch D1 and I think it really escalated unnecessarily and it may have been a distraction.

Lastly, it's not my fault people decided to vote there when I wasn't pushing it in any way and wasn't around
You're really helping my kota/doggo wolf pack theory though with how much you've defended her though

 

[WonderingStudent]

Feeling village on paws, Coop, Genny. Susp on Kota and you for the most part. Everyone else files into a neutral category

Any particular reason it's felt like you're lying low today and trying to blend into the background?

lol if we find out that kota and doggo are the wolf pack then I will find this post hilarious

 

[Coopah]

Oh also it should go without saying, but I have Coop, genny, and wonder as solid village

Why wonder?

 

[Coopah]

Sorry @WonderingStudent I thought that the “we” meant that her and genny were the JOATs

Nope I just meant me and the other one 😉

 

[WonderingStudent]

Also PSA, as we have 7 players alive today

maj is 4 players

 

[WonderingStudent]

Meaning (to at least me) please refrain from having 3 votes on one player so that someone does not accidentally tip it to maj without knowing.

 

[Coopah]

Meaning (to at least me) please refrain from having 3 votes on one player so that someone does not accidentally tip it to maj without knowing.

I was thinking more along the lines of don't have two villagers in one person because the wolves can trigger Maj and make it look like an accident

 

[kaydubs]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (1) - Kota
Kota (1) - Coops
Doggo (1) - Wondering

3/7
lynch close in ~4 hours

 

[Coopah]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (1) - Kota
Kota (1) - Coops
Doggo (1) - Wondering

3/7
lynch close in ~4 hours

Ok we need to narrow this down to two. Please