Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

[Crayola227]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I wasn't saying it was an issue, but rather every interaction has to be either v/v, v/w, or w/w. Leans are fine though.

Point taken. When I read a disagreement or exchange, I read it thinking about all 4 scenarios and try to process of eliminate which I think are most likely. Sometimes I can lean, sometimes I can only conclude "not likely w/w" or decide only 1, 2, or 3 possibilties seem likely.

My thinking anway. I'm sure I don't do this perfectly.

 

[kaydubs]

N3
get back to studying. LIS deserves a better writeup and I will deliver one tomorrow.

Dead is @LetItSnow, who was a Djinn, and the village vigilante

I hate all of you. Cept @LetItSnow

 

[Melchizedek]

That's literally every interaction in this game.

I saw BJ flip in the write up and knew she was a seer, but hadn't gotten to reading the part where she role revealed and cleared you and Hamm.

I hit that part when I posted this:

ohhhhhhh this is what you mean.....




WHAT THE **** @SnowshoeDog143

So why do you think cray is village? What are your thoughts on coffee?

Cray:
1. I liked her answer to my question about BJ/AM
2. I left her name off my suspicious list specifically to see who would pick up on the discrepancy.

Coffee?
1. Reminiscent of my reaction to LIS the first few games I played here.
2. Level of emotion/frustration is too hard to fake.

If Coffee? is a wolf, then good job to her, but I'm just not seeing it.

Bed time.

 

[Melchizedek]

Woke up and read my last post, I meant to quote this one of AM’s posts not the first one that I accidentally did.

I guess it confused me that you didn't see bryndy in the writeup as well.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

WOW wtf. The grumpy turd went down. And as the vigilante!

That was the reason I didn't trust LIS much this game. Seems I was wrong. Even when he's village and is losing his marbles, it's not always right to trust him, especially if he's tunneling a noob.

I'm definitely going to take a closer look at Coffee now.

Contingency Lynch coffee

If you guys really want me dead okay but can I maybe offer another theory?

If LIS wanted me dead he could've killed me, but, what if he was blocked since the beginning? Like a wolf was playing a game but got really lucky with their target? Based on this game alone, I can definitely think of one player that might try that

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Also guys I'm back from my interview so I'll try to make up for being MIA after work.

 

[allieh8607]

WOW wtf. The grumpy turd went down. And as the vigilante!



If you guys really want me dead okay but can I maybe offer another theory?

If LIS wanted me dead he could've killed me, but, what if he was blocked since the beginning? Like a wolf was playing a game but got really lucky with their target? Based on this game alone, I can definitely think of one player that might try that

Who?
And are you implying that the wolves have been blocking LIS all game because they found out he was the vig? Pretty sure they would have taken him out asap after getting that little nugget of info. Which could be what happened here.

 

[Animal Midwife]

WOW wtf. The grumpy turd went down. And as the vigilante!



If you guys really want me dead okay but can I maybe offer another theory?

If LIS wanted me dead he could've killed me, but, what if he was blocked since the beginning? Like a wolf was playing a game but got really lucky with their target? Based on this game alone, I can definitely think of one player that might try that

I don't really think LIS was that grumpy this game tbh. He just does things differently than I do. Who do you think would be blocking him?

 

[Animal Midwife]

@CoffeeQuestionMark I would also like to discuss some of the actions you made last night.

 

[WildZoo]

WOW wtf. The grumpy turd went down.

This is uncalled for. Remember this is a game, and we are still on a professional forum, among (current or future) colleagues. There is no need to make things personal or resort to name-calling.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Who?
And are you implying that the wolves have been blocking LIS all game because they found out he was the vig? Pretty sure they would have taken him out asap after getting that little nugget of info. Which could be what happened here.

I don't know. Maybe it is crazy, but MJ seems like the kind that would keep blocking him for fun, or at least until it's useful (casting a lot of suspicion on me)
Far out there. I keep coming back to MJ.

@CoffeeQuestionMark I would also like to discuss some of the actions you made last night.

I just switched to you to break the tie. I didn't mean it personally.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't know. Maybe it is crazy, but MJ seems like the kind that would keep blocking him for fun, or at least until it's useful (casting a lot of suspicion on me)
Far out there. I keep coming back to MJ.

How much do you know about MJ? How long have you had this theory?

I just switched to you to break the tie. I didn't mean it personally.

You didn't break the tie. You made one. That wasn't all I was talking about though.

 

[kaydubs]

This is uncalled for. Remember this is a game, and we are still on a professional forum, among (current or future) colleagues. There is no need to make things personal or resort to name-calling.

Yup. And if you are visiting from your own professional forum, still practice the golden rule. No rudeness and disrespect necessary.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

How much do you know about MJ? How long have you had this theory?



You didn't break the tie. You made one. That wasn't all I was talking about though.

I have been off and on MJ all game for the very reason that he has been toying around.

I think you and I were tied. But I was trying to be quick because I was on my way home. What do you mean?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

This is uncalled for. Remember this is a game, and we are still on a professional forum, among (current or future) colleagues. There is no need to make things personal or resort to name-calling.

Sorry. I thought it vibed playful not serious. Retracted.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I have been off and on MJ all game for the very reason that he has been toying around.

I haven't really noticed you being on MJ. It seemed more a a D1 joke/learning vote. After that you mentioned him, but never proceeded to vote for or otherwise pressure him again. Why was that?

I think you and I were tied. But I was trying to be quick because I was on my way home. What do you mean?

It seemed like really odd timing and never mentioned as a preservation vote when I questioned you about it.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I haven't really noticed you being on MJ. It seemed more a a D1 joke/learning vote. After that you mentioned him, but never proceeded to vote for or otherwise pressure him again. Why was that?



It seemed like really odd timing and never mentioned as a preservation vote when I questioned you about it.

Look back to the posts on depression. I was trying to cut him some slack out of personal reasons but my doubt was never removed.

Also I didn't post afterward last night?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Look back to the posts on depression. I was trying to cut him some slack out of personal reasons but my doubt was never removed.

Okay, but I don't think he would take it personally if you pressured him. No move should be taken personally in this game actually. This is a smaller roster and we can't afford to let wolves live for much longer.

Also I didn't post afterward last night?

I know you didn't, but not posting =/= not being on.

 

[Haxx]

###lynch Coffee?###

Because AM clearly knows something I don't and with both of us being cleared, I'm going to stick together.

 

[Haxx]

At least I think I'm reading that right. Correct me if I'm wrong, AM.

 

[Animal Midwife]

###lynch Coffee?###

Because AM clearly knows something I don't and with both of us being cleared, I'm going to stick together.

At least I think I'm reading that right. Correct me if I'm wrong, AM.

I'm just testing things out at the moment.

 

[WeimMama]

If you guys really want me dead okay but can I maybe offer another theory?

If LIS wanted me dead he could've killed me, but, what if he was blocked since the beginning? Like a wolf was playing a game but got really lucky with their target? Based on this game alone, I can definitely think of one player that might try that

Is it you? Cause thats kinda where my mind went....

 

[WildZoo]

Night 3 writeup and table of contents updated

Remember if you want more background on your monster, let me know in your role PM

 

[WildZoo]

Day 4 Not Enough Death Tally

Coffee? (2) - AM, Haxx

2/12 votes 🙁

Deadline is 10pm EST

Not voting:

5. @youngkal
6. @Coopah
7. @Crayola227
8. @Stella Mudd
9. @Melchizedek
10. @allieh8607
11. @Mad Jack
13. @genny
14. @WeimMama
16. @CoffeeQuestionMark


Content Posts
1. Animal Midwife - 12
5. @youngkal
6. @Coopah - 2
7. Crayola227 - 12
8. @Stella Mudd
9. Melchizedek - 5
10. @allieh8607 - 1
11. @Mad Jack
13. @genny
14. @WeimMama - 1
16. CoffeeQuestionMark - 4
17. @Haxx - 2

AM Quest for 20 Question (Marks): 8

 

[Crayola227]

###lynch Coffee?###

Because AM clearly knows something I don't and with both of us being cleared, I'm going to stick together.

I know you're both cleared villagers, but we all need to put our thinking caps on.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 4 Not Enough Death Tally

Coffee? (1) - Haxx

1/12 votes 🙁

I contingencied last night.

Contingency Lynch coffee

 

[Animal Midwife]

I know you're both cleared villagers, but we all need to put our thinking caps on.

I think we still do have them on?

 

[vetmedhead]

WOW wtf. The grumpy turd went down. And as the vigilante!

This is uncalled for. Remember this is a game, and we are still on a professional forum, among (current or future) colleagues. There is no need to make things personal or resort to name-calling.

Yup. And if you are visiting from your own professional forum, still practice the golden rule. No rudeness and disrespect necessary.

Sorry. I thought it vibed playful not serious. Retracted.

I see this was already addressed but do want to add on more generally for the whole roster to read: personal attacks, insults, name calling, and general rudeness have no place on this forum and especially not in these games. This goes for all players.

None of us as mods are above modkilling players who engage in this behavior repeatedly.

We recognize that sometimes comments meant to be tongue in cheek come off baring more teeth than originally intended. Everyone, please be cognizant of the context of your words and be willing and ready to take responsibility for and ownership of the impact your words can have on other players.

Coffee - thank you for redacting your comment on thread. Again, we get that sometimes things sound different in your head than they do when people read them, and we appreciate your apology.

 

[Crayola227]

I think we still do have them on?

I'm not sure a quiet player coming on to essentially say they're just gonna vote whoever you vote, is exactly evidence of deep thought.

Even if he just asserted, "I agree with AM's reasoning" and could even give us a one liner on it, it would be appreciated. Just saying, "hey, maybe she knows something just because she's confirmed village" isn't the most original, and we can't afford mislynches.

I get it that I've frakked up this game, but it isn't for lack of trying to analyze. Maybe Haxx has some sort of Investigative Board with red string and thumbtacks that he's keeping on the DL.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm not sure a quiet player coming on to essentially say they're just gonna vote whoever you vote, is exactly evidence of deep thought.

Even if he just asserted, "I agree with AM's reasoning" and could even give us a one liner on it, it would be appreciated. Just saying, "hey, maybe she knows something just because she's confirmed village" isn't the most original, and we can't afford mislynches.

I get it that I've frakked up this game, but it isn't for lack of trying to analyze. Maybe Haxx has some sort of Investigative Board with red string and thumbtacks that he's keeping on the DL.

He can switch at any point. It's just something to start with. I've followed players on their votes before and still ran my own theories. It's still rather early in the day as well.

 

[vetmedhead]

This is uncalled for. Remember this is a game, and we are still on a professional forum, among (current or future) colleagues. There is no need to make things personal or resort to name-calling.

Yup. And if you are visiting from your own professional forum, still practice the golden rule. No rudeness and disrespect necessary.

I see this was already addressed but do want to add on more generally for the whole roster to read: personal attacks, insults, name calling, and general rudeness have no place on this forum and especially not in these games. This goes for all players.

None of us as mods are above modkilling players who engage in this behavior repeatedly.

We recognize that sometimes comments meant to be tongue in cheek come off baring more teeth than originally intended. Everyone, please be cognizant of the context of your words and be willing and ready to take responsibility for and ownership of the impact your words can have on other players.

Coffee - thank you for redacting your comment on thread. Again, we get that sometimes things sound different in your head than they do when people read them, and we appreciate your apology.

Also, I feel the need to mention that these collective posts were not made at LIS's request or anything like that. This is something we feel strongly about as a mod team.

Remember, the #1 Rule of every WW game is don't talk about WW to have fun! This means fun for everyone - so please be mindful.

Alright, I'm getting off my mod soap box now. What's the lynch tally? 😏

 

[Crayola227]

He can switch at any point. It's just something to start with. I've followed players on their votes before and still ran my own theories. It's still rather early in the day as well.

Lol, I thought it was 9 am here. I'm probably going to bed around 10 am and might not even be on around lynch 🙁

Haxx hasn't been on much this whole game, and I guess I expected him to be busy with class.

I'm in the boat where I'm going to have to cast my vote now and may not get to follow it up, or if I do, it will be last minute.

 

[vetmedhead]

Remember if you want more background on your monster, let me know in your role PM

We'll tell you where your monster went to college! Their favorite type of pasta! Which brother they hope kills them someday!

 

[Crayola227]

We'll tell you where your monster went to college! Their favorite type of pasta! Which brother they hope kills them someday!

How about which brother they hope to suck dry

 

[Mad Jack]

How about which brother they hope to suck dry

We know you, we know it's Dean, let's be real

 

[Crayola227]

Torn between SMel vs YK vs Allie vs Coffee. I need to review Allie's posts and other people's thoughts on her, though. I feel like this might just be an old suspicion I haven't shaken.

I have no idea what that Snowy thing was about. It makes you wonder if it was some sort of wolf total brain fart - like a Freudian slip - first instinct was to vote those they know to be village on reflex, lol. Could be confused village. Lord knows I've done some dumb shyte around lynch time (last game as villager I said dumb shyte around lynch that got me lynched, this game, the game before last game when I killed myself making a tie.....)

I sorta hate to punish Mel if he's just inherited horrible village play. But I also don't want to give him a wolf a pass.

Coffee, I've had as pretty nooby up until today with the LIS flip. Definitely has risen on my sketchdar, but I'm not sure above the rest. I'd hate for LIS to have been wrong, but I can't dismiss the concern.

I'm going to go with my vote from yesterday, YK. Just, I haven't seen anything besides LIS thing or SMel (and that was sketchyyyyy) to get me off that vote, so it still seems like my best bet for netting a wolf. Can't lynch them all in one day.

I need to do a re-read or see what happens today before I can really set that vote aside and focus on the others.

lynch YK

 

[Crayola227]

We know you, we know it's Dean, let's be real

why no los dos?? Is it wrong if I said I'd take an angel, too?

 

[Crayola227]

My ex's personal style of dress was very much like Dean's and he looked somewhat like Jake Gyllenhaal. I'm a hardcore monogamist, still, I did have to inform him that Jensen Ackles was on "the list." We watched SPN together, and he was just like, "I understand."

I will say that Dean's style is my favorite look for a guy.

 

[Mad Jack]

why no los dos?? Is it wrong if I said I'd take an angel, too?

Oh nothing wrong with that, I mean, in for a penny, in for a pound... A pound of

 

[WildZoo]

I contingencied last night.

Who said I'm accepting contingencies

 

[Animal Midwife]

Who said I'm accepting contingencies

I thought you loved me Dubz...

 

[WildZoo]

I thought you loved me Dubz...

Check the tally 😉

 

[WildZoo]

I thought you loved me Dubz...

Still, you shouldn't assume things...

 

[Crayola227]

N3
View attachment 229094

He wasn't just any old genie. I mean, he could grant your wishes, if your wishes involved maximum bloodshed. In any case he'd be more inclined to make you hallucinate that your dreams were coming true...all the while slowly draining you of your blood and feeding on your life force.

He was a force to be reckoned with, but he wasn't all-powerful, and sadly had been unable to carry out his missions as of late. A beautiful creature, my djinn, especially when working his magic. He was persistent in his quest, but a silver knife dipped in lamb's blood was enough to extinguish his blue glow.

not sure hallucinating in the back of a white van is a dream coming true.... I mean, not since I graduated college

my WW Jesus worship notwithstanding

Awesome write up

 

[Coopah]

WOW wtf. The grumpy turd went down. And as the vigilante!



If you guys really want me dead okay but can I maybe offer another theory?

If LIS wanted me dead he could've killed me, but, what if he was blocked since the beginning? Like a wolf was playing a game but got really lucky with their target? Based on this game alone, I can definitely think of one player that might try that

No he really wanted you dead, he probably submitted the kill that night, but then was killed instead. Only a stupid vigilante fires shots before they are really sure about something. LIS is many things, grump, crotchety, maybe even a little crusty, but definitely not stupid.

 

[Coopah]

@CoffeeQuestionMark I would also like to discuss some of the actions you made last night.

How do you know coffee had actions last night?

 

[WeimMama]

I know you're both cleared villagers, but we all need to put our thinking caps on.

I feel like they are and this statement kinda just rubs me the wrong way.

I have no idea what that Snowy thing was about. It makes you wonder if it was some sort of wolf total brain fart - like a Freudian slip - first instinct was to vote those they know to be village on reflex, lol. Could be confused village. Lord knows I've done some dumb shyte around lynch time (last game as villager I said dumb shyte around lynch that got me lynched, this game, the game before last game when I killed myself making a tie.....)

So the bolded was my initial though but then, really, if they're a wolf I'd think it would be more likely that they'd just ignore it and pretend to have seen nothing or to move their vote to some other villager randomly just to get village cred for attempting to save those guys. Or move to coffee, which seemed to be the logical move to preserve three known villagers. So I'm having a hard time making that a wolf thing, although its possible.

 

[Crayola227]

I feel like they are and this statement kinda just rubs me the wrong way.


So the bolded was my initial though but then, really, if they're a wolf I'd think it would be more likely that they'd just ignore it and pretend to have seen nothing or to move their vote to some other villager randomly just to get village cred for attempting to save those guys. Or move to coffee, which seemed to be the logical move to preserve three known villagers. So I'm having a hard time making that a wolf thing, although its possible.

Yeah, that's a good point.

I don't mean to rag on AM - I think she's playing a great game. Haxx's reasoning on his vote rubbed me wrong, and there's other reasons I took issue with it.

 

[WeimMama]

Also I'm wondering about coffee, I don't see the wolves letting her draw this much attention to herself on thread unless they're all noobs (which is possible, there are many in this game) or unless they're intending.

I'd also love to hear more from stella. I know this has been beat to death but being quiet is a great place for a wolf to hide so the longer she is this quiet and not adding much of value the more likely I am to vote there (so share your thoughts! even if you feel iffy about them. I know it can be intimidating as a noob, I'm still basically a noob too so I feel ya)

 

[WeimMama]

I don't mean to rag on AM - I think she's playing a great game. Haxx's reasoning on his vote rubbed me wrong, and there's other reasons I took issue with it.

I agree that haxx didn't give much there. Maybe I'm just closed minded but I feel like there are bigger bears to poke, if you will, than two people who were confirmed as village yesterday.