Monty Python and the Holy Grail Official WW game thread

[PetPony]

---

Members don't see this ad.

So the coconuts were smashed with me. Does that mean they're gone and not an item anymore?

 

[zanydogz]

Who the hell used the holy hand grenade on me?!?!?! 😡😡

Now I can't vote...🙁

Well, for the heck of it, lynch jdh

 

[jdh71]

hmmmmm lynch jdh for now. I am interested to hear his defense.

I don't have much of a defense. I got a message, I assumed it was from docE, based on his hinting in the open forum I figured he was trying to tell me he knew I wasn't a wolf.

What I figure is that I've been played, probably by him, as the specific word for my role were used in the message, and now he's throwing me under the bus.

It's super shrewd.

 

[DocEspana]

Why are you always trying to throw me under the bus?

I was sent a message that told me petpony was a wolf and to use the badger. I assumed it was from you, since you kept overly hinting again and again that you knew my role. You seered me and clearly saw I wasn't a wolf. So I went with it.

Better be safe and kill you anyways. Like i said, you clearly are using your power enough to deserve to die, tohugh you *might* have actually killed a wolf, i'd rather not take the chance that youre deceiving us.

 

[jdh71]

Lynch Vote:

JDH 11 (DocEspana, EquineConstant, swings, lissarae, kakuru, nstarz, SnS, MrsSOV, orca2011)

Deadline may last until 12 noon... prefer you get your votes in tonight!

Future planning:
IF we end Lynch early.... PM deadline will be 8am tomorrow, so be prepared for a quicker than usual night turnaround.
If not... night deadline will be 6pm.


JDH??? You out there?

I was reading a little boy a bed-time story.

A Wrinkle in Time.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Lynch Vote:

JDH 16 (DocEspana, EquineConstant, swings, lissarae, kakuru, nstarz, SnS, MrsSOV, orca2011, FH, JJ, Abber, Dyachei, zany)

Deadline may last until 12 noon... prefer you get your votes in tonight!

Future planning:
IF we end Lynch early.... PM deadline will be 8am tomorrow, so be prepared for a quicker than usual night turnaround.
If not... night deadline will be 6pm.

 

[swingnsave]

jdh, if you come back as innocent when you're lynched, then we'll probably believe that either DocE or PP is a wolf. So regardless if you're innocent or now, it somewhat benefits us anyway.

 

[dyachei]

unlynch JDH

Seems fishy to me

 

[jdh71]

Better be safe and kill you anyways. Like i said, you clearly are using your power enough to deserve to die, tohugh you *might* have actually killed a wolf, i'd rather not take the chance that youre deceiving us.

I can appreciate that logic, but I think you've clearly started a bandwagon that can't be pulled back. Everyone is voting and going to bed.

So you know PetPony was NOT a wolf?

 

[StartingoverVet]

Someone has been healed!!!!

 

[jdh71]

jdh, if you come back as innocent when you're lynched, then we'll probably believe that either DocE or PP is a wolf. So regardless if you're innocent or now, it somewhat benefits us anyway.

I appreciate the cold strategy. I've been there, done that.

 

[PetPony]

I'd rather not tell who I am, but better check your source JDH.

What do people think about cuit? Trustworthy or not? If you think so, I'll tell cuit who I am.

I wish I would have had enough time to post about Samoa right away after I reread everything. But by the time I got the chance, everyone else already had. So my voting there doesn't speak for me since I joined in pretty late. 🙁

 

[StartingoverVet]

Lynch Vote:

JDH 15 (DocEspana, EquineConstant, swings, lissarae, kakuru, nstarz, SnS, MrsSOV, orca2011, FH, JJ, Abber, zany)

Waffle-o-meter: 1

Deadline may last until 12 noon... prefer you get your votes in tonight!

Future planning:
IF we end Lynch early.... PM deadline will be 8am tomorrow, so be prepared for a quicker than usual night turnaround.
If not... night deadline will be 6pm.

 

[jdh71]

We don't even get to find out roles until the deadman cart comes along . . .

 

[Lissarae06]

Better be safe and kill you anyways. Like i said, you clearly are using your power enough to deserve to die, tohugh you *might* have actually killed a wolf, i'd rather not take the chance that youre deceiving us.

Wait, so you're not sure jdh is a wolf? Did you tell him that PP was a wolf?

 

[DocEspana]

I can appreciate that logic, but I think you've clearly started a bandwagon that can't be pulled back. Everyone is voting and going to bed.

So you know PetPony was NOT a wolf?

No I know your role, and you continued to use it despite being told that it KILLS players. If you were honestly given a message from someone saying what you claim, then you're screwed because your actions prior to your explanation scream wolf (and the french character would be someone i'd assume to be a wolf). And your reasoning for killing them, if true, are legitimate but yours still screwed because we cant be sure for two or three rounds if you hit a wolf and since your kill move is a one time deal your now a completely useless villager and the least painful role to kill off then having served out your role in the best possible way for the villagers.

 

[zanydogz]

lynch JDH

he has now tried to kill me and succeeded in "killing" petpony. He is the french soldier(s) and his powers are sending insults/messages to any player or attempting to kill a player. He has chosen to try to kill players on multiple occasions. I have hinted to him to not use his power or to waste in on people in the gorge. He chose to target another player who is almost certainly a villager (who knows... maybe he hit a wolf).

Just for the fact that he keeps using a dangerous power, something he would lynch anyone else for doing, he needs to go.

Wait. You knew he was capable of killing villagers and you're just telling us to lynch him NOW??? How long have you known about jdh's role?

And in other news, I've apparently been healed. So thanks to the healer 😀 and no thanks to the idiot who threw the holy hand grenade at me 😡

 

[DocEspana]

Either way it makes no sense to keep you alive on the chance you are a wolf, because you're no longer a useful villager and *were* really suspicious anyway.

 

[PetPony]

Wait, so you're not sure jdh is a wolf? Did you tell him that PP was a wolf?

If so, please check/kill/lynch DocE next. If he sent that lie, then we should have found another wolf!

 

[DocEspana]

Wait. You knew he was capable of killing villagers and you're just telling us to lynch him NOW??? How long have you known about jdh's role?

And in other news, I've apparently been healed. So thanks to the healer 😀 and no thanks to the idiot who threw the holy hand grenade at me 😡

I knew about his role just before i learned of samoas. Can only kill one person at a time and I wasnt sure if the french guy was evil until i did my homework. Still not sure, but strongly leaning to "french guy is evil" given their role in the movie and the way his powers work out.

 

[jdh71]

I'd rather not tell who I am, but better check your source JDH.

What do people think about cuit? Trustworthy or not? If you think so, I'll tell cuit who I am.

I wish I would have had enough time to post about Samoa right away after I reread everything. But by the time I got the chance, everyone else already had. So my voting there doesn't speak for me since I joined in pretty late. 🙁

My source was a message, sent anonymously.

Like I said, I assumed it was docE because the message was very explicit about knowing my role. He spent a few posts to go out of his way to tell me he knew my role and clearly knew I'm not wolf.

I do also get to taunt someone and they don't get to vote, but I haven't seen much use for this so far. Has anyone been taunted?? Anyone chime in.

 

[jdh71]

No I know your role, and you continued to use it despite being told that it KILLS players. If you were honestly given a message from someone saying what you claim, then you're screwed because your actions prior to your explanation scream wolf (and the french character would be someone i'd assume to be a wolf). And your reasoning for killing them, if true, are legitimate but yours still screwed because we cant be sure for two or three rounds if you hit a wolf and since your kill move is a one time deal your now a completely useless villager and the least painful role to kill off then having served out your role in the best possible way for the villagers.

Right.

I got a message that told me petpony was a wolf, or the message said thought was a wolf, so I launched that puppy because I thought you sent it.

Hey man, like I said, I thought it was form you. So I went with it. Who else knew about my role? Just you.

 

[PetPony]

My source was a message, sent anonymously.

Like I said, I assumed it was docE because the message was very explicit about knowing my role. He spent a few posts to go out of his way to tell me he knew my role and clearly knew I'm not wolf.

I do also get to taunt someone and they don't get to vote, but I haven't seen much use for this so far. Has anyone been taunted?? Anyone chime in.

I remember him hinting at knowing your role. Not at knowing you're NOT a wolf. Care to look back and search for it and then quote it?

 

[zanydogz]

unlynch jdh

Something seems fishy to me...going to reread the thread and see if anything pops out at me.

 

[Lissarae06]

the French guys were douches in the movie so I'm going to keep my vote.

 

[DocEspana]

Wait, so you're not sure jdh is a wolf? Did you tell him that PP was a wolf?

No. I know who sent messages (i may not know every message sender) and messages by swallow were NOT sent to JDH. But who knows, maybe there are multiple swallows.

 

[jdh71]

Wait. You knew he was capable of killing villagers and you're just telling us to lynch him NOW??? How long have you known about jdh's role?

And in other news, I've apparently been healed. So thanks to the healer 😀 and no thanks to the idiot who threw the holy hand grenade at me 😡

Killing "villagers" is a bad way to phrase it. I had a one time use to take out a player. I did try it on DocE first night as a "just in case" kind of a thing, but he was saved because LIS turned him into a newt. I didn't use it the next night because I was waiting for the right time, and then I got the message so I went with it because it was SPECIFIC about my role, so I figured it was DocE trying to get info to me.

And then I show up here and he's tossing me under the bus first thing.

He's good. Really good.

 

[PetPony]

the French guys were douches in the movie so I'm going to keep my vote.

👍

Even though no use, just to make it clear what I think: Lynch JDH

 

[jdh71]

Either way it makes no sense to keep you alive on the chance you are a wolf, because you're no longer a useful villager and *were* really suspicious anyway.

No more suspicious than you !!

I get your logic though.

Still lynching villagers is bad for the game. Even my little amount of game theory is good on that point.

 

[jdh71]

I remember him hinting at knowing your role. Not at knowing you're NOT a wolf. Care to look back and search for it and then quote it?

Dude. Because I'm not a wolf, I figured he knew that too. Logic.

If he really thought I was a wolf he would have gone after me, but this way he was able to cause me to kill someone and then toss me under the bus.

Hell. We still have no clue if you're a wolf or not!

He may be right.

I may have gotten played.

OR they could even be someone else playing the whole situation against us all.

 

[jdh71]

No. I know who sent messages (i may not know every message sender) and messages by swallow were NOT sent to JDH. But who knows, maybe there are multiple swallows.

Oh that some VERY convenient information now!

Dude, you're really gunna play me like that?

 

[PetPony]

I do think DocE is worth looking into either way if JDH is a wolf or not.

If he's not, maybe his guess of the message coming from DocE could be right since DocE knew his role.

If he is a wolf, he might throw DocE's name out there to make us think that he wouldn't be a wolf since one wolf wouldn't throw another one under the bus.

Both sound reasonable and like something thought up by a veteran.

 

[swingnsave]

My source was a message, sent anonymously.

Like I said, I assumed it was docE because the message was very explicit about knowing my role. He spent a few posts to go out of his way to tell me he knew my role and clearly knew I'm not wolf.

I do also get to taunt someone and they don't get to vote, but I haven't seen much use for this so far. Has anyone been taunted?? Anyone chime in.

i was been taunted night 1, but was still allowed to vote day 2

 

[hedgiehog]

lynch jdh

 

[swingnsave]

the French guys were douches in the movie so I'm going to keep my vote.

i concur

 

[jdh71]

i was been taunted night 1, but was still allowed to vote day 2

That taunt wasnt from me. My taunt doens't allow you to vote. Ask DocE. He KNOWS my role.

 

[jdh71]

I do think DocE is worth looking into either way if JDH is a wolf or not.

If he's not, maybe his guess of the message coming from DocE could be right since DocE knew his role.

If he is a wolf, he might throw DocE's name out there to make us think that he wouldn't be a wolf since one wolf wouldn't throw another one under the bus.

Both sound reasonable and like something thought up by a veteran.

since when??

 

[PetPony]

Just because he knows your role/role description, doesn't mean he knows you're a wolf or not. So assuming something doesn't help.

Also, there have been dead people messing with live players so many times here, it's stupid to trust anonymous messages. I've been a player like that before. It's fun to throw stuff like that out there.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Lynch Vote:

JDH 15 (DocEspana, EquineConstant, swings, lissarae, kakuru, nstarz, SnS, MrsSOV, orca2011, FH, JJ, Abber,hedgie, PP )

Waffle-o-meter: 2

Deadline may last until 12 noon... prefer you get your votes in tonight!

Future planning:
IF we end Lynch early.... PM deadline will be 8am tomorrow, so be prepared for a quicker than usual night turnaround.
If not... night deadline will be 6pm.

 

[swingnsave]

That taunt wasnt from me. My taunt doens't allow you to vote. Ask DocE. He KNOWS my role.

so does that mean there are probably mutiple french men since they were pretty much known for taunting in the movie? hmm

 

[PetPony]

since when??

Is that a confession?

 

[abbercadaver]

so does that mean there are probably mutiple french men since they were pretty much known for taunting in the movie? hmm

👍 Good thought!

 

[zanydogz]

Ugh. While I still think something fishy is going on, I do agree that the french were a**holes in the movie so lynch jdh. DocE you'd better be right about this or your next.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Lynch Vote:

JDH 16 (DocEspana, EquineConstant, swings, lissarae, kakuru, nstarz, SnS, MrsSOV, orca2011, FH, JJ, Abber,hedgie, PP , zany)

Waffle-o-meter: 2

Deadline may last until 12 noon... prefer you get your votes in tonight!

Future planning:
IF we end Lynch early.... PM deadline will be 8am tomorrow, so be prepared for a quicker than usual night turnaround.
If not... night deadline will be 6pm.

 

[jdh71]

Just because he knows your role/role description, doesn't mean he knows you're a wolf or not. So assuming something doesn't help.

Also, there have been dead people messing with live players so many times here, it's stupid to trust anonymous messages. I've been a player like that before. It's fun to throw stuff like that out there.

Based on the verbage in the message, I thought I was being given information to help.

I didn't figure this early in the game anyone else would have had a chance to find out my role. I didn't tell anyone. And we've had a few rounds for seering.

Was a bit of a gamble? Sure. But that's how I play WW. I gamble a bit.

And I find it ironic you bring up dead people messing with live players!

 

[Flim Flam Man]

Wholey moley. Put the little one to bed, and I have ~50 posts to read. Based on the info presented, lynch jdh, though DocE, you are obviously next if you are wrong.

 

[jdh71]

so does that mean there are probably mutiple french men since they were pretty much known for taunting in the movie? hmm

could be

I'd pay attention to people in or who have been in my castle

 

[zanydogz]

so does that mean there are probably mutiple french men since they were pretty much known for taunting in the movie? hmm

Hmm...I wouldn't be surprised and it makes sense.

 

[PetPony]

Based on the verbage in the message, I thought I was being given information to help.

I didn't figure this early in the game anyone else would have had a chance to find out my role. I didn't tell anyone. And we've had a few rounds for seering.

Was a bit of a gamble? Sure. But that's how I play WW. I gamble a bit.

And I find it ironic you bring up dead people messing with live players!

I'm not completely dead yet. 😛

 

[jdh71]

Is that a confession?

Not in so many words, just it could be anything.

The bandwagon is in full effect. I'm gonezo.

DocE is right my useful ability is gone now. The taunt wouldn't be much help until the endgame, not really.