Noobs...in SPAAAAACE - 5th Annual Noob WW Game

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Doctor-S said:
Wondering about M935: he might be a chaos role or some other type of non-villager role.

It may be worth noting, Shelter called out M935 a few days ago:


Does this still bother you @sheltermed? Please like this post or post a "yes" type image, if your response is an unqualified "yes."



Still have not received a response from M935 … and wondering if M935 has anything to say about this matter because the wolves decided to NK Frosty (after Frosty claimed to have spoken with M935)? Otherwise, Frosty had been pretty quiet on the thread.
Click to expand...
[/QUOTE]

I must have missed your question. Can you ask again?

Also, I’ve role revealed from day 1. You’re welcome for killing pickles.
 
Also @CoffeeQuestionMark I understand your concerns. But I already said that I legitimately wasn’t on the thread Saturday due to my miscalculation about my new job. And then Sunday stupid microbe. I thought before that point I was playing well. But I mean maybe not to y’all.
 

I must have missed your question. Can you ask again?

Also, I’ve role revealed from day 1. You’re welcome for killing pickles.[/QUOTE]
@Matthew9Thirtyfive
I am confident in you.

Do you have any current reads?
Edit to tag
 
sheltermed said:
giphy.gif
Click to expand...
It's interesting that you chose an image of Joey shrugging from the "Friends" television show because "Princess Consuela Banana Hammock" (see below) was also a name used in the "Friends" television show. Just saying or it just might be a coincidence.

@sheltermed if you're able, please like this post ... or post another image, if that works better for you.

picklegurl said:
Princess Consuela Banana Hammock, I am, Beagle Easter and Paws Santa for waiting. We are the world, we are the children, we are the ones who make a brighter day, so let's start giving. Oh, there's a choice we're making, we're saving our own lives. It's true we'll make a better day, just you and me.
Click to expand...
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
I must have missed your question. Can you ask again?

Also, I’ve role revealed from day 1. You’re welcome for killing pickles.
Click to expand...
@Matthew9Thirtyfive
I am confident in you.

Do you have any current reads?
Edit to tag
Click to expand...
Tags don't usually work if they are edited in (as in the user won't get a notification about it) :prof:
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
I must have missed your question. Can you ask again?

Also, I’ve role revealed from day 1. You’re welcome for killing pickles.
@Matthew9Thirtyfive
I am confident in you.

Do you have any current reads?
Edit to tag
Click to expand...

I almost feel like we need to start over with the potential for converts. I made an item last night that will help us a little.
 
I really would like to hear from everyone today. Many of the remaining members of the group have not been posting much, whether because you have been busy or because you are a wolf and trying to be low key.
@emlady09 I am hoping to hear from you more about your connection with shelter. Atm, I am a bit skeptical of both of you because I am not super sure what is going on with that
@Barkley13, @dolphin106258, and @killerleaf I would like to hear some reads. Don't feel like I have seen much lately
@Dinashadow any responses to the skepticism of too many seers? I am inclined to think you had other ways of being skeptical of mutts over MSU but for some reason still skeptical of MSU
@MSUcvmHOPE any responses to skepticism about you?
 
Doctor-S said:
It's interesting that you chose an image of Joey shrugging from the "Friends" television show because "Princess Consuela Banana Hammock" (see below) was also a name used in the "Friends" television show. Just saying or it just might be a coincidence.

@sheltermed if you're able, please like this post ... or post another image, if that works better for you.
Click to expand...

giphy.gif
 
Also it’s sketchy to me that someone could see a player so aggressively go after wolves to the point of making an item that killed one overnight (pickles) and then somehow still be skeptical of them. To me, that is sketch and has been the hallmark of basically every wolf we’ve outed.
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
I really would like to hear from everyone today. Many of the remaining members of the group have not been posting much, whether because you have been busy or because you are a wolf and trying to be low key.
@emlady09 I am hoping to hear from you more about your connection with shelter. Atm, I am a bit skeptical of both of you because I am not super sure what is going on with that
@Barkley13, @dolphin106258, and @killerleaf I would like to hear some reads. Don't feel like I have seen much lately
@Dinashadow any responses to the skepticism of too many seers? I am inclined to think you had other ways of being skeptical of mutts over MSU but for some reason still skeptical of MSU
@MSUcvmHOPE any responses to skepticism about you?
Click to expand...
Honestly I spent all night looking back over posts and cannot defend my ignorance to misreading/missing key info. I looked very strange for not knowing who to vote for (when it was obvious). I only noticed how bad I looked when looking back.

I can say I am village, haven't been converted...hell, no one's tried to even act on me (cause then maybe I could use my abilities).

I get if you guys want to vote me out to get me out of the way, especially since my abilities are not as useful as others at this point, but then we would be another villager down. I support the group choice since we've been doing decently well so far.

My biggest worry are the possibility of multiple converts (hoping that's not the case).

Also sorry for suspecting you Coffee, but your posts are still weird to me. Lol

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile
 
MSUcvmHOPE said:
Honestly I spent all night looking back over posts and cannot defend my ignorance to misreading/missing key info. I looked very strange for not knowing who to vote for (when it was obvious). I only noticed how bad I looked when looking back.

I can say I am village, haven't been converted...hell, no one's tried to even act on me (cause then maybe I could use my abilities).

I get if you guys want to vote me out to get me out of the way, especially since my abilities are not as useful as others at this point, but then we would be another villager down. I support the group choice since we've been doing decently well so far.

My biggest worry are the possibility of multiple converts (hoping that's not the case).

Also sorry for suspecting you Coffee, but your posts are still weird to me. Lol

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

Eh I don’t think that’s a good idea. I don’t think it’s good to vote to lynch someone on a whim. We have two days for this cycle.
 
MSUcvmHOPE said:
I would hope not. I just understand why I'm on some people's sus list.

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

Right now nearly everyone should be on everyone’s sus list. We don’t know who—if anyone—got converted.

I brought up my night action to kill pickles as well as build something I can use to help against the wolves to demonstrate that I haven’t been converted.
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
I really would like to hear from everyone today. Many of the remaining members of the group have not been posting much, whether because you have been busy or because you are a wolf and trying to be low key.
@emlady09 I am hoping to hear from you more about your connection with shelter. Atm, I am a bit skeptical of both of you because I am not super sure what is going on with that
@Barkley13, @dolphin106258, and @killerleaf I would like to hear some reads. Don't feel like I have seen much lately
@Dinashadow any responses to the skepticism of too many seers? I am inclined to think you had other ways of being skeptical of mutts over MSU but for some reason still skeptical of MSU
@MSUcvmHOPE any responses to skepticism about you?
Click to expand...
Yes so currently I have Barkley and killler more on the ? To wolfy category. More from the fact of me viewing other players as village than them doing something outright wolfy. Obviously conversion muddles this a little so I’m slightly ignoring that for now. I have had you as village, m###, obvs coffee, Dr. S as well, I feel like they’ve had some good thoughts and contributions for the village.
MSU I want to place into my village camp, especially after their recent post. But I just am not sure.
Dina is more of a true question mark for me.

Again I know conversion screws it up. So I’m gonna think of that into everything but these are my reads I’d like to have posted before my microbe fun. Lol

Edited: left out two words
 
Oh I left out Stagg...but that’s bc he is always tricky and would def be an excellent concert choice. He can definitely be super helpful while also being a wolf. But it’s like a crazy theory in my brain just bc he makes me paranoid. He also gave all that seer info but then didn’t think there were other possible explanations for extra info. (Which I’m waiting for an answer from him on the item question). And that just makes me weirded out a little. Again not a solid theory at all, nor a popular one but i want it out there.
 
Okay also, just saw emlady’s post. Idk if them being interconnected allows the microbe to affect shelter and herself. But I recieved an item in the middle of the day yesterday (indicating that random items have most likely been a thing. Hence my Stagg question) but the item allowed me to monitor someone’s role PM. So I chose shelter, at first bc people seemed confused and unsure of shelters claims so I wanted to check. It showed me that shelter was indeed infected by a microbe for sure.
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
@Dinashadow any responses to the skepticism of too many seers? I am inclined to think you had other ways of being skeptical of mutts over MSU
Click to expand...

I can't really touch on the 'too many seers' comment because this is my first game and I have nothing to compare it to. I think staggs thought shelter was a seer because she knew em's ability but it seems like they are just connected. We have one confirmed seer which is Dandy.
 
I'm not sure who could be a wolf at this point. I have no strong suspicion that someone is a wolf. I'm more certain about people being villagers. I'm questioning my MSU choice from yesterday and the wolf converting possibility makes it more confusing.
 
Just caught up on thread thus far, but about to leave work. I will be more than happy to answer more questions later in more depth, but given recent events with Shelter and EM, I believe my "too many seers" theory was not correct. So while that hasn't cleared anyone, I'm less suspicious of Dina and Shelter for now. Will certainly answer questions later on, but want to get home and spend some time with family, as they are flying out of town early tomorrow. So I will have all day on Christmas (after work) to figure things out and answer more questions.
 
Doctor-S said:
Wondering about M935: he might be a chaos role or some other type of non-villager role.

It may be worth noting, Shelter called out M935 a few days ago:


Does this still bother you @sheltermed? Please like this post or post a "yes" type image, if your response is an unqualified "yes."



Still have not received a response from M935 … and wondering if M935 has anything to say about this matter because the wolves decided to NK Frosty (after Frosty claimed to have spoken with M935)? Otherwise, Frosty had been pretty quiet on the thread.
Click to expand...
[/QUOTE]I'm curious as to why you think this is important now? Matt, given his roles in taking down wolves and not showing any inclination of trying to confuse villagers, doesn't seem very chaos like to me at least. Especially at this point. (I'll give it to you at the beginning it was a poss)
Do you have any other leans?

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile
 
Barkley we haven't heard much opinions from you lately. Any leans/thoughts?

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile
 
ok potato salad made, deviled eggs ready to be filled, cookie dough chilling and frosting made. have a moment to sit and read thru.. but this really feels like d1. everything just gets reset due to conversion. ugh.
 
matt and em and shelter in village....

leaning a little toward msu being wolf...or may just be clueless.
 
Matthew9Thirtyfive said:
I’m a bit suspicious of Dr S. It seems odd to suspect someone who just made an item specifically to kill the alpha wolf.
Click to expand...
I thought that initially as well. But I went back and read some of her posts from yesterday and she seems less suspicious to me now. I was worried about convert with her but not as much now. One thing is both doc and staggs pushed for the idea that pickles is alpha, and not to waste Lynch votes on her yesterday. This turned out to be true.

@dolphin106258 why were you going between lynching mutts and msu yesterday? Were you trying to warn us about MSU in some way?

Killer is appearing more village to me upon reading yesterday. But I would like to hear your thoughts when you catch up.

To me, MSU is either a total noob, or is attempting to come across as a total noob (sorry lol). I will need to hear more from you today.

I am highly suspicious of Barkley for a number of reasons after re-reading some of the thread from yesterday. Waited a while to vote for mutts, changed her vote, then changed it again when it was clear mutts was going down. She wasn't contributing much, just more asking questions of people. She also claimed shelter could talk to mutts, which was untrue and not sure why she said it.
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
I thought that initially as well. But I went back and read some of her posts from yesterday and she seems less suspicious to me now. I was worried about convert with her but not as much now. One thing is both doc and staggs pushed for the idea that pickles is alpha, and not to waste Lynch votes on her yesterday. This turned out to be true.

@dolphin106258 why were you going between lynching mutts and msu yesterday? Were you trying to warn us about MSU in some way?

Killer is appearing more village to me upon reading yesterday. But I would like to hear your thoughts when you catch up.

To me, MSU is either a total noob, or is attempting to come across as a total noob (sorry lol). I will need to hear more from you today.

I am highly suspicious of Barkley for a number of reasons after re-reading some of the thread from yesterday. Waited a while to vote for mutts, changed her vote, then changed it again when it was clear mutts was going down. She wasn't contributing much, just more asking questions of people. She also claimed shelter could talk to mutts, which was untrue and not sure why she said it.
Click to expand...
Dolphin said she was trying to show that she was sus of both myself and mutt.
 
Barkley13 said:
1. Why do you think she is alpha and not 1x lynch avoidance?



2. Why did you choose to heal Ziggy?



Have any of your reads changed?



What do you think about the bolded?



Why do you think emmy is likely village?
Click to expand...

Barkley13 said:
3. I'm pretty torn on M# because on one hand I feel like he's been so outspoken and sketchy all game it actually makes him seem like a villager because I feel like he would be a little more careful as a wolf but he's also still alive even after saying he had an ability the first day but that could also just be the wolves trying to make him look sketchy so that we'll lynch him
Click to expand...

Barkley13 said:
4. How likely is it that there were 3 wolves on the killer lynch the first day?
Click to expand...

Barkley13 said:
5. I mean like strategy wise would it make more sense for them to vote all together like that or spread their votes out?
Click to expand...

1. This could be trying to get us to waste a Lynch on pickles
2. no one else questioned this, seems pretty obvious
3. everyone else seemed pretty sure of m# at this point...
4. again, could be trying to indicate she thought it was unlikely they would all vote for killer on the first day, which turned out to be true
5. strategy wise, it wouldn't make sense for them to do it. but they did it. see 4
 
Also, are we going to talk about @Dandelion18 's cryptic messages from the grave yesterday? Could be important somehow
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
I thought that initially as well. But I went back and read some of her posts from yesterday and she seems less suspicious to me now. I was worried about convert with her but not as much now. One thing is both doc and staggs pushed for the idea that pickles is alpha, and not to waste Lynch votes on her yesterday. This turned out to be true.
Click to expand...

Your points about bark are valid. Why are you no longer concerned about doc and staggs being converts? Did mutt have to pull all her converts before she got lynched?
 
Matthew9Thirtyfive said:
Your points about bark are valid. Why are you no longer concerned about doc and staggs being converts? Did mutt have to pull all her converts before she got lynched?
Click to expand...
Doc was the first to lynch mutts yesterday and was going voting alpha. I don't see her as 100% in the clear but not super duper suspicious.
I am not swayed one way or another about staggs honestly. I could see her being a convert, but I would need to investigate this more or hear more.
I am not sure what you mean by the last sentence.
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
Doc was the first to lynch mutts yesterday and was going voting alpha. I don't see her as 100% in the clear but not super duper suspicious.
I am not swayed one way or another about staggs honestly. I could see her being a convert, but I would need to investigate this more or hear more.
I am not sure what you mean by the last sentence.
Click to expand...

I'm asking if there was any way for mutt to get converts after the lynch vote. Also, can they get converts during the day or just at night?
 
ziggyandjazzy said:
Doc was the first to lynch mutts yesterday and was going voting alpha. I don't see her as 100% in the clear but not super duper suspicious.
I am not swayed one way or another about staggs honestly. I could see her being a convert, but I would need to investigate this more or hear more.
I am not sure what you mean by the last sentence.
Click to expand...
Lol in this case Stagg is a he 😉
 
Matthew9Thirtyfive said:
I'm asking if there was any way for mutt to get converts after the lynch vote. Also, can they get converts during the day or just at night?
Click to expand...
In the game I played with converts it was only after wolf numbers dropped low enough and then it was during nights only.
 
WildZoo said:
N3

200.gif


-insert X-Files theme here-

He wanted to believe, believe in his ability to find those who had been killing his friends. And he had been right before. So it was with confidence that Foxy Smolder Agent Mulder set off for his next investigative target. He had made himself vulnerable in order to take down the first one. Surely someone would have his back.

He was approached by a short figure in dark clothing.
"Hello, Agent."
"Who are you?" Mulder eyed the man suspiciously. It wasn't who he had come looking for, but looked downright nefarious.
"That doesn't matter. This is the end of the line for you. Evil will always triumph. Do you know why? Because good is dumb."
"Are you sure about that? You guys don't seem to be doing too hot."
"Oh you have no idea. Our numbers grow stronger even as we speak. Soon our forces will..."

Mulder blocked out the sound of the man's monologue as he looked around for a way to save himself. Was there really no one here to help him out? He supposed it was to be expected - there were others that needed protecting too. It might not have made a difference anyway. He looked back towards his enemy and was not surprised to find that the weird little dude was still talking.

"Look, if you're gonna kill me, just get it over with. I'd rather have the silence of death than continue to listen to the sound of your voice."

That seemed to do the trick.

Dead is @Dandelion18, who was Spooky Mulder, a villager and affiliation seer.


14 players remain
1. @emlady09
3. @Barkley13
5. @Matthew9Thirtyfive
6. @Dinashadow
7. @ziggyandjazzy
8. @Doctor-S
11. @picklegurl
14. @MSUcvmHOPE
15. @sheltermed
16. @muttmanager
18. @killerleaf
19. @Stagg737
20. @dolphin106258
21. @CoffeeQuestionMark

Lost in Space
2. @SkiOtter - Marvin the Paranoid Android, Ritual Sacrifice
9. @mypetmoose - Magrathean Sperm Whale, Lover
10. @Beagle-Brigade - Joseph Cooper, Night Cancel
12. @FrostySparrow - Black Hole, Neutral
13. @Stella Mudd - Bowl of Petunias, Lover
4. @grebes4lyfe - Quiet Supernova, Wolf
17. @Dandelion18 - Spooky Mulder, Seer

It is now Day 4. Lynch deadline is 10pm EST.​
Click to expand...

See the bold from N3. I think someone was converted that night.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3 4
Replies
150
Views
7K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
WildZoo
Cthulhu & Friends: A Lovecraftian Tale - 9th Annual Noob WW Game
63 64 65 66 67
Replies
3K
Views
98K
WildZoo
WildZoo
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2022 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
330
Views
11K
TelemarketingEnigma
TelemarketingEnigma
Top