Noobs...in SPAAAAACE - 5th Annual Noob WW Game

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I said NEARLY ALL

Cool cool cool.

 

[SkiOtter]

Is this a pressure vote?

Bc im inclined to lean dandelion since she didnt actually answer your question, or my follow up just yet

Mostly because she came back on the thread, didn’t switch her vote from the reasoning of “I’m just jumping on the bandwagon” after the rest of this day has happened

 

[sheltermed]

I'm not sure why there are so many votes on killerleaf and emlady?

 

[grebes4lyfe]

I'm inclined to believe these statements because I have made similar mistakes in the past. I do think that there is a good bit of manatoring going on here, though, almost to the point where he is repeating what his manator has advised verbatim. Just how I feel about the phrasing. I'm going to be [potentially] naive, though, and give you the benefit of the doubt.

unlynch M935 for now

This turns my attention more toward @grebes4lyfe, who seems to be moving on now, but I would still like to hear why you felt compelled to put up such a strong (in my opinion) defense to the fishing claims, especially when it was only Stagg and then Matt who only jumped on that logic after Stagg.

I'm confused by your question, sorry.
Why did I defend myself against fishing claims from stagg and matt?
I mean... i literally asked matt if he had a night action... which is fishing. so there wasn't really anything to defend there and i didn't realize it was fishing until it was pointed out to me.
i did defend pushing matt about his claims up to that point though, and i stand by it. he was very vocal that he could prove that killer was a wolf, but he had to live to D2, and that didn't sit right with me so I pressed him about it and asked him to back up his claim.
i don't really understand why that is sketchy

 

[sheltermed]

he was very vocal that he could prove that killer was a wolf, but he had to live to D2, and that didn't sit right with me so I pressed him about it and asked him to back up his claim.

what do you think about the logic that if you were village, you wouldn't want to draw attention to Matt's role and/or ability (provided it's true) to prevent him from getting killed?

 

[Karabiner13]

🙂🙂🙂🙂

PSA: don’t say WHO your manator is

Who, who, whoooo

I mean, yes. @Trilt @kaydubs @someone put MJ in the manator chat at the very least por favor

****
It’s all up to Trilt. I’m maxed out. But am trying to be recognized as an official doctor person.
****

It’s like everyone forgot I added KD 😢

🙂🙂🙂🙂

 

[mypetmoose]

I don't feel very strongly about the grebes vs. m-numbers situation at the moment... but maybe someone can convince me otherwise? If not, I'm happy to sit on my vote and see what happens...

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[killerleaf]

I'm not sure why there are so many votes on killerleaf and emlady?

can we say bandwagon?? lol

 

[grebes4lyfe]

what do you think about the logic that if you were village, you wouldn't want to draw attention to Matt's role and/or ability (provided it's true) to prevent him from getting killed?

i think it's solid logic that didn't occur to me until it was pointed out.
i was more focused on whether or not he could back up his claims that he could prove someone was a wolf and making sure he wasn't a wolf just trying to dupe us and i fished and it wasn't smart and i see that now.

 

[emlady09]

@MSUcvmHOPE @muttmanager @mypetmoose why the lynch vote?

 

[SkiOtter]

I'm not sure why there are so many votes on killerleaf and emlady?

Killer: because her name has killer in it SO SHE MUST BE A WOLF!!!1!1!1!1!!!!1!1!!!!!

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

I'm not sure why there are so many votes on killerleaf and emlady?

Not sure about emlady. I think people jumped on Killer because she said she thought beagles were silly. Which is honestly kind of a dumb reason to lynch someone.

 

[muttmanager]

Nearly all the people starting with M names must really not like me for their need to lynch me... 🙁

Any suggestions on anyone else or sticking with your bandwagon vote?

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

i think it's solid logic that didn't occur to me until it was pointed out.
i was more focused on whether or not he could back up his claims that he could prove someone was a wolf and making sure he wasn't a wolf just trying to dupe us and i fished and it wasn't smart and i see that now.

Hmm, and yet you're still talking about it.

 

[sheltermed]

I don't feel very strongly about the grebes vs. m-numbers situation at the moment... but maybe someone can convince me otherwise?

It's hard to say for me. The interaction between pickles and m-numbers (I like that nickname) seemed like a lot right off the bat, which is why I asked if they knew each other. Now it seems like all three of them (not so much pickles) are in a big noob cluster****, but I don't want to just write it off as noobiness and not look at it. Been there done that.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Hmm, and yet you're still talking about it.

because shelter literally just asked me about it

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

because shelter literally just asked me about it

What a convenient cover that would make.

 

[killerleaf]

funny story....o so many years ago, I walked out of the garage on a windy winter day. a leaf stuck in my cheek. it drew blood! so, the name killerleaf was born...

 

[SkiOtter]

funny story....o so many years ago, I walked out of the garage on a windy winter day. a leaf stuck in my cheek. it drew blood! so, the name killerleaf was born...

LOL

 

[grebes4lyfe]

What a convenient cover that would make.

This turns my attention more toward @grebes4lyfe, who seems to be moving on now, but I would still like to hear why you felt compelled to put up such a strong (in my opinion) defense to the fishing claims, especially when it was only Stagg and then Matt who only jumped on that logic after Stagg.

what do you think about the logic that if you were village, you wouldn't want to draw attention to Matt's role and/or ability (provided it's true) to prevent him from getting killed?

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

It's hard to say for me. The interaction between pickles and m-numbers (I like that nickname) seemed like a lot right off the bat, which is why I asked if they knew each other. Now it seems like all three of them (not so much pickles) are in a big noob cluster****, but I don't want to just write it off as noobiness and not look at it. Been there done that.

I feel like m-numbers is almost as tedious to write as my whole name. For some reason, I have taken a liking to dirty thirty. Probably because it's more reminiscent of the call signs we gave each other at my last two commands.

 

[SkiOtter]

@CoffeeQuestionMark how are you feeling about dirty thirty and also the killer lynch currently

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

@grebes4lyfe That doesn't make it less convenient. That was actually my point.

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

Unlynch Killer
Lynch Grebes

 

[sheltermed]

I do not think we should waste d1 lynching baseless bandwagons. Read people's posts and think about what they've said and how they've interacted with others. Coming up with theories based on those things might be fruitless on d1, but it's better than just voting for someone because someone else is, IMO.

 

[mypetmoose]

So my original reason for picking emlady was bc she was the last at that point to jump on killers bandwagon

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[mypetmoose]

Now I'm second guessing though bc I had to go back like 20 pages to find my reason

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[grebes4lyfe]

@grebes4lyfe That doesn't make it less convenient. That was actually my point.

so do you think shelter and i are wolves together or something?

 

[SkiOtter]

Now I'm second guessing though bc I had to go back like 20 pages to find my reason

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

What’s making you second guess

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

so do you think shelter and i are wolves together or something?

Not sure, but I think you could be using shelter's curiosity as a way to justify your own wolfy activity.

 

[picklegurl]

Now I am intrigued, is there something going on with Shelter and M935? Shelter was a little concerned about the reaction between M935 and me. But these posts make me question the Shelter and M935 interactions... Maybe it's a coincidence, maybe it's not.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Not sure, but I think you could be using shelter's curiosity as a way to justify your own wolfy activity.

i'm not really sure how else i was supposed to respond to her...
your tin-foil theories have gone above my head now

 

[killerleaf]

so do you think shelter and i are wolves together or something?

birds of a feather...is a saying.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Unofficial "Where no manator has gone before" Lynch Tally
M935 (2) - z&j, killer
emlady (3) - MSU, mutts, mpmoose
Beagle (1) - Barkley
killer (4) - beagles, dandelion, Dinashadow, emlady
shelter (1) - grebes
pickles () -
Dandelion (1) - Dr. S
Ski (1) - dolphin
Dinashadow (2) - pickles, Ski
mpmoose (1) - Coffee?
grebes (2) - Stagg, M935
z&j () -

18/21 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~40 minutes)

 

[killerleaf]

🙂

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

i'm not really sure how else i was supposed to respond to her...
your tin-foil theories have gone above my head now

I've got the tinniest, foiliest hat of them all, sister.

 

[SkiOtter]

If I'm changing my vote? I wanted to know what would happen with a tie before I decided.

Now that you know some things that can happen in a tie, have you decided to just stay on the killer lynch? If so, why killer?

 

[grebes4lyfe]

I've got the tinniest, foiliest hat of them all, sister.

i'm beginning to realize this!

 

[emlady09]

Grebes is loooking awfully suspicious.
M395 does talk more than necessary...
I agree with @sheltermed we shouldn't waste a good lynching on a bandwagon vote.

UNLYNCH Killer

 

[sheltermed]

lynch grebes

For a few reasons. I thought she was moving on from the M935 fishing accusations, but once I started asking more questions about it she picked it back up. Yes, I was asking you questions, but you had a few options. You could have quoted your previous defense and said you already addressed it, you could have ignored me altogether, or you could have introduced an entirely new theory about other people. I get you aren't an experienced player, but neither am I. I would also like to put to rest any "birds of a feather" theories between myself and grebes before that goes any further. Not a thing. Honestly weirded out that grebes even suggested something about being wolves together. No thanks.

 

[mypetmoose]

What’s making you second guess

Honestly just because I have weird potentially wolfy feels for m-number and because I needed to check on my emlady reasoning bc it had been so long... still seems like sound logic though so I'm gonna stick with it I think... I just want to wait overnight to see how m-number plays out

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[Dinashadow]

Now that you know some things that can happen in a tie, have you decided to just stay on the killer lynch? If so, why killer?

I was hesitant to change because I would inadvertently create a tie and I don't want to cause too much chaos on my first day...

What's going to happen is we're all going to pull our votes off of Killer and then she'll end up being a wolf

 

[grebes4lyfe]

lynch grebes

For a few reasons. I thought she was moving on from the M935 fishing accusations, but once I started asking more questions about it she picked it back up. Yes, I was asking you questions, but you had a few options. You could have quoted your previous defense and said you already addressed it, you could have ignored me altogether, or you could have introduced an entirely new theory about other people. I get you aren't an experienced player, but neither am I. I would also like to put to rest any "birds of a feather" theories between myself and grebes before that goes any further. Not a thing. Honestly weirded out that grebes even suggested something about being wolves together. No thanks.

1) if i ignored you that would have looked sketchy
2) i could have quoted my previous defense, yes. didn't think of that
3) you LITERALLY asked me about it and i'm sketchy for answering you??

 

[SkiOtter]

I was hesitant to change because I would inadvertently create a tie and I don't want to cause too much chaos on my first day...

What's going to happen is we're all going to pull our votes off of Killer and then she'll end up being a wolf

Okay this still doesn’t give a reason for why you’re voting killer specifically.

 

[killerleaf]

Dina, but think positive. I am not a wolf...so how you gonna feel when it is revealed that you killed an innocent villager?

 

[sheltermed]

What's going to happen is we're all going to pull our votes off of Killer and then she'll end up being a wolf

Then we're going to be very disappointed in ourselves.

 

[emlady09]

Honestly just because I have weird potentially wolfy feels for m-number and because I needed to check on my emlady reasoning bc it had been so long... still seems like sound logic though so I'm gonna stick with it I think... I just want to wait overnight to see how m-number plays out

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

I had no significant reasoning hadn't been on all day until this evening. Finally caught up on the discussion making me believe there are some very suspicious people out there.

grebes, M395

 

[dolphin106258]

I was hesitant to change because I would inadvertently create a tie and I don't want to cause too much chaos on my first day...

What's going to happen is we're all going to pull our votes off of Killer and then she'll end up being a wolf

Why do you think that? Just bc people may pull off? Don’t you think the lynch was a little silly to start with?

 

[SkiOtter]

I had no significant reasoning hadn't been on all day until this evening. Finally caught up on the discussion making me believe there are some very suspicious people out there.

grebes, M395

What is making you suspicious of them?

 

[Barkley13]

lynch grebes

For a few reasons. I thought she was moving on from the M935 fishing accusations, but once I started asking more questions about it she picked it back up. Yes, I was asking you questions, but you had a few options. You could have quoted your previous defense and said you already addressed it, you could have ignored me altogether, or you could have introduced an entirely new theory about other people. I get you aren't an experienced player, but neither am I. I would also like to put to rest any "birds of a feather" theories between myself and grebes before that goes any further. Not a thing. Honestly weirded out that grebes even suggested something about being wolves together. No thanks.

Not sure I follow this logic. If she had ignored it then wouldn't she have been seen as wolfy for intentionally ignoring questions directed at her?