Noobs...in SPAAAAACE - 5th Annual Noob WW Game

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Dina, but think positive. I am not a wolf...so how you gonna feel when it is revealed that you killed an innocent villager?

Agreed. I don't think we should lynch someone just for funsies when there are actually wolves to be hung.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Not sure I follow this logic. If she had ignored it then wouldn't she have been seen as wolfy for intentionally ignoring questions directly at her?

i don't follow it either

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Unofficial "Where no manator has gone before" Lynch Tally
M935 (2) - z&j, killer
emlady (3) - MSU, mutts, mpmoose
Beagle (1) - Barkley
killer (3) - beagles, dandelion, Dinashadow
shelter (1) - grebes
pickles () -
Dandelion (1) - Dr. S
Ski (1) - dolphin
Dinashadow (2) - pickles, Ski
mpmoose (1) - Coffee?
grebes (3) - Stagg, M935, shelter
z&j () -

18/21 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~25 minutes)

 

[Lawpy]

 

[dolphin106258]

Okay ew three way ties are a no go.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

also for reference... last game (pokemon) shelter found something i said sketchy, got everyone to bandwagon on me and lynch me D1, i was village, and shelter was wolf..... #justsayin

 

[mypetmoose]

lynch grebes

For a few reasons. I thought she was moving on from the M935 fishing accusations, but once I started asking more questions about it she picked it back up. Yes, I was asking you questions, but you had a few options. You could have quoted your previous defense and said you already addressed it, you could have ignored me altogether, or you could have introduced an entirely new theory about other people. I get you aren't an experienced player, but neither am I. I would also like to put to rest any "birds of a feather" theories between myself and grebes before that goes any further. Not a thing. Honestly weirded out that grebes even suggested something about being wolves together. No thanks.

Presented with a third option, I may take it... or just sit on it... idk... I actually feel like this is a really good argument against grebes though...

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[SkiOtter]

also for reference... last game (pokemon) shelter found something i said sketchy, got everyone to bandwagon on me and lynch me D1, i was village, and shelter was wolf..... #justsayin

Previous games have no effect on affiliation in future games.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Previous games have no effect on affiliation in future games.

just pointing out a common strategy

 

[Barkley13]

Why are people voting emlady? Or did I miss that?

 

[Barkley13]

Why are people voting emlady? Or did I miss that?

@MSUcvmHOPE @mypetmoose @muttmanager ?

 

[sheltermed]

Not sure I follow this logic. If she had ignored it then wouldn't she have been seen as wolfy for intentionally ignoring questions directed at her?

I didn't say whether or not it would be wolfy, I just said it was one of her options. I've ignored things before that have gone under the radar, it has happened before.

As for my being a wolf last game, that's false. There was another game in between now and then where I was village and lynched d1, grebes didn't play that game IIRC. But that's neither here nor there, and it is completely NAI.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Presented with a third option, I may take it... or just sit on it... idk... I actually feel like this is a really good argument against grebes though...

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

why is this a good argument against me?

1) if i ignored you that would have looked sketchy
2) i could have quoted my previous defense, yes. didn't think of that
3) you LITERALLY asked me about it and i'm sketchy for answering you??

Not sure I follow this logic. If she had ignored it then wouldn't she have been seen as wolfy for intentionally ignoring questions directed at her?

 

[emlady09]

lynch grebes

For a few reasons. I thought she was moving on from the M935 fishing accusations, but once I started asking more questions about it she picked it back up. Yes, I was asking you questions, but you had a few options. You could have quoted your previous defense and said you already addressed it, you could have ignored me altogether, or you could have introduced an entirely new theory about other people. I get you aren't an experienced player, but neither am I. I would also like to put to rest any "birds of a feather" theories between myself and grebes before that goes any further. Not a thing. Honestly weirded out that grebes even suggested something about being wolves together. No thanks.

This.

 

[mypetmoose]

###unlynch emlady######lynch grebes###
I have been swayed... but I'm stressed about it....

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[grebes4lyfe]

you all are the worst

 

[sheltermed]

you all are the worst

Perhaps, but if there's a reason you shouldn't be lynched you should consider giving it instead of telling us this.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

is there anything i can do to get votes off of me?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Unofficial "Where no manator has gone before" Lynch Tally
M935 (2) - z&j, killer
emlady (2) - MSU, mutts
Beagle (1) - Barkley
killer (3) - beagles, dandelion, Dinashadow
shelter (1) - grebes
pickles () -
Dandelion (1) - Dr. S
Ski (1) - dolphin
Dinashadow (2) - pickles, Ski
mpmoose (1) - Coffee?
grebes (4) - Stagg, M935, shelter, mpmoose
z&j () -

18/21 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~15 minutes)

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Perhaps, but if there's a reason you shouldn't be lynched you should consider giving it instead of telling us this.

i'm not a wolf...? but that's the defense that got me in hot water with you last time... so i'm not really sure what to say here

 

[SkiOtter]

i'm not a wolf...? but that's the defense that got me in hot water with you last time... so i'm not really sure what to say here

Who do you think is sketchier than you and why? Why should we vote for them?

 

[SkiOtter]

Why have you not self-prezzed?

 

[dolphin106258]

This.

What about it? I don’t see something majorly compelling in this argument. You are saying when people ask questions, answering is somehow possibly sketchy...

Feels like overkill to give all these “reasons” that aren’t really reasons to me. Not saying grebes is or isn’t a wolf. Just saying I don’t see this as the best argument everyone should be pushing vs coming up with their own ideas....

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

Why does no one think pickles and soggy should be lynched? I'm not saying I do, they're just the only ones without any votes.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

Who do you think is sketchier than you and why? Why should we vote for them?

i think shelter is sketch AF right now
i originally joke voted for her, but im gonna keep it where it is because she is coming for me full force and her reasons are not solid IMO. i'm wolfy because i answered her questions?? and so she started a bandwagon on me??

 

[SkiOtter]

Why does no one think pickles and soggy should be lynched? I'm not saying I do, they're just the only ones without any votes.

Their names on the list with no votes means someone (me) has voted for them at some point in this day cycle and then unlynched. There are plenty of people who have not had votes on them.

 

[dolphin106258]

Why does no one think pickles and soggy should be lynched? I'm not saying I do, they're just the only ones without any votes.

There are several people without any votes at all? I’m confused

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

Their names on the list with no votes means someone (me) has voted for them at some point in this day cycle and then unlynched. There are plenty of people who have not had votes on them.

Gotcha.

 

[SkiOtter]

There are several people without any votes at all? I’m confused

He’s reading the tally and seeing them with () next to them from lynch unlynch on them

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

There are several people without any votes at all? I’m confused

Yeah, I misunderstood the way the list was done. I also forgot there were like 21 people playing.

 

[dolphin106258]

Their names on the list with no votes means someone (me) has voted for them at some point in this day cycle and then unlynched. There are plenty of people who have not had votes on them.

Lol nevermind ninja’d with a much better explanation

 

[emlady09]

Grebes is very defensive and trying extremely hard to prove she is innocent.

i'm not a wolf...?

Seems very wolf like.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

@CoffeeQuestionMark how are you feeling about dirty thirty and also the killer lynch currently

Currently I feel that we should be lynching mousse ☕

Matt I'm willing to believe. Plus I rarelyyy can pick out a wolf D1.

I'd be more inclined to support a killer lynch but not for the reasons that began the wagon

 

[deleted867257]

lynch grebes

For a few reasons. I thought she was moving on from the M935 fishing accusations, but once I started asking more questions about it she picked it back up. Yes, I was asking you questions, but you had a few options. You could have quoted your previous defense and said you already addressed it, you could have ignored me altogether, or you could have introduced an entirely new theory about other people. I get you aren't an experienced player, but neither am I. I would also like to put to rest any "birds of a feather" theories between myself and grebes before that goes any further. Not a thing. Honestly weirded out that grebes even suggested something about being wolves together. No thanks.

I'm finally caught up with chat! I think this is something I can definitely understand.
I think this becomes difficult with fellow noobs, because we don't have as much gameplay as we would like.. so it can be harder to read people or to even get your desired point across.

lynch grebes

Unless something changes in the time we have left.

What about it? I don’t see something majorly compelling in this argument. You are saying when people ask questions, answering is somehow possibly sketchy...

Feels like overkill to give all these “reasons” that aren’t really reasons to me. Not saying grebes is or isn’t a wolf. Just saying I don’t see this as the best argument everyone should be pushing vs coming up with their own ideas....

It may not be the best reasons, but it's also night one, and so we don't have very many reasons or info to go off of until night actions happen or until backtracking by certain players is noted. Just my two cents.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

also since matt is a self-proclaimed tin-foiler, he's increasingly sketch to me too

maybe this was all an elaborate scheme and he's actually a wolf. claim he has a night action to stay alive.

Grebes is very defensive and trying extremely hard to prove she is innocent.

Seems very wolf like.

im wolfy for defending myself?

 

[SkiOtter]

Currently I feel that we should be lynching mousse ☕

Matt I'm willing to believe. Plus I rarelyyy can pick out a wolf D1.

I'd be more inclined to support a killer lynch but not for the reasons that began the wagon

What reasons for mlp or killer?

 

[WildZoo]

Lynch close in 9 minutes

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

maybe this was all an elaborate scheme and he's actually a wolf.

I actually wish I was, because I think that would be super fun.

 

[grebes4lyfe]

you all were literally just like "lol we hate bandwagons #lynchgrebes"

.....ok

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Unofficial "Where no manator has gone before" Lynch Tally
M935 (2) - z&j, killer
emlady (2) - MSU, mutts
Beagle (1) - Barkley
killer (3) - beagles, dandelion, Dinashadow
shelter (1) - grebes
pickles () -
Dandelion (1) - Dr. S
Ski (1) - dolphin
Dinashadow (2) - pickles, Ski
mpmoose (1) - Coffee?
grebes (5) - Stagg, M935, shelter, mpmoose, FrostySparrow
z&j () -

19/21 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~8 minutes)

 

[muttmanager]

@MSUcvmHOPE @mypetmoose @muttmanager ?

It was more for bandwagining.

###unlynch emlady, lynch killer###

 

[SkiOtter]

you all were literally just like "lol we hate bandwagons #lynchgrebes"

.....ok

A bandwagon is something that grows quickly. Yours has not.

 

[mypetmoose]

Currently I feel that we should be lynching mousse ☕

Matt I'm willing to believe. Plus I rarelyyy can pick out a wolf D1.

I'd be more inclined to support a killer lynch but not for the reasons that began the wagon

Not that this will change things before 10pm, and I may have asked before, but what have I done that made you feel weird about me?

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

 

[dolphin106258]

It was more for bandwagining.

###unlynch emlady, lynch killer###

......?

Edit: I forgot my question mark

 

[grebes4lyfe]

A bandwagon is something that grows quickly. Yours has not.

this has grown pretty quickly

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

What reasons for mlp or killer?

Killer for avoiding answering questions
Mousse for a certain posting style (I picked it up on her first post)

Grebes was my wolf pup. I feel fairly confident she is not a wolf this time.

 

[Doctor-S]

[I'm on the West Coast - so I'll be checking into this WW thread when I'm able to check into it - since this game is on Eastern Time.]

I quickly scanned some posts ... and do not have any conclusive thoughts this early in the game.

Feeling nothing about most people at this early stage of the game.

grebes4lyfe. Grebes (and some other posters) seem to be waiting overnight for M935 to do (or to not do) something with some type of ability.

Matthew935. I am noticing a lot of chatter between M935, and several other players on the board. Don’t know if the chatter is meant to be a distraction. Grebes has challenged M935 because M935 claimed that he has an ability that he can (presumably) use at overnight. Don't know if M935's claimed ability is a villager-ability or a non-villager-ability. Too soon to tell.

M935, emlady and shelter. All changed their lynch votes from killerleaf to someone else near the end of the first day. As a result, there is now a 3-way tie between killer, emlady and grebes at the end of D1 (i.e., killerleaf is no longer leading the lynch tally). Wondering if there is a reason *why* M935, emlady, and shelter all decided to change their lynch votes near the end of the first day? Just wondering, that's all.

Killerleaf. Wondering why killerleaf was not making a stronger effort to defend herself against a lynch - since she was leading the lynch tally with 5 votes before the end of the first day (and before the 3-way lynch tie mentioned above). I wouldn’t think a "wolfy" person would be willing to be the lead person in the lynch tally in this game for most of the day, without putting up some type of a fight. Just saying.

 

[killerleaf]

hey wait a minute. what questions did I not answer????

 

[SkiOtter]

Killer for avoiding answering questions
Mousse for a certain posting style (I picked it up on her first post)

Grebes was my wolf pup. I feel fairly confident she is not a wolf this time.

Unless you’re pulling a subs with shelter and you’re BOTH wolves

 

[picklegurl]

Killer for avoiding answering questions
Mousse for a certain posting style (I picked it up on her first post)

Grebes was my wolf pup. I feel fairly confident she is not a wolf this time.

Thank you Koffee for providing the answer that I was seeking from M935.

UNLYNCH DINASHADOW

LYNCH KILLER