Official LOST WW Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
unlynch SnS

Checking something with the mod. And it looks like she can't post, so I'm holding off for a bit.
 
Lynch DVMD - I used an item on her and found out that she was NOT on the plane. Not sure what that could mean but I thought I'd share this now and await her defense. Unfortunately, I have an academic meeting-thing to go to at 9:30 and am leaving shortly. I will not be back til later.
 
DVMDream said:
Then we have LIS admitting to killing a player and saying that it is very possible that he will do this again in the game. But everyone seems to be ok with this? Am I missing something crucial here?
Click to expand...

I'm not ok with it, but at least for the immediate future I'm willing to let it slide because he makes it seem like his role is important. I'm curious enough to let it play out for another few rounds.
 
Weird...

We're lynching SnS because SOV has indicated to us that she would be a good choice. But we don't know if its just him agreeing without info or him having info he can't communicate.which is it SOV?

If we're going off the idea that those who have been taken out as not on the plane are the others, then I'm strongly considering changing my vote to DVMD. Clarification from SOV would be nice though, especially if SnS is silenced.
 
I think he was trying to communicate that she was blocked last night. Which doesn't necessarily mean she's a wolf.
 
HOLY ****!! What WAS that!? Someone heard it right, right!? This is crazy man... Stupid bugs all over me...
 
that redhead said:
Weird...

We're lynching SnS because SOV has indicated to us that she would be a good choice. But we don't know if its just him agreeing without info or him having info he can't communicate.which is it SOV?

If we're going off the idea that those who have been taken out as not on the plane are the others, then I'm strongly considering changing my vote to DVMD. Clarification from SOV would be nice though, especially if SnS is silenced.
Click to expand...

There are other characters in the show that were neither on the plane or others. Just think about it before you lynch me.


I just find it odd that we are following SOV's slight indication when we have no idea what he is really indicating. Is he indicating that SnS was blocked or that SnS is a wolf? And can we trust him? I mean, people have the idea that the others are bad, SOV was an other before he died the first time so can we really trust him?

Also, I don't have any lost knowledge so if I am missing something let me know.
 
LIS killed based on inaction it seems, and is likely due to him having to press the button to relieve the build up of electromagnetic energy (lostpedia is my friend)... if thats the case, he didn't kill on purpose, just killed by inactivity...

if DVMD wasn't on the plane, then who is she? she hasn't given an explanation as to who she is or why she wasn't on the plane, which is good enough for me...

Lynch DVMD

and lol Dwin... guess its not related to TRH's role...
 
DVMDream said:
There are other characters in the show that were neither on the plane or others. Just think about it before you lynch me.


I just find it odd that we are following SOV's slight indication when we have no idea what he is really indicating. Is he indicating that SnS was blocked or that SnS is a wolf? And can we trust him? I mean, people have the idea that the others are bad, SOV was an other before he died the first time so can we really trust him?

Also, I don't have any lost knowledge so if I am missing something let me know.
Click to expand...

i still don't know what to make of you... you weren't on the plane, and it seems you are implying that you aren't an other... so who are you?
 
thedrjojo said:
i still don't know what to make of you... you weren't on the plane, and it seems you are implying that you aren't an other... so who are you?
Click to expand...

Just wiki characters who weren't others and were not on the plane. There are beneficial characters that fall into this category.

I am tempted to lynch you though for asking people to say what their role is outright.
 
Looking at some things from Day 1, I'm pretty confident SnS isn't a wolf. Not a good lynch choice. Still thinking on a lynch vote.
 
Upon Request, Lynch Deadline extended until Noon.

I have to take a sick dog to the vet, so I won't be around to close until after 1pm probably. But lynch will close at 12pm EST
 
Flim Flam Man said:
Now that I think a little more, I have at least 5. But, moat bad guys were not on the plane too.
Click to expand...

I found a couple 👍 I agree that most of the people not on the plane are likely bad but there are enough good ones to justify not lynching DVMD just for that reason, at least right now.

I'm going to stick with my SnS lynch. I feel like SOV is a completely new character after his ressurection and dogs are intuitive, so I'm going to take his tail wag gif for the "lynch SnS" vote to be a sign that he agrees. Don't yet know if he has his own info or if it's just what he agrees with, but I don't have anything better to go off of at this point.
 
DVMDream said:
I have decided lynch rojo, because asking for people to reveal roles on the thread is not a good idea this early in the game and he knows that.
Click to expand...

I was asking who you could be, as I am not as aware of lost, and thought most off the plane were bad and figure I need more than, trust me I'm good guys. You not being on the plane is much higher likelihood of you being a wolf compared to random lynch, and you haven't convinced me not to lynch you yet...

I've already hinted who I am... A villager originally on the plane...
 
thedrjojo said:
I was asking who you could be, as I am not as aware of lost, and thought most off the plane were bad and figure I need more than, trust me I'm good guys. You not being on the plane is much higher likelihood of you being a wolf compared to random lynch, and you haven't convinced me not to lynch you yet...

I've already hinted who I am... A villager originally on the plane...
Click to expand...

And from my wiki reading there were some on the plane that became bad after the crash, granted a lot less, but there were some. So just because it is a minority does not mean that it should be ignored completely.

I have already revealed who I am as well... I was not on the plane and I am not an other, that significantly decreases who I could possibly be, even more so than it does for you.
 
Official Lynch Talley:

SnS 5 (dyachei, TRH, Lissa, orcagirl, SOV)
DVMD 3 (SnS, rojo, kaydubs)
devyn 1 (FFM)
rojo 1 (DVMD)

Deadline is 12pm EST.

Votes cast: 10 out of 25
 
Jamr0ckin said:
Official Lynch Talley:
SnS 5 (dyachei, TRH, Lissa, orcagirl, SOV)
DVMD 3 (SnS, rojo, kaydubs)
devyn 1 (FFM)
rojo 1 (DVMD)

Deadline is 12pm EST.

Votes cast: 10 out of 25
Click to expand...

😕

Ummm... I definitely did not see this vote in the thread. Does this mean that the players we are presuming to be silenced can vote?
 
Official Lynch Talley:

SnS 5 (dyachei, TRH, Lissa, orcagirl, SOV)
DVMD 2 ( rojo, kaydubs)
krist 2 (Escalla, SnS)
devyn 1 (FFM)
rojo 1 (DVMD)

Deadline is 12pm EST.

Votes cast: 11 out of 25[/QUOTE]
 
thedrjojo said:
I've already hinted who I am... A villager originally on the plane...
Click to expand...

Now that I really think of this. This really does not hint well to who you are at all. Anyone could say this same thing and since there are quite a few characters that fit this description no one would question it. So, my vote for you still stands.
 
Some players can't post on the thread until a specified time. That's presumably why Jam stated the FH rule does not apply.
 
Seeing as I am about to die, I will say screw it. Dear husband, I know English and i'm not afraid to use it. Please villagers, do not kill me, I am good!
 
SOV thinks I am bad because I did not respond to his PM, but I was not allowed to because of my dear husband.
 
Much thank to person who give me medicine. I attacked by large white bear. So much pain no words I could speak. SnS is good people - please to not kill.

lynch krist
 
DVMDream said:
Now that I really think of this. This really does not hint well to who you are at all. Anyone could say this same thing and since there are quite a few characters that fit this description no one would question it. So, my vote for you still stands.
Click to expand...

I gave more information previously that should limit me to one of two people now...
 
lynch dvmd - her first vote against me yesterday was based on absolute crap, and her argument today is classic dvmd distortion of what I said. She's obviously trying hard to get my head on the block, and using weak arguments. Further, the way she distorted what jojo said also caught my attention. She's doing what she can to throw suspicion on people, but without any good support.
 
Lissarae06 said:
Alright then. unlynch SnS, lynh jojo. i can't tell if he is being purposefully confusing or what.
Click to expand...

Ugh.

I'm not trying to be confusing. I can role reveal, but someone close to me might not like that if they are a character in this game.

We need to figure out who the wolves actually are if it's not the others.

unlynch dvmd, lynch krist

I'll give dvmd a benefit of the doubt for now, which is usually a mistake
 
Alright. Unlynch SnS Maybe SOV was just trying to vote to lynch someone since he can't talk in anything other than dog pictures. My original post did say I have no reason. Going to read through this all again and then vote.
 
LetItSnow said:
lynch dvmd - her first vote against me yesterday was based on absolute crap, and her argument today is classic dvmd distortion of what I said. She's obviously trying hard to get my head on the block, and using weak arguments. Further, the way she distorted what jojo said also caught my attention. She's doing what she can to throw suspicion on people, but without any good support.
Click to expand...

1. My vote yesterday for you was not based on absolute crap. You have many times singled out a group of people as a wolf in order to draw attention away from other groups and yourself. The vet school game is a good example of this, IIRC. I think you also tried this in Lord of the Rings when you came up with a "list" of people.

2. What argument about you is weak? You admitted to killing WS, then admitted that there is a good chance you will kill again in the game. Why in the world would I want to keep someone in the game that is killing other players, inadvertently or not.

3. I did not distort what jojo said, he flat out said, "who are you?" That is asking someone to role reveal.

I have given a better defense for who I am then anyone else has yet in this game. If I absolutely have to role reveal, I will but you had better damn well hope that the wolves are feeling sympathetic to the villagers or you are going to really screw them over.
 
thedrjojo said:
Ugh.

I'm not trying to be confusing. I can role reveal, but someone close to me might not like that if they are a character in this game.

We need to figure out who the wolves actually are if it's not the others.

unlynch dvmd, lynch krist

I'll give dvmd a benefit of the doubt for now, which is usually a mistake
Click to expand...

I don't think you should role reveal. I'm just not picking up on what you are trying to say. Ugh unlynch jojo. I'm going to wait a minute before voting again.
 
DVMD, I think LIS has given us a pretty good clue as to who he is and I think that he is not someone that should be lynched, at least not right away. If his inaction last night led to a death, than presumably being dead (via lynch) will lead to further inaction which will result in more death.
 
that redhead said:
DVMD, I think LIS has given us a pretty good clue as to who he is and I think that he is not someone that should be lynched, at least not right away. If his inaction last night led to a death, than presumably being dead (via lynch) will lead to further inaction which will result in more death.
Click to expand...

Yes, I know. Which is why I am not lynching him, at this time. But before I had known that, I my reasoning was plenty sound. And his claim of me distorting what he was saying is crap, I didn't distort anything, I repeated exactly what he said.
 
that redhead said:
DVMD, I think LIS has given us a pretty good clue as to who he is and I think that he is not someone that should be lynched, at least not right away. If his inaction last night led to a death, than presumably being dead (via lynch) will lead to further inaction which will result in more death.
Click to expand...

If he is who I think he is, someone else might have to take up the role if he leaves, as is in the show...

And I agree with dvmd, my question comes off as a straight asking of role reveal, so I don'tfault her for iinterpreting it like that.... I meant it rhetorically, and literally was posting from my phone awaiting to give my grand rounds talk, so it didn't come out correctly... Others have said there are plenty of good non flight passengers, so I'll give dvmd the benefit of a doubt for now
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
157
Views
9K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Top