Panem et Circenses - Game Thread

[WildZoo]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

You are getting awfully defensive this game whenever anyone questions you even a teensy tiny bit. Yesterday you snapped at the newest nooblet for being presumptuous enough to drop a vote on you. Salamanders pee in your coffee or something?

Dolphin's comment was pretty snarky itself and I wasn't sure what she was getting at, and when I asked she didn't answer in any way that was helpful, so I asked again. Navilly voted for me with a misrepresentation of my comments after I had just caught up on the thread a minute prior. Not sure what him being a "noob" has to do with it.

 

[PippyPony]

Dolphin's comment was pretty snarky itself and I wasn't sure what she was getting at, and when I asked she didn't answer in any way that was helpful, so I asked again. Navilly voted for me with a misrepresentation of my comments after I had just caught up on the thread a minute prior. Not sure what him being a "noob" has to do with it.

Ok, but both of those have been single votes. You worried they are going to pick up steam or something?

 

[WildZoo]

Ok, but both of those have been single votes. You worried they are going to pick up steam or something?

Since when do I not address single votes if I'm around? Nope, not really worried, it's just how I play.

 

[PippyPony]

But what about that quote is why you are voting me?

@Ms Procrastinator[/QUOTE]
Actually it's more about SAR and why she died. I like to look at what dead people were doing before they got killed. She didn't really do much on this thread. She just found you sus.[/QUOTE]
Any wolf worth their salt is going to mess with this kind of thing enough that it makes this kind of analysis virtually meaningless. Particularly when there has only been a single kill, because now you're not even looking for a pattern.

 

[PippyPony]

Wait why is the quoting thing doing that

 

[genny]

Wait why is the quoting thing doing that

Because Mel isn't allowing editing.

 

[dolphin106258]

I'm raising my eyebrow at you right now @dolphin106258 because the way you're tripping over yourself to make a mountain out of a molehill right now reminds me a lot more of your wolf play than the solid village play I've come to expect from you

Dolphin's comment was pretty snarky itself and I wasn't sure what she was getting at, and when I asked she didn't answer in any way that was helpful, so I asked again. Navilly voted for me with a misrepresentation of my comments after I had just caught up on the thread a minute prior. Not sure what him being a "noob" has to do with it.

I don’t really think it’s bad village play, and I don’t think you are objectively able to comment on it due to you being involved in it. I didn’t say I was parked on this vote all day even. But geez I wasn’t even trying to get a reaction but thanks for one I guess.

 

[dolphin106258]

Also how am I tripping over myself? Besides my ability to type well on a phone. I feel very sure footed actually.

 

[JustPaws]

Wait why is the quoting thing doing that

it only happens when quoting ms pro 🙁

 

[WildZoo]

I don’t really think it’s bad village play, and I don’t think you are objectively able to comment on it due to you being involved in it. I didn’t say I was parked on this vote all day even. But geez I wasn’t even trying to get a reaction but thanks for one I guess.

Did you expect me not to respond?

 

[JustPaws]

@Navilly my most recent wolfing was New Hampshire 48, my favorite was Afterparty, i sucked in Michigan, and our sweep thanks to Pippy and my first wolfing was Shufflin'
Can't think of any others off top of head

 

[dolphin106258]

It was just a comment, because AM's votes tend to gain followers and I've seen again and again that her accuracy is not as good D1, or even before the first wolf is lynched. I was noting it as another example. You're blowing it way out of proportion. I make comments like that all the damn time.
I also switched my vote to mutts, and asked where the waffles were. I'm not going to shout from the rooftops telling people to switch on every vote I mildly disagree with. Sometimes it's better not to, if people feel less pressured to vote a certain way, the analysis is more pure.

Also just as a side note I am always on people’s case lately about sheeping AM. And if I feel kinda icky about a lynch and the reasoning is REALLY WEAK or bad like sheeping I will point it out. Not to force people to change their vote but to actually analyze. Why would it have been bad to force all those on Ziggy to come up with better reasoning or pressure them on the sheeping. I don’t feel that’s bad village play, and if you had done that in the moment and not after the fact I’d probably feel differently.

Overall I don’t know why you’re getting bent out of shape. I’m snarky I tend to have banter when I respond to players I know and have played with. You do respond to single votes on yourself but not usually in this way. At least in my opinion.

 

[dolphin106258]

Did you expect me not to respond?

No I thought you might offer a comment or a snarky rebuttal but I didn’t get that.

 

[PippyPony]

With respect to pippy "being angry" over the SAR death, does that fit with their meta? Is that someone they are close with/value highly?

Yes.

Does anyone know of games that Stayingpositive was a wolf (forget which ones I looked up yesterday)?

She crushed it in a game that I modded last summer -- almost had a sweep.

WWild WWedding Afterparty Game Thread - A Pipsy & Jbooze Production

this sounds like you are trying too hard

Wrong.

 

[Animal Midwife]

D2 The People Want More Bread Unofficial Tally
Mutts (3) - AM, Lawpy, dubz
Paws (2) - Nav, MsP
genny (1) - mutts
dubz (1) - dolphin
Stagg (1) - genny
emmy (2) - Barks, Pippy

10/18 Voting
Lynch closes in ~6.5 hrs

 

[WildZoo]

Also how am I tripping over myself? Besides my ability to type well on a phone. I feel very sure footed actually.

It's a tone thing

I don’t really think it’s bad village play, and I don’t think you are objectively able to comment on it due to you being involved in it. I didn’t say I was parked on this vote all day even. But geez I wasn’t even trying to get a reaction but thanks for one I guess.

Didn't say it was bad, said it was less solid than what I'm used to seeing from you recently. Of course I can't be 100% objective, but I can say that

Also just as a side note I am always on people’s case lately about sheeping AM. And if I feel kinda icky about a lynch and the reasoning is REALLY WEAK or bad like sheeping I will point it out. Not to force people to change their vote but to actually analyze. Why would it have been bad to force all those on Ziggy to come up with better reasoning or pressure them on the sheeping. I don’t feel that’s bad village play, and if you had done that in the moment and not after the fact I’d probably feel differently.

Overall I don’t know why you’re getting bent out of shape. I’m snarky I tend to have banter when I respond to players I know and have played with. You do respond to single votes on yourself but not usually in this way. At least in my opinion.

My point is I did point out that it was a groce lynch, and acted accordingly. Zig had already pointed out the sheeping aspect so there was no need for me to repeat her words. I said it after the fact because it was proven correct.

I'm not bent out of shape, I'm examining your thought process and seeing if it stands up to what I'm used to from village!dolphin.

 

[WildZoo]

No I thought you might offer a comment or a snarky rebuttal but I didn’t get that.

Because I didn't understand what you were saying lol

 

[JustPaws]

@Navilly my most recent wolfing was New Hampshire 48, my favorite was Afterparty, i sucked in Michigan, and our sweep thanks to Pippy and my first wolfing was Shufflin'
Can't think of any others off top of head

Yes.

She crushed it in a game that I modded last summer -- almost had a sweep.

WWild WWedding Afterparty Game Thread - A Pipsy & Jbooze Production


Wrong.

My favorite!

 

[JustPaws]

Yes.

She crushed it in a game that I modded last summer -- almost had a sweep.

WWild WWedding Afterparty Game Thread - A Pipsy & Jbooze Production


Wrong.

Also spoiler, Chaos posted first and village lynch voted first. And voted to correctly Lynch a wolf lol

 

[JustPaws]

Also spoiler, Chaos posted first and village lynch voted first. And voted to correctly Lynch a wolf lol

Oops, I guess chaos voted before lawper my bad

 

[Navilly]

Oops, I guess chaos voted before lawper my bad

So what you are trying to say is you support my theory?

But looking through those games, the start of this game was significantly fluffier than any of your other starts as a wolf. I just am not sure if you would be someone who would intentionally change their meta.

 

[jaboo]

Wait why is the quoting thing doing that

I got an aneurysm while catching up on thread 😵

 

[jaboo]

Lynch Dubz

I feel like the wolves tried a mutts push yesterday to avoid pressure from the Ziggy lynch. And then Dubz quickly hopped on a mutts lynch like 5 minutes after Pips voted there. I’ve definitely done that in the past where I wait until someone votes and then I also hop on to try and get a wagon going. Plus some feelz.

Idk, I’ll reassess to see if I think this theory is dumb in a few hours. Have a headache

 

[JustPaws]

So what you are trying to say is you support my theory?

But looking through those games, the start of this game was significantly fluffier than any of your other starts as a wolf. I just am not sure if you would be someone who would intentionally change their meta.

I think wolfing is a bit fluid depending on who you wolf with and the thread. It was an after-party and WZ is a party wolf. Also we thought there were prizes for partying and there were so....

 

[SportPonies]

If something happened that could benefit the village it would be helpful to the whole class if they shared it? Considering we can't PM in this game (thanks Mel -_-), we have to have everything out in the open in order to better strategize as village. Not being able to PM puts village at a huge disadvantage for reasons just stated.



Ok, thank you for clarifying that.

Tone here feels slightly coached. Not loving the last bit because it reminds me some of the methods I used to fly low in vet clinic as a noob wolf

#####lynch em#####

Sorry if you’re Village; I hate lynching noob villagers early.

 

[JustPaws]

I like the em Lynch cuz her posts are sketch but it could definitely be noobiness... I am interested in the wz Lynch but I think it's more a morbid fascination cuz she's Lynch Teflon. Ok going back to my reread

 

[genny]

I hate this gif btw Mel

Why is the bread so shiny?

And how do you feel about paws?

 

[WildZoo]

Lynch Dubz

I feel like the wolves tried a mutts push yesterday to avoid pressure from the Ziggy lynch. And then Dubz quickly hopped on a mutts lynch like 5 minutes after Pips voted there. I’ve definitely done that in the past where I wait until someone votes and then I also hop on to try and get a wagon going. Plus some feelz.

Idk, I’ll reassess to see if I think this theory is dumb in a few hours. Have a headache

I know you have a headache but I'd like to hear more about why you think mutts is village if when/you return

 

[Doggo Labs]

What do you think of the analysis they have been doing?

Not really sure I've seen to much of an analysis... Paws has one on em which I think is reasonable

I like the em Lynch cuz her posts are sketch but it could definitely be noobiness...

Genny I would like to hear more on why you are voting to lynch Stagg? Also trying to find any analysis you have on anyone else, but I cont seem to find them.

 

[genny]

Also trying to find any analysis you have on anyone else, but I cont seem to find them.

Try harder. Like use a search function. Or, I don't know, read some of the things I've posted today:

So I'm not so great at reading paws, but I'm OK with her being up for lynch at this stage/time of day. This is about the only flipflop that pings my feels from yesterday:


That kind of inconsistency kind of makes me think wolf trying to increase the general stink of suspicion on players that most people were village-reading yesterday, or it can be early village paranoia creeping in. I'm undecided about which way I'm leaning with it at this point. Probably more village.

Lynching mutts would give us plenty of info if mutts flipped wolf. Less so if village, but I'd feel better about Pips if mutts is village. Cubs and Sporty have both said that mutts sounds village today, so I don't know that I'm inclined to go there again right now. Though I suppose that would also inform my feelings about Sporty and cubs.

lynch stagg

I feel like the last time he argued so much about a day 1 vote, he was a wolf defending his RNG.

I never said that you said you had me as sketchy. Not sure where that comes from.

I didn't ask you about it yesterday because I didn't iso you until this morning when I was asked for an opinion about you. The way I interpreted the two quotes was that the first one had you village reading the group of players named, and the second one was calling out someone else for also village reading the same group. And like I said, I was leaning the perceived inconsistency more village.

But it was enough to make navilly change his vote, and that was interesting.

I read it more as "hey guys, look how hard I'm villaging right now!"

All of the above posts contain analysis of other players. Just because it's not in list form doesn't mean I'm not giving reads on other players. If you're going to make a blanket statement that I'm not posting analysis, at least do your homework first.

 

[genny]

Genny I would like to hear more on why you are voting to lynch Stagg?

I find Stagg's insistence on voting Sporty yesterday sketchy as heck, especially since he said he had zero feels for Sporty as a wolf.

 

[PippyPony]

Tone here feels slightly coached. Not loving the last bit because it reminds me some of the methods I used to fly low in vet clinic as a noob wolf

#####lynch em#####

Sorry if you’re Village; I hate lynching noob villagers early.

Which methods would those be?

 

[WildZoo]

If you're going to make a blanket statement that I'm not posting analysis, at least do your homework first.

That's gonna earn another "Ooo SNAP" from me

 

[genny]

That's gonna earn another "Ooo SNAP" from me

Sorry, it cheeses me off when I get accused of posting only fluff. I love fluff, and I know I post a lot of stupid jokes. Maybe I need a nap.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Why is the bread so shiny?

And how do you feel about paws?

Paws feels pretty great.

 

[WildZoo]

Sorry, it cheeses me off when I get accused of posting only fluff. I love fluff, and I know I post a lot of stupid jokes. Maybe I need a nap.

Oh I was amused [emoji23]

 

[SportPonies]

Which methods would those be?

Tugging at feelings, “oh thank you so much for explaining your post/point/the thing I clearly misunderstood not on purpose.”

 

[Navilly]

I am skeptical of those jumping on the Em lynch. It feels like a new player mistake, irregardless of if they are wolf or villager. Outside of that one comment, can anyone on the Em bandwagon explain why you are voting for Em?

 

[Navilly]

Also is there a tally ready to go?

 

[Doggo Labs]

Try harder. Like use a search function. Or, I don't know, read some of the things I've posted today:

Definitely was trying and using the search thing. I'm still trying to figure out everyone, when looking through the searches they did not stick out to me as being analyses, now I see that they are, and thank you for pointing them out to me. I could have also decided to lynch you but I wanted to hear your response before doing so

 

[Animal Midwife]

D2 The People Want More Bread Unofficial Tally
Mutts (3) - AM, Lawpy, dubz
Paws (2) - Nav, MsP
genny (1) - mutts
dubz (2) - dolphin, jboo
Stagg (1) - genny
emmy (3) - Barks, Pippy, Sporty

12/18 Voting
Lynch closes in ~4.5 hrs

 

[genny]

I could have also decided to lynch you

Is that a vague threat? 😱

 

[WildZoo]

Paws feels pretty great.

 

[Navilly]

Is that a vague threat? 😱

It sounds more like a direct threat personally.

@Barkley13 @SportPonies @PippyPony Other than the comment by Em earlier, why else are you currently voting to lynch them.

 

[genny]

Did you notice that she dodged my bread question? Do you think it's related to feeling Paws?

 

[genny]

It sounds more like a direct threat personally.

@Barkley13 @SportPonies @PippyPony Other than the comment by Em earlier, why else are you currently voting to lynch them.

I have thoughts, but I'll let the people you tagged respond first.

 

[WildZoo]

Did you notice that she dodged my bread question? Do you think it's related to feeling Paws?

How did that bread get so shiny?? 😱

 

[Barkley13]

It sounds more like a direct threat personally.

@Barkley13 @SportPonies @PippyPony Other than the comment by Em earlier, why else are you currently voting to lynch them.

I voted to lynch her before that and said why

 

[Melchizedek]

Y'all need anything from me? No? good.

~goes back to absentee modding~

 

[Barkley13]

Lynch emlady

Started getting feels yesterday when she came on, posted one post saying she was here and asking what people wanted, and then disappearing again. Her two long posts don’t say much about her reads and seem to be asking questions, bringing up things that have already been addressed, or just commenting on things that have happened without saying thoughts on it.

@Navilly