Last night my husband and I were at our neighbors apartment for movie night. They are a couple about our age and have a dog almost exactly the same size as ours so we get together pretty often.
The dogs were playing as usual, but they both started getting really rough and were bumping into us. My husband and I both had drinks with very dark juice in our hands. I told them repeatedly to calm down, but after not listening and almost spilling my drink I finally gave Scooter a smack and told him to calm down. He immediately did, but I got a "your terrible" look
and a pretty snappy response from our neighbor even suggesting that we take our dog home if I didn't want him playing. Her reaction was because she didn't agree with me smacking Scooter.
This especially ticked me off as their dog although good most of the time is an excessive barker and has been known to bite people. Not that she is drawing blood, but she is still making marks on the skin. Later in the evening I witnessed her bite her owner and he did nothing more than to say ouch and announce to us that she bit him. She went on to bite my husband later.
HELLO discipline your dog! I have never hit scooter any harder than what would cause a small sting for about 5 seconds and that is even if he is just really out of line. More than anything it is just a tap that hurts his feelings which is why it is an effective form of discipline.
I am completely against beating your dog or even using kicking or hard hits to discipline, but I should not get looked at like I am the devil because I keep my dog in line with a small smack. Our dog is loved and treated like his is our kid, but he is also really well behaved because we discipline him when needed (which is really only maybe once a week). We can take him anywhere and have him be around any other animals or people without worrying at all. I would rather hurt his feelings when he is out of line with a quick smack than to have a dog that believes it is the alpha of the house and can not be trusted.