Saturday Morning Cartoons - 7th Annual Noob WW Game

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Controversial opinion - we only win if we get out the wolves. Both cult and wolves are pushing for parity. So if the cults are ahead of the wolves thats something they need to worry about more than us.
So w the cult, should we not worry about them too much unless they’re killing us?
in the past couple of days I’ve been a little conflicted and confused about whether we should try to find and focus on yeeting both cults and wolves but this logic might be flawed?
 
So w the cult, should we not worry about them too much unless they’re killing us?
in the past couple of days I’ve been a little conflicted and confused about whether we should try to find and focus on yeeting both cults and wolves but this logic might be flawed?
So the cults are still a threat to us winning. If they're still converting people they stand a good chance of winning. I'm just saying contrary to cult members we only win if we yeet all the wolves. Wolves only win if they get parity with us. If there are more cult members than wolves then they can't win. So at this moment I *think* it is a bigger threat to them.
 
Cult related?

Big tinfoil time

Is it possible that the orchid converts cultists?
It looks like for M935's kill, she was converted before she was killed. So order of events for her kill (she had 3 visitors):
1. covert to cultist
2. killed by unknown
3. orchid laid on body

It seems to me that the orchid is unrelated to cult activities, but not sure :/
 
Controversial opinion - we only win if we get out the wolves. Both cult and wolves are pushing for parity. So if the cults are ahead of the wolves thats something they need to worry about more than us.
I also agree with this. We are not 100% sure that a second cult leader exists, and neither do the wolves. There is a chance that the cult is still growing, but there is also a chance that the cult is now finished (we're just not sure). If we as villagers run around in circles trying to identify both the cult and the wolves, this may end up hurting us more than if we focused on a single enemy that we know exist and will hurt us each night.
 
So the cults are still a threat to us winning. If they're still converting people they stand a good chance of winning. I'm just saying contrary to cult members we only win if we yeet all the wolves. Wolves only win if they get parity with us. If there are more cult members than wolves then they can't win. So at this moment I *think* it is a bigger threat to them.
I agree that we need to focus on wolves because that's how we win. But, the cult does pose some threat because I think if they convert villagers they don't count as village anymore for parity meaning the wolves can win faster? Like, just for numbers, if there's 3 wolves, and 5 villagers, and 1 cult, and the wolves killed 1 vilager and the cult converts 1 villager, then there's 3 wolves, 3 village, and 2 cult so then the wolves would win unless cult counts to help village?
 
I'm hoping since the cult leader is dead that that's the only one and we should focus on wolves at least for now unless/until there's credible information that we need to also go for the cult
 
I agree that we need to focus on wolves because that's how we win. But, the cult does pose some threat because I think if they convert villagers they don't count as village anymore for parity meaning the wolves can win faster? Like, just for numbers, if there's 3 wolves, and 5 villagers, and 1 cult, and the wolves killed 1 vilager and the cult converts 1 villager, then there's 3 wolves, 3 village, and 2 cult so then the wolves would win unless cult counts to help village?
This is true, and also this is more math than my last 3 years of undergrad combined (jk) so had to really think there for a second
 
This is true, and also this is more math than my last 3 years of undergrad combined (jk) so had to really think there for a second
Haha, same. I took my last math class... oh man like 6 years ago? Unless you count stats which I suppose was technically math, in which case it's been 4 years since I took a math class so not much better.
 
I'm still sus of TME and nothing that's happened yesterday/today has really changed my mind. I'm still going through old posts but I have to go do some things for work for awhile so for now

yeet enigma
 
I agree that we need to focus on wolves because that's how we win. But, the cult does pose some threat because I think if they convert villagers they don't count as village anymore for parity meaning the wolves can win faster? Like, just for numbers, if there's 3 wolves, and 5 villagers, and 1 cult, and the wolves killed 1 vilager and the cult converts 1 villager, then there's 3 wolves, 3 village, and 2 cult so then the wolves would win unless cult counts to help village?
That's fair, but if cult is only one person it isn't much of a concern. If there's only one cult they can't turn people and they're not a concern at all for either of us. My concern that cult is >4 if there is another cult leader. If that is the case then the wolves can't win.
 
mayo, I know you unyeeted Alleycat, but why were you so determined to vote her out? Just curious

I'm also wondering that because Mayo has been hitting the eject alleycat button for a while now??

i have a very good reason to believe I was wrong about alleycat.
Not because of their defense of themself. Something more reliable.
 
Day 7: Gotta Catch 'Em All Yeet Tally

TelemarketingEnigma (3) - hallowmann, lumya, vetschools
alleycat ()

3/14

Leading: --

Missing: a lot

70f866c115cfe84da26d02923e174a38.gif


Yeet/Vote closes at 9pm Eastern (~3.25 hours)
 
i have a very good reason to believe I was wrong about alleycat.
Not because of their defense of themself. Something more reliable.
Are you able to safely elaborate? Because the only people I trust are kras and samac (assuming they haven’t been converted to cultists but I’m not getting that vibe). And you wanted to yeet alleycat still this morning so I’m assuming you didn’t get a night message like others have claimed before? What changed?
 
think I will follow the confident vote of
###enigma###
Will try and do some deep reading when i qm done hanging with family from out of town.
 
I can get behind this bandwagon. The speed with which the wagons shifted off of enigma and alley yesterday looked very wolfy to me. Would also like to hear more from mayo about why not alleycats.

yeet enigma
 
I can get behind this bandwagon. The speed with which the wagons shifted off of enigma and alley yesterday looked very wolfy to me. Would also like to hear more from mayo about why not alleycats.

yeet enigma
you know.
 
I am really not sure who to trust between you and kras in all honest
Can you elaborate? Why do you need to choose between them, I was under the impression the masons are a package deal?
Unless you meant between kras and enigma (still ?) but you quoted samac
 
Are you able to safely elaborate? Because the only people I trust are kras and samac (assuming they haven’t been converted to cultists but I’m not getting that vibe). And you wanted to yeet alleycat still this morning so I’m assuming you didn’t get a night message like others have claimed before? What changed?
I can’t safely elaborate:/
I got a night message but probably a very different one than others got
The only person I can elaborate to is in a mayor pm
 
Are you able to safely elaborate? Because the only people I trust are kras and samac (assuming they haven’t been converted to cultists but I’m not getting that vibe). And you wanted to yeet alleycat still this morning so I’m assuming you didn’t get a night message like others have claimed before? What changed?
Also the last time I wanted to yeet alleycat was yesterday, also because of events last night (the same kind) I’m still a bit weary but I think the enigma vote is more important
 
i have a very good reason to believe I was wrong about alleycat.
Not because of their defense of themself. Something more reliable.
Are you able to safely elaborate? Because the only people I trust are kras and samac (assuming they haven’t been converted to cultists but I’m not getting that vibe). And you wanted to yeet alleycat still this morning so I’m assuming you didn’t get a night message like others have claimed before? What changed?

@vetschoolsletmeinplease I was asking that to mayo, sorry if that wasn't clear!
 
Can you elaborate? Why do you need to choose between them, I was under the impression the masons are a package deal?
Unless you meant between kras and enigma (still ?) but you quoted samac
Because samac and kras seem to be masons and have a better feel for villagers than i do based on last night. And i need to vote am am very impaired by alcohol at the moment because family is in town
 
I feel a bit out of the loop with everyone else either getting night messages or having closed discussions with people. I'm left trying to figure out who to trust. It seems there is a big push to yeet enigma which I understand given the more-solid information I assume these people are getting but not sharing. However, I don't see anyone so far trying to defend enigma or vote somewhere else and that kind of concerns me. Either the wolves are happy, they're not here right now, or they're unwilling to try to defend Enigma because they don't want to shoot themselves in the foot if Enigma comes back wolf.
 
I feel a bit out of the loop with everyone else either getting night messages or having closed discussions with people. I'm left trying to figure out who to trust. It seems there is a big push to yeet enigma which I understand given the more-solid information I assume these people are getting but not sharing. However, I don't see anyone so far trying to defend enigma or vote somewhere else and that kind of concerns me. Either the wolves are happy, they're not here right now, or they're unwilling to try to defend Enigma because they don't want to shoot themselves in the foot if Enigma comes back wolf.
Literally my manator just question guided me again, asking if there is only one strong candidate to vote out who isn't a hard confirmed wolf, what do you think the wolves are thinking?
 
I feel a bit out of the loop with everyone else either getting night messages or having closed discussions with people. I'm left trying to figure out who to trust. It seems there is a big push to yeet enigma which I understand given the more-solid information I assume these people are getting but not sharing. However, I don't see anyone so far trying to defend enigma or vote somewhere else and that kind of concerns me. Either the wolves are happy, they're not here right now, or they're unwilling to try to defend Enigma because they don't want to shoot themselves in the foot if Enigma comes back wolf.
My best guess is that the bottom of your post is right. When vis was confirmed wolf the first thing I did was go through and look at ho they interacted w most or defended. They probably know the same thing would happen
 
Because samac and kras seem to be masons and have a better feel for villagers than i do based on last night. And i need to vote am am very impaired by alcohol at the moment because family is in town
Maybe I missed an unyeet but I thought they're both voting the same right now so no need to make a choice between who's lead to follow

I can get behind this bandwagon. The speed with which the wagons shifted off of enigma and alley yesterday looked very wolfy to me. Would also like to hear more from mayo about why not alleycats.

yeet enigma
This hurts me because I want to trust her so much.

yeet enigma
 
I feel a bit out of the loop with everyone else either getting night messages or having closed discussions with people. I'm left trying to figure out who to trust. It seems there is a big push to yeet enigma which I understand given the more-solid information I assume these people are getting but not sharing. However, I don't see anyone so far trying to defend enigma or vote somewhere else and that kind of concerns me. Either the wolves are happy, they're not here right now, or they're unwilling to try to defend Enigma because they don't want to shoot themselves in the foot if Enigma comes back wolf.
Myself, I have no hard evidence for Enigma.
it is purely based on voting history and I have been sus of her and alley.
I have decent recent to believe alley isn’t one.
 
My best guess is that the bottom of your post is right. When vis was confirmed wolf the first thing I did was go through and look at ho they interacted w most or defended. They probably know the same thing would happen
I'm just very worried about jumping on another bandwagon blindly because last night I screwed it up royally. Had my vote been different it likely would have tied and Samac could have swung it the other way. I definitely can't do that again.
 
It’s so hard to figure out if people are purposely being absent and laying low, or if we are all just busy spending time with family and celebrating the holidays.

Depending on the mechanics of the cult, the wolves are getting very close to losing if there is another cult leader still in the game.

But as Samac pointed out, the only way we win is if we yeet all of the wolves. We could still lose to the cult, especially if they’re still growing, but we need to find a wolf to give us a better chance at winning.

I’m having a hard time with the TME vote. Mainly because they seemed genuine in their defense posts yesterday. 2 big things stick out to me: first, the fact that Zepp was suspicious of Vis and TME both, and we know now that she was a seer and Vis was a wolf. Second, the whole confusion yesterday when somebody quoted TME explaining how roles are given/assigned to Jhmmd a few days ago. If TME was a vanilla villager, I’m not sure they would be confident enough to explain to Jhmmd exactly how WW works and how roles were assigned since SDN’s version of WW does differ quite a bit from other werewolf or mafia games. True, their manator could’ve told them, but that does seem sus.
 
Literally my manator just question guided me again, asking if there is only one strong candidate to vote out who isn't a hard confirmed wolf, what do you think the wolves are thinking?
I'm thinking if we were going after a villager, the wolves would want to defend that villager and give alternatives to not look too content, and especially if it looks like the bandwagon is going to be voted out so that if they come up villager in the write up then the wolves can claim "but I defended them!" But they could also just be content and not say anything and let us shoot ourselves in the foot. But also if we have a wolf they would be careful how they defend because if they're voted out then we would immediately look at who was the strongest support of the dead wolf.
 
I haven't been able to be at my computer or on my phone most of the afternoon because my (real life) symptoms have been really bad today, and I have a lot of reading to catch up on in this thread. I'm worried about bandwagoning, but when I diverged from samac, who seems to know what's up, I was way off and I don't want to do that again.

I want to make sure I get a vote in, so I'm going to do the noob thing and follow samac's lead / the bandwagon for now.

yeet enigma
 
When I’ve had the free time today, I have been doing deep dives on several different people, but I haven’t found anything suspicious. Every time I think somebody is suspicious, I go through their posts and become even less confident that they are a wolf. We are all still super new at this game and I honestly don’t know what I should be looking for to “prove” that somebody is a wolf.
 
Top