StardeWW Valley - GAME THREAD

[WildZoo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

samac
Barks
cubs
Sporty
Zenge
Bob
genny
dubz

Excuse me?

 

[WildZoo]

She knows better than to push me D1 for pushing someone she's not even village reading.

I don't have to be village reading someone to think the way you joined the wagon was weird.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Excuse me?

You heard me.

 

[WildZoo]

You heard me.

You'd better put your money where your mouth is and get on my vote then.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't have to be village reading someone to think the way you joined the wagon was weird.

You've seen me do multiple switches like this before as village. It's an overreaction.

 

[Animal Midwife]

You'd better put your money where your mouth is and get on my vote then.

You know I don't vote N1 kills on D1.

 

[bluestoat]

Kds still feels more like the right vote, even though Aggro!Stout feels pingy as well. Dana is kind of an enigma floating around in there. I thought all these votes would bring out more of a kds defense, so still monitoring that.

I like stout, this nickname gets you village points
(That's joking around, people)

 

[WildZoo]

You've seen me do multiple switches like this before as village. It's an overreaction.

This one felt different I can usually follow what you're trying to do

 

[bluestoat]

You know I don't vote N1 kills on D1.

Ooohhh, I'm adding this to my box of notes for gameplay soft ethics/making sure everyone has fun

 

[Truenamer]

Ooohhh, I'm adding this to my box of notes for gameplay soft ethics/making sure everyone has fun

Protec the babies and the people who just had to spend the entire game in the graveyard

The real question is, should we protect the last game's mods? Should I feel guilty about my Cubs vote?

 

[WildZoo]

You know I don't vote N1 kills on D1.

Hmm. Guess you're safe from breaking the streak then. For today at least.

 

[Animal Midwife]

This one felt different I can usually follow what you're trying to do

I don't see what isn't followable. I've been clear about wolf reading kdsw.

 

[WildZoo]

The real question is, should we protect the last game's mods? Should I feel guilty about my Cubs vote?

Typically yes.

I mean it's all kind of similar reasoning. Give people a chance to play when they haven't gotten the chance recently.

 

[bluestoat]

Typically yes.

I mean it's all kind of similar reasoning. Give people a chance to play when they haven't gotten the chance recently.

Thanks for letting us know!

 

[WildZoo]

I don't see what isn't followable. I've been clear about wolf reading kdsw.

Where? I saw you say you had no reads on the noobs yet yesterday, and then you switched your vote without commentary.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Protec the babies and the people who just had to spend the entire game in the graveyard

The real question is, should we protect the last game's mods? Should I feel guilty about my Cubs vote?

Ironically, cubs doesn't believe in grace periods himself, but I personally still wouldn't yeet him today.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Where? I saw you say you had no reads on the noobs yet yesterday, and then you switched your vote without commentary.

There was commentary. I said I released samac into the wild.

And then I spend posts questioning kdsw.

 

[Animal Midwife]

You even said I was going after her for "false pings" so to imply I had no visible reasoning contradicts that statement.

 

[WildZoo]

You even said I was going after her for "false pings" so to imply I had no visible reasoning contradicts that statement.

I wasn't referring to you with false pings, I was referring to the initial reads from cubs and samac about her thread entry. I'll look for your questions though.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Stout

Stout

 

[WildZoo]

There was commentary. I said I released samac into the wild.

I don't see how this is commentary on kdswg

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Okay but what if... Dubz and AM are w/w?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I wasn't referring to you with false pings, I was referring to the initial reads from cubs and samac about her thread entry. I'll look for your questions though.

Then I fail to see why I was grouped in with them or what your actual reason for voting me is.

 

[WildZoo]

Okay but what if... Dubz and AM are w/w?

No lol

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't see how this is commentary on kdswg

That was commentary on samac.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Okay but what if... Dubz and AM are w/w?

No. Bussing sucks.

 

[WildZoo]

Then I fail to see why I was grouped in with them or what your actual reason for voting me is.

You weren't? I mentioned you with Dana, not with them.

 

[Animal Midwife]

You weren't? I mentioned you with Dana, not with them.

Then why are you voting me?

 

[WildZoo]

That was commentary on samac.

Let me clarify: I did not have a problem with you removing your vote on samac. That part I followed.

I will otherwise stand by the fact that I don't think there has been enough wolf equity from that slot to justify 3 veteran players going after her in her first non-noob game.

Then why are you voting me?

Because your vote pinged me, and I have no reason not to vote you

 

[Truenamer]

No. Bussing sucks.

I get that you're a never-busser but not even the strictest definition of bussing includes "having a mild disagreement in-thread."

 

[Animal Midwife]

Let me clarify: I did not have a problem with you removing your vote on samac. That part I followed.

I will otherwise stand by the fact that I don't think there has been enough wolf equity from that slot to justify 3 veteran players going after her in her first non-noob game.


Because your vote pinged me, and I have no reason not to vote you

So you are voting me because I'm voting her. Like I originally said.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I get that you're a never-busser but not even the strictest definition of bussing includes "having a mild disagreement in-thread."

This isn't a disagreement. I put dubz at the bottom of my list.

 

[Truenamer]

This isn't a disagreement. I put dubz at the bottom of my list.

Right, right. That follows.

I do see the value in your stance, by the way; it really does make reading you easier for other villagers.

 

[WildZoo]

So you are voting me because I'm voting her. Like I originally said.

Sure

 

[kdswg]

Kds still feels more like the right vote, even though Aggro!Stout feels pingy as well. Dana is kind of an enigma floating around in there. I thought all these votes would bring out more of a kds defense, so still monitoring that.

I get called wolfy for being over defensive and not defensive enough so idk how to balance. I find it interesting that samac hasn't really given any reads on anyone other than me, and its because of circumstantial similarity to her first wolf entrance. Your vote was based on a ping from timing, and dana and AM phrased their votes mostly as "throw down a vote and see how it feels" so I don't see much to defend

 

[supershorty]

I'm just going to say that I find it incredibly entertaining to see the look of guilt on stoat's face and how she slams the phone down to pretend she wasn't checking the thread when I walk in on her doing it, even though she knows full well that I'm doing exactly the same thing when I'm sitting at my desk.

 

[Barkley13]

Okay but what if... Dubz and AM are w/w?

What makes you think this?

 

[Barkley13]

I keep reading Dana as Dina. Must be because of how sneaky Dina is that she’s sneaking in like this

 

[WildZoo]

I keep reading Dana as Dina. Must be because of how sneaky Dina is that she’s sneaking in like this

Oh no, the last time you called Dina sneaky you were wolfing 😱

 

[Animal Midwife]

I get called wolfy for being over defensive and not defensive enough so idk how to balance. I find it interesting that samac hasn't really given any reads on anyone other than me, and its because of circumstantial similarity to her first wolf entrance. Your vote was based on a ping from timing, and dana and AM phrased their votes mostly as "throw down a vote and see how it feels" so I don't see much to defend

Who are you wolf reading?

 

[bluestoat]

I'm just going to say that I find it incredibly entertaining to see the look of guilt on stoat's face and how she slams the phone down to pretend she wasn't checking the thread when I walk in on her doing it, even though she knows full well that I'm doing exactly the same thing when I'm sitting at my desk.

🥲

 

[kdswg]

I'm still not getting v/v vibes from the earlier samac/cubs interactions. Cubs claim of trying a new village tactic doesn't really hold weight to me bc whats stopping him from trying a new wolf strategy. Samac I felt ok about until I went back and saw how quiet shes been about everyone but me. It would be pretty ballsy to have w/w interactions that prominent this early, so im leaning towards one of them being wolves

 

[samac]

Alright. I actually thought that all looked villagey for someone who just came off a wolf game.

Eh, maybe. I’m not wolf reading her but it could also be a cautious oh **** I’m wolfing with vets attitude about her. I’m not comfortable writing it off as village yet.

I feel like theres a wolf somewhere in kds, dana, and stoat, not just for the "prior game" stuff, just the overall interactions between them. Call it feels I guess if you have to.

Why specifically those 3? Interactions with everyone or between them specifically?

yeah of course! i don’t want to come across as over explaining but here was my exact thought process:
i kept thinking back to what AM told me about placing an early vote actually helping to prevent a tie. in my head, i decided i wanted to place a vote, even if it wasn’t confident with it
looking at my options, i was thinking that out of the 3 main vote getters (kdswg, dubz and cubs) a vote with kdswg made the most sense for a few reasons
- i am village reading cubs so i don’t want to vote there
- samac and cubs, two people i am village reading, were the two votes already on kdswg
- i had no idea how to feel about dubz or the two people voting her (sporty and bob)

so yeah i didn’t feel comfortable or confident to say kdswg is truly wolfy, but i did decide that i wanted to place a vote and so voting for her made the most sense for me out of what options i saw. and like i said before, i’m more than willing to move if i see a compelling argument elsewhere

Did you consider voting anyone who wasn’t a leading wagon? Your top wolf read?

I'm coming for you @samac 😉
View attachment 349525
And to stoat: nice

Rooooooood
You would think people wouldn’t come to the hospital in an ice storm unless it’s a true emergency
But no
That’s not how we do it in Kentucky
WE ALL COME

samac
Barks
cubs
Sporty
Zenge
Bob
genny
dubz

Y’all gonna get me killed
😡

 

[samac]

Okay but what if... Dubz and AM are w/w?

If this is W/W day 1 between these 2 that would rock my whole world and turn it upside down

 

[samac]

I get that you're a never-busser but not even the strictest definition of bussing includes "having a mild disagreement in-thread."

Didn’t dubz vote AM?
Am I crazy?

 

[WildZoo]

WE ALL COME

phrasing

 

[bluestoat]

Eh, maybe. I’m not wolf reading her but it could also be a cautious oh **** I’m wolfing with vets attitude about her. I’m not comfortable writing it off as village yet.

Why specifically those 3? Interactions with everyone or between them specifically?

Did you consider voting anyone who wasn’t a leading wagon? Your top wolf read?

Rooooooood
You would think people wouldn’t come to the hospital in an ice storm unless it’s a true emergency
But no
That’s not how we do it in Kentucky
WE ALL COME

Y’all gonna get me killed
😡

My sister works for the Kentucky State Cabinet!!

 

[samac]

I get called wolfy for being over defensive and not defensive enough so idk how to balance. I find it interesting that samac hasn't really given any reads on anyone other than me, and its because of circumstantial similarity to her first wolf entrance. Your vote was based on a ping from timing, and dana and AM phrased their votes mostly as "throw down a vote and see how it feels" so I don't see much to defend

Ya want me to have strong reads day 1?
Too bad you’re not getting em.

 

[WildZoo]

Didn’t dubz vote AM?
Am I crazy?

I did

 

[bluestoat]

Didn’t dubz vote AM?
Am I crazy?

True's learning the game, I think he didn't think about Dubz as not likely to bus either and focused on the in-theead comments