StardeWW Valley - GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Wine in front of me.

Also, the issue is blue wasn’t even on your vote and people who did yeet you are here and the roundabout explanation didn’t help the case.
Also didn’t like the delay in responses at first like maybe wolfchat was helping you, but that’s improved.

I dunno where to go.
I think I’m in a tunnel.
And to clarify further, "wine in front of me" is referencing the scene from Princess Bride.

And if anyone hasn't seen Princess Bride, you have to, it's possibly the best movie ever made.
 
So you changed your mind from your earlier genny read?
not necessarily, she just moved a little further down on my "need more info" list towards possibly wolfy. But would still like more info
 
Now that we are approaching the nighttime deadline, it might be time to start squinting at the people at the bottom of the posting list. I'll try and do that once I get home and take care of the Big Chungus.

Though in a game with just a few wolves, it seems pretty suboptimal for them to not being engaged on the thread.
 
Wine in front of me.

Also, the issue is blue wasn’t even on your vote and people who did yeet you are here and the roundabout explanation didn’t help the case.
Also didn’t like the delay in responses at first like maybe wolfchat was helping you, but that’s improved.

I dunno where to go.
I think I’m in a tunnel.
ok, I promise this is the last time I'll defend it, but stoat WAS on my vote earlier that night before I role revealed, and actually kick-started the bandwagon (bc of the whole investigation thing). The only other person here that actually did yeet me in the end was dana, but she was a wolf and I had just called out 2 wolves (in my RR) so the wolves had to get rid of me bc it seemed like I had some super special power. But it wouldn't have even come to that if stoat hadn't started the bandwagon that left me cornered

also dont expect me to be this responsive every night, my only day off is thursday and one of the vets at work has gotten on us (ahem, mostly me) about being on our phones
 
ok, I promise this is the last time I'll defend it, but stoat WAS on my vote earlier that night before I role revealed, and actually kick-started the bandwagon (bc of the whole investigation thing). The only other person here that actually did yeet me in the end was dana, but she was a wolf and I had just called out 2 wolves so the wolves had to get rid of me bc it seemed like I had some super special power. But it wouldn't have even come to that if stoat hadn't started the bandwagon that left me cornered

also dont expect me to be this responsive every night, my only day off is thurday and one of the vets at work has gotten on us (ahem, mostly me) about being on our phones
Oh absolutely no judgement about activity it was the time between posts like crafting a response, not being thread absent.

who should I vote? Im not willing to go cubs.
 
Oh absolutely no judgement about activity it was the time between posts like crafting a response, not being thread absent.

who should I vote? Im not willing to go cubs.
my leaning-wolfy list is still zenge, cubs, and dana (and possibly genny)
 
Looks Like We Better Get To Work - D1 Tally

D0221FA5-0959-4BA9-B434-FF6669AAF944.png


samac ()
DubZ (2) - Sporty, Bob
genny (1) - PSV
Zenge (1) - genny
AM ()
cubs (2)- True, kdswg
stoaty ()
Sporty ()
kdswg (3) - samac, Dana, AM
Barky (1) - stoaty
Dana (1) - Barks

@kdswg, you are in the lead!
11/14 voting
Missing: @Zenge142 @WildZoo @cubsrule4e

Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Thursday, 2/3 (~2.75 hours)
 
Zenge hasn’t done anything in particular that makes him seem wolfy at this point
for me, its the way he was so combative the first night, especially with the fight with PSV(?), and has stayed pretty quiet since. Potentially reads to me like a wolf that realized that they were coming on too strong, so they backed off and are floating now
 
for me, its the way he was so combative the first night, especially with the fight with PSV(?), and has stayed pretty quiet since. Potentially reads to me like a wolf that realized that they were coming on too strong, so they backed off and are floating now
This one post?
It seems more like you’re throwing me under the bus from last game, as opposed to saying anything relevant to this game.

So it’s more like a conversation where last games roles apply, and in that spirit I get where AM is coming from.
 
for me, its the way he was so combative the first night, especially with the fight with PSV(?), and has stayed pretty quiet since. Potentially reads to me like a wolf that realized that they were coming on too strong, so they backed off and are floating now

This is actually what made me feel like they were the same affiliation, and moreso to be v/v. When they were wolfing there wasnt much interaction at all. Of course you could say "well they changed it up this time" but it just felt like a village encounter to me on both sides. Im not ruling out w/v which was AMs follow up question, but v/v was my perception.
 
Explain Barks vs Bob rankings to me, cause I'd switch them

Barks standard cubs vote to start, and nothing really wolfy that ive seen. She typically doesnt throw a ton out there the first cycle. If she were still voting me right now it might start to raise a little suspicion.. Bob seemed village coming out of the gate but I missed a few of his posts that when I reread the next day seemed odd, like the "Ewwwww" intro.
 
This one post?
I think I mis-remembered that fight being bigger than it actually was, but in general, his tone seemed more direct than it does now
You’re handing out village reads like a sketchy dude in a van handing candy to kids and it’s making me nervous.

Is there a reason you left off v/w midwife?
these seem more harsh than the "hey what are your thoughts" posts hes done recently
 
I'm still not getting v/v vibes from the earlier samac/cubs interactions. Cubs claim of trying a new village tactic doesn't really hold weight to me bc whats stopping him from trying a new wolf strategy. Samac I felt ok about until I went back and saw how quiet shes been about everyone but me. It would be pretty ballsy to have w/w interactions that prominent this early, so im leaning towards one of them being wolves
So you’re leaning Cubs wolfy? What about his new changed play style is making you think wolf?
 
So you’re leaning Cubs wolfy? What about his new changed play style is making you think wolf?
i have a longer post about cubs but I can explain more if you want
I don't really like the above posts, cubs came out swinging on day 1, handing out reads and dominating the thread but had over-dramatic replies when he was questioned? Being this reactive doesnt make a ton of sense to me for a power!village. You know that your reads are going to be questioned when your super vocal, so why the hurt defense


I also don't like how cubs called out me and stoat for joking around but gave bob a village read for similar joking? Either a noob bias or wolf arbitrarily placing reads

And of all of your wolfy pings the first night, why was I the one to get your vote? Only bc samac jumped on me? This post is the one that gives me the most pocket-y vibes
 
The noob game’s table of content is broken
What day did kdawg get yeeted?
Is this because of my own procrastination, or did it break at some point after I created it?

Ah, but couldn't that be the calmness that comes from knowing exactly what role everyone has?

(Though I agree, she feels quite different from last game.)
This is weird because I feel like samac "feels" about the same every game.

I hope JojaMart is a wolf
I already said this in my role PM before you posted it, Barky. Keep up.
I also said that I hope Alex, Sebastian, and Haley are wolves because they suck.
 
Is this because of my own procrastination, or did it break at some point after I created it?


This is weird because I feel like samac "feels" about the same every game.


I already said this in my role PM before you posted it, Barky. Keep up.
I also said that I hope Alex, Sebastian, and Haley are wolves because they suck.
You were the one who called me out day 1 last game for being weird
 
Top