The Little Mermaid WW

Discussion in 'Pre-Veterinary' started by PrincessButterCup, Oct 5, 2017.

  1. SDN is made possible through member donations, sponsorships, and our volunteers. Learn about SDN's nonprofit mission.
  1. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    You're going to have to explain that a little more, because I'm not seeing the connection, or why you should be basing anything on what Mel said in PM
     
  2. SDN Members don't see this ad. About the ads.
  3. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Mel started calling Crayola chaos out of nowhere which implies to me the wolves already knew and he slipped that out. And Mel has avoided saying anything about DVMD the whole game.
     
  4. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Unofficial Day 7 Lynch Tally

    AM (1) - DVMD
    DVMD (1) - AM

    2/5 votes
    lynch close in ~ 11 hours
     
  5. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    Well, he wasn't alive that long. But I see what you mean.

    Still, I'd like some reason why I shouldn't lynch you rather than just reasons why I should lynch DVMD.
     
  6. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Oh FFS, AM is full of crap.

    @Animal Midwife how about this....I've laid out everything....I'm Max the dog, had one lynch avoidance.

    You've laid out nada...who are you...it is time. We are at that point.

    You've been shady as hell all game

    Lynched yourself.

    Wouldn't answer questions directly when asked. Especially the whole how you knew there were 3 wolves. And how you knew who 2 were. You evaded and avoided then claimed accolades only once those players were gone.

    So clear the air.... because you've been the only one dodging questions all game.
     
  7. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Exactly what are you implying here....I'm very curious to what you are suggesting.
     
  8. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    I really suck at defending. Is there a specific reason(s) you think I'm a wolf?

    You know I hold out on role revealing as long as possible.

    I was being a little b****. I only ended up knowing one wolf instead of two and was frustrated.

    Through my experience with PMing, I've gotten pretty decent at parsing out wolfy reactions towards me. I still think there's three wolves.

    Ask away.
     
  9. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    All a bunch of non-answers... and repeated hand waving. How does "my experience with PMing/parsing out wolfy interactions" have ANYTHING to do with the number of wolves in the game? Huh? Also, how did you KNOW the wolves but only claimed accolades and went "ha-ha, see told you!" after the wolves finally died? These are the questions I asked above that you did not answer in this above response you need to do better than vague responses... direct answers with supportive evidence is needed.

    Also please explain how Mel mentioning Crayola as chaos has anything to do with me... as you stated it does above. You seemingly just ignored that question.
     
  10. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Someone told Mel Crayola was chaos and he didn't want to discuss you.
     
  11. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    It has to do with wolf-hunting the old-fashioned way. Looking for inconsistencies in game progress and knowledge. If someone seems wolfy, boom. One wolf.

    Would you rather I didn't say anything at all? I've been doing my best to keep wolves in the dark this whole game.

    Missed it on my first read through. Answered now.
     
  12. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    So you are implying I told Mel that Crayola is chaos...

    Two issues with this:

    1. If even thought or had ANY inclination Crayola might be chaos, I would have been all over that in the thread. I don't let chaos live, at all, ever. You can see my prior game history as proof. Chaos should be killed with fire, from space. And I would have been screaming all over this thread to kill it. Yet, nada... that is because I never even thought Crayola was chaos.

    2. I couldn't even PM with Crayola until well after Mel died.... and I refused to PM with her. I won't open that can of worms but basically Crayola is like WS for me, so I just avoid PMing... you probably weren't around when WS was, but for anyone who was, they would get what I am saying.

    3. I bet Mel didn't discuss multiple people... not just me. Are you going to go through the list of every person Mel mentioned? Or are you only honing in on me because I am the easy lynch target today?

    So your above "theory" is falling flat for multiple reasons.
     
  13. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Umm... duh, we all know there will be at least one wolf.. this isn't even an answer.



    Actually, for your own info in future games since I am now 99.9% sure you are wolf, yes, saying nothing would be better for you. Going around bragging that you "know 2/3 wolves" and then skating and avoiding every question involving that until AFTER the wolves die and then going "Ha! See I told you I knew who the wolves are!!! Ha ha ha!" makes you look horridly suspicious. You would have been better to not say anything at all.
     
  14. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Good to know.

    Okay...

    You're not easy. I'm the only one voting for you. Mel mentioned 10 different villagers/non-villagers in our chat, but never any wolves (that I'm aware of).

    If it not kc or WZ, it has to be you. I can't think of any reason LIS would be a wolf.

    I'm talking about knowing.

    Too bad that 0.01% is enough for you to be wrong.
     
  15. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Then why the hell didn't you LYNCH the wolf and why the hell were you cryptic about who they were?
     
  16. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Prove it... quote them and post them.
     
  17. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Shouldn't be too difficult or even take long.
     
  18. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Because I was sure SP was one and was going to use her hesitation to lynch Mel against him the next day.

    Sure. Give me a second.
     
  19. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Exactly my point. I am the easiest lynch target for you...

    WZ just claimed Prince Eric, so you aren't likely getting a lynch in there

    KC was rezzed by WZ and was previously a villager, you are unlikely to get a lynch there.

    LIS is claiming an ability that (as far as I know) you don't know what it is... you are unlikely to get a lynch there.

    SO... what is your choice?? Hmm... I know I am going to early lynch DVMD because she has been suspicious all game and had a suspicious ability.

    This is my entire point... you left me in and targeted me because I AM the easy lynch target right now. And you notice... we have information on every single player in this game except for you.. so why exactly are you so adamant to hold back?
     
  20. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    In the interim... this is every mod PM I have received this game..... minus the obvious thing in brackets to not allow wolves more info about what happened with LeTits and I. I am good after this. I have nothing else to share/give. I urge the others to see if they can get @Animal Midwife to reveal more about her role/character, because she really is the last unknown in the game. I am off to get lunch and enjoy another day off...

     
  21. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
     
  22. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    That why I said barring conversion. You're the only one that makes sense as an original. If there was a conversion, I'd consider a different candidate. 5 original non-villagers is realistic in a game this size, yes?

    I hold back because I don't like role revealing unless necessary. At all.
     
  23. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Hmm... Interesting Mel was concerned about being redirected to LIS... especially since we know Mel was a wolf... maybe more concerned about killing LIS??? Did this ever cross your mind AM?
     
  24. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Where are the PMs from Mel about Crayola being chaos?
     
  25. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Honestly no.

    I only quoted one for each mentioned player.

    Here's the chaos specific one.

     
  26. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    When was that chaos specific one sent? Date/time?

    I will try to look back later to see if it was before or after FFM claimed his ability on thread.
     
  27. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Monday 10:58 PM EST
     
  28. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Where is the PM prior to that chaos one... clearly you guys were discussing chaos players prior to that... I want to see that PM as the one you quoted is very obviously taken out of context.
     
  29. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Here.

     
  30. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Ok, I really am going to go get food now.

    And watch a movie.

    Will come back later.
     
  31. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Ah... so the truth shows that YOU suggested she is chaos... nice. Thank you.
     
  32. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    ???
     
  33. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    That quote is from you.... you stated chaos then she responded with the Crayola having two abilities. You started the chaos talking in that PM thread.... but then again you are cherry picking things....so maybe post all of the convo...you've got nothing to hide, so you say.
     
  34. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    Yeah, because LIS said not to block him and I assumed Crayola saw that and would be causing trouble if that happened if chaos.

    And the entire PM or am I misunderstanding?
     
  35. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    That part there shows you suggested Crayola as chaos, so posting on thread that someone else told Mel that is incredibly dishonest...heck you said Mel mentioned it to you and the reverse is actually true. And yes, posting all of the PMs instead of cherry picking so we can see flow and conversation.... how can we know you aren't just omitting where Mel mentioned others?
     
  36. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    I don't think AM would have fabricated all of those PMs, and most wolves don't have the forethought to have full on conversations with fellow wolves outside of the pack PM. It would be a good strategy but it's time consuming and just doesn't happen. So I'm inclined to believe these conversations were legitimate, which would mean AM is not a wolf.

    Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
     
  37. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    Barring conversion, which I don't think we have evidence of...

    Although, did we ever resolve the issue of why there wasn't a wolf kill on the night Mel died?

    Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
     
  38. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    I'm thinking that way too to be honest, but where does that lead us because I can promise you I'm not a wolf..... didn't fabricate my role PM. Didn't just sit on a tie last night while able to change it thus losing my lynch avoidance. I mean that would've been game winning for me.
     
  39. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    How confident are you in LIS's ability being villagery?

    Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
     
  40. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Let's put it this way....I'm the only crazy person to have given that ability to a wolf, specifically because it is a decent cover. Didn't Finn or Mel state they were originally going after LIS but were redirected? I think it was Mel who said that on thread.

    I dunno, I've felt odd about LIS all game but yes that ability is very much village typically.
     
  41. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    I guess we could go down the conversion route if we wanted to. Because like I said, I don't think we have an explanation for the lack of wolf kill the night kcough killed Mel.

    Unless she was the wolf doing the kill, and just made up the extra ability story.

    That would make me super grumpy though.

    Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
     
  42. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    [replies placed next to each other for easier reading]

    There. Just for you @DVMDream .
     
  43. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
  44. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Thanks!

    Actually makes me less suspicious of you.... I'm finding Mel's repeat concerns about being redirect to LIS odd, especially since there was no blocking ability. Why was he so concerned about that? Just bizarre.
     
    Animal Midwife likes this.
  45. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    If kc was the wolf, she would lose her lynch protection ability, right?
     
  46. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    I didn't realize kc had a lynch protection ability.... when was this mentioned?
     
  47. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    First I've heard of it

    Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
     
  48. WildZoo

    WildZoo Illegal in all 50 Gold Donor 2+ Year Member

    30,120
    35,342
    Apr 18, 2013
    The doll factory
    Oh! Wait, nvm, I read that as lynch avoidance. Yeah her original ability was to protect someone from lynch, I assumed she kept it when she was rezzed.

    Sent from my SM-G950U using SDN mobile
     
  49. cdoconn

    cdoconn Hydration Specialist. Pro-Quivering

    7,871
    10,437
    Jan 18, 2016
    Day 7 I’m Not a Child Anymore Lynch Tally

    AM (1) - DVMD
    DVMD (1) - AM

    2/5 votes
    lynch close in ~ 4 hours at 9pm CST

    [​IMG]
     
  50. DVMDream

    DVMDream Don't disturb the snowflakes 7+ Year Member

    35,560
    20,092
    Jul 15, 2009
    The Dragon School
    Veterinarian
    Yeah, not sure. I mean if she came back as the same person then I'd think she kept that ability. But since she gained an ability and we don't know who she is, I'd be surprised if she still had that ability.
     
    Animal Midwife likes this.
  51. Animal Midwife

    Animal Midwife perpetually confused

    2,733
    1,494
    Jan 23, 2016
    I feel like that'd be OP to have lynch protection as a wolf. I also feel like it be easy to test if she still has this ability.
     

Share This Page