- Joined
- Apr 22, 2007
- Messages
- 22,957
- Reaction score
- 9,984
- Points
- 9,821
- Location
- Southeast
- Attending Physician
You are right. It would not be a good idea to predict Covid 19 behavior on SARS 1, nor should we relax our measures to to pre SARS levels. I was just asking the question what happened to the other Corona viruses? There was no new normal with them. I have heard the gov in our state wants to keep schools closed until 2021 and extend social distancing into 2022. I'm not sure why we are talking about a new normal now. Guess I'm getting a little fed up with the shelter in place stuff. I cant help but think there is some secondary gain in all of these orders. I understand Fauci is on the board at Galead and the institute of allergy and infectious disease, which he heads, is doing the big study on Remdesivir. Might explain why he so adamantly criticized HCQ so early on, when only preliminary data was coming in. I gotta quit watching the news.You said it yourself. SARS had a few cases in the USA then went away. SARS-2 at one point also had a few cases and then instead of going away, it climbed to over 1 million and is still going strong. It's pretty obvious that using SARS as a predictor of the future behavior of SARS-2 is rather illogical given their paths have diverged many tens of thousands of deaths ago.
I was just asking the question what happened to the other Corona viruses? There was no new normal with them.
Thank you! I had not seen it explained in those terms anywhere. It makes more sense now.It's pretty simple. Viruses that strike hard like SARS 1, MERS, Ebola have some unique characteristics: 1. The infected are usually symptomatic when they are contagious so they're easier to isolate and quaratine. 2. These viruses kill the infected pretty quickly.
Both of those things help to significantly limit the spread and essentially these kind of viruses will just burn themselves out.
SARS-2 on the other hand is very insidious. It has a long incubation period, and the devastating part is that there can be an R value >1 (or even 2) during the period where the infected are asymptomatic. The long asymptomatic incubation / contagion period combined with the fact that the virus has a somewhat lower mortality than SARS significantly increases the likelihood that it could become endemic, similar to flu.
He has a historyI hope these are the header pictures in future US history textbook chapters about COVID-19. Sums up our federal response and attitude pretty well
![]()
![]()
This seems like an awful high death rate. Nyc has 18.8 million residents. 1 in 400 is .0025. Multiply by 18.8 million, you get 47,000. To date, 13,000 deaths from covid in nyc. I think your math is off. 13,000 is a lot in anybody's bookTo date, 1 out of every 400 ppl in NYC has died. Mind-boggling. Even with NY's continued descent in cases and deaths, the daily deaths today in the US will be >2000 and new cases > 30,000. What this tells you is that while some states have decreasing cases, many states are on the upswing.
Hold up, you think the population of NYC is almost 19 million? Lol. It's around 8 million dude. Also, that death count is underestimated compared to the most updated figures I have seenThis seems like an awful high death rate. Nyc has 18.8 million residents. 1 in 400 is .0025. Multiply by 18.8 million, you get 47,000. To date, 13,000 deaths from covid in nyc. I think your math is off. 13,000 is a lot in anybody's book
Hold up, you think the population of NYC is almost 19 million? Lol. It's around 8 million dude. Also, that death count is underestimated compared to the most updated figures I have seen
Information on coronavirusHold up, you think the population of NYC is almost 19 million? Lol. It's around 8 million dude. Also, that death count is underestimated compared to the most updated figures I have seen



▼
market timing tends to work out well, especially when remembered after the timing took place.
But seriously, a Roth IRA should never be in all cash. Ever.
This seems like an awful high death rate. Nyc has 18.8 million residents. 1 in 400 is .0025. Multiply by 18.8 million, you get 47,000. To date, 13,000 deaths from covid in nyc. I think your math is off. 13,000 is a lot in anybody's book
Agreed. It's not 1 in 400 as another poster claimed.New York State has about 20mil population.
1 in 825 (23000/20mil)New York State residents have died of COVID in the last 2 months.
1 in 650 (13000/8.5mil) New York City residents have died of COVID in the last 2 months.
And it’s not done yet.
This was the problem I had when I was up north. No one wanted to CPAP. But they did high flow.
There were a few delayed intubations. Eventually they bought the tube.
With helmets, absolutely. Without, I think it's a matter of getting the proper seal.
I would intubate when the patient fails NIV, based on the patient's assessment, not on numbers. Even then, there are anecdotes about patients who were put on morphine for respiratory comfort, and still survived without intubation.
You have more experience with Covid than me, so you're asking the wrong person. 🙂
There is one thing about Covid that's definitely good for the future of critical care: it punishes disgusting knee-jerk medicine with a vengeance. This disease is about treating the patient's personal physiology like nothing else.
Regarding CPAP, some people are even considering whether the upper airway edema may be contributing to a special form of OSA in these patients, hence the success of CPAP.
I completely agree. People want to talk about frontline heroes, but I've seen ridiculous behavior from many physicians and nurses. Refusing to go into rooms. Not titrating medications appropriately.The problem with the hard hit area of NYC is that a lot of their facilities are very old hence care decisions had to be made not BiPAP or CPAP.
I am asking you because I value your opinion, but also in answering the questions. It's easy to bring up the situational adjustments that must be made in cities of hospital from the 70s.
Well if anything I was not knee-jerk in my critical care, but we are still feeling out the elephant at the same time. I think low does heparin used to be somewhat questioned but now it's' universally accepted as Covid is an endothelial and hyper coagulation disease. Steroids have largely fallen and HCQ and Azithromycin have largely showed no benefit.
The ECMO numbers have been dismal as well.
The hardest struggle in caring for COVID in crisis care is that do you go all out for your pt or do you taper and protect your team to fight for another day. Its a ****ty situation and something to ponder about as the country reopens.
It's pretty damn close if you are using the most updated figures. NYC has ~18,100 deaths, not 12,000. Jesus christ learn how to look up basic info. Population is 8.4 million (you were off by >10 million lol). And the true death count is significantly higher and cases+deaths are still ongoing so it won't be very long til we go higher than 1 in 400.Agreed. It's not 1 in 400 as another poster claimed.
Incorrect.It's pretty damn close if you are using the most updated figures. NYC has ~18,100 deaths, not 12,000. Jesus christ learn how to look up basic info. Population is 8.4 million (you were off by >10 million lol). And the true death count is significantly higher and cases+deaths are still ongoing so it won't be very long til we go higher than 1 in 400.
View attachment 304771
Never say never, ever.
I'm not sure its that big of a deal either way. I went for the most +EV play.
I don't say never lightly. And the most +EV play has never been all cash and likely never will be.
The stats for NYC deaths I quoted were published by the state of New York. 1 in 400 deaths you quoted for a population of 8.4 million people comes to 21,000 deaths. Not pretty damn close to 18,100 as you suggest. As far as accepting advice from a deep thinker like yourself on how to research basic info, I think I'll take a pass. Have a nice day 🙂It's pretty damn close if you are using the most updated figures. NYC has ~18,100 deaths, not 12,000. Jesus christ learn how to look up basic info. Population is 8.4 million (you were off by >10 million lol). And the true death count is significantly higher and cases+deaths are still ongoing so it won't be very long til we go higher than 1 in 400.
View attachment 304771
Beyond JHU, another easy way to look up the right numbers is... weather.com.It's pretty damn close if you are using the most updated figures. NYC has ~18,100 deaths, not 12,000. Jesus christ learn how to look up basic info. Population is 8.4 million (you were off by >10 million lol). And the true death count is significantly higher and cases+deaths are still ongoing so it won't be very long til we go higher than 1 in 400.
View attachment 304771
Because, beyond the different characteristics that vector2 mentioned, SARS was tracked and isolated like Ebola, as any epidemic should be.I dont disagree, but I dont remember any super sleuthing in America, school closures, or available testing for SARS. It was here, then it was gone. Nothing like we see going on today. Thanks for your thoughts!
I'm not so sure about that. Yes we screwed up pretty impressively, but there is not a single country that is doing great with this.Because, beyond the different characteristics that vector2 mentioned, SARS was tracked and isolated like Ebola, as any epidemic should be.
This got out of control first in China, then it got out of control in the US, with this administration in denial for months.
Had we isolated and tracked every international traveler and contact, and had we looked at every pneumonia back in December-January, when we first heard about the epidemic, as if this were Ebola, we would have not needed the shutdown. We would have only isolated a few hundred thousand people at a time for 2 weeks. Still a lot to track and enforce, but incomparable.
We are where we are because we are a people of scientifically illiterates who elected scientifically illiterates as their leaders. What I tend to call *****s (regardless what side of the political spectrum they are on).
There are some. Usually the smaller ones who learned from SARS. Taiwan, NZ etc.I'm not so sure about that. Yes we screwed up pretty impressively, but there is not a single country that is doing great with this.
There are some. Usually the smaller ones who learned from SARS. Taiwan, NZ etc.
We are definitely among the worst offenders, and it's absolutely expected, given the abysmal federal response.
We are virtually an island nation, too. That's why we haven't had a foreign invader on our soil for about two centuries (which has helped us tremendously). We didn't get this from illegal immigrants. We could have done everything those countries did, if only we weren't in denial.Small island nations that have had very strict border control for years (in the case of NZ due to ecosystem issues). Even if we wanted to, not sure we could do what they've done from that perspective alone.
This was the problem I had when I was up north. No one wanted to CPAP. But they did high flow.
There were a few delayed intubations. Eventually they bought the tube.
“We’ll revisit the 2,200 S&P low, if not make a lower low — probably by late summer,” he said. “That’s going to come because we’re going to find out now is a critical time for the market.”
Bianco predicts there will be an overwhelming realization that life isn’t getting back to normal when then economy starts to reopen.
“What the market seems to be thinking is we’re going to restart, and we’re all going to pretend that it’s 2019,” said Bianco. “And, we’re all going to stand on the subway platform with 500 other people waiting for the next train.”
He contends a recovery will still be long and slow — despite the Federal Reserve’s aggressive policies to support the economy and financial system.
“We are moving to a lower growth environment, and I think the market is a little ahead of itself right now in what that means,” Bianco said. “There’s going to be more changes and more evolution that the economy is going to have to go through before we’re ready to start a full on bull market.”
The problem with Japan was that the market got to crazy valuations, i.e. average P/E ratio in the neighborhood of 80-100.i dont think we even stand a chance at predicting the market anymore (not that we were good at it in the past, but even worse now).
WIth the craziness in the economy, most of us would say market will dip. But i believe its impossible to predict at all with the Fed's actions. They are artificially propping up the market. We dont know how long can this continue for. They injected like 10 Trillion dollars which is why stocks are almost back to pre corona levels. If they inject another 10T next month, we may see new highs. This will hurt younger people 10-20 years later, but with the current crisis its completely unpredictable.
I saw a hedgefund manager make a good point. People have been feeding us this 'lie' that stock market will go up in the long run so its a 'safe/smart' investment, especially index fund. This gets more people into stock market which raises prices. At some point that may stop, and at some point, stocks may no longer be a great investment even in the LONG run.
Below is Japan's stock exchange. THIRD largest economy in the world. It peaked in 1980s, so if you placed it in stock 30 years ago, you wouldve LOST significant amount of money. So far we are seeing large increases in our stock market over the long run, similar to japans stock levels from 1965 to 1980s, but we dont know what it will be like after this, it could be similar to japans were we level off and go horizontally and not vertically.
View attachment 304790
Up north, especially at peak times, we had whole floors on non invasives like CPAP/BIPAP/HF/Non rebreather. Seal sucked. None of them in neg pressure rooms. but what can you do? let all of them die? Tube ALL of them?
I would have tubed them all if HF/non-rebreather made their O2 sat below 88 and their O2 delivery made them uncomfortable clinically. But this takes a clinician that knows what they're doing and can intubate on a whim without needing to call a team 1 hour in advance. How many ICU has this kind of physician staffing them?
So you don't have that kind of physician covering your ICU, the smart thing is probably intubate them ALL. CPAP/BIPAP is great in theory but they are very difficult to keep on a patient when the nurse cannot enter the room every 5 mins. If you're making your nurse go in the room every 5 mins, you're not protecting your nurse. It's not the standard situation... people nee to keep that in mind.
dont have enough vent to tube them all.
also i agree they are difficult to keep on a patient, but breathing tube in that situation wasnt that great of a choice either when the nurse cant enter the room every 5 min and cant even see the patient without opening the door. lot of self extubations
where are you that you don't have enough vents to tube them all?
S&P 500 Historical Annual Returns (1927-2026)
Interactive chart showing the annual percentage change of the S&P 500 index back to 1927. Performance is calculated as the % change from the last trading day of each year from the last trading day of the previous year.www.macrotrends.net
I don't know why doctors think they know everything about everything just because they have a medical degree. But clearly the EV of cash is - (inflation rate) and for any year that the S&P 500 is down more than the inflation rate the most +EV play is cash. Those years are 2000-2003, 2008, 2018, and 2020.
Says the dude who was quoting a population of 19 million for NYC.The stats for NYC deaths I quoted were published by the state of New York. 1 in 400 deaths you quoted for a population of 8.4 million people comes to 21,000 deaths. Not pretty damn close to 18,100 as you suggest. As far as accepting advice from a deep thinker like yourself on how to research basic info, I think I'll take a pass. Have a nice day 🙂
If we get out of this mess, it will be DESPITE (not because) of the federal government.Quite an informative thread here.
“Welcome to May.
As I feared, the federal government wasted April much as it wasted February.
That is a harsh assessment given how much the country has been suffering. But without competent federal leadership, the best we are managing is to tread water. Some stats:”
![]()
Thread by @JeremyKonyndyk: Welcome to May. As I feared, the federal government wasted April much as it wasted February. That is a harsh assessment given how much the c…
Thread by @JeremyKonyndyk: Welcome to May. As I feared, the federal government wasted April much as it wasted February. That is a harsh asseshow much the country has been suffering. But without competent federal leadership, the best we are managing is to…threadreaderapp.com
No, unless he (or his cronies) buy Tesla stock in the aftermath. He's right, btw.Is this not stock manipulation? Tesla dropped 10 percent from this tweet
Elon Musk just declared that he's selling almost all his physical belongings and 'will own no house' and that he thinks Tesla's stock price is 'too high'
I don't say never lightly. And the most +EV play has never been all cash and likely never will be.
Can I hold up a mirror for you?
Do you know what the "E" in "EV" means? Expected. Not historical. It's easy to point at a graph 20 years ago and say man I wish I was in all cash right before this crash. It's quite another thing to be right now, after a crash, pointing at it and saying you are all cash.
The statistics say basically nobody can successfully market time. What makes you think that YOU can do it? Using the 20/20 hindsight to find years the market declined in the past does not give you any special powers for predicting the future.
So to be clear, I find it ironic that you wonder why doctors think they know "everything about everything" while telling us why you know so much about market timing when the evidence says nobody can do that. My advice is based the soundest research (by professionals and academics, not by doctors) suggesting you should never be all cash. Hell, you should probably never be more than maybe 20% cash at most but I suppose if you were filling lucky you could go to 40% or even 50% cash but that is probably still a little crazy.
I'm in all cash right now 🙂
I've decided to time the market, i'm all cash 😀
I've seen the chart in econ in college, but i don't have a reference. it's usually about a year.
As an econ major, I have. I don't believe it. managing stock with the assumption of an efficient market is like doing a case and using SVV as your measure of preload - A LOT of assumptions that aren't true.
If they are all equally as bad, shouldn't all of them be in the HOF?
No email yet, i paid for hotel and airline... what a major F up if i didn't 🙁
Can't tell if you're being for real. If you scroll back and see that my investment horizon is very long and this money that i'm messing with is essentially meaningless.
I do'nt believe I can time the market. But this is the wrong time to buy.
i was referring to peak. in nyc, hospitals had hundreds of covid patients. many were tubed, many others were on non invasive. dont have hundreds of vents just waiting there . i dont know if you saw this NYT video interview with ED physician in nyc complaining they at one point they only had like 1 free vent left.. not too different in other NYC hospitals at peak

You still never said how you divined the 1 in 400 number which you presented as a fact. I collegially pointed out that I thought that was too high. You could have said My Bad, and ok, we"re done. But you got snarky, and since I give as I get, I became that annoying poster. But I've wasted too much time on you already so I'm done with this topic.That said, I do agree with you in that you could be right if we just wait long enough. Just not on April 29th. Cheers!Says the dude who was quoting a population of 19 million for NYC.
Btw, what is the point of your fixation on the precision of me stating 1 in 400 lol? That you have had to make 5 or 6 different pointless waste of time posts about it. The most fukn annoying kind of poster. Yah, I’m trying to mislead everyone by saying 1 in 400 as if 1 in 500 or 600 ppl is not impressive enough lol.
You do realize where the nyc numbers are headed right? Look at their death count from just a couple weeks ago. Many have not been counted yet who have died in their homes. Wait until where the final numbers end up and 1 in 400 will look like a joke.
arstechnica.com
The NIH has not provided a clear explanation for its move to cancel the funds, which occurred April 24 and was first reported by Politico Monday, April 27. However, in emails exchanges published April 30 by Science magazine, it is clear that the NIH was motivated by conspiracy theories that allege—without evidence—that the virus was somehow released by Chinese researchers in Wuhan, the central Chinese city where the pandemic began.