Wash U vs. Michigan, MD/PhD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

harvman11

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2009
Messages
155
Reaction score
0
So I've been accepted to the MST programs at both Wash U and Michigan, and I'm having a bit of trouble deciding between them. Obviously they're both great programs, and I think I'll be happy at either one, but I do have to make a decision eventually. My research interest is in the biology of aging, and I'm pretty sure that's what I will want to do my PhD in, though of course having other strong research is a plus if my interests do change. Here's some of the facts/thoughts I've had so far about the programs:

Research:
Mich - Outstanding research in aging, with the Nathan Shock Center and all, and numerous (7+) PIs doing work that's pretty much exactly what I'd like to do now. Facilities seem outstanding, and only getting better with their recent purchase of a new facility.
Wash U - Lots of younger PIs doing very forward thinking research. A couple (2 that I've found so far) of PIs doing work that I'd be very interested in, but other labs are doing interesting work and the PIs seem very MD/PhD friendly. Facilities didn't seem quite as nice, but obviously I had a limited view.

Economics:
Mich - $25,500 first 2 years, $26,500 in grad school, $27,500 last 2 years. From what I've seen a slightly higher cost of living than Wash U
Wash U - $27,500 each year, low cost of living.

Location:
Mich - Ann Arbor seems like a great place, and I'd love to be back in a college town.
U Wash - St Louis has more things to do, but it doesn't really seem like there's siginificantly more than in Ann Arbor when you consider Detroit is fairly close by.

Reputation/Resident Placement:
both schools are great here, but I feel like Wash U definitely has the edge.

Any thoughts are welcome, and I'd especially like to hear what people think about the research at both schools and other things I should be considering.
 
I'm not applying MD/PhD, and I know this isn't a technical measure of which school you should choose, but let me just say one thing:

The University of Michigan tries to lure students away from Wash U, not the other way around.
 
i applied MSTP so one thing that I found important is whether or not you want to stay there for 8 years. i'm sure you know from your research experience that research can be gruel and uncontrollable sometimes, try to look for a supportive group of people (i dont know how, but i have heard some bad things about certain programs, not WashU or UM)

if you are really really sure about aging research, go with UM. how's the housing market in michigan, isnt it a good investment opportunity? idk about ann arbor though
 
got an interview invite at Wash U, Surprising pre-interview rejection from Michi. So i may be a little biased when I say go with Wash U.😛
 
got an interview invite at Wash U, Surprising pre-interview rejection from Michi. So i may be a little biased when I say go with Wash U.😛

Although, if you really wanted to be strategic about it, VOP, you'd urge harvman11 to go to UMich, in order to open up more space for you at Wash U ... 😉
 
Although, if you really wanted to be strategic about it, VOP, you'd urge harvman11 to go to UMich, in order to open up more space for you at Wash U ... 😉
harvman, go to UM😀😀😀
 
he's an MSTP acceptee. they would just probably pick another MSTPer from the waitlist. good try though, but you should probably jump a MD applicant
 
i applied MSTP so one thing that I found important is whether or not you want to stay there for 8 years. i'm sure you know from your research experience that research can be gruel and uncontrollable sometimes, try to look for a supportive group of people (i dont know how, but i have heard some bad things about certain programs, not WashU or UM)

if you are really really sure about aging research, go with UM. how's the housing market in michigan, isnt it a good investment opportunity? idk about ann arbor though

The housing market in Michigan is a buyer's market, and I'm definitely looking to buy a house. St. Louis also has some pretty cheap property, but I'm not so confident about it being a good investment, more just that it's cheap there. I'm probably leaning towards going to Michigan right now, mostly because I'm pretty confident about wanting to do aging research. It's just hard to turn down what is arguably the top medical school in the country...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top