- Joined
- Aug 14, 2016
- Messages
- 2
- Reaction score
- 0
During the fall 2015 of my junior year I wrote a paper for my honors college class (Oxford) explaining my undergraduate research and my plans to publish a thesis over it. The honors college requires every student to publish a thesis before they graduate, and Oxford is a class to help students begin researching and creating outlines for their future thesis projects.
When explaining my research (I had begun merely a couple weeks before) in the Oxford paper I asked my research professor what I should say. He sent me a two partial sections of his unpublished grant proposal over the research we were doing. Having signed a binding agreement with the research professor through the Honors College that he would be mentor and thesis advisor I believed at the time that anything I wrote in this paper for the Oxford class would represent both him and I.
Being native in this situation I used my research professor's grant proposal to help me explain the research I would be doing to write my thesis over. Having only a few weeks of research completed I was still confused on the methodology and mission statement, so I used/copied almost word-for-word my research professor's grant proposal in these sections because I didn't want to explain my research wrong.
After submitting my paper I gave an additional copy to my research professor so he would be up to date on my progress. The next day I got called into a meeting with my research professor and Oxford tutorial professor, and they asked me why I had plagiarized his work while citing all my other sources. I was in complete shock because I thought since the grant proposal is unpublished, that I was merely an extension of his authorship and represented him instead of myself and I believed I didn't need to cite him. Scientists do not cite their own grant proposals in their publications, so I thought for a simple paper for a class I definitely wouldn't since I was under his authority and authorship.
I realize now how idiotic that mistake was and how easy it would have been to avoid. After discussing the circumstances with my professors they agreed that even though I did not intentionally plagiarize his work, ethically they believed they still had to report it so that if a mistake like this ever happen again my future professors would know that I have had a previous offense. I was filed for academic misconduct, but they decided to keep my grade as an A because they didn't think my situation was intentional.
I did not file for an appeal, because even though I was outraged by the situation I knew that it was my mistake and I had to own up and accept to consequences. That week I wrote formal apology letters to both professors involved and to my school. In addition to that I attended two different plagiarism seminars to ensure I would never make a mistake like this again. That next semester I held a presentation for the younger classes in my fraternity and the honors college over my experience, the knowledge I learned, the effects it can have on their future, and how to prevent mistakes similar to mine to happen. My senior year I served on the Greek console judicial board, and used this position to hold myself and my Greek community to a higher standard.
My question is, how will this impact me during my application process this year for MD schools. I have a 3.85 GPA, 515 MCAT. I may not have a perfect application, but I believe it is definitely very competitive. My only concern is my academic misconduct. I would appreciate any advice on my chances, similar situations, how I should approach the Academic Violation portion on the AMCAS, if I should write about this in my PS, etc.
I sincerely apologize for the long post. I wanted to make sure my situation was explained thoroughly enough for you all to make the most accurate judgement.
When explaining my research (I had begun merely a couple weeks before) in the Oxford paper I asked my research professor what I should say. He sent me a two partial sections of his unpublished grant proposal over the research we were doing. Having signed a binding agreement with the research professor through the Honors College that he would be mentor and thesis advisor I believed at the time that anything I wrote in this paper for the Oxford class would represent both him and I.
Being native in this situation I used my research professor's grant proposal to help me explain the research I would be doing to write my thesis over. Having only a few weeks of research completed I was still confused on the methodology and mission statement, so I used/copied almost word-for-word my research professor's grant proposal in these sections because I didn't want to explain my research wrong.
After submitting my paper I gave an additional copy to my research professor so he would be up to date on my progress. The next day I got called into a meeting with my research professor and Oxford tutorial professor, and they asked me why I had plagiarized his work while citing all my other sources. I was in complete shock because I thought since the grant proposal is unpublished, that I was merely an extension of his authorship and represented him instead of myself and I believed I didn't need to cite him. Scientists do not cite their own grant proposals in their publications, so I thought for a simple paper for a class I definitely wouldn't since I was under his authority and authorship.
I realize now how idiotic that mistake was and how easy it would have been to avoid. After discussing the circumstances with my professors they agreed that even though I did not intentionally plagiarize his work, ethically they believed they still had to report it so that if a mistake like this ever happen again my future professors would know that I have had a previous offense. I was filed for academic misconduct, but they decided to keep my grade as an A because they didn't think my situation was intentional.
I did not file for an appeal, because even though I was outraged by the situation I knew that it was my mistake and I had to own up and accept to consequences. That week I wrote formal apology letters to both professors involved and to my school. In addition to that I attended two different plagiarism seminars to ensure I would never make a mistake like this again. That next semester I held a presentation for the younger classes in my fraternity and the honors college over my experience, the knowledge I learned, the effects it can have on their future, and how to prevent mistakes similar to mine to happen. My senior year I served on the Greek console judicial board, and used this position to hold myself and my Greek community to a higher standard.
My question is, how will this impact me during my application process this year for MD schools. I have a 3.85 GPA, 515 MCAT. I may not have a perfect application, but I believe it is definitely very competitive. My only concern is my academic misconduct. I would appreciate any advice on my chances, similar situations, how I should approach the Academic Violation portion on the AMCAS, if I should write about this in my PS, etc.
I sincerely apologize for the long post. I wanted to make sure my situation was explained thoroughly enough for you all to make the most accurate judgement.
Last edited: