- Joined
- Jan 23, 2016
- Messages
- 35,474
- Reaction score
- 43,325
How do you feel about Moose's d1 vote for her now?
Unsure.
How do you feel about Moose's d1 vote for her now?
My mind went here too, but that would have been bold AF to swing the vote from a wolfmate to FS when FS had 0 votes and quite honestly I don't see Snowy attempting it (based on what I've seen of her wolfing it tends to be more low key)
lynch FS
Because he/she hasn't done like any analysis yet, but still has been posting (to look like participating?). Would like to hear more from them before I change my vote.
Colorado's southwest corner borders Arizona, New Mexico and Utah the only place in America where the corners of four states meet.
He hasn't posted since Day 1.
We all love last minute wafflefests, right?
Thanks for remembering better than I can.It's been EOD so far.
Also, @WildZoo I think I stated last night - but 75-85% sure of stagg. But ability has not been proven
yesCan the ability be proven?
Alright, let me get out the wheelchair. I'm ready.I think Sporty should be pushed too.
@Lawper were you PMing with Moose?
I also don't like this sudden train on me with nothing but feels.
jayna seems most wolfy to me at this point.
lynch jayna.
@CoffeeQuestionMark
Seer me tonight. Idk what MJ will flip, but I am absolutely village and am not about to go down for nothing.
Did Moose attempt to open a PM with you? Have you been PMing with anyone?Nope
A joke, whatever do you mean, it's clearly what brought me back 😉and yay, @WildZoo is back. Glad we could get 3 Dubz hats eaten even if it was a joke (and we had moose helping 😱 ). But why are you so far away? BTW I'm still waiting, twiddling my thumbs![]()
So I ate Colorado brownies last night. Did someone else mention this happening to them?
One of the other delightful things that Colorado has to offer. I'm jelly. Send me some.So I ate Colorado brownies last night. Did someone else mention this happening to them?
Did Moose attempt to open a PM with you? Have you been PMing with anyone?
@Karabiner13 did you or Moose initiate PM?
On a kind of unrelated note, was MOOSE the one who claimed to be blocked early on or was that someone else? Has there been other evidence of a blocker besides the jailer?
So final tallies color coded, but this game looks like one where lynch tracking is going to be way more useful since things have gotten crazy at the end of the day and final votes have been pretty concentrated. A project if I live long enough. Leaving D4 off for the moment. And I changed FS to orange because yellow is obnoxious. I recognize there isn't a lot here yet.
Official Final D1 Lynch Tally
Pippy (1) - FS
MJ (2) - SAR, genny
Paws (1) - kara
Sporty (1) - Moose
Coffee? () -
AM (1) - dpmd
dolphin (1) - Jayna
Kara () -
Jayna (2) - Coffee?, dolphin
genny (1) - Sporty
Stagg (1) - jboo
jboo (1) - Stagg
WZ (6) - allie, Mel, Pippy, YK,AM, Paws
FS () -
Kal(5) - Snowy, lawpy, MJ, WZ, Finski
Katashark () -
dpmd (1) - kata
Official D2 lynch tally
Mel (2) - MJ, Sporty
Jayna () -
Lawper (4) - YK, SAR, Jboo, Finski
Stagg (2) - Pippy, Kara
dolphin 23) - Snowy, Kata
jboo (2) - stagg, Coffee?
allie (5) - Jayna, Mel, Moose, AM, Lawper
Coffee? (1)-dolphin
AM (1)- dpmd
19/23
D3 Final Lynch Tally - Please check your votes!
Coffee? () -
Moose (2) - Mel, AM
Mel (1) - MJ
FS (7) - Snowy, Pippy, Kata, Moose, Lawpy, Coffee?, dpmd
Houston (1) - Stagg
Stagg (2) - Kara, Dolphin
Lawpy (1) - booJay
Kata (1) - Genny
AM (1) - Jayna
16/22
@Karabiner13 Would love to hear your thoughts on everything tomorrow. You were excessively chatty at the beginning of the game, but barely posted today. And I seem to remember you tried (halfheartedly but noteworthy) to convince people to move off a moose lynch today..
@WildZoo , thoughts?
I'm not going to answer for kata, but I want to point out that I've previously answer the bolded several times already. However, I'll clarify further and both Kata and Dolphin can confirm this through my PMs with them. If Moose had flipped village, I believed that either coffee or Mel was wolf. However, before the Coffee role reveal even happened, her and Mel were two of my top choices for wolves. So I had very little confidence in Coffee's seer claim when she started typing in all caps and role revealed. I was also skeptical because it seemed like the same tactics she used with Dolphin, and she ended up flip-flopping off of Dolphin. So I was considering a wolf who cried wolf situation where she'd just waffle again. Idk what the purpose of that would have been, but that's what it felt like to me. On top of that, I wasn't getting a wolfy read from Moose for most of the game (neither was Kara). So no, I didn't just jump up and believe that Coffee was a seer and I had a theory as to why which is now completely wrong since Moose flipped wolf.
You can ask kata to confirm all of that (and Dolphin can confirm some of that as well) in addition to their personal feels from PMs. But that's why I said I didn't think she was a wolf at the time.
Oh, Boulder. Known for being the liberal hippy town of Colorado. It kind of deserves it though, with the University of Colorado heavily influencing its culture, extensive bike paths and walking trails, and just generally being very outdoorsy. Also a great place to go if you want to try some Colorado-style baked goods. Not all was as hippy-dippy-happy as it seemed though. @dolphin106258 wandered off in the middle of the night and was found in the morning trampled to death.
Kara, I can't remember, when we agree a lot does it mean we're both village or one of us is a wolf? 😛
N4
I like that Boulder. That is a nice Boulder.
![]()
Oh, Boulder. Known for being the liberal hippy town of Colorado. It kind of deserves it though, with the University of Colorado heavily influencing its culture, extensive bike paths and walking trails, and just generally being very outdoorsy. Also a great place to go if you want to try some Colorado-style baked goods. Not all was as hippy-dippy-happy as it seemed though. @dolphin106258 wandered off in the middle of the night and was found in the morning trampled to death.
On the bright side, @Animal Midwife was found tubing down Boulder Creek, so there's that.
********************
Go to class alive come back dead. 😡 That’s super fun
********************
I have explained my reasoning from d1 voting. Clearly I was wrong, but I've explained it. Go reread the post if you want to beat that dead horse again.
Allie wasn't a villager, she was chaos, so don't try to claim I lynched a villager. Its a good thing I stayed there because we need to kill anything that isn't village.
As I stated that day, AM does a crap ton of questioning but never posts reads. It is easy for a wolf to look like they are wolf-hunting by posting questions but never sharing their thoughts, which seemed like what she was doing. Yeah, she was questioning moose, so I clearly need to go back and reevaluate my reading of her, but I still want to know what her reads are other than just seeing her asking question after question.
Re: my statement about lynching coffee if she was wrong...are you saying you wouldn't have? Pretend things didn't play out this way and she flat out says moose is a wolf, then moose flips village because we lynched on coffee's say-so. darn sure I'm lynching coffee or whoever she got bad info from...that's what happens in WW. you make bold claims without follow through you get lynched. Luckily it all played out and we got a wolf.
You're just salty I kept voting for you, but oh look, MJ was a villager. I've said for days now that I didn't think MJ was a wolf and I was right. He claimed vanillager early, which I had reason to believe was a legitimate claim. My feelings about MJ being village were stronger than a semi-vouch from kara or kata or whoever did it, so I stuck with you since I would have rather kept mj around.
What Jayna-Mel-AM-Coffee PM train? I am certainly not a part of such a PM train. I'm not even anywhere near the same group as them so how do you think I'm involved? Why tf are you trying to lump me in with them? Only person I've PMed with is genny, which I've already said on the thread. Get your facts straight.
Eh, it's believable. Not clearing or anything. It's not a role that points to a specific alignment and there have been many games where wolves have post restrictions. I don't currently have other reasons to believe snowy is a wolf.
It's been EOD so far.
every other dayEOD?
Can the ability be proven?
So when someone says to seer them my mind jumps to unseerable wolf. You've defended a lot and I've been feeling better about you but this didn't help
So I ate Colorado brownies last night. Did someone else mention this happening to them?
kara lynched pippy (1)
AM lynch MJ (1)
MOOSE lynched Paws (1)
Paws lynched sporty (1)
genny lynched paws (2)
lawp lynched coffee? (1)
SAR lynched AM (1)
Jayna lynched dolphin (1)
Pippy lynched kara (1)
Coffee? lynched Jayna (1)
Sporty lynched genny (1)
jboo lynched Stagg (1)
dolphin lynched Jayna (2)
Stagg lynched jboo (1)
Snowy lynched genny (2)
dpmd lynched AM (2)
allie lynched dubz (1)
dubz lynched froyo (1)
finski lynched paws (3)
lawp unlynched coffee? (0)
lawp lynched kal (1)
Cheezit lynched dubz (2)
Moose unlynched paws (2)
Moose lynched sporty (2)
lawper unlynched kal (0)
lawp lynched kata (1)
pippy unlynched kara (0)
pippy lynched jayna (3)
pippy unlynched jayna (2)
pippy lynched dubz (3)
kara unlynched pippy (0)
kara lynched paws (3)
paws unlynched sporty (1)
paws lynched jboo (2)
MJ lynched kara (1)
AM unlynched MJ, lynched MJ 😛 (1)
SAR unlynched AM (1)
SAR lynched MJ (2)
Kal lynched genny (3)
dubz unlynched froyo (0)
snowy unlynched genny (2)
snowy lynched kal (1)
kata lynched dpmd (1)
genny unlynched paws (2)
genny lynched MJ (3)
lawp unlynch kata (0)
lawp lynched kal (2)
froyo lynched pippy (1)
MJ unlynched kara (0)
MJ lynched kal (3)
dubz lynched sporty (2)
Kal unlynched genny (1)
Kal lynched dubz (4)
Dubz unlynched sporty (1)
Dubz lynched kal (4)
Finnski unlynched paws (1)
Finnski lynched kal (5)
AM unlynched MJ (2)
AM lynched dubz (5)
Paws unlynched jboo (1)
Paws lynched dubz (6)
lynch closed
Jayna unlynched dolphin
Jayna lynched dubz
don't pull me into it. You can think on your own and form your own opinions. Just because I thought one thing does not have any bearing on your affiliation
Sorry, but unseerable wolf sounds like a stupid power since it automatically makes someone suuuuper sketch. Has this actually happened in the past? Only time I could see this actually being valid is if you've got an unseerable wolf and unseerable village in the same game. In which case the mods basically took a huge dump on the unseerable village and potentially screwed them over completey. Overall seems really dumb. That's a good question though, @CoffeeQuestionMark why did you not seer me last night?
Yes, this has definitely happened in the past. In the Michigan game (whoops) we had a wolf who was unseerable. It doesn't necessarily make the person super sketch. It depends on how the mods have set things up. In the case of my game, the result returned left it unclear to the seer whether they'd been blocked, the target protected, or whatever. It's not like we just returned "error: this person can't be seered." Because if that were the case you're right... would instantly make them super sketch.
There can also be wolves who seer as village. Js. Within realm of possibility.
Can you clarify the bolded a bit? I'm not sure what you're saying.
There have been previous games with unreliable seer results or an additional wolf power can be being seered as village.Okay, that makes sense then. I guess I don't really know how all that works since I haven't had any contact with the mods about people taking action against me or blocking/protecting/whatevering my moves since I haven't used my ability yet. So I don't really know how that works.
Can you clarify the bolded a bit? I'm not sure what you're saying.
I've got a quick errand to run and then I want to look into someone before I make my lynch vote.
Being that I likely have limited nights left (I will assume that I'm being killed tonight) my interest is not in clearing villagers but finding a wolf.Also, because it kind of got lost in a longer post. @CoffeeQuestionMark , why didn't you seer me last night?
What? In the process of finding a wolf you will inherently clear villagers. Someone asking to be seered is normally doing so because enough people think they're a wolf.Being that I likely have limited nights left (I will assume that I'm being killed tonight) my interest is not in clearing villagers but finding a wolf.
Being that I likely have limited nights left (I will assume that I'm being killed tonight) my interest is not in clearing villagers but finding a wolf.
I have notHave you claimed a type of seer? I asked earlier, but it might have gotten lost.
Jayna can’t PM with them, she’s in a different group. Or was that your point? That her activity looked coordinated with other villagers despite not being able to PM? I am so confused by whatever you’re trying to say.What I don't like is that 3 people were were all next to each other in PM line (you-AM-Paws) all waffled after what looked like a signal from both Mel (next to Paws in PM) and the person getting lynched.
Yes, bold indicates that the vote either put them in the lead or maintained their lead.The bolded means they were leading at the time, correct?
That's how I took it. But reading back on d1 if that is what Stagg was referring to, it looks like Mel just called Jayna out because she had an earlier post that talked about being suspicious of the former me, not that he had discussed it with her behind the scenes or anything. He talked about the behind the scenes discussion with Paws and AM, not Jayna.Jayna can’t PM with them, she’s in a different group. Or was that your point? That her activity looked coordinated with other villagers despite not being able to PM? I am so confused by whatever you’re trying to say.
This makes me wonder about lawp and dpmd.Looking back at this made me feel better about Stagg, and worse about lawp.
Moose contingency lynched Coffee? (1)
Mel contingency lynched Moose (1)
kara lynched mel (1)
snowy lynched FS (1)
Stagg lynched houston (1)
Lawp lynched moose (2)
Kara unlynched mel (0)
Kara lynched stagg (1)
jboo lynched lawp (1)
AM lynched moose (3)
MJ lynched mel (1)
genny lynched kata (1)
Coffee? lynched stagg (2)
Stagg unlynched houston (0)
Stagg lynched moose (4)
Moose unlynched coffee? (0)
Moose lynched stagg (3)
Pippy lynched froyo (1)
Jayna lynched AM (1)
kata lynched froyo (2)
moose unlynched stagg (2)
moose lynched froyo (3)
lawp unlynched moose (3)
lawp lynched froyo (4)
coffee? unlnyched stagg (1)
coffee? lynched froyo (5)
dpmd lynched froyo (6)
dolphin lynched stagg (2)
Stagg unlynched moose (2)
Stagg lynched houston (1)
-lynch closed-
Yeah. You're much more likely to land on a villager than a wolf anyway. Depends on how you approach seering but I tend to ignore the people who are likely to be lynched, because honestly it's better to just test them through lynching, and go for people who are likely to live a while. But there are various ways to go about it. I don't even always seer the people who I am most suspicious of. Being outted changes the strategy a bit, but I'm also wary of seering anyone who explicitly asks to be seered lolWhat? In the process of finding a wolf you will inherently clear villagers. Someone asking to be seered is normally doing so because enough people think they're a wolf.
I came across this in passing and was curious why you didn't have this same reaction to the allie lynchlol everyone piling onto the zero poster who will probably flip village
good ****