WW: Mysterious Planet Official Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Thank you!!!! I remembered 7 but couldn't remember if it was 7 my time or DVMdream's time! Off to walk the pooch then 🙂

C'mon PP! I wanna have my lynch ready when I get back 😀
 
Just waiting for you to go back and read the PM and see what it actually said. How come you can post but not read PM's?
 
Well I gotta go. We still have a few hours right? I'll answer when I get back. I'm about to get in trouble here for being on my phone
 
Wouldn't you know the name of your creature?

I get like a camera stand when I looked up monopod
 
PetPony said:
Because I'm on my phone. I can't see all of my PMs.
Click to expand...

All of your PMS? :eyebrow: Correct me if I'm wrong, because I'm new here, but if it was just the night before, wouldn't it be a fairly new PM? Unless you've gotten a bunch since then...:meanie:
 
BTW, krist is cooking dinner and this is killing her not to be able to talk about it :laugh:
 
Finally caught up on the thread for the first time all day!

I don't think PetPony's all that suspicious, actually. A lot of the suspicion is from wolfspeaker, right? But I thought her defense that she was just trying to help noobs was reasonable.

So I'm going with someone I'm more suspicious of for now: lynch FTB
 
Official Vote Tally:

PetPony 7 (heylodeb, dyachei, mrskrist, emiloo, wildcatj, TW, nohika)

FTB 1 (equineconstant)

Waffle meter: 1

Deadline is 7PM PST

C'mon peeps. Lynch some people!!!! You've got less than 3 hours.
 
Lissarae06 said:
You should rub it in that you aren't silenced :meanie:
Click to expand...

Oh I am, I keep calling her over here to read everything and then she just gets frustrated and leaves...back to the kitchen honey! :meanie:
 
A monopod, a monopod...
An interesting choice by the mod god
Are you neutral good or bad
We don't know and it makes us sad.
Tell us now where your allegience lies
Or the be prepared for mournful cries
 
equineconstant said:
Finally caught up on the thread for the first time all day!

I don't think PetPony's all that suspicious, actually. A lot of the suspicion is from wolfspeaker, right? But I thought her defense that she was just trying to help noobs was reasonable.

So I'm going with someone I'm more suspicious of for now: lynch FTB
Click to expand...

I personally am suspicious of her because she was stopped from performing a night activity because krist used a plant that sets a trap for the person if they leave their house at night, and then PP was silenced, and no one died. I wasn't really paying attention before today, but I know krist has been very suspicious of her from the first day, I think she even sent that in a group PM a while back. And then she isn't really defending herself, and then the part about how she can't see all of her messages in this whole Petpony being attacked debacle.
 
Alright. Time to reveal a truth.

Someone (could be me, could be another leader, could be anyone, could be someone from my group) blocked pp's action on the first night of no kills. Wasn't quite sure if it meant anything but didn't want to mention it until something more suspicious came up. This is getting more suspicious.

My vote stands.
 
Your villager role is mighty phony,

I vote now to lynch petpony
 
Mod will not close out day until the end of the lynch cycle (at 7PM PST). I am going to give PP every opportunity to defend herself..

Remember: People have REAL LIVES to attend to and can not be on here 24/7. 🙂
 
nyanko said:
That's pretty good info, TW.
Click to expand...

👍 Alright PP, time to come out with the truth about who you are. I've been suspicious since you tried to protect WS from lynching. The info from TW and MrsKrist are just too much to ignore at this point. So...

lynch PetPony

I'll check back after dinner for any updates.
 
TigerWillow said:
Alright. Time to reveal a truth.

Someone (could be me, could be another leader, could be anyone, could be someone from my group) blocked pp's action on the first night of no kills. Wasn't quite sure if it meant anything but didn't want to mention it until something more suspicious came up. This is getting more suspicious.

My vote stands.
Click to expand...

Was anyone else's action blocked at that time?

In the meantime, lynch petpony, unless the answer to the above is yes
 
Official Vote Tally:

PetPony 12 (heylodeb, dyachei, mrskrist, emiloo, wildcatj, TW, nohika, Lissa, Jamr0ckin, nyanko, Philliab, WTF)

FTB 1 (equineconstant)

Waffle meter: 1

Deadline is 7PM PST.
 
TigerWillow said:
Someone (could be me, could be another leader, could be anyone, could be someone from my group) blocked pp's action on the first night of no kills. Wasn't quite sure if it meant anything but didn't want to mention it until something more suspicious came up. This is getting more suspicious.
Click to expand...
That is suspicious. Of course, with so many players it's possible that her actions being blocked have nothing to do with no kills. Anyway.

Lynch PetPony.

For now, at least. Off to see if I can validate something I just thought of...
 
Official Vote Tally:

PetPony 16 (heylodeb, dyachei, mrskrist, emiloo, wildcatj, TW, nohika, Lissa, Jamr0ckin, nyanko, Philliab, WTF, swampdog, HoH, cuitl, devyn)

FTB 1 (equineconstant)

Waffle meter: 1

Deadline is 7PM PST.
 
Last edited:
Ok... with the blocked night 1 action, the silencing thing, and PP not fully defending herself... for now

lynch PP

I will keep checking back, but working on a project and also procrastinating at the same time...:laugh: and the deadline is at 3 AM my time - I may try to actually go to bed at a decent hour tonight. 🙄
 
**********************************
:corny::corny::meanie::meanie::meanie::roflcopter:
*******************************
 
mrskrist said:
BTW, krist is cooking dinner and this is killing her not to be able to talk about it :laugh:
Click to expand...

Tell her to cook something with GREENS and post in the cooking challenge thread. 🙂 And just for fun tell us what she's cooking for dinner now. ...'Cause I'm nosey. And love food. And love cooking.....

WhtsThFrequency said:
Holy crap HoH, I completely forgot you were playing....:laugh:
Click to expand...

Wow, I did, too.
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
Was anyone else's action blocked at that time?

In the meantime, lynch petpony, unless the answer to the above is yes
Click to expand...


I feel like people aren't really going to come forward with this for fear of giving too much away, although I'm sure many people, if not everyone, has night time actions.


Also, It wasn't so much her defense of WS that got my suspicion, although I did make a note of it, but more her back and forth saying she didn't know what attacked her, and then claiming it was this possible jackalope in the post. And then I think she even went back to saying she just assumed that bit was about her but didn't really know.

And then not knowing what her role name is is kind of suspicious too. I could understand not remembering how to spell it or something like that, but to present your role in a way that make it sound like your a bit unsure of what it actually is called, doesn't sit well with me.

For now Lynch PP
 
abbercadaver said:
Tell her to cook something with GREENS and post in the cooking challenge thread. 🙂 And just for fun tell us what she's cooking for dinner now. ...'Cause I'm nosey. And love food. And love cooking.....

haha tonight she made oven baked chicken fingers and panera's mac and cheese, and for dessert we are having frozen smores 🙂 all recipes from pinterest of course! 👍
Click to expand...
 
I'm casting my vote for lynching PP right now....because it's the best to go on. But if she comes back and explains, then I'll change. 🙂 I just don't want to miss the vote since I'm drinking in a different time zone....haha.
 
Pony, Pony, Little Pony
How I wonder what you are!
I have no ideas oh my, oh my
Now I lynch thee and hope not to cry


😳
 
abbercadaver said:
Tell her to cook something with GREENS and post in the cooking challenge thread. 🙂 And just for fun tell us what she's cooking for dinner now. ...'Cause I'm nosey. And love food. And love cooking.....
Click to expand...

:nod: me too! Although I have royally sucked these past few weeks at cooking and posting on the thread. Just ask the BF, I haven't made a meal in weeks! Working 2nd shift makes it weird though.
 
I am going to have to go with Lynch PP considering no other information available at this point (that I can see), and after reading about the Monopods I can't see how they can be a benevolent creature based on their description (being normal dwarfs initially and then being punished and turning themselves invisible). I would say at the least, it's a neutral role...IMO anyway.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
For now, at least. Off to see if I can validate something I just thought of...
Click to expand...
Okay, so my thought was that wolf kills are tied to the planet's appearance (I think someone mentioned this earlier?) -- i.e. wolf X can only kill when the planet is desert-like in appearance. So the lack of kills could be due to the fact that we killed a specific wolf.

Anyway, the planet was forest-like in appearance the first no-kill night and it was tundra-like in appearance last night. If PP's actions being blocked are directly responsible for the lack of kills then this theory falls apart. If we look at the dead confirmed wolves next -- I'd guess that kakuru (Kulshedra, dragon) could only kill when the planet is desert-like and that wolfspeaker (Water Leaper, amphibious creature) could only kill when it is swamp-like (could maybe argue forest-like). The planet was forest-like in appearance the first night there were no kills and it was tundra-like last night. So I don't think there's much support for my theory with this info. On the other hand, we know that IPB was killed by kakuru, and the planet was desert-like in appearance that night.

Anyone care to comment or pick the theory apart? Hopefully that all makes sense.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Okay, so my thought was that wolf kills are tied to the planet's appearance (I think someone mentioned this earlier?) -- i.e. wolf X can only kill when the planet is desert-like in appearance. So the lack of kills could be due to the fact that we killed a specific wolf.

Anyway, the planet was forest-like in appearance the first no-kill night and it was tundra-like in appearance last night. If PP's actions being blocked are directly responsible for the lack of kills then this theory falls apart. If we look at the dead confirmed wolves next -- I'd guess that kakuru (Kulshedra, dragon) could only kill when the planet is desert-like and that wolfspeaker (Water Leaper, amphibious creature) could only kill when it is swamp-like (could maybe argue forest-like). The planet was forest-like in appearance the first night there were no kills and it was tundra-like last night. So I don't think there's much support for my theory with this info. On the other hand, we know that IPB was killed by kakuru, and the planet was desert-like in appearance that night.

Anyone care to comment or pick the theory apart? Hopefully that all makes sense.
Click to expand...

I like this theory!
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Okay, so my thought was that wolf kills are tied to the planet's appearance (I think someone mentioned this earlier?) -- i.e. wolf X can only kill when the planet is desert-like in appearance. So the lack of kills could be due to the fact that we killed a specific wolf.

Anyway, the planet was forest-like in appearance the first no-kill night and it was tundra-like in appearance last night. If PP's actions being blocked are directly responsible for the lack of kills then this theory falls apart. If we look at the dead confirmed wolves next -- I'd guess that kakuru (Kulshedra, dragon) could only kill when the planet is desert-like and that wolfspeaker (Water Leaper, amphibious creature) could only kill when it is swamp-like (could maybe argue forest-like). The planet was forest-like in appearance the first night there were no kills and it was tundra-like last night. So I don't think there's much support for my theory with this info. On the other hand, we know that IPB was killed by kakuru, and the planet was desert-like in appearance that night.

Anyone care to comment or pick the theory apart? Hopefully that all makes sense.
Click to expand...

It does. I was actually beginning to think this also was a possibility.
 
Poor little SnS. She has to come up with rhymes to respond to my pms
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
40K
katiemcat
katiemcat
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
54K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
39K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5
Replies
249
Views
16K
katiemcat
katiemcat
Top