A Lighthouse, A Man, A City...A BioShock WW Game

[Lupin21]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Overexplainy. Which is in the please wolf meta.

Cray, do you think please has rounded out of this early read?

 

[supershorty]

@pawprintsandponytails has a trend of only posting on the second IRL day of the Game Day, it's happened at least twice in this game, but I really hope we hear more from her today.

I'm looking back at pawprints' posts again because I wanted to see if we've usually started to hear from her by this point of the Game Day, and this might not be accurate. Threadloom is doing the same thing that it did when I was looking at katashark's posts earlier, where it shows the wrong date on the search results page and the correct one on the actual post. Just wanted to make a note of that while I look.

 

[Lawpy]

And we're reverse

 

[Lupin21]

I love goats. especially baby ones. Kids are so cute!




Hey! I'm not that chaotic. What do you mean by "suspicious amount of thread knowledge"? I was village that game. Since I was village that game your reasoning for voting me because of how I played previously is kind of flawed. You're obviously not aiming for a wolf.




Awwww! Just like old times



There are times when AM doesn't vote me off the bat. She eventually gets there if I don't post enough to please her after a certain point.



Bussing a wolf D1, especially AM kinda seems crazy (for lack of a better word)



I'm reading through the thread and catching up. Chill

I like this reply to zenge and calling him out for MsP. Don't think that is coming from w/w

 

[Lawpy]

presses votecount button

 

[samac]

I like this reply to zenge and calling him out for MsP. Don't think that is coming from w/w

I also like that Ms. P has had wolf reads on alley and Cyndia.
her excitement after the reveal felt genuine.

 

[LetItSnow]

Honestly, emotionally I want to vote Chaos, but I'm wrestling with whether that's just retaliatory annoyance on my part for how hard he came at me vs how much I truly think Chaos might be a wolf.

The pleasy thing ... I don't know that I've ever really understood it.

Won't vote Lupin, unless someone convinces me she's a convert. I'm about as confident she started village as I am anyone did.

Obviously I've pushed on kata/samac all game, but I'm having trouble with it now because samac was villy in PMs to me. Might just be stellar PM play, but... it's giving me pause.

I've committed mentally to Trilt being villager.

Cray, AM, and Supes all seem to be working way too hard to be wolfy. Whichever of them is a wolf, if any, is doing a fantastic job.

Who am I forgetting?

 

[Lawpy]

Day 6: If You Don't Draw First, You Don't Get To Draw At All Vote Tally

samac (3) - vetschoolsplz, Barks, supershorty
Chaostrodon ()
Trilt (2) - AM, Lawpy
pawprints (2) - Trilt, Lupin
Lawpy (1) - samac

8/15

Missing: many

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/12/21 (~7 hours)

This is a recent tally i found

Trouts vs pawprints is W/V but i'm getting more concerned about pawprints when i read her posts.

 

[Lawpy]

Honestly, emotionally I want to vote Chaos, but I'm wrestling with whether that's just retaliatory annoyance on my part for how hard he came at me vs how much I truly think Chaos might be a wolf.

The pleasy thing ... I don't know that I've ever really understood it.

Won't vote Lupin, unless someone convinces me she's a convert. I'm about as confident she started village as I am anyone did.

Obviously I've pushed on kata/samac all game, but I'm having trouble with it now because samac was villy in PMs to me. Might just be stellar PM play, but... it's giving me pause.

I've committed mentally to Trilt being villager.

Cray, AM, and Supes all seem to be working way too hard to be wolfy. Whichever of them is a wolf, if any, is doing a fantastic job.

Who am I forgetting?

Who is Supes?

 

[LetItSnow]

And by pleasy I meant pawprints.

 

[LetItSnow]

Who is Supes?

Supershorty, sorry.

 

[samac]

Alleycat is reacting to my posts and I don’t like it.
I don’t know if she’s trying to make me look wolfy or what but I feel a little weird about it.

 

[supershorty]

Alleycat is reacting to my posts and I don’t like it.
I don’t know if she’s trying to make me look wolfy or what but I feel a little weird about it.

She's reacting right now?
Aren't dead people not supposed to react to posts?

 

[Lupin21]

This game may give Navs Unknown WW vibes for me given the video game theme. And that makes me terrified of Trouts

Day1 you were very focused on Trilt before she even posted, and you are still on her, so did you ever have her as a village read?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Alleycat is reacting to my posts and I don’t like it.
I don’t know if she’s trying to make me look wolfy or what but I feel a little weird about it.

If it's content posts, she really shouldn't be regardless because she's dead.

 

[supershorty]

And by pleasy I meant pawprints.

How do you feel about please?

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

She's reacting right now?
Aren't dead people not supposed to react to posts?

They're not supposed to

 

[Animal Midwife]

Honestly, emotionally I want to vote Chaos, but I'm wrestling with whether that's just retaliatory annoyance on my part for how hard he came at me vs how much I truly think Chaos might be a wolf.

The pleasy thing ... I don't know that I've ever really understood it.

Won't vote Lupin, unless someone convinces me she's a convert. I'm about as confident she started village as I am anyone did.

Obviously I've pushed on kata/samac all game, but I'm having trouble with it now because samac was villy in PMs to me. Might just be stellar PM play, but... it's giving me pause.

I've committed mentally to Trilt being villager.

Cray, AM, and Supes all seem to be working way too hard to be wolfy. Whichever of them is a wolf, if any, is doing a fantastic job.

Who am I forgetting?

jboo, Barks, mayo, please, and MsP.

 

[Trilt]

There have been enough small things from Chaos (beyond the derpclear) that I genuinely don't think he's a wolf. Small things about mechanics and about money that I would be surprised to be faked/not discussed in wolf chat.

Do you have any actual questions for me, AM? I actually have a minute right now in my shift.

 

[supershorty]

Unyeet samac

samac's seeming much more villagey to me today than kata ever did.

 

[LetItSnow]

How do you feel about please?

I don't.

Neutral.

 

[Lupin21]

I mean honestly her antivillage play from last time i played w her makes me want to autoyeet her regardless of affiliation. Antivillage is still hurting the village, no matter who's doing it. I may move my vote from joke Shorty to real MsP depending on how the next day goes
After catching up: I think that in the last page she's sounded a lot more provillage than what I saw before. I'm still wary but I'll hold off voting there for now

seeing the quotes all together doesn't make me feel great

Interesting comment when you were wolfing the last time you played with her, and her misyeet was to your advantage.

I like this in regards to shorty though and please in regards to MsP. Still looking hard at please right now for both this read on MsP and being one of the ones trying to make me out wolfy for the april town read.

 

[samac]

She's reacting right now?
Aren't dead people not supposed to react to posts?

It was this one. She probably just wasn’t thinking but because she’s a wolf it makes me feel weird.

dude why would I fake that stupid ass restriction and then remove it off myself to draw attention to myself?

I started the game that morning, explained what kind of notification I got, I was working at night close and at first found it hilarious and was looking forward to it because it kind of sounded like fun.
I quickly became frustrated. That’s when I remembered Kata bought a first aid kit and went back to read the description. Asked the mods, had to wait for a response, then they asked me if I wanted to use it during rounds, responded after rounds and waited until the message for them to say I’m clear before I started posting here.

if it would have been something I bought I would have been vigilant of it from the start, but coming in as a sub or just took me a minute to even make the connection.

 

[LetItSnow]

jboo, Barks, mayo, please, and MsP.

How the hell do you do that?

MsP is low-volume compared to some, but the content reads well to me.

Please neutral.

Jboo, Barks, Mayo ... meh.

I guess it's clear why I forgot those 5.

 

[Animal Midwife]

There have been enough small things from Chaos (beyond the derpclear) that I genuinely don't think he's a wolf. Small things about mechanics and about money that I would be surprised to be faked/not discussed in wolf chat.

Do you have any actual questions for me, AM? I actually have a minute right now in my shift.

If I can think of some, I'll let you know. I'm just in a place where everyone else is so villagey that I feel stuck in my POE with little room left for movement.

 

[Lupin21]

I've gotten wolfy pings so far from the following:

alissa: the super rapid vote switch was weird. I've also thought it's weird that she's continued kind of poking at AM, but leaving her vote on LIS. The majority of her posts so far have been fluff and not content.

pleasy: again, very slight pings because she has felt overexplainy, and as Cray mentioned, that was part of her meta when she was wolfing. Because I misread wolf!pleasy, I might be putting too much stock on the overexplainy feeling, and I'm not comfortable putting a vote on her right now, but I made a note of it.

April and genny both defending pleasy felt a little odd to me especially given that both of them were wolfing with her in basics, but RNG makes it unlikely that all 3 of them are wolfing together again. But I gave it a light red on my spreadsheet.

Dina is still pinging me with her posts, particularly with the misremembering things, but I also thought it was an odd comment to say that calling out quiet players early is wolfy. However, I have stronger weird vibes from alissa right now.

I'm going to put my tentative village reads in another post because I know people don't like wall posts and I'm trying to be better about not making them.

hmmm. haha

Just laughing a bit. Still looking at please though, so maybe you're onto one!

 

[alleycat03]

It was this one. She probably just wasn’t thinking but because she’s a wolf it makes me feel weird.

*****
I only care reacted because it sounded like you had a long day and seemed stressed. The dead just cannot react to strategy posts. Wasn’t trying to start anything or get in trouble.
*****

 

[LetItSnow]

lynch mayo... just picking from my list of meh.

But I'm ok with chaos. I can sorta live with samac. I just think maybe I made an early-game mistake with kata. I tend to tunnel, I know that.

Not thrilled with a Trilt lynch, although it is getting to be that time. ;-)

Won't vote Lupes unless I can be convinced she was converted somewhere in there.

If it comes to saving Trilt I'll jump to paws or, if necessary, samac.

 

[LetItSnow]

Oh. Lawpy is the other one with a vote, not Lupes. (My prev post was meant to give my thoughts on current lynch tally.)

Um. Don't care. 10/10 would let Lawpy get lynched.

 

[supershorty]

hmmm. haha

Just laughing a bit. Still looking at please though, so maybe you're onto one!

If I've had one consistency in my games so far, it's that my day 1 reads are often trash 🙁

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Yeet Paws

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

just starting back at d1, I have some reservations about the reacts on this. Would zenge react wow to this for any reason you can think of, shorty? alley also liked it, so two wolves responding to this vote is odd.

alley liked it bc I literally mentioned her in it
Idk abt z ¯\_(シ)_/¯

Still looking hard at please right now for both this read on MsP and being one of the ones trying to make me out wolfy for the april town read.

Yo I dropped that a long time ago, you’re in the village reads now lol

 

[sunshinefl]

presses votecount button

************
FYI the mods hate this
************

 

[Lupin21]

alley liked it bc I literally mentioned her in it
Idk abt z ¯\_(シ)_/¯

Yo I dropped that a long time ago, you’re in the village reads now lol

I am looking at d1 for things that people weren't being careful about yet. Best place to find some hidden clues

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

Idk what’s been going on today and I still haven’t even started my midterm so I don’t want to stay on a pressure vote

Unyeet samac
Yeet paws

Still don’t want her at endgame w this play. I’m hoping to do some serious ww’ing tomorrow night I just really really can’t today

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

That’s fair

I am looking at d1 for things that people weren't being careful about yet. Best place to find some hidden clues

 

[Lupin21]

At the moment, yes.

I thought his initial post voting for MsP was kind of unnecessarily wordy, and I gave it a red box on my spreadsheet, but I do understand the logic behind it, and since he's now pulled his vote on her, it does seem like it was the pressure vote he claimed it was.

Rodney dangerfield adjusting neck tie here. lol

I tried to be selective while pulling quotes to not overwhelm you guys and also to participate in current game state.


well I'm not looking to punish play styles, i'm looking for wolves. if someone is sus/??? and we don't have better suspects sure.

exactly

this is weird to me because it was early and lawny hadn't done anything special



I agree with shorty here. I put please village the time before last game because she sounded like herself, but she was a wolf. I have no read on her yet here but i think it's misguided to clear her based on tone because she was almost exactly the same.

I thought that too from WW lately but she was (mostly) fun playing live on thursday and saturday

also not sure why this point had so much traction and i kinda stopped reading anything about it.

Re: bolded, wolves can throw shade on villagers easily by finding a weak point. i don't think barks can get too much cred for this. Not saying barks is a wolf, but a wolf would want to look like they are doing something AND throw suspicion off the pack.

Me too. (Also I've never played with you before Lupin but so far you make a lot of sense to me in general game approach. Not sure if AI or just play style agreement.)

Sun also noted that please doesn't have a tell for wolf vs village.

Please, is there something in your play that you feel is a good tell for either side?

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

Please, is there something in your play that you feel is a good tell for either side?

As a woof I tried really hard not to change my tone at all and it’s biting me in the butt now lol

but as w wolf I was also MUCH more careful about what I said and how I said it. So much so that I didn’t even cast a joke vote bc I didn’t want it to be analyzed
i was also more scared about sus’ing anyone bc I knew it was all wrong and a lie lol

 

[supershorty]

It was this one. She probably just wasn’t thinking but because she’s a wolf it makes me feel weird.

You know what's weird, I'm looking back at when I started posting ISOs and both alley and Cyndia liked my ISO of Zenge, where my tl;dr said I'd gone from village side of neutral to wolfy side of neutral on him. But neither of them liked my ISO of please or alley.

 

[Trilt]

If I can think of some, I'll let you know. I'm just in a place where everyone else is so villagey that I feel stuck in my POE with little room left for movement.

well that kind of sucks from my perspective, lol.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 6: If You Don't Draw First, You Don't Get To Draw At All Vote Tally

samac (1) - Barks
chaos (1) - Cray
Trilt (2) - AM, Lawpy
pawprints (4) - Trilt, Lupin, MsP, please
Lawpy () -
mayo (1) - LIS

10/15

Missing: many

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/12/21 (~2.5 hours)

 

[Lupin21]

As a woof I tried really hard not to change my tone at all and it’s biting me in the butt now lol

but as w wolf I was also MUCH more careful about what I said and how I said it. So much so that I didn’t even cast a joke vote bc I didn’t want it to be analyzed
i was also more scared about sus’ing anyone bc I knew it was all wrong and a lie lol

what do you think is the best reason to read you town for this game so far?

 

[Animal Midwife]

well that kind of sucks from my perspective, lol.

I know. I just can't figure out how to further evaluate without another flip from at least one in my POE.

 

[Lupin21]

i think this could be a good point. I think it might be w/w or w/v but honestly i don't have a feeling either way for which is wolf or village. April doesn't super sound like wolf!April to me and I only spectated on wolf!AM game. However, I am noticing that what April is saying is making sense to me and I'm not getting what AM's not getting. So I guess thats.. slight lean more towards AM? I think its too early to tell but I wanna keep eyes on both of their interactions

Plus, I'd say this sounds pretty careful. hehe

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

what do you think is the best reason to read you town for this game so far?

I've voted 2 wolves, and things get hairy considering the z vote but i really tried to show my progression of logic on the thread and from my (admittedly biased) perspective we dont read w/w
ill give it to anyone that alley and i dont exactly read w/v until she died but i was on the alley vote while there was still hope to save her from yeet

 

[kaydubs]

Day 6: If You Don't Draw First, You Don't Get To Draw At All Vote Tally

samac (1) - Barks
Chaostrodon (1) - Cray
Trilt (2) - AM, Lawpy
pawprints (4) - Trilt, Lupin, MsP, vetschoolsplz
Lawpy ()
mayo (1) - LIS

9/15

in danger: @pawprintsandponytails

Missing: @samac @supershorty @holdthemayo @pawprintsandponytails @jaboo @Chaostrodon

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/12/21 (~2.5 hours)

 

[Lawpy]

Day1 you were very focused on Trilt before she even posted, and you are still on her, so did you ever have her as a village read?

No not really. At best she was neutral

 

[Lawpy]

lynch mayo... just picking from my list of meh.

But I'm ok with chaos. I can sorta live with samac. I just think maybe I made an early-game mistake with kata. I tend to tunnel, I know that.

Not thrilled with a Trilt lynch, although it is getting to be that time. ;-)

Won't vote Lupes unless I can be convinced she was converted somewhere in there.

If it comes to saving Trilt I'll jump to paws or, if necessary, samac.

What makes Trouts so village?

 

[Lupin21]

I still don’t understand how you could see what Jaboo did as anything other than an attack trying to throw shade on me. Like, yes, I was here at yeet close, with everyone else. I was eating dinner, and I didn’t feel like I had a lot to contribute. It was hard enough just to stay up to date with how fast the thread was expanding. But it was only me who was singled out for being here and “lurking in the shadows” That’s an attack.

Im sorry if saying you were being obtuse was over the line, but it genuinely felt like you were stone walling by refusing to acknowledge how that’s perceived as an attack, and how you piling on for something so innocuous was adding fuel to the fire.

Well, I'd say the z vote has so little village cred as he did his very best to pretend, considering he replied to a person known to him to have been killed and obviously knew he'd been seered. I'd almost say I'm most suspicious of people who voted him prior to Dina outing him.

 

[Lawpy]

************
FYI the mods hate this
************

But i didn't know 🙁