- Joined
- Jan 7, 2014
- Messages
- 4,597
- Reaction score
- 4,440
Ah, if that's what the "." was, hmmm.my guess is his role has to do with time travel. He doesn't play until that white dragon goes back in time to interact with him.
Ah, if that's what the "." was, hmmm.my guess is his role has to do with time travel. He doesn't play until that white dragon goes back in time to interact with him.
I believe it was the timing of the block that indicated a wolfyness.Why so sure that blocking is wolfy? Blocking can also be protective. It all depends on who is wielding it right?
That Thread shutter thing sounds like a protective measure to me, for instance. It seemed to keep out the ability thief, which sounds like a positive thing to me. And if Thread had been coming down, that could be a great thing.
Any reasons for the deva lynch? I haven't seen anything wolfy there, myself. But I'd love to hear if there is something I've missed.
So if one of these is your blocker and you think you have ruled out Dy, STL and FFM.Fort Hold
dyachei
Gwenevre
vetmedhead
BeautifulBritishColumbia
Flim Flam Man
SummerTheLynx
I thought she said it had to be someone outside her group because the shutters stopped outside actions from coming in, so everyone in her group would be clear but all outside would be potential suspects.So again, I'm operating under the idea that ability stealing is wolfy. Blocking, eh...it seems like in a lot for games there have been both wolf and village blockers, so I'm not as concerned about that, although it still might be worth pursuing. PBC was targeted for ability stealing last night. She claims that no one in her group knew they would be shuttered, and everyone in her group knew that she was not tithing. So, if a wolf thought she had an important ability and that's why she wasn't tithing, they or another wolf may have attempted to steal it, not knowing it wouldn't be possible. I picked deva because she is in PBCs group and already had a vote (I don't think a bunch of people with 1 vote each is helpful, as it doesn't pressure anyone to talk).
I think it makes sense for the ability thief to be outside the group because of the shutters. However, if the ability thief is a wolf that can talk to other wolves - there would likely be one in the group that would have just said in the group wolf chat who was tithing in their groupI thought she said it had to be someone outside her group because the shutters stopped outside actions from coming in, so everyone in her group would be clear but all outside would be potential suspects.
We've had people in our group mention receiving a tithe and being able to use that ability immediately.I like all the theories on tithing. I guess I was a bit attached to the idea that they were being distributed to players currently. But if they are being used basically as a "Hold effect" and which abilities are offered as tithes matter, or even if they are being banked for later, both change my ideas as to who it is good to get to tithe and when.
I would love to figure this whole thing out sooner rather than later so we can most efficiency figure out what to do with tithe rotations and all that.
Edited to add a word as underlined.
He's been pretty chatty in our group. You are right that hia thread posting is way down though. Do with that as you will, I refuse to let anyone even try to trust my affiliation judgments on MJ.Not sure I would go as far as put a lynch vote for this reason, but is it only me that has noticed MJ is posting way less than usual? He's only posted 2 times since the game started, and one of those was a plain lynch vote.
The other games I have played with him have been an onslaught of posts
I feel like there are a few people that normally talk considerably more that haven't really been present. That was why my discussion with Lupin about the 2 games earlier. But if that isn't the reason. I wonder why.
Anything specific you can point to? I'm seeing that she hasnt posted much on the thread and I'm not entirely against lynching quiet players but i feel like we hardly ever find wolves in that group.Lynch AM
Of the people in my hold and the interactions we've had in our pm thread, I think AM would be most likely to be a wolf. I'll put my vote there.
Oh, my agreement was with the entirety of that post 😉Also @WildZoo , I thought you were agreeing with LIS that I'm sexy when I'm angry.![]()
For the thief him/herself yes, but a wolf in her group could have told the thief she wasn't tithing, and wouldn't have known about the shutters.I thought she said it had to be someone outside her group because the shutters stopped outside actions from coming in, so everyone in her group would be clear but all outside would be potential suspects.
I thought she said it had to be someone outside her group because the shutters stopped outside actions from coming in, so everyone in her group would be clear but all outside would be potential suspects.
Actually, I saw in my notes that SOV was also previously blocked N1. If that is the same person that blocked dy, I have my doubts that it is a Fort person and may simply be targeting players who have proven dangerous. Not necessarily that they had intent specifically on info from a group PM.I am interested in figuring out who the blocker in our group is. It may lead nowhere, but it's a line of investigation that I feel more comfortable with than "this person is too quiet". I'm open to waffling if anyone has a particularly strong feeling about anyone else.
Lynch BBC.
So is your group where all tithes go? Or just those from your group? Or, does it match the other theory that they seem to be all mixed up and randomly distributed?We've had people in our group mention receiving a tithe and be
I'm really sorry guys. Icu is ****ing insane. I just called in the on call student. I happen to have a small lull while I'm waiting for radiographs.I am interested in figuring out who the blocker in our group is. It may lead nowhere, but it's a line of investigation that I feel more comfortable with than "this person is too quiet". I'm open to waffling if anyone has a particularly strong feeling about anyone else.
Lynch BBC.
Actually, I saw in my notes that SOV was also previously blocked N1. If that is the same person that blocked dy, I have my doubts that it is a Fort person and may simply be targeting players who have proven dangerous. Not necessarily that they had intent specifically on info from a group PM.
I don't mind the probable shock for bbc that she is next in line for lynch along with @katashark , but for now
Unlynch BBC
My current assumption is that tithes go to any players who are in the weyrs. I doubt they would be particularly talkative about it, as it could make them good candidates for wolf kills.So is your group where all tithes go? Or just those from your group? Or, does it match the other theory that they seem to be all mixed up and randomly distributed?
It's okay!I have not read the thread. We're slammed. Calling in the back-up. I probably won't
I'm really sorry guys. Icu is ****ing insane. I just called in the on call student. I happen to have a small lull while I'm waiting for radiographs.
It wasn't so much that she was quiet, it was the complete disregard for people voting/being suspicious of her.
Again I only skimmed the thread super fast so I'm sorry if I missed kata poking her head in.
I am not this person and i have no idea who the ability stealer is but it is NOT historically a wolf role. It has been occasionally, but mostly a villager role. @DocEspana probably has a lot to say about the role because he was the first to include it I believe (and yours truly received it... and boy was JDH pissed when i stole his investigation role permanently ..... @Lissarae06 , good times right!).So again, I'm operating under the idea that ability stealing is wolfy.
it could be a wolf role in this game, just saying your assumption is wrong on the face.I am not this person and i have no idea who the ability stealer is but it is NOT historically a wolf role. It has been occasionally, but mostly a villager role. @DocEspana probably has a lot to say about the role because he was the first to include it I believe (and yours truly received it... and boy was JDH pissed when i stole his investigation role permanently ..... @Lissarae06 , good times right!).
Thank god, someone made a lynch tally!"Check your Votes I'm SOVing this Bitch" Lynch Tally
kata 5 (Kam, Abney, Sandy, Hmufasa, STB)
lotf 1 (Dy)
BBC 2 (FFM, LotF)
FFM 1 (SOV)
AM 1 (PBC)
MJ 1 (Promo)
Deva 1 (MJ)
12/25 votes
I'd actually like to lynch someone in telgar since Guis was supposedly attacked.
Lynch MQ
I agree with this, which is why I voted for someone from telgar yesterday. Now that MQ is dead and was the protector, I wonder if they assumed since Guis was protected that someone in telgar was also likely the protector.
I am not this person and i have no idea who the ability stealer is but it is NOT historically a wolf role. It has been occasionally, but mostly a villager role. @DocEspana probably has a lot to say about the role because he was the first to include it I believe (and yours truly received it... and boy was JDH pissed when i stole his investigation role permanently ..... @Lissarae06 , good times right!).
I had it in SOV's survive alive game. That was a good time. lolInteresting, I never knew that ability stealing roles were historically villager roles.
Also I am fairly sure Kata is a villager. I can't officially vouch for her or anything, but I would be very surprise if she was a wolf
Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
it could be a wolf role in this game, just saying your assumption is wrong on the face.