Friends WW Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Wait... this is not fair. Everything I said about Nav the day I lynched him was raw. I was just talking about the different ways I was thinking about it. If that is wolfy, I guess that I should learn to do it in my PMs. By myself. Because I am Carol, Ross's ex-wife, the vanillager. Another reason I brought Navi/Susan back is because I thought it was funny that I accidentally lynched my wife.
How is it not fair? You did say multiple times that day that you wanted to see what he had to say without a post restriction and then voted him anyway.

That is funny though lol
 
@mizchiefmanaged to clarify, how do you feel about petmoosy and dolphino?
MPM has read pretty village to me. Dolphin seems to be playing a bit differently to me than in her last village game, but there’s nothing that’s really jumped out at me dramatically. Maybe on the lower sketchy side. Homemade pasta is nearly done cooking and then I should have some time to ISO. Between MPM and dolphin I would vote for dolphin, however would still go for mutts or possibly cubs above that.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
How is it not fair? You did say multiple times that day that you wanted to see what he had to say without a post restriction and then voted him anyway.

That is funny though lol
It was just what I felt needed to happen that day. I was hesitant on who to trust what with the mutts vs navi vs moose situation I had going on in my feels that day. Then, when mutts and cubby said the things, I felt less like voting mutts, who was my next wolfy leader, and didn't want to vote moose that day because I thought she had an injury/restriction or something of the sort
 
MPM has read pretty village to me. Dolphin seems to be playing a bit differently to me than in her last village game, but there’s nothing that’s really jumped out at me dramatically. Maybe on the lower sketchy side. Homemade pasta is nearly done cooking and then I should have some time to ISO. Between MPM and dolphin I would vote for dolphin, however would still go for mutts or possibly cubs above that.
I understand how mutts and cubs almost have to be on the same side, but like what is leaning them both wolfy for you?
 
I understand how mutts and cubs almost have to be on the same side, but like what is leaning them both wolfy for you?
I’m not convinced they’re both on the same side. Mutt’s VCA combined with completely ignoring Kata and the strange write-up business has me concerned there. Cubs has been mixed up in that ordeal and their interactions have seemed w/v to me. Will be back in 20.
 
I’m not convinced they’re both on the same side. Mutt’s VCA combined with completely ignoring Kata and the strange write-up business has me concerned there. Cubs has been mixed up in that ordeal and their interactions have seemed w/v to me. Will be back in 20.

Completely ignored is a strong phrase. When I flip village, how will that impact your reads?
 
Mutts - thought it was weird she said she had cubs in her wolf leans for voting MsP when she also voted MsP. Originally thought she was sketchy but no one has really disputed her being the ugly naked guy so it is possible for her to have been the original NK choice but I also don't like how she keeps pushing that she was the NK target and is obviously village. Currently conflicted

Acanthy - has made sure to provide plenty of justification for her votes but a lot of it seems like flimsy reasoning. Sketchy

mpm - rezzed Nav but could be NAI because it wasn't an ability and there are definitely some advantages to using it as a wolf instead of just letting it go to waste. The day nav was lynched she kept trying to throw shade on him while also saying that it wasn't a good day to lynch him because of his post restriction before lynching him. wolfy

Cubs - so sketchy and has been misrepresenting things a lot to fit his argument but apparently used the guitar on mutts and if mutts really was the intended NK then it doesn't make sense to me that he would interfere with a wolf kill while also being a wolf so that's the only village point he has

Nav/Mel - died as a villager and play (of both of them) has felt fine to me (although with a lack of crazy schemes 😛)

AM - feels village to me but I'm wrong a lot
If I were a wolf, why wouldn't I claim it to be a 1x ability instead of an item? That would be smarter wolf play...
 
Completely ignored is a strong phrase. When I flip village, how will that impact your reads?
Completely ignored may be a bit harsh. But what I've seen through re-reading is that you tried to skirt this issue of Kata for the most part. If you do flip villager my next lynch may be cubs. Rereading AM and dolphin posts now so could also go to either of those. But I'm not convinced you'll flip villager.
 
You didn't ask me but I was thinking about role names and what are people's thoughts on Rachel being a wolf? I was thinking that because there's been a few of Ross's girlfriends or whatever come up and they've been village
Hey hey hey wait, I was one of Ross's girlfriends lol how does this make you feel?
 
@Lawpy What are you thinking? I am seeing you ask the same question 3x in a row. Do you have anything else you'd like to share with the class/talk about? What is your opinion of mutts?
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Tags are not my friend... Oh, and because I don't like the mutts lynch and preserving myself is a must, I will now vote AM
unlynch coffee lynch AM, unless anyone wants to go for an acanthy lynch tonight?

Have AM and Stagg interacted like at all?
 
Tags are not my friend... Oh, and because I don't like the mutts lynch and preserving myself is a must, I will now vote AM
unlynch coffee lynch AM, unless anyone wants to go for an acanthy lynch tonight?

Have AM and Stagg interacted like at all?
You realize acan is voting for me right?
 
@Lawpy What are you thinking? I am seeing you ask the same question 3x in a row. Do you have anything else you'd like to share with the class/talk about? What is your opinion of mutts?

I ask because i have you and dolphin in my wolfy reads with AM but for different reasons and feels. Mutty looks less sketch than these 3 but is still in my wolf lean because of her previous posts and presentation look weird and off to me.
 
Tags are not my friend... Oh, and because I don't like the mutts lynch and preserving myself is a must, I will now vote AM
unlynch coffee lynch AM, unless anyone wants to go for an acanthy lynch tonight?

Have AM and Stagg interacted like at all?

Stagg has voted for a different person each day, and hasnt really further addressed his feelings on these people (miz and barks, now acanthamoeba), just kind of forgot about them and moved on, like he's trying to vote but not really be noticed or remembered.
 
Trying to start putting together a wolf pack... If AM is a wolf, I could see Stagg also being one (I could probably see this regardless)
Coffee is in the wolfy range due to feels
Acanthy is also there (will elaborate on this more in next post)
Further down is dolphin

Felling good about cubby mutty lawper and mel

Okay, but there's still like 90 minutes.
If things change and I am around I will change my vote
 
Unofficial Day 4 Lynch Tally
Stagg (1) - Coffee?
AM (4) - cubs, Lawpy, acan, mpm
mutts (3) - AM, miz, dolphin
Coffee? () -
mpm (2) - mutts, Skim
dolphin (2) - Mel, Barks
acan (1) - Stagg

13/13
lynch close in ~1.5 hours
 
Unofficial Day 4 Lynch Tally
Stagg (1) - Coffee?
AM (4) - cubs, Lawpy, acan, mpm
mutts (3) - AM, miz, dolphin
Coffee? () -
mpm (2) - mutts, Skim
dolphin (2) - Mel, Barks
acan (1) - Stagg

13/13
lynch close in ~1.5 hours
I think Mel is on me... unfortunately haha (this is part of why I self prezzed)
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Well this is getting more interesting.

@CoffeeQuestionMark what are your thoughts on Barkley?

@Barkley13 , what are your thoughts on anything?

I have predominately not felt good about Barks. But, Nav said Barks was a bad lynch. I am not sure why he would say that but am willing to leave Bark for now.
@CoffeeQuestionMark i'm interested to know your thoughts on petmoosy and dolphino, as well as your thoughts on Stagg's posts
I trust d-fin and am neutral to slight village on petmoose
 
What are the reasons for acanthy lynch? I'm reading that her explanations are weak and she's probably being coached? Or is this a misread?

Yes, this is kind of what I am seeing too. Mostly the coached thing for me. So, when I read her post about Fern D1, I wondered if she had played before on another forum. (Has she, or is she a total noob?) Who is the person who is friends with her again?

Some things that sound coached/bug me are listed below

Fast (but not the first) to lynch someone in the beginning, made sure to provide a justification, and stayed under the radar after. Seems like someone who isn't worried about getting killed tonight, but doesn't want villagers looking at them too closely. Too perfect of a reply.
This sounds like this person either knows the game very well, or is being told what to say (btw kata liked this)

Talks briefly to katashark without much else in the way of interaction

Well since I'm voting to lynch Animal Midwife, my feels would be that they are voting for the wrong person.
Seems unnecessarily short when responding. Kind of dodges some questions...

Votes were explained on those days.
Re-explaining things can be almost as important as explaining them the first time. Care to do so?

Not sure what the deal was here... happened to me yesterday evening when the orange couch wore off... weird...
From the Mod: "This PM is closed!"


No evolution. I only get one lynch vote a day, so I can't vote for everyone I think might be a wolf that day.
No, you can't, but you can talk about things/contribute more. Not every player plays that way, but it helps the village in my opinion to bounce ideas off of each other. Being so tight lipped about everything makes you seem shady... (I am inherently more suspicious of everyone who plays this way even though I know it can be a viable strategy)

Lynch Animal Midwife
Why
 
Hmm let's go with:

Unlynch AM
Lynch dolphino
Also any particular reason you don’t want to decide between us? Or are you expecting someone else to break the tie for you?

Edit: jk it was a three way tie even more fun
 
Last edited:
Voting to lynch Animal Midwife because of previously-stated reasons, plus:
> I am the first person who pushed hard to lynch Animal Midwife (I know katashark initially suggested it, but she moved off of her vote quickly when Animal Midwife pushed her...interesting interaction). If I am lynched or night killed, I do hope there will be good follow up and an Animal Midwife lynch tomorrow.
 
Voting to lynch Animal Midwife because of previously-stated reasons, plus:
> I am the first person who pushed hard to lynch Animal Midwife (I know katashark initially suggested it, but she moved off of her vote quickly when Animal Midwife pushed her...interesting interaction). If I am lynched or night killed, I do hope there will be good follow up and an Animal Midwife lynch tomorrow.
Oh **** forgot about that bit/missed it on read through. Thinking.
 
Voting to lynch Animal Midwife because of previously-stated reasons, plus:
> I am the first person who pushed hard to lynch Animal Midwife (I know katashark initially suggested it, but she moved off of her vote quickly when Animal Midwife pushed her...interesting interaction). If I am lynched or night killed, I do hope there will be good follow up and an Animal Midwife lynch tomorrow.
I still don't understand what you even mean by this.
 
Why has this phrase been used like 5 times since last night? Subconsciously making me want to move back to my other vote choice. Who has been strangely quiet the entire day after having heat on her for the last 2
I had this same thought, and went back to look if there was some hidden meaning behind it. I don't think a dog plays a big part in the source material and couldn't come up with anything besides NAI and people just using a phrase they recently heard.
@Melchizedek do you agree to this, or at least follow his train of thought?
I don't see why it would help or why it would hurt (besides the obvious outing info to wolves). I don't see any strict reason Judy Geller would be a wolf, so mass claiming probably wouldn't be helpful in affiliation determination.
Nav/Mel - died as a villager and play (of both of them) has felt fine to me (although with a lack of crazy schemes 😛)
Be careful what you wish for 😏
(I still protest the replacement of the other sneaky emoji for the lack of sinister look on this new one)

Mel's reads are apparently different from Navs though.
Mel doesn't seem bothered by Barks either
This is true, I am not bothered by barks, I think there are wolfier people to deal with for now.
 
Unofficial Day 4 Lynch Tally
Stagg (1) - Coffee?
AM (2) - cubs, acan
mutts (3) - AM, miz, dolphin
Coffee? () -
mpm (2) - mutts, Skim
dolphin (3) - Mel, Barks, Lawpy
acan (2) - Stagg, mpm

13/13
lynch close in ~40 minutes
 
Last edited:
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Mmkay so I’m just about to tell you all I’ve done/role name so others don’t claim stuff later on in case since apparently everyone wants me or mutts to die. And who knows it could be both.
 
Okay I’m Joey, had the death cab once and used it on mpm which resulted in her moving. Had something done to me twice I’m not completely sure what it’s actual benefit for me is, though I have ideas. That thing is I’ve run away from phoebe’s bad music twice. And I got the glady’s protection thing and used it last night and INSTEAD of using it on myself I used it on Nav and what do I get, Mel comes in and pushes my lynch... :rage:
 
Okay I’m Joey, had the death cab once and used it on mpm which resulted in her moving. Had something done to me twice I’m not completely sure what it’s actual benefit for me is, though I have ideas. That thing is I’ve run away from phoebe’s bad music twice. And I got the glady’s protection thing and used it last night and INSTEAD of using it on myself I used it on Nav and what do I get, Mel comes in and pushes my lynch... :rage:
Oh also the thing that’s been done to be twice is in effect for today.