GGoats!! - An aMAAAAAHzing WW thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I've completely lost track of where I stopped catching up and where I jumped into this flurry of an argument. My thoughts at the moment are leaning toward Sun is a really, really frustrated villager who started playing kinda poorly because of her outside-of-game NAI life stuff and now is playing REALLY poorly because everyone is flinging poop at each other and she's right in there flinging poop too.

Now what in the world happened to Alissa? Because I'm starting to feel my suspicions grow there.
If sun is really village, she's so far down a tunnel that I'd like to hear her explanation of her reads on the rest of her wagon with quotes/evidence/explanation. But she's acting super weird for her and it doesn't seem village to me at all.

I wouldn't read anything into her flipping out at me because that's pretty standard regardless of our affiliations. I'd focus on the super weak logic instead.

I really really really hate the dichotomy that I'm either a wolf or a villager playing poorly. I am in fact a very frustrated villager making legitimate contributions and don't see anyone doing much better.
 
As someone who's been there... you're in the argument

yell bugs bunny GIF by Looney Tunes
I know, and I've been in many arguments with sunny before and I'm sure will be in plenty in the future, but normally those have been evidence-based reads disagreements. This is ... super weak evidence??? not sure I can even call it that
 
I see the case on zenge but one piece of evidence I had evaporated when I thought about it. So I'm back to Dubz.

I wanna shake things up because I don't love the other wagons. Want a new one.
no it shouldn't evaporate because making that "innocent" 3P vs wolf kill comment could have been on purpose like you said initially. Not sure why you backtracked it into saying that he would have just asked in wolf chat.
 
MOSTLY OFFICIAL D2 Yeet Tally
alissa (3) - AM, Dina, Doggo
sunshine (4) - Barks, dubz, Zenge, supershorty
samac (1) - Lainey
April (1) - mayo
Zenge (1) - sunshine
DubZ (1) - Cray

11/15

Leading: @sunshinefl
Missing: @samac @Aprilthearab @mkg323 @alissa14

Yeet/Vote closes at 10pm Eastern/11pm AST/9pm Central/7pm fantasyland (~70 MINUTES)

CHECK YO VOTES
 
no it shouldn't evaporate because making that "innocent" 3P vs wolf kill comment could have been on purpose like you said initially. Not sure why you backtracked it into saying that he would have just asked in wolf chat.
For the record, this is a much more legit claim to make than the one we've been arguing over. That was weird. I think it was a weird tinfoil, knowing him, but it was weird.
 
I really really really hate the dichotomy that I'm either a wolf or a villager playing poorly. I am in fact a very frustrated villager making legitimate contributions and don't see anyone doing much better.
and when I flip village I don't want to hear any BS about how i was playing poorly or anti-village and it's my fault. It's not my fault you guys don't agree with the true and real (as verified by multiple people without migraines who pulled the quotes) evidence I presented.
 
I'm starting to think sunny's going to flip 3p just because this is striking me as so similar to last night.

I'm not going to engage on the question thing anymore.

That’s what I am thinking and I’m still much more suspicious of samac so I’m leaving my yeet as it is.
 
I'm starting to think sunny's going to flip 3p just because this is striking me as so similar to last night.

I'm not going to engage on the question thing anymore.
well i'm not so when I flip village if you say anything about it being due to my "poor play" I will never play with you again.
 
If sun is really village, she's so far down a tunnel that I'd like to hear her explanation of her reads on the rest of her wagon with quotes/evidence/explanation. But she's acting super weird for her and it doesn't seem village to me at all.

I wouldn't read anything into her flipping out at me because that's pretty standard regardless of our affiliations. I'd focus on the super weak logic instead.

I'm certainly not following her on the zenge sus
 
I know, and I've been in many arguments with sunny before and I'm sure will be in plenty in the future, but normally those have been evidence-based reads disagreements. This is ... super weak evidence??? not sure I can even call it that

It's hard to draw that line between frustrated villager and frustrated wolf. And I've read it wrong before.

I'm just not comfortable voting Sunshine tonight based on the aggro. I think I would be frustrated coming back tonight into what she did.

I'll admit this may not be great gameplay logic. If you are sure in your read, keep it. I just think I would react like her if I were in her shoes as a villager.
 
I see the case on zenge but one piece of evidence I had evaporated when I thought about it. So I'm back to Dubz.

I wanna shake things up because I don't love the other wagons. Want a new one.

I'm willing to buy this.

No one seems to want to jump back on the April wagon with me. I'll switch to one of my other wolf reads.

Unyeet April
Yeet WZ
 
It's hard to draw that line between frustrated villager and frustrated wolf. And I've read it wrong before.

I'm just not comfortable voting Sunshine tonight based on the aggro. I think I would be frustrated coming back tonight into what she did.

I'll admit this may not be great gameplay logic. If you are sure in your read, keep it. I just think I would react like her if I were in her shoes as a villager.
I feel as good about my vote as you can being an uninformed villager.
 
I am so sorry for being late! I had a minor family emergency to attend to (brother got stuck in a ditch because of snow but everyone is okay) i am trying to catch up as much as possible but full reads won't come after close at this point
 
and when I flip village I don't want to hear any BS about how i was playing poorly or anti-village and it's my fault. It's not my fault you guys don't agree with the true and real (as verified by multiple people without migraines who pulled the quotes) evidence I presented.
I think we need to go back to level ground about this argument. There's a reason you've been heavily village-read the past two games and have been heavily wolf-read this game. You can't say that's all on us not looking at evidence - the evidence you've been presenting is shaky and what you're saying, although partially valid, seems stretched from the truth. I'm willing to believe that your migraine is affecting how you're playing and your stretched truths maybe aren't intentional. I'm starting to believe that you're a really frustrated villager. But this poop-flinging is not getting us anywhere.

I know you can play better than this, Sun. I think you know it too. I also know that once the poop-flinging starts, you're usually the one to get right up in the poop-flinging instead of going back to square one. Which, honestly, is part of the reason I'm starting to believe you're a really frustrated villager. But it doesn't look good and we need to take a step back.
 
MOSTLY OFFICIAL D2 Yeet Tally
alissa (3) - AM, Dina, Doggo
sunshine (4) - Barks, dubz, Zenge, supershorty
samac (1) - Lainey
April ()
Zenge (1) - sunshine
DubZ (2) - Cray, mayo

11/15

Leading: @sunshinefl
Missing: @samac @Aprilthearab @mkg323 @alissa14

Yeet/Vote closes at 10pm Eastern/11pm AST/9pm Central/7pm fantasyland (~60 MINUTES OF PANIC/50 MINUTES TO WAFFLEMANIA)

CHECK YO VOTES
 
@Aprilthearab

You aren't on the chopping block tonight. No self-prez. What are your honest thoughts.

@samac

Any indication where you want to vote?

@alissa14

Give us something here. It's been two days and you haven't put in a vote yet. At this point why should anyone not vote for you?

If Alissa is gonna get modkilled anyway why waste a yeet on her.
 
What is the deal with Alissa’s play usually? Is this lack of thread presence typical wolf for her and village she’s more active, or is this just her usual play regardless of affiliation?

I haven't played with her for a while, but she is usually pretty good. Which is why I've been reluctant to vote for her just for inactivity. Still, it's hitting a limit.
 
There are people in between. I have no idea what people see so strongly in alissa.
I've mentioned already a few times.
What is the deal with Alissa’s play usually? Is this lack of thread presence typical wolf for her and village she’s more active, or is this just her usual play regardless of affiliation?
I don't consider myself an expert on her playstyle, but she has been known to make less content posts while wolfing. She can be a quiet villager too, but context is important.
 
I think we need to go back to level ground about this argument. There's a reason you've been heavily village-read the past two games and have been heavily wolf-read this game. You can't say that's all on us not looking at evidence - the evidence you've been presenting is shaky and what you're saying, although partially valid, seems stretched from the truth. I'm willing to believe that your migraine is affecting how you're playing and your stretched truths maybe aren't intentional. I'm starting to believe that you're a really frustrated villager. But this poop-flinging is not getting us anywhere.

I know you can play better than this, Sun. I think you know it too. I also know that once the poop-flinging starts, you're usually the one to get right up in the poop-flinging instead of going back to square one. Which, honestly, is part of the reason I'm starting to believe you're a really frustrated villager. But it doesn't look good and we need to take a step back.
Thanks for this, nice!April. I agree.
I might consider moving my vote back to alissa, but I'll need to see a lot more from sunshine tomorrow to change my read on her. Because the super shaky logic, especially coming from her when I've seen her put together devastating cases against people, is reading super wolfy to me.
 
@Aprilthearab

You aren't on the chopping block tonight. No self-prez. What are your honest thoughts.
I think we've (myself included) gotten very wrapped up in Sun and I need to take a step back and not let the heat of the argument cloud my decision, might take me a minute. Village leans on zenge, shorty, cray, and mkg. Can elaborate if needed. More than a few still in neutrals. Starting to think Sun is a really frustrated villager and I'm not comfortable putting my vote there tonight. When I was catching up, some things that Alissa called me out for seemed intentionally taken out of context, and now I think she's letting Sun dig her own grave. Although I haven't really mentioned it, Barks is giving me weird vibes and it's something I can't really put my finger on, but that's not where I want to put my vote less than an hour before yeet close with such a shaky basis. Some people have mentioned the same about doggo and I need to think about that too.

I think I am most comfortable putting my vote on Alissa tonight unless something big changes.

Yeet Alissa
 
I've mentioned already a few times.

I don't consider myself an expert on her playstyle, but she has been known to make less content posts while wolfing. She can be a quiet villager too, but context is important.
well thats really the only thing I remember you saying about her. That she is MIA.
Thanks for this, nice!April. I agree.
I might consider moving my vote back to alissa, but I'll need to see a lot more from sunshine tomorrow to change my read on her. Because the super shaky logic, especially coming from her when I've seen her put together devastating cases against people, is reading super wolfy to me.
well thanks for the flattery but not sure it's true. The only thing different tonight is not my logic, but just the fact that with my migraine and everything else I don't have the ability to thread search and quote posts. I literally can't.
 
well thanks for the flattery but not sure it's true. The only thing different tonight is not my logic, but just the fact that with my migraine and everything else I don't have the ability to thread search and quote posts. I literally can't.
It is true. The cases that you'd put together in the basics game were great. We might not have the same playstyle but it doesn't mean I don't respect you as a player, we just don't play the same way, and disagree on almost everything, even important things like whether pumpernickel bread is good or not.

That's why your logic tonight really pinged me - because I've seen you put together those reads in other games and I know how well you can do that.
 
Just asking.

Also, why Samac?

I’ve already posted this but it seems as if they are pretty absent, don’t directly answer questions or avoid responding. Flipped sunshine from wolf to village quickly after just skimming through everything.
 
GIF OFFICIAL D2 Yeet Tally
alissa (5)
- AM, Dina, Doggo, April, Cray
sunshine (4) - Barks, dubz, Zenge, supershorty
samac (1) - Lainey
April ()
Zenge (1) - sunshine
DubZ (1) - mayo

12/15

Leading: @alissa14
Missing: @samac @mkg323 @alissa14

Baby Goat GIF by MOODMAN


Yeet/Vote closes at 10pm Eastern/11pm AST/9pm Central/7pm fantasyland (~45 MINUTES OF PANIC/35 MINUTES TO WAFFLEMANIA)

CHECK YO VOTES
 
In some ways it feels like we're having to waste yeets on silent people and lurkers. I hope maybe if we keep killing them over and over maybe eventually we won't have to one day.
It's not a waste when if they flip wolf. Outside that though, I think lowposters are slowly being crushed out in general which is nice.
 
Top