Henry Stickmin - Game Thread

[Viscernable]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Day 1 Yeet Tally
April () -
dubz ()
Sporty () -
Bread (1) - mkg
Cray () -
Vis (1) - genny
Mel (1) - Vis
mayo () -
Zenge (3) - mayo, Bob, Bread
genny (3) - dubz, Zenge, Pippy
Bob (3) - alley, April, Mel
sunshine (1) - Sporty
Mel (1) - sunshine

14/15
yeet close in ~1 hour

Mel’s wagon is split in two

which works fine for me because I don’t feel good enough about sunny to want to vote with her

Unvote Mel

 

[genny]

I wonder who breaks first: Zenge switching to Bob, or Bob switching to me?

 

[Viscernable]

Vote Z

 

[genny]

Well, that's no fun. There goes the tie.

 

[sunshinefl]

awww is someone a little jealous?

You know what you’ve also done as a wolf? Pushed bad logic on thread (I.e. voting dubz based on an emoji), and then doubled down on it and tunneled when people started poking holes in your theory.

Besides her, what two other players would you consider voting today and why?

my n=1 on wolf!sunny is from the last game I played, so I recognize the tendency for recall bias. Does anyone have more data? Is this AI or just baseline?


I would appreciate expansion on what specifically pinged your radar.



Who else is on your suspicious list right now?

@Viscernable what are your thoughts on April?

it wasn't bad logic, it was early. but congrats, my vote is on you now!

There's been so much meta discussion in this game so far.

@Melchizedek you going to drop a vote at any point today?

exactly. Super quick to jump on me about my vote being dumb, but withholding his vote until multiple people directly ask him. And then he votes for the popular vote without much (any?) explanation

Thinking harder about possible wolfy Bob with that reads list that I don't feel really reflects what's been going on

I actually agreed with a lot of it

I almost don't want to say this because I feel like I'm going to shoot myself in the foot... but I think if I were a wolf and saw a villager say "yo wolves, early death plz," I would village read that person and then night kill them.

Just saying.

ugh pippy please stop adding layers to this "kill me" thing

And I agree with Pippy on this whole Pip v Sunny conversation on page 4. Sunny's word choice sounded too sure of herself; like a wolf slip.

unyeet Dubz
yeet sunny

Time to go wrangle a foal again so brb.

how does the word IF sound sure of anything?

if
/if/

conjunction

1. 1.
   (introducing a conditional clause) on the condition or supposition that; in the event that.
   "if you have a complaint, write to the director"

Ok so I’m catching up rn, sorry for being MIA all day. I’d say today was a dumpster fire, but tbh that would be an understatement. My thoughts on the first 6 pages:

Sunny had some odd word choice, but I’m not sure if it’s wolfy yet, I don’t remember her talking like that in the England game, and she’s an easy misyeet so I’m willing to hold off on it.
April - similar tone to the last game when she was a wolf, just a bit toned down. Need to see more to make a decision
Cray - so far sounds like herself?
Pippy - usually sounds sketchy
Kinda brain dead but that’s what I got so far

again, what odd word choice? the one where I said I would rather hunt wolves that euthanize villagers IF she's village?

 

[Aprilthearab]

Vote Z

Why?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
April () -
dubz () -
Sporty () -
Bread (1) - mkg
Cray () -
Vis (1) - genny
Mel (1) - sunshine
mayo () -
Zenge (4) - mayo, Bob, Bread, Vis
genny (3) - dubz, Zenge, Pippy
Bob (3) - alley, April, Mel
sunshine (1) - Sporty

14/15
Missing: Cray
yeet close in ~1 hour

 

[WildZoo]

Vote Z

Wut? Didn't you have a whole post about how you were reading him village after iso? Did I imagine that?

 

[Crayola227]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
April () -
dubz ()
Sporty () -
Bread (1) - mkg
Cray () -
Vis (1) - genny
Mel (1) - Vis
mayo () -
Zenge (3) - mayo, Bob, Bread
genny (3) - dubz, Zenge, Pippy
Bob (3) - alley, April, Mel
sunshine (1) - Sporty
Mel (1) - sunshine

14/15
yeet close in ~1 hour

The votes should be consolidated on Mel.

I think if I

#### yeet Mel ####

It makes a 4way tie with him in it, and I like the candidates so far

 

[Aprilthearab]

I don't understand why Zenge would be the yeet pick out of those three

 

[Crayola227]

Mel’s wagon is split in two

which works fine for me because I don’t feel good enough about sunny to want to vote with her

Unvote Mel

Nvm lol

 

[Aprilthearab]

Wut? Didn't you have a whole post about how you were reading him village after iso? Did I imagine that?

Last I heard she called Zenge neutral but I don't get it because I thought Genny was a stronger wolf read

 

[Crayola227]

it wasn't bad logic, it was early. but congrats, my vote is on you now!

exactly. Super quick to jump on me about my vote being dumb, but withholding his vote until multiple people directly ask him. And then he votes for the popular vote without much (any?) explanation

I actually agreed with a lot of it

ugh pippy please stop adding layers to this "kill me" thing

how does the word IF sound sure of anything?

if
/if/

conjunction

1. 1.
   (introducing a conditional clause) on the condition or supposition that; in the event that.
   "if you have a complaint, write to the director"

again, what odd word choice? the one where I said I would rather hunt wolves that euthanize villagers IF she's village?

This last sentence made me cackle so loud Cessna's like WTF

 

[Zenge142]

@holdthemayo You coming back? Any updated thoughts?

 

[Crayola227]

#### unyeet Mel ###

#### yeet Bob ####

 

[Crayola227]

I favor Bob out of the candidates I can vote for and create a tie rn

 

[Crayola227]

I'm not certain genny is wolfing yet. The vote switch from Visc is very concerning though

 

[Aprilthearab]

I wonder if His thought the yeet close was at 9 and wanted to break the tie?

But if that's the case I still don't understand why she would have chosen Zenge to break the tie when she just said she had Zenge in neutrals

 

[Aprilthearab]

I wonder if His thought the yeet close was at 9 and wanted to break the tie?

But if that's the case I still don't understand why she would have chosen Zenge to break the tie when she just said she had Zenge in neutrals

Sorry meant to say Vis, autocorrect changes it to His

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
April () -
dubz () -
Sporty () -
Bread (1) - mkg
Cray () -
Vis (1) - genny
Mel (1) - sunshine
mayo () -
Zenge (4) - mayo, Bob, Bread, Vis
genny (3) - dubz, Zenge, Pippy
Bob (4) - alley, April, Mel, Cray
sunshine (1) - Sporty

15/15
yeet close in ~45 minutes

 

[BobLoblaw78]

I wonder who breaks first: Zenge switching to Bob, or Bob switching to me?

Lololol. I was so assuming I was one down bc zenge was gonna switch to me, that I didn’t even realize I could switch to you.

It goes against my nature to switch but I can understand it. But even goes more against my principle to switch to someone I think is village....

Someone help me out. I will return the favor by saving your life sometime...

 

[holdthemayo]

@holdthemayo You coming back? Any updated thoughts?

I'm still a few pages back. Trying to react as I read so that people know I'm catching up.

Based off of what I've read so far, I'm uncomfortably comfortable with the three choices on the board.

I would like to hear from @SportPonies @mkg323 and @sunshinefl on the three leading wagons, since right now they just look like wolves hiding their votes safely off wagon rather than actually making a case for their votes.

Presumably genny is waiting on her weird vis vote to self prez if necessary.

 

[sunshinefl]

I'm not certain genny is wolfing yet. The vote switch from Visc is very concerning though

yeah Visc was my strongest village read but that was really odd

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Lol again. Vote got in my favor so I thought whew. Then back to oh nooo!

 

[sunshinefl]

I'm still a few pages back. Trying to react as I read so that people know I'm catching up.

Based off of what I've read so far, I'm uncomfortably comfortable with the three choices on the board.

I would like to hear from @SportPonies @mkg323 and @sunshinefl on the three leading wagons, since right now they just look like wolves hiding their votes safely off wagon rather than actually making a case for their votes.

Presumably genny is waiting on her weird vis vote to self prez if necessary.

I actually feel that way about sporty's vote


I really do want people to vote for Mel, but people are coming off of it rather than on it. Visc was my strongest village read but then weirdly switched off of him to zenge. Kinda weird after ISO'ing zenge and saying she was feeling better about him, and that my 2nd vote on Mel may actually have started to make it real. So Im concerned there.

but anyway between the 3, Genny is ??? to sus, Zenge is Mixed???, and Bob is mixed. If I had to choose between the 3 with the information I had now, I would yeet Genny.

 

[PippyPony]

Pippy - usually sounds sketchy

Simply a revelation

 

[Crayola227]

Lololol. I was so assuming I was one down bc zenge was gonna switch to me, that I didn’t even realize I could switch to you.

It goes against my nature to switch but I can understand it. But even goes more against my principle to switch to someone I think is village....

Someone help me out. I will return the favor by saving your life sometime...

Like by not NK them for a single night?

 

[Viscernable]

Lololol. I was so assuming I was one down bc zenge was gonna switch to me, that I didn’t even realize I could switch to you.

It goes against my nature to switch but I can understand it. But even goes more against my principle to switch to someone I think is village....

Someone help me out. I will return the favor by saving your life sometime...

K here’s the reaction I was looking for. Doesn’t look like W/W Bob/Zenge. I am wondering about whether W/W Bob/genny is possible, now, though.

unvote Z
Vote Bob

 

[Melchizedek]

hmmmm

Unvote bob
Vote Bread

 

[Aprilthearab]

I'm still a few pages back. Trying to react as I read so that people know I'm catching up.

Based off of what I've read so far, I'm uncomfortably comfortable with the three choices on the board.

I would like to hear from @SportPonies @mkg323 and @sunshinefl on the three leading wagons, since right now they just look like wolves hiding their votes safely off wagon rather than actually making a case for their votes.

Presumably genny is waiting on her weird vis vote to self prez if necessary.

Mkg worries me because we usually see a lot more from her in general as well as good content but I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt for the first cycle in case of IRL priorities

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
April () -
dubz () -
Sporty () -
Bread (2) - mkg, Mel
Cray () -
Vis (1) - genny
Mel (1) - sunshine
mayo () -
Zenge (3) - mayo, Bob, Bread
genny (3) - dubz, Zenge, Pippy
Bob (4) - alley, April, Cray, Vis
sunshine (1) - Sporty

15/15
yeet close in ~30 minutes

 

[sunshinefl]

where is everyone?

It's crunchtime now.

and really mostly the only action is some reaction test from Visc that I don't understand.

 

[Crayola227]

#### unyeet Bob ####

#### yeet Bread ####

I'm high on ties

 

[Viscernable]

Mkg worries me because we usually see a lot more from her in general as well as good content but I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt for the first cycle in case of IRL priorities

Yeah I don’t love what I’ve seen so far but I know she had an exhausting day so it’s not fair or smart to wolf read her for it

 

[Crayola227]

With 4 people tied for lead, one would hope that at least one of the wagons is on a wolf

 

[BobLoblaw78]

K here’s the reaction I was looking for. Doesn’t look like W/W Bob/Zenge. I am wondering about whether W/W Bob/genny is possible, now, though.

unvote Z
Vote Bob

It’s true

 

[Viscernable]

where is everyone?

It's crunchtime now.

and really mostly the only action is some reaction test from Visc that I don't understand.

Bob is voting Z. I’ve been wondering if it’s a bus that’s banking on genny getting misyeeted or on Bob’s yeet being too hard to prevent and giving Z some credit as he goes down. Wanted to see if Bob would switch when Z pulled into the lead. He didn’t, and claims the idea of voting for genny never occurred to him.

 

[PippyPony]

How come everyone just wants to yeet the dudes? genny got cooties or something?

 

[genny]

How come everyone just wants to yeet the dudes? genny got cooties or something?

i do

 

[BobLoblaw78]

yeah Visc was my strongest village read but that was really odd

K here’s the reaction I was looking for. Doesn’t look like W/W Bob/Zenge. I am wondering about whether W/W Bob/genny is possible, now, though.

unvote Z
Vote Bob

He was mine too...is that why this hurts so much?

 

[BobLoblaw78]

i do

I wouldn’t doubt it....For goodness sakes, put that cats tongue away!

(btw- I love that avatar)

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Bob is voting Z. I’ve been wondering if it’s a bus that’s banking on genny getting misyeeted or on Bob’s yeet being too hard to prevent and giving Z some credit as he goes down. Wanted to see if Bob would switch when Z pulled into the lead. He didn’t, and claims the idea of voting for genny never occurred to him.

Yeah. When I lock in a vote I am more in plead my case then I am about changing my principles. Plus, I have faith you guys will do the right thing and figure this out

 

[genny]

Bob is voting Z. I’ve been wondering if it’s a bus that’s banking on genny getting misyeeted or on Bob’s yeet being too hard to prevent and giving Z some credit as he goes down. Wanted to see if Bob would switch when Z pulled into the lead. He didn’t, and claims the idea of voting for genny never occurred to him.

Maybe Bob and i are v/v, and you and Zenge are the wolves.

 

[holdthemayo]

#### unyeet Bob ####

#### yeet Bread ####

I'm high on ties

I swear I just read something where you said forcing ties right before close was one of the reasons you will always vote for someone.

Seems like good advice.

Unyeet Zenge
Yeet Cray

 

[Zenge142]

Maybe Bob and i are v/v, and you and Zenge are the wolves.

Have we ever played a game where you weren't wolf reading me?

 

[genny]

Have we ever played a game where you weren't wolf reading me?

Yes, I believe you were a wolf that game.

 

[holdthemayo]

You weren't the only player that asked for death. Besides, I was trying to use readily available examples of the kind of stuff that just will always make it harder to read someone as village, their meta aside. If this was an MU game and no one was known, certain actions would raise questions about Aff because they are independently concerning. I'm making a grander statement about general philosophy of game play, not trying to focus solely on one particular thing you did.

Other examples of play that will always invite questions besides asking to be NK, self-voting, asking for mod-smiting, posting content that appears to be game-flavor related but seems off-topic, is not limited to but also includes vote holding, creating ties close to deadline, naked vote placements, lurking, barely making post minimums, the list goes on.

Here it was

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Maybe Bob and i are v/v, and you and Zenge are the wolves.

Which is funny bc I think you and Vis are village lean! Oh what a tangled web. I stick with Zenge and April for my wolf lean (probably not wise when my doctor is giving me a bad prognosis)

 

[PippyPony]

Maybe Bob and i are v/v, and you and Zenge are the wolves.

This feels lackluster

 

[genny]

Have we ever played a game where you weren't wolf reading me?

This questions also implies knowledge of my villageness. In what world does a villager wolf-reading me ask this question?