Okay, as always a lot of my D1 reads are trash. Time to update.
Village:
Mel- Still like my village read. Seems to be wolf hunting. The Genny vote makes Mel seem more village to me in a Derp clear kind of way. Especially since I’ve been told Mel is a pretty good wolf and a smart wolf wouldn’t have drawn attention to themselves like that.
Pippy- Reading her as village. Seems like she’s contributing in an meaningful way, and actively wolf hunting.
Sunny- Still village reading her. I’m actually inclined to give her the same clear I’m giving to Vis and Mel. Her vote switch to Genny did come earlier, with two minutes to spare, but the vote was tied between two villagers, Genny and Bob at the time. Her logic for the switch, based on her posts was to take away Genny’s ability to control the situation, but at best it stopped Genny from self preservation voting onto Bob. I think if Sunny was wolfing, knowing both Genny and Bob were villagers, she would have stayed the hell away from either vote and just quietly left her vote on Mel.
Vis- Again, my village read here hasn’t changed. Her participation this game has been helpful, and pro-village. Also like Mel, I’m inclined to derp clear her for the last second switch to Genny. What wolf in their right mind does that?
Cray- I’m nervous to say it but I think I have to give Cray a village read. There’s nothing about Cray’s posts that have stood out to me as wolfy, not that I’m great at reading her but her tie making in the last hour seems village to me. I know her tie making shenanigans really sketched Mayo out, but this seems like Village!Cray trying to cause a little tension and get information by seeing what people do. I really don’t think wolf!Cray would be reckless like that. It really seems like a village!Cray move.
Neutral:
Dubz- Still the village side of neutral. Nothing stands out as wolfy, but nothing that’s making me sure she’s village either.
April- I’m moving her down to neutral. Since my top two wolf contenders are dead, I need to reevaluate everyone and there have definitely been things that have pinged me. I didn’t like how quick she was to vote onto Mayo after saying she wouldn’t vote there. She made that post about how “bread stayed away from wolves” in the last game which wasn’t accurate and since bread is one of my wolf reads, it gives me pause for sure. She has said a lot on this thread defending me, which I have to wonder now if this is a pocketing. Definitely going to keep a close eye on April during this cycle.
Mayo- He came off as a frustrated villager in our disagreement. It read genuine. Still hasn’t posted a whole lot of content or thoughts about the game to really get a sense of his affiliation yet though, so I’m leaving him in neutral.
MKG- Too few posts to say anything about this effectively. Her EOD posts were weird, and Sunny called her out for it. Still not sure what to make of it without further content for analysis.
Sporty- I don’t really have a good sense of her affiliation right now. She doesn’t have very many posts to analyze and help me make a determination.
Wolfy:
Alley- Not much content. But what she’s just posted, she’s working pretty hard to shade me based on posts from over 1/2 the thread ago from my argument with Mayo. It’s what really sketches me out about Bread too. They’re both driving this narrative that it HAS to be a w/v interaction. Neither one even remotely considering a v/v possibility. I also thing it’s pretty sketchy that she’s making the argument that when I’m wolfing I make this twisty arguments. You know where that narrative had the most traction? England, when I was arguing with Sunny and MK, where Cray shot me because she thought my arguments were “twisty” and I was village. So if you’re going to try and shade me by saying I’m only “twisty” when I’m wolfing, you’re dead wrong on that point.
Bread- Also very little content to actually analyze, still feel wolfy about the things I’ve mentioned above, and other posts.
