Magical WW Signups and Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Could have been. I don't like her hemming and hawing above about looking elsewhere than jilary and then voting jilary. It is suspicious.

No. You misunderstood me then. What I was trying to get at was that I was okay with looking elsewhere today BUT IF WE DO let's not forget about Jilary !! I mean that I am suspicious of her but not sold in that I could see it going either way. She was the only person I had solid suspicion in, that's why I voted for her, but I wasnt sold on it which is why I said what I did basically. Anyway now with LIS's post about knowing a different lynch avoiding villager, I'm more comfortable with my vote anyway.
 
Have items been going around this game? (If you hold an item today please don't reveal that.)
 
lynch PBC

I may regret this since they claim to be a villager magic creature with useful powers. However, I don't have a better suspect. People (I think mostly Trilt from yesterday's notes I took) say that they are usually a bad villager, that they like to be converted wolf, will ask to be, and just generally do things that hurt the village.

I've learned that yes, you always try to catch wolves, but if you can't get a wolf removing certain villagers can be good for the village too.
I don't know what else to think but someone who can't be trusted to act village ...

Hey, no one said I intentionally hurt the village when I'm village. This comment seems like a huge misconstruction in an attempt to justify lynch.

Maybe I just have butt hurt feelings.
 
Hey, no one said I intentionally hurt the village when I'm village. This comment seems like a huge misconstruction in an attempt to justify lynch.

Maybe I just have butt hurt feelings.
I would just like to note that I did not say you were a bad villager, and tried really hard to clarify what I meant re: that lynch throughout the day. I kind of regretted bringing up your self-conversion and wolfy love by the end of it all, although I was still pretty convinced you were sketchy.

...apologetic david tennant gif? 😉

UpVMqGC.gif
 
I saw Gwen's ability post... I'm not quite sure which way I read it, but likely villager, and especially because you responded :woot:.

I don't like the Jilary lynch, at least as far as it is based on a lynch cancellation, because I have been a villager multiple times with both a cancellation and an avoidance. I can see a bit of difficulty with the defense yesterday, but can also relate to that too.

Basically, a waffle is likely soon. I just don't know where to yet.
 
I will not be voting Jilary because to me our conversations are giving me a pretty strong villager vibe. She is playing 100% the same as she has in any game when she is a villager up for lynch. Her ability could go either way, but she has been honest about it.

Forgive me if I am mistaken, but is Gwen lynch just feels and suspicion of her being annoyed at the comments of the deads?
 
I will not be voting Jilary because to me our conversations are giving me a pretty strong villager vibe. She is playing 100% the same as she has in any game when she is a villager up for lynch. Her ability could go either way, but she has been honest about it.

Forgive me if I am mistaken, but is Gwen lynch just feels and suspicion of her being annoyed at the comments of the deads?
It was just trying to get conversation going. It happened. I'm trying to decide what to do with that info or whether to pick someone else.
 
Did everybody have a note about their eyes this morning or was it just me?

I have been assuming it was the dust from the lynch cancel, but since nobody mentioned it, I was less sure. I can't find a creature that really fits the description either.
 
Did everybody have a note about their eyes this morning or was it just me?

I have been assuming it was the dust from the lynch cancel, but since nobody mentioned it, I was less sure. I can't find a creature that really fits the description either.

Nothing about my eyes was shared


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Forgive me if I am mistaken, but is Gwen lynch just feels and suspicion of her being annoyed at the comments of the deads?
Originally. After that, her lack of anything yesterday beyond "whhhy am I being lynched" (which is a nothing response) and the very lackluster ability claim today (that she kind of preemptively put out there, despite it being an ability that loses a lot of power once it is known...) have made me feel better about my Gwen vote.
 
Originally. After that, her lack of anything yesterday beyond "whhhy am I being lynched" (which is a nothing response) and the very lackluster ability claim today (that she kind of preemptively put out there, despite it being an ability that loses a lot of power once it is known...) have made me feel better about my Gwen vote.
And the ability claim is my biggest reason for pause. It sounds like a "just try me!"
 
And the ability claim is my biggest reason for pause. It sounds like a "just try me!"
Easy to say "just try me!" when you know you won't be tried. Unverifiable, passive abilities like that are bread and butter wolf claims, and now she has an excuse for not being night-killed going forward.

I mean, I'm 0/1 on feels so far this game, so if it feels convincing to you, swap away. I just don't really like how that played out much.
 
Yeah I'm actually going to unlynch Jil, lynch Gwen unless we get some hard info on either. I don't see why she would volunteer that role info when she wasn't in danger of being lynched, since it would screw up her opportunity to catch a wolf with it.
 
Also, methinks that a necromancer may be present in this game. Aye, the amount of revives, if it continues, bring back memories, if ye can remember, of zombies and the like. With posting restrictions gone on our lad finn, this theory is class. Unfortunately, taking down the recipients of a chancer's magic normally doesn't do much, it's taking down the chancer himself that yields the massive result.
This interests me. So two rezzes are a normal amount, but three is just bonkers? I'm honestly asking because I haven't played that many games.
 
I would just like to note that I did not say you were a bad villager, and tried really hard to clarify what I meant re: that lynch throughout the day. I kind of regretted bringing up your self-conversion and wolfy love by the end of it all, although I was still pretty convinced you were sketchy.

...apologetic david tennant gif? 😉

UpVMqGC.gif

We're good. I was quoting Cray's post, which was misrepresenting what you had said about your feels on me.
 
I sort of want to lynch Cray for the weird comment about me. But I'm not biased or anything :whistle:

On to real business. Jil doesn't read wolf to me yet, and I don't think a lynch would be fruitful if it goes her way today. I don't have a better target to suggest though.
 
This is good to know, but I'm not sure I'm super convinced by that because Jil's was a lynch cancellation (as verified by the write-up). An avoidance and a cancellation in the same game doesn't feel oh-too-weird to me. Could be wrong.

I guess my thoughts are that Gwen is starting to ring my alarm bells a little, and if we all pile on Jilary we're going to somewhat waste the day of discussion.


Yup. I totally acknowledge that. But it is still sketchy.... This isn't a game of certainty, so I'm comfortable with the lynch.
 
Both PBC and Finn are villager (barring a mechanic I wasn't told about with my role).

So. Any more rezzes in the game should be lynched.

Obviously if/when we progress to a conversion hunt both PBC and Finn are as suspect as any of us.

I wanted to use my rezzes early because I feel it is safer than dying with them.

I f'd up rezzing PBC - I submitted the move hastily and was confused over who the dead seer was. No offense, PBC. I meant to Rez the seer and trust that an angel role would protect them. C'est la vie.
 
Did everybody have a note about their eyes this morning or was it just me?

I have been assuming it was the dust from the lynch cancel, but since nobody mentioned it, I was less sure. I can't find a creature that really fits the description either.
I heard faint singing night 2. Nothing last night.
 
Easy to say "just try me!" when you know you won't be tried. Unverifiable, passive abilities like that are bread and butter wolf claims, and now she has an excuse for not being night-killed going forward.

I mean, I'm 0/1 on feels so far this game, so if it feels convincing to you, swap away. I just don't really like how that played out much.
are you saying you have an active role?
 
Top o' the mornin' (I guess afternoon) to ye laddies. It's time the rest of ya pull yer socks up and get ta lynchin'. Lads like crayola may be throwing shapes but at least their heart be in it. To those that last game treated favorably, I send me lot to PBC.

**********lynch PBC********

Hmmm. I'm not a lad, but a lass! Was wondering if this post was part of a posting restriction to sounds like a Irishman. Haven't heard from STL since that I can remember.

I'm going to lynch PBC for being next to all of the other BCs on roster. Obviously open to
waffles. Or lucky charms, Crayola? 😉

Haha, I do love those Lucky Charms. That's how I lost 20 lbs in my first month of internship. I call it the "Lucky Diet."

Hey, no one said I intentionally hurt the village when I'm village. This comment seems like a huge misconstruction in an attempt to justify lynch.

Maybe I just have butt hurt feelings.

I would just like to note that I did not say you were a bad villager, and tried really hard to clarify what I meant re: that lynch throughout the day. I kind of regretted bringing up your self-conversion and wolfy love by the end of it all, although I was still pretty convinced you were sketchy.

...apologetic david tennant gif? 😉

UpVMqGC.gif

We're good. I was quoting Cray's post, which was misrepresenting what you had said about your feels on me.

I sort of want to lynch Cray for the weird comment about me. But I'm not biased or anything :whistle:

On to real business. Jil doesn't read wolf to me yet, and I don't think a lynch would be fruitful if it goes her way today. I don't have a better target to suggest though.

I know that I have watched PBC A) convert herself, and B) beg to be converted to the non-village side... in multiple games. To revel in non-villager roles. To sit on information about chaos players when she's a villager because she likes that. Because of that, it strikes me as out of character for her to be so excited to be a villager, so I followed that lead.

It has a strong chance of being wrong - it's D1 for Pete's sake - but that's my feels. :shrug:

Let me just repeat again what Trilt said that I based it on

"I know that I have watched PBC A) convert herself, and B) beg to be converted to the non-village side... in multiple games. To revel in non-villager roles. To sit on information about chaos players when she's a villager because she likes that."

Um, so, as a new player what do I make of this?

I'm not thrilled that if someone is given a *choice* between villager and wolf, that they would go wolf.

Or that they would ask wolves to convert them - better to have wolves have to guess at who to convert, because if they're not being helped they can screw themselves and convert someone useless.

Also not thrilled about someone who would keep intel potentially important to the village to themselves because they like chaos.

So tell me again, how am I misconstruing Trilt's words? It's fine if this is all inaccurate, but don't act like I'm making stuff up or I'm just injustifiable in not liking what I read *Trilt* say.
 
Hmmm. I'm not a lad, but a lass! Was wondering if this post was part of a posting restriction to sounds like a Irishman. Haven't heard from STL since that I can remember.



Haha, I do love those Lucky Charms. That's how I lost 20 lbs in my first month of internship. I call it the "Lucky Diet."











Let me just repeat again what Trilt said that I based it on

"I know that I have watched PBC A) convert herself, and B) beg to be converted to the non-village side... in multiple games. To revel in non-villager roles. To sit on information about chaos players when she's a villager because she likes that."

Um, so, as a new player what do I make of this?

I'm not thrilled that if someone is given a *choice* between villager and wolf, that they would go wolf.

Or that they would ask wolves to convert them - better to have wolves have to guess at who to convert, because if they're not being helped they can screw themselves and convert someone useless.

Also not thrilled about someone who would keep intel potentially important to the village to themselves because they like chaos.

So tell me again, how am I misconstruing Trilt's words? It's fine if this is all inaccurate, but don't act like I'm making stuff up or I'm just injustifiable in not liking what I read *Trilt* say.
STL posted both yesterday and several times this morning. You can use the search bar in the top right and put in a particular person's name, then hit "search this thread only" to see everything they've posted.

Lots of people like being wolves. Lots of people like being converted. Hell, I'll admit I had a jolly 24 hour romp the time I was converted. Doesn't mean I don't play hard for the village when I am one, or that I was accusing PBC of not doing so.
 
I prefer being a wolf myself, but I must admit it doesn't thrill me that someone would sit on information or ask to be converted when they're a villager. That's not playing hard for the village and although it may not be what you meant, I can see why Crayola interpreted it the way she did.
 
STL posted both yesterday and several times this morning. You can use the search bar in the top right and put in a particular person's name, then hit "search this thread only" to see everything they've posted.

Lots of people like being wolves. Lots of people like being converted. Hell, I'll admit I had a jolly 24 hour romp the time I was converted. Doesn't mean I don't play hard for the village when I am one, or that I was accusing PBC of not doing so.

Thanks. I did so. Yeah, it's funny, all of STL's posts have that Irish theme. I'm guessing they're a Leprechaun. I don't know what that means in the game. They usually have powers but it's usually mischevious.
 
Trilt, I don't want to make you role reveal, but I'd be curious to know who can vouch for you.

I'm goint to

lynch Trilt

She seems to be going after people, and I've heard through my grapevine that she can't be seered. Maybe that's to protect her from wolves who can have seer powers. It would have the unfortunate side effect of making her look suspicious to any village seers. Not sure what kind of mind**** the mods are going for if she can't be seered.
 
interesting.

We've had 3 nights? And a couple people?
Literally a couple. I get that you think I'm a wolf, but I'm not, and you're tunneling just as much as I was with PBC.

I prefer being a wolf myself, but I must admit it doesn't thrill me that someone would sit on information or ask to be converted when they're a villager. That's not playing hard for the village and although it may not be what you meant, I can see why Crayola interpreted it the way she did.
I get it. I just didn't like that as a reason to lynch, and didn't like my words being interpreted like that so I probably got a bit grumpy. We're looking for wolves, not villagers who maybe like to be wolves.
 
Trilt, I don't want to make you role reveal, but I'd be curious to know who can vouch for you.

I'm goint to

lynch Trilt

She seems to be going after people, and I've heard through my grapevine that she can't be seered. Maybe that's to protect her from wolves who can have seer powers. It would have the unfortunate side effect of making her look suspicious to any village seers. Not sure what kind of mind**** the mods are going for if she can't be seered.
Your grapevine about seering is wrong, considering someone across the roster magically knew my role name yesterday.
 
Quick note before I go reading posts to come up with my lynch vote today:
I just asked the mods to confirm, but I believe I go back to lonely world tonight either directly after lynch or when the night closes
 
Literally a couple. I get that you think I'm a wolf, but I'm not, and you're tunneling just as much as I was with PBC.


I get it. I just didn't like that as a reason to lynch, and didn't like my words being interpreted like that so I probably got a bit grumpy. We're looking for wolves, not villagers who maybe like to be wolves.
I have some info from the grapevine that makes that very interesting. Regardless of previous thoughts.

lynch trilt
 
Why are you assuming that she was blocked?

I just took it to mean she had dust in her eyes which to me seems like it would make it hard to do any "menacing glaring". I may have interpreted it wrong.

If it's dust in the eyes it seems like someone could be trying to prevent someone else from seering/investigating.


Did everybody have a note about their eyes this morning or was it just me?

I have been assuming it was the dust from the lynch cancel, but since nobody mentioned it, I was less sure. I can't find a creature that really fits the description either.
 
Top