Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024

Started by kaydubs
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Not upset if MsP gets voted out just because of inactivity, but I also don't like alleys logic re: her reads list and me. I think we nearly had identical reads lists aside from PSV (she ranked her village and I had her in my neutrals) and her explanation of me sounding wishy washy doesn't feel like a valid reason to vote for me if all of her other game reasoning supposedly lines up with mine. Would like to hear more explanation on why @alleycat03 ranked her reads that way?
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
What would you consider his village meta?
He feels more forthecoming when village and more insightful. I remember that I thought he was extra stretchy in wolf games and then I was lambasted for thinking that in the last game I accused him of wolfing (and was wrong iirc). So far I think it is interesting that he has misremembered several things this game and used that egg emoji. I don't expect him to remember *everything* but it stood out to me as a little odd
 
How do you do fellow midwesterners.
Scared On Guard GIF
 
Day 1 Vote Tally:
MsP (4)
- genny, mkg, Santy, dya
samac (1) - MsP
genny ()
Clem (1) - Stagg
Santy ()
Cyndia (2) - PSV, alley
mkg ()
PSV (1) - Clem
alley ()
Zenge (1) -samac
 
Zenge didn’t react to my vote
🙁
I assumed you were doing that thing where you vote for a villager and see if anyone immediately follows you to see who’s sketchy and then turn around to vote for them. But I’m starting to think you’re actually voting for me? Not just trap voting for me?
 
I don't like D1 MsP votes because they are misyeets so often, but she didn't give us anything to really go on.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Not upset if MsP gets voted out just because of inactivity, but I also don't like alleys logic re: her reads list and me. I think we nearly had identical reads lists aside from PSV (she ranked her village and I had her in my neutrals) and her explanation of me sounding wishy washy doesn't feel like a valid reason to vote for me if all of her other game reasoning supposedly lines up with mine. Would like to hear more explanation on why @alleycat03 ranked her reads that way?
I didn't feel like you were contributing to the game enough to justify a village placement. It felt like a lot of off-topic comments and then a reads list that didn't feel authentic imo
 
Day 1 Vote Tally:

MsP (4) - genny, mkg, Santy, dya
samac (1) - MsP
genny ()
Clem (1) - Stagg
Santy ()
Cyndia (2) - PSV, alley
mkg ()
PSV (1) - Clem
alley (1) - Cyndia
Zenge (1) -samac
zenge is the only one not voting atm
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I didn't feel like you were contributing to the game enough to justify a village placement. It felt like a lot of off-topic comments and then a reads list that didn't feel authentic imo
I guess where I'm confused with you logic in picking me is that our lists were so similar but you don't think it was authentic? How are you so much more confident in your reads in D1? I saw that post where you said you haven't played in 2024 and played last a while back in 2023, which is similar to my timeline.
 
i dont care about the MsP votes, its somewhat weh but i came back late so

Not me is good tho
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
While not comforting, as a psychiatrist I do appreciate this self-awareness.


Why Cyndia and Santy?
I explained in the following posts but cyndia didn't feel genuine and contributed mostly off-topic convos and I thought Santy was being intentionally confusing but have decided to re-evaluate his deception after he clarified (since I misinterpreted his posts).