Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

[Crayola227]

---

Members don't see this ad.

What is sketch?

Sad!


Hanging back cause i haven’t given more than 2 people I’m watching? I feel like it’s dumb when people list half the list...like yeah duh.. most people besides yourself are gonna be on your radar it’s how the game works... I’m not waiting on anyone, my vote has cast and i will watch for someone to get on my radar but I’m not unlynching left and right that confuses the **** out of me lmao

I’d be worse than LIS and his “Unlynch whoever and Lynch...”

Actually D1 even having just half the village on your sketch list, and the other half on your "IDEK" list is worth something. Might even be worth mentioning imo.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Because she like actually gave more than a single sentence answer... that's my problem with how you've been playing thus far. Plus when KB asked who else you would pressure you picked some of the easiest targets and then didn't bother to elaborate why... of course we would probably all like to hear from them more because they've been quite. I just feel like we are not getting quality posts out of you to benefit village like we've been getting from others even if they are wolf they're contributing quality posts.

Why are they the easiest? Who should I be looking at instead? I don't write novels in my posts.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

What the heck is this nonsense?

I'm saying like her play is not contributing to help village much imo. Yes I know wolves are out to win. With that though if they are at least contributing to thread after we flip a wolf at least go back and I can find some truth in some of their posts to help me differentiate some village off my sketch list. So a contributing wolf for me is more helpful than what AM was putting out during lynch.

 

[LetItSnow]

Why are they the easiest? Who should I be looking at instead? I don't write novels in my posts.

Hey Cray, I think this was a shot at you.

I know you don’t do subtlety..... 🙂

*ducks n runs*

 

[jaboo]

Super Double Extra Purgatory

Sooooo still definitely not dead. Got it.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Why are they the easiest? Who should I be looking at instead? I don't write novels in my posts.

They're easiest because they've been pretty quiet also could've given a bit of a reason why you picked them. Not saying you have to write novels just a bit more than one sentence with some solid stuff would be nice.

 

[youngkal]

A convertible player? Just trying to make sure i understoood that right. Another ideas?

 

[genny]

I'm saying like her play is not contributing to help village much imo. Yes I know wolves are out to win. With that though if they are at least contributing to thread after we flip a wolf at least go back and I can find some truth in some of their posts to help me differentiate some village off my sketch list. So a contributing wolf for me is more helpful than what AM was putting out during lynch.

Are you kidding me? You think you'll get anything truthful out of a wolf post? Good luck with that.

 

[genny]

A convertible player? Just trying to make sure i understoood that right. Another ideas?

I read it as his monster = werewolf. Mel was vanillager, nothing in there about conversion.

 

[Animal Midwife]

They're easiest because they've been pretty quiet also could've given a bit of a reason why you picked them. Not saying you have to write novels just a bit more than one sentence with some solid stuff would be nice.

It's Day 1.

 

[youngkal]

I read it as his monster = werewolf. Mel was vanillager, nothing in there about conversion.

Lol wow i feel dumb! Thanks

 

[WildZoo]

Sooooo still definitely not dead. Got it.

To clarify: In terms of the game, dead. However on the show it was never really explained what happens to monsters when they die in purgatory. They're already dead. So...super extra double purgatory it is 😛

 

[Crayola227]

Being a noob sucks, i liked the noob game we were all basically noobs it made me happy and less hated

It took me a while to realize, not only does the hate never die, it's actually the fuel the game runs on.

 

[Mad Jack]

Official TIE D1 Monsterish Tally of Votes and Content Posts

Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (4) - Kara, Cray, MJ, Coop
Coop (4) - AM, allie, LIS, Mel
Mixy (0) - genny
AM (3) - jboo, snowy, Mixy
Bryn (2) - kal, snowy, coop, Haxx
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (0) - Mel
jboo (1) - genny

15/17 votes
Roll Call: @Stella Mudd

@Coopah and @Melchizedek You are winning! It's a tie! So exciting!!

Content Posts (not including posts that are just a vote):

Animal Midwife: 7
johnnaboo: 4
Melchizedek: 6
bryndiana.jones: 12
youngkal: 12
Coopah: 12
Crayola227: 11
@Stella Mudd: 0
SnowshoeDog143: 3
@allieh8607: 1
@Mad Jack: 2
LetItSnow: 10
genny: 5
MixedAnimals77: 7
Karabiner13: 11
@CoffeeQuestionMark: 2
Haxx: 3

Deadline 10pm EST (~10 minutes)

I had three content posts, silly. Plus my vote.

 

[WildZoo]

I had three content posts, silly. Plus my vote.

I told you, vote post didn't count as content because it didn't make a tie 😛

 

[Mad Jack]

I told you, vote post didn't count as content because it didn't make a tie 😛

I posted three times after that though 😛 our mod is mathematically defective, I demand a recount!

 

[WildZoo]

I posted three times after that though 😛 our mod is mathematically defective, I demand a recount!

I think the issue here is a disagreement on what constitutes "content" 😉

 

[Crayola227]

So the last time Mel did this you called him wolf and were right, but this time he is doing the same thing and it isn’t wolfy?

Why would you interpret it differently this time if you were right last time?

The comment he made on Coopah felt wrong in that it didn't seem to me to be typical good Mel logic, which is how I caught him before. It was in what sense did I find it wolfy, not necessarily how much. So, there was a similar lapse in logic, however it wasn't like before in that it just wasn't quite as... convoluted as other lapses. It was enough that I didn't feel bad leaving my D1 vote where it was, despite being wrong.

 

[WildZoo]

nIGHt CLosED reSULts PENDING!!!!

 

[WildZoo]

N1

It was a quiet night. We mourned the death of the innocent Werewolf. My grief didn't completely hold my attention though - I noticed a few of you wandering in the dark. What were you up to, I wonder?

I suppose it doesn't matter. At least we all survived the night.

No one has died. It is now Day 2. Lynch deadline is 10pm EST.

1. @Animal Midwife
2. @johnnaboo
4. @bryndiana.jones
5. @youngkal
6. @Coopah
7. @Crayola227
8. @Stella Mudd
9. @SnowshoeDog143
10. @allieh8607
11. @Mad Jack
12. @LetItSnow
13. @genny
14. @MixedAnimals77
15. @Karabiner13
16. @CoffeeQuestionMark
17. @Haxx

Super Double Extra Purgatory
3. Melchizedek - Werewolf

 

[Crayola227]

Can you reexplain this? I'm not understanding.

Actually, even when wolfing with you she managed to be sketched out.

#truestory

Spoiler: actual SPN spoiler maybes

just like that time that Dean found out Sam had no soul, but still had to sleep in the same motel room and hunt with him

Omg, the more soulless Sam gifs I went through for LIS.....

 

[Haxx]

I missed something here - what of LIS' play are you vouching for?

All I'm vouching for is that he often posts a lot. That's all.

 

[Crayola227]

I have (for once) no good D1 reads. Maybe time for to finally retire.

But I do love all the play today, right or wrong.

ugh the irony when all the people that make you want to retire start whining about how much they don't want you to retire

 

[Crayola227]

But St. LIS...

lol WW Jesus to some...

 

[Crayola227]

Official FINAL D1 Monsterish Tally of Votes and Content Posts
CHECK YOUR VOTES

Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (5) - Kara, Cray, MJ, Coop, Stella
Coop (4) - AM, allie, LIS, Mel
Mixy (0) - genny
AM (3) - jboo, snowy, Mixy
Bryn (2) - kal, snowy, coop, Haxx, Stella
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (0) - Mel
jboo (1) - genny

17/17 votes

Content Posts (not including posts that are just a vote):
Those of you who are tagged here - This is your first warning.

Animal Midwife: 8
johnnaboo: 4
Melchizedek: 6
bryndiana.jones: 12
youngkal: 12
Coopah: 12
Crayola227: 12
@Stella Mudd: 2
SnowshoeDog143: 3
@allieh8607: 1
@Mad Jack: 2
LetItSnow: 10
genny: 5
MixedAnimals77: 8
Karabiner13: 11
@CoffeeQuestionMark: 2
Haxx: 3

Results soon...

Uh, what are the line cross outs? I thought those were votes that had been canceled out for mod punishment for people not meeting content quotas... but now that I'm looking closer. WTF is going on?

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Uh, what are the line cross outs? I thought those were votes that had been canceled out for mod punishment for people not meeting content quotas... but now that I'm looking closer. WTF is going on?

I believe they are for waffles. So you can track how someone voted.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Uh, what are the line cross outs? I thought those were votes that had been canceled out for mod punishment for people not meeting content quotas... but now that I'm looking closer. WTF is going on?

I thought it maybe was mod-flair? Whatever it is simultaneously makes tallying harder and tracking 50x easier.

 

[Crayola227]

Hey Cray, I think this was a shot at you.

I know you don’t do subtlety..... 🙂

*ducks n runs*

*put the LIS wolf detector tunnel tinfoil hat on*
*cracks knuckles and prepares to write novels*
*attaches all the gifs*

 

[Crayola227]

Sooooo still definitely not dead. Got it.

Lol no one ever really dies in SPN.

Although, with an "open" set up, what are the chances of there being a rez? God I hate rezzes. Did LIS teach me, "if you kill it, and it doesn't stay dead, kill it twice?"

 

[Crayola227]

A convertible player? Just trying to make sure i understoood that right. Another ideas?

I think this raises a good point. The rehab game was pretty straightforward in some ways, not in others. I don't know how "open" an open set up is, never played that way. I don't want us to get lulled into complacency on the mechanics. Which I think I was until I read this.

The most simple games are just gonna have the power roles we saw WZ put out, but I'm without doing internet research I'm not sure what other twists you can put in.

 

[WildZoo]

Uh, what are the line cross outs? I thought those were votes that had been canceled out for mod punishment for people not meeting content quotas... but now that I'm looking closer. WTF is going on?

For waffles. Because I felt like it.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lol no one ever really dies in SPN.

Although, with an "open" set up, what are the chances of there being a rez? God I hate rezzes. Did LIS teach me, "if you kill it, and it doesn't stay dead, kill it twice?"

That's a strange rule to apply to rezzes when they mostly been village as of late. There's a zero percent chance anyways. An open setup is WYSIWYG.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

So I have an early morning and won't be around much tomorrow (12 hours at the human hospital yay). I'll agree the coop, Brandi thing feels villagey but I need to go back if I get a chance and reevaluate that. Stella feels more village to me now swapping her vote as quickly as she did unless coop is wolf and she's a wolf. AM her last few comments are starting to sound more village-will evaluate todays actions based on how that goes. Jboo is still on my sketch kind of for her call out on Snowy since I felt Snowy's AM lynch wasn't 100% baseless because they're fond of AM usually. Would like to hear more from those who were particularly more quite yesterday than others. Current wolf list though there's almost guaranteed a wolf that was voting for Mel or Coop so will evaluate those players when I get a chance tomorrow after work.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Jboo is still on my sketch kind of for her call out on Snowy since I felt Snowy's AM lynch wasn't 100% baseless because they're fond of AM usually.

I thought you just said jboo was fine.

Would like to hear more from those who were particularly more quite yesterday than others.

Didn't you call me out for this?

 

[MixedAnimals77]

I thought you just said jboo was fine.



Didn't you call me out for this?

Jboo appeased me for the time being when deciding between you and her. It is now later. I called you out for picking easy people to pressure without justifying. Like if you would've named them and been like because I'd like to hear more from them then that would've been fine but you just said who you'd pressure and not why. So yes of course I'd like to hear from those not as involved yesterday=obvious blanket statement. Someone would've called them out later anyway. However I also have a decent base to start narrowing down who might be wolves and now the trick is to decipher the villagers out of that. Also gave my thoughts on some players and why they might be village or why they might be wolf.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Okay I'm working 7-3 tomorrow then driving across the state to the vet school for pre-interview night so I'll put out my developed thoughts now cause I prob won't put much more thought into it. I've included who stands out the most to me.

Bryndiana.jones

Not much of a team player on first day. Created a very loud distraction that inevitably just made everyone loco towards each other. Wolf or villager, personally dislike that she’s turning people against each other.

Coop
I suspect villager, somehow became an easy target for trying to defend another player.

Crayola
You’re kind of all over the place. Arguments do not seem to be concrete, just random paranoia? Maybe that's normal? But I don't like it.

MJ
Added fuel to lead to a mislynch for someone who seemed rather unassuming and without reason. Don't like it.

Allie
Jumped on Coopah for trying to analyze b. Jone and started a massive chain reaction. But, from what it looks like didn’t have a good reason. Crowd manipulation at its best.

I feel like my analysis points me to lynch Allie.

 

[Karabiner13]

Do you people actually like get notifications some other way than getting on? Cause i typically check every hour on a real device like to play and when I’m bored i open the app on my phone but not to actively play so if i see my name I’ll quick respond and then comeback. I mean i guess but i see everything at the same time and yeah my name gets my attention...isn’t that the point of using my name lol

I don't get notifications outside of actually coming on

Saw tally. Please don't kill my manator

Coop having been your manator isn't a great reason to not vote for her. It's a different game. I look forward to seeing your thoughts later today when you get on 🙂

 

[Karabiner13]

A convertible player? Just trying to make sure i understoood that right. Another ideas?

We don't need to figure out any mechanics as everything has been handed to us as to what the set-up is. All we need to do is focus on player and vote analysis to find the wolves

It's Day 1.

But I have to agree that you weren't your typical AM self even for D1. Don't forget I got to see your spectacular melt down in wolfchat and the corresponding play that you did on thread

 

[Karabiner13]

lynch AM

I'm going to start here. Has been feeling more like the wolf AM than village AM even for D1

Could also go kal and maybe allie

I need to re-read through yesterday but I'm running out of time this morning

I basically already gave my reason by quoting Coop's post involving Bryndy, but it's because Bryndy gave what I found to be a suitable D1 reason for lynching someone (albeit wrong in her stella wolf statement) and Coop pressed for further reasoning. Also called Mel out for "throwing shade early" and then Coop proceeds to do exactly that as well. Just hard to tell if this is village play coming out swinging or a wolf trying too hard to find reasons to lynch people. Nothing major but in the interest of voting often and early, Coop stood out most to me.

Are you saying Bryndy called Mel out for throwing shade? Coop is actually the first one to mention Mel throwing shade after I said Mel wasn't looking at the context of my post that Mel had called out

 

[jaboo]

Lynch AM

I’m sticking with this for now. AM hasn’t done much except call out other people. Which is fine, but calling people out this early and with higher frequency than I’m used to from her is setting off my feelers.

 

[Karabiner13]

@allieh8607 If not for Coops, who would you want to take a closer look at?

@allieh8607 can we get an answer to this?

I tend to point out all lurkers, vets or noobs. Someone harped on me early on that lurking only helps wolves. I've only seen proof of that ever since.

While looking at the lurkers can be good, not all wolves will be lurkers so, jboo, who besides the quiet ones are you looking at?

 

[Karabiner13]

Lynch AM

I’m sticking with this for now. AM hasn’t done much except call out other people. Which is fine, but calling people out this early and with higher frequency than I’m used to from her is setting off my feelers.

Calling people out is village AM's jam. The fact she wasn't pressuring people for more reads yesterday is actually what has put her on my radar and is the opposite of what you are saying.

You just put yourself on my radar manatee

Follow up to my last quote of you, if not AM (and the quiet ones) who would you be going for?

 

[Mad Jack]

I think the issue here is a disagreement on what constitutes "content" 😉

I guess I'll just have to give you discontent instead 😛

 

[Mad Jack]

Lol no one ever really dies in SPN.

Although, with an "open" set up, what are the chances of there being a rez? God I hate rezzes. Did LIS teach me, "if you kill it, and it doesn't stay dead, kill it twice?"

Generally the rule is if it doesn't die (death avoidance, not resurrection), kill it twice. Rezzes aren't as clear cut.

 

[Mad Jack]

So any blockage happen last night?

 

[Karabiner13]

So any blockage happen last night?

Go read the N0 posts. Then come back and stop role fishing 🙂 It’s pretty clear what probably happened

 

[Mad Jack]

Go read the N0 posts. Then come back and stop role fishing 🙂 It’s pretty clear what probably happened

Me? Read anything thoroughly?
*guffaws*

 

[Mad Jack]

Okay I read it. So uh, that blocker willing to talk anyway? 😉

 

[WildZoo]

Note: Night posts will not count toward daily content post tallies, but will be considered as evidence of participation if a player is in danger of modkill.

 

[WildZoo]

Day 2 Official Tally of Tallies

allie (1) - Coffee?
AM (2) - Karabou, jboo

3/16 votes
Deadline 10pm EST


Not voting:
Animal Midwife
bryndiana.jones
youngkal
Coopah
Crayola227
Stella Mudd
SnowshoeDog143
allieh8607
Mad Jack
LetItSnow
genny
MixedAnimals77
Haxx

Content Posts:
Animal Midwife - 2
johnnaboo - 1
bryndiana.jones
youngkal
Coopah
Crayola227 - 2
Stella Mudd
SnowshoeDog143
allieh8607
Mad Jack - 3
LetItSnow
genny
MixedAnimals77 - 2
Karabiner13 - 5
CoffeeQuestionMark - 1
Haxx - 1