Smash Bros WW Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Question for the players: What's the likelihood of the village having 2 protectors?

Sent from my SM-G900T using SDN mobile
It's possible. Allie sounded like a bodyguard, not a true protector.

Edit: forgetting
latest
 
Last edited:
If I'm wrong it'd be a mistake
I must go through various levels of self-debate now before saying anything more.
If you aren't protecting any one, why can't you just show use your proof so we can decide? i can't blindly follow you without more after the Colorado WW debacle
That doesn't mean i don't love you but I need moar...
 
that's weird. it's really creeping me out that more than one person is being affected by the same issues. d2: two post restrictions N2: two ticklers
I don't believe any of you now.

I have good reason to believe there are game mechanics behind the double message from last night.
 
I have good reason to believe there are game mechanics behind the double message from last night.
based on your knowledge of smash bros or something else? you don't have to say the something else if you don't want to but obvs would appreciate more info
ETA: cuz im dumb. help me out here. i'm definitely part of your "i don't see it" club
 
Unlynch AM
For now 😏

Mel, to clarify, the post that you quoted I am talking about my vote from D2. I voted Jboo D2, and today I was explaining why I found her sketchy (hence my vote for D2), I then go on to explain that I have since been PMing with her (D3), and think her ability sounded more village than wolf, and was willing to vote elsewhere. I hope that makes sense.
I get what you're saying but I also see why AM thought you were bussing PBC (still don't understand why she wouldn't lynch PBC at the end of the day).
What I'm curious about is what did Jboo say in PM's between the 2nd and 3rd of the posts I quoted, to convince you that the ability was village?
 
Yeah not ready to blindly follow coffee. @PippyPony I sent RL my explanation the immediately sent it to dolphin as well. At the current time everything has seemed chill. I have continued pms with them since rez. Dolphin has continued to sound village to me. We have tossed around ideas.

Now on the other hand RL has been less than helpful which is giving me real feels. (Kb&mods are trying to make her play majority even in pm so minor contributions from kb) I sent her a message after crays death asking how they felt about if the wolves had attacked her and that was why coop had died. Similar to my thoughts I posted on thread. She messaged me saying there was terminology she didn't understand like nk and cape reference. So I told her nk is night kill and cape was in reference to the write ups. It has been over a day and I have yet to get anything contributing out of that conversation even reminding her I was still waiting for an answer. Kb sent me quotes from their pm along the lines that rl is confused what I'm wanting. All I wanted are her independent thoughts on that situation and current happenings now that we are far beyond those events. I don't have a great feeling about this and is where I'm pursuing my lynch today unless more relevance comes about for now. Could still go back to pbc.

*Also is it not weird that Crayola227 has yet to answer WZ question that would answer so much as to if she was attacked which is why coop is dead despite being tagged so many times?* -eta ignore this

Anyway for now
###lynch RL/KB###
 
Last edited:
Yeah not ready to blindly follow coffee. @PippyPony I sent RL my explanation the immediately sent it to dolphin as well. At the current time everything has seemed chill. I have continued pms with them since rez. Dolphin has continued to sound village to me. We have tossed around ideas.

Now on the other hand RL has been less than helpful which is giving me real feels. (Kb&mods are trying to make her play majority even in pm so minor contributions from kb) I sent her a message after crays death asking how they felt about if the wolves had attacked her and that was why coop had died. Similar to my thoughts I posted on thread. She messaged me saying there was terminology she didn't understand like nk and cape reference. So I told her nk is night kill and cape was in reference to the write ups. It has been over a day and I have yet to get anything contributing out of that conversation even reminding her I was still waiting for an answer. Kb sent me quotes from their pm along the lines that rl is confused what I'm wanting. All I wanted are her independent thoughts on that situation and current happenings now that we are far beyond those events. I don't have a great feeling about this and is where I'm pursuing my lynch today unless more relevance comes about for now. Could still go back to pbc.

Also is it not weird that @Crayola227 has yet to answer WZ question that would answer so much as to if she was attacked which is why coop is dead despite being tagged so many times?

Anyway for now
###lynch RL/KB###
Re: Cray, didn't she post last night that she is not the reason coop is dead as far as she knows? I may be making it up, but I feel like she responded
 
******************
I was less than enthused when I opened my role PM :yeahright:
******************
Well hey at least you weren't a villager called Wolf that would seer as a wolf 😉

@DVMDream
 
that's weird. it's really creeping me out that more than one person is being affected by the same issues. d2: two post restrictions N2: two ticklers
I don't believe any of you now.
Maybe a boost ability somewhere?

Hey anybody else got items? I got a capsule thing d2, there was food inside. Didn't do ****.
 
contingency lynch BJ

OK, the fact that Stagg edited his post, it does sketch me out. And in general he's shady for reasons I could explain. If I take the leap of faith that he's villager, not a horrible bet given it's statistically most likely, then he is telling the truth about BJ.

That is way too cagey for someone to be in a PM. Yes, telling your PM partner everyone who you suspect and all your thoughts, can give wolves too much data. But you should always be able to reiterate who you will vote for and maybe a few other people you *should* have expressed doubts about on thread. This level of caginess in PM has never been a good sign in my experience.

I don't know why it seems like a lot of other people are going for BJ, but there's a high chance they're on to something, and without knowing more, if what Stagg says is true, I feel good voting here on that basis alone, unless there's some data I'm missing. I'd like BJ to defend.

I started a PM with him yesterday he had responded to me with some of his thoughts on who he thought was/is sketchy. I didn't respond for about an hour and I think he took it as me trying to evade his questions (@Stagg737 is that correct?). I responded to him and we have been going back and forth with our thoughts since then. The PM was originally started to see if he had been silenced since up until that point he had been MIA all day.
 
Do you think you'll vote for PBC again today?

I could vote there, or WZ. My hope is to go back and reread later this afternoon, and see if anyone else sticks out on another reread. I feel more strongly about sketch content on PBC's part, with some gut feeling, and I have just a little (content-wise) about WZ, and her sketch comes mostly from feeling like she is off. Looking back to last night, I can totally see how my vote could have looked like a bus vote, but I still think some of your lies were eyebrow-raisers for sure, so you are also on my list as well. Again, all depends on who accumulates the most sketch points, and if anyone else earns themselves more in the meantime.
 
Unlynch AM
For now 😏


I get what you're saying but I also see why AM thought you were bussing PBC (still don't understand why she wouldn't lynch PBC at the end of the day).
What I'm curious about is what did Jboo say in PM's between the 2nd and 3rd of the posts I quoted, to convince you that the ability was village?
Yeah I get the first part as well. She PMed me yesterday at 3pm PST (6pm EST), asking me to stop going after her, and revealing her ability. I asked her a couple of questions about her thoughts on some of the players, and was satisfied enough to hold off for another day, and look to lynch elsewhere. I did not clear her at all just because she messaged me, but her ability seemed more village than wolf, with being able to share information among villagers. She was still on my list because reaching out to me could have been a pocket attempt (I have done it in the past).
 
dude, one of these days, you are going to be a legit village affiliation seer, you're gonna get results back "xxx is a wolf" and none of us are going to believe you lol

now why are you on bryndi?
Because jboo flipping village screwed up what I had plotted in my head and now I'm like a lost puppy
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally Final
RL-KB (1) - DVMD
SAR () -
MA (6) - PBC, jboo, Cray, Coop, Pippy, Elfabeth
bryndy (1) - SAR
Coops () -
genny (1) - BBC/Ferny
BBC () -
Paws (1) - Skimble
Elfabeth (2) - MOOSE, Nyan
Cray () -
Mel () -
Coffee (4) - Stagg, genny, Glam, MA
PBC (2) - WZ, Paws, Mel
allieh (1) - Coffee
MJ () -
MOOSE (3) - AM, RL-KB, kc
DVMD (1) - dolph

24/27 missing allie, MJ, bryndi

DAY 2 LYNCH TALLY


Elfabeth (1) - Stagg
jboo (6) - Moose, PBC, Skimble, bryndy, Glamm, cray, dolph
Fern/BBC (1) - Elfa
PBC () -
WZ (1) - DVMD
bryndy (2) - nyan, MJ
RL-KB (1) -
Moose (2) - RL-KB, jboo
Coffee ()
AM (1) - SAR
Stagg (1) - BBC
Cray (8) - AM, MA, genny, Pippy, WZ, kc, Paws, Mel

24/26 missing allie, coffee

Day 3 Lynch Tally FINAL:

Stagg (1) - DVMD
WZ (2) - allieh, Pippy
Glamm (1) - WZ
Moose (2) - RL-KB, Jimble
DVMD ()
Bryndy (2) - AM, Stagg
jboo (7) - kcough, dolph, Moose, PBC, MJ, LoTF, Coffee?
SAR (1) - nyan
PBC (6) - Mel, SAR, bryndi, MA, genny, jboo
NY (1) - BBC

23/26 missing paws, cray, glamm
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally Final
RL-KB (1) - DVMD
SAR () -
MA (6) - PBC, jboo, Cray, Coop, Pippy, Elfabeth
bryndy (1) - SAR
Coops () -
genny (1) - BBC/Ferny
BBC () -
Paws (1) - Skimble
Elfabeth (2) - MOOSE, Nyan
Cray () -
Mel () -
Coffee (4) - Stagg, genny, Glam, MA
PBC (2) - WZ, Paws, Mel
allieh (1) - Coffee
MJ () -
MOOSE (3) - AM, RL-KB, kc
DVMD (1) - dolph

24/27 missing allie, MJ, bryndi

DAY 2 LYNCH TALLY


Elfabeth (1) - Stagg
jboo (6) - Moose, PBC, Skimble, bryndy, Glamm, cray, dolph
Fern/BBC (1) - Elfa
PBC () -
WZ (1) - DVMD
bryndy (2) - nyan, MJ
RL-KB (1) -
Moose (2) - RL-KB, jboo
Coffee ()
AM (1) - SAR
Stagg (1) - BBC
Cray (8) - AM, MA, genny, Pippy, WZ, kc, Paws, Mel

24/26 missing allie, coffee

Day 3 Lynch Tally FINAL:

Stagg (1) - DVMD
WZ (2) - allieh, Pippy
Glamm (1) - WZ
Moose (2) - RL-KB, Jimble
DVMD ()
Bryndy (2) - AM, Stagg
jboo (7) - kcough, dolph, Moose, PBC, MJ, LoTF, Coffee?
SAR (1) - nyan
PBC (6) - Mel, SAR, bryndi, MA, genny, jboo
NY (1) - BBC

23/26 missing paws, cray, glamm
@Animal Midwife A challenger appears
 
So, just finished seriously catching up on what happened after the D3 writeup and Glam said something that really stuck out to me
As for current reads - Pippy/Mixy/Cray getting passes obvs.

I kinda don't like this. I'm not convert hunting lol just don't like how Glam gives the people who have been rezzed "obvious passes".
 
stagg- why so fixated on dvmd'd d1 vote reasoning? slight sketch point for that, wolf lean. This is stagg's read list post-d1-lynch, with barely a mention of dvmd after 4 posts about the hydra issue prior (and no thoughts on coop either). Then 6 more about hydra.
Just catching up again so my general thoughts from today:

Cray has been giving me feels and some of her early comments confused me, but logic is telling me that she's within her meta/norm so going to wait for a better read.
I feel like AM has been pushing the 20 Q's hard for day one, but maybe that's normal as I've only played 1 game with her.
I'm not sure how I feel about Moose, but she's giving me some feels and she seems weird today.
Dubz seems more quiet than usual, but D1 so not going to read into that too much yet.
SAR seems like the same SAR as Colorado, so not much there.
I like that Dolphin is saying more this game, and I like the contributions she's made so far.
PBC's giving me feels and some of the arguments she's making are confusing me.
Haven't played/seen Coopah or DVMD play much, so idk where I'm at with them.
Not really sure how to read the hydra right now, but keeping an eye out.
Would like some actual thoughts from Elf and not just a bandwagon vote, especially if they are actually checking in.
Would like to hear more from everyone else.
@bryndiana.jones , you there?

Who is BBC?

My top choices right now are PBC and Cray because their logic seemed strange to me at some points, but for now

Contingency Lynch Elf because I'd like some actual game commentary. Likely won't be on until tomorrow afternoon since tomorrow will be our baptism by fire (me and another intern are running our floor, no seniors residents), but I'll try and get caught up well before lynch rolls around.

lynch stagg
for now while i go back and re-read d2 and 3, and iso as needed. (i really don't want to make a last minute vote again, cuz thats honestly more confusing)
 
End Night 3

"Wouldn't it be funny if no one died again?" Crazy Hand nudged Master Hand. They watched our group of fighters from far, far away. They apparently had nothing better to do and didn't feel like adding to the chaos down on stage, so they had wandered over to the stands. Two giant gloves are obviously the most objective critics.

tumblr_nc2f9ifOle1taopdso1_500.gif


Sadly, they were wrong. A limp, furry body was found this morning.
Dead is @allieh8607, Wolf, who could protect someone each night, but would die if there was an attempt on their life.
howling_wolf__brawl_picture__by_tigerwithwings.jpg

That crazy cape is at it again. Check your placement on the roster and adjust your PMs accordingly.​
The Roster:
1. @Animal Midwife
2. @Melchizedek
3. @WildZoo
18. @Mad Jack
6. @RedLauren/@Karabiner13 hydra
7. @MixedAnimals77
8. @dolphin106258
9. @kcoughli
10. @nyanko
11. @TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo
12. @Elfabeth
14. @SARdoghandler
15. @CoffeeQuestionMark
16. @genny
17. @Miranda Senft
19. @Skimble
21. @Stagg737
22. @bryndiana.jones
23. @Glammyre
25. @PippyPony
26. @DVMDream
4. @PrincessButterCup
5. @Crayola227
27. @StayingPositive2017
Dead:
24. Coopah - Sheik, Untrackable wolf
20. johnnaboo - Mewtwo, PMer
13. allieh8607 - Wolf, Bodyguard

It is now Day 4. Lynch close at 9 PM CST.
Oi. Nudge nudge.
 
contingency lynch BJ

OK, the fact that Stagg edited his post, it does sketch me out. And in general he's shady for reasons I could explain. If I take the leap of faith that he's villager, not a horrible bet given it's statistically most likely, then he is telling the truth about BJ.

That is way too cagey for someone to be in a PM. Yes, telling your PM partner everyone who you suspect and all your thoughts, can give wolves too much data. But you should always be able to reiterate who you will vote for and maybe a few other people you *should* have expressed doubts about on thread. This level of caginess in PM has never been a good sign in my experience.

I don't know why it seems like a lot of other people are going for BJ, but there's a high chance they're on to something, and without knowing more, if what Stagg says is true, I feel good voting here on that basis alone, unless there's some data I'm missing. I'd like BJ to defend.

My edit was just to add "to work" to the "if s*** hits the fan statement". Just clarifying that I wasn't talking about this thread (which has a fan already FOS).

Trying to stay relatively caught up in between patients, just wanted to address that edit really quick though.
 
Top