Smash Bros WW Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
MOOSE seems to be the woman of the hour today, so here are my thoughts on her posts thus far.
There were 106 when I isolated them. Holy.

Her D1 vote was interesting because she votes for someone she doesn't actually want to see lynched. If she thought Mixy was village, why not put her vote somewhere where it might save Mixy? Voting for Elf accomplished nothing but checking that "congrats you voted!" box.

Okay y'all, it's freaking Day 1 and I mentioned before the game even started that I would be busy until July 8th as I'm driving all day tomorrow and packing up today. But as Dubz said everyone has lives lol.

Lynch Elfabeth

because, although you're a noob, it's a great strategy as a noob to declare that because you're a noob you're going to bandwagon and, therefore, go under the radar. You deserve to live another day in my opinion and based on the current votes I don't believe you'll get lynched, but I don't believe mixy is giving off wolfy vibes because tbh (sorry mixy) she always gives off vibes and she's almost never a wolf. I don't want to not vote for anybody, but I want it on the record that I dislike first day votes (as I'm sure most people do). So, there!
tenor.gif

The following interaction between MOOSE and AM begins with MOOSE's reads, where she mentions SAR seems suspicious (which is vague) but she's voting for Elf.

You seem like your normal questioning self
Mel seems like his normal self as well
Dubz is a bit quiet but I'm not too concerned
PBC seems a bit defensive but to be voted on the first day makes you so so I'm eh
I'm always suspicious of Cray just based on her meta so I'm keeping my eye on her
RL-KB is a dangerous hybrid since RL is a noob and can claim as such and KB is such an experienced player and, having wolfed with her recently, she's excellent at directing people
I don't agree with the Mixy vote as she sounds normal
I think allie is a bit defensive, but again, she got lynched last time for being quiet so I'm willing to give her a day
SAR seems suspicious
Jboo is kinda setting off my radar but I just wolfed with her last game and she was less active that game
Paws seems normal as well
I haven't played with a lot of the people here so this is what I've got so far.
Why aren't you voting for her?
Because the feels are not that strong. It's Day 1.
Are the feels stronger for Elfabeth?
A bit. I don't like the acknowledgement of being a noob without any prodding for it. Like, when you make a mistake or say something with improper etiquette in your first game, you say, "sorry, i'm still a noob", but not as a justification (along with bandwagoning!!) for the vote.
She's backtracking on her initial feels for Elf now that's she's been called on it. Originally she said she was voting for Elf because she didn't think Elf would be lynched, and she needed to vote for someone. She literally said nothing about having feels for Elf (beyond saying it's a good strategy to play the noob card - which is funny, because most of the Elf votes stemmed from her doing just that). Once she identifies SAR as sketchy she has to justify her Elf vote, and suddenly her feels for Elf are stronger than for SAR.

And continuation of the "I'm getting feels" without articulating why.
Since Coop flipped wolf, her voting for Elfy either clears her or condemns her (I'm leaning towards clears just because she's a noob and an easy target).
Jboo is really the only one I'm getting strong feelings from as of now. I don't want to jump on anyone's back that I'm not getting feels from just yet. I want to hear more from Skimble, Allie, DVMD, Bryndy, and SAR.

So wishy-washy. SAR was suspicious but oh that was a misreading, but she's still suspicious, but I don't have enough info. What info are you waiting for to figure out your feels?
I realized that my SAR feels were based on me misreading the thread. But I am a bit suspicious that she "just missed" the vote and said they'd be back on with a long time left to vote. But, I don't have enough info.

Her response to Coffee? was strange, where she almost defends Red but then tried to negate it with her second bold comment
I'm not casting shade on you, my point was that RedBean is being drawn towards the quiet players.
To be fair, that's what noobs do (myself being one). And only 1 time has it been right (sporty in the bake it game). But with kara behind her, she should know a bit better.
Sent from my SM-G900T using SDN mobile


I don't like how often she's used D1 as an excuse (?) for the reads she posted.
Can I mention that I pointed out it was D1 multiple times when I was making my reads.

This is kind of adorable, actually:
I don't know if Jboo is a wolf. I have feels and on D2 that's all I can really go on.
@johnnaboo if you're village, and I'm village, then are you willing to switch your vote with me to someone else? You can pick who we switch to. I'm village and I don't want to role reveal.
Edit: with pippy voting for Cray, we can keep our votes where they are if you want.

Bold can kind of explain MOOSE, too. She's posting A LOT (over 100 messages so far) but most of it is conversational. Her reads and feels have all been pretty vague.
Just wanna point out your posting restriction is making me laugh hysterically 😛
Initially I thought Dubz was just her usual sassy self, but I've noticed she's not posting a lot of original thought, she's just posting a lot and it's mostly reactionary. Normally she posts a few jokes but then some content and then gets into some 20 questionesque play. I'm not seeing all of that here in a way that's familiar. To be fair, I've only played with her twice, which is why it's hard to make a decision, especially when a very seasoned player like DVMD was leading the charge yesterday but is not voting for her today. I've never played with DVMD so when we were reminded yesterday (I believe by WZ) that she's an excellent wolf, it made me pause. So, I'm taking a step back and I'm going to wait for more people to come onto the thread. And I remember what you said about voting early, but I'm not going to let you pressure me into making a vote when I'm not ready.
The second bold sentence above: what? The magical things about votes is that you can change them. You don't have to believe 100% that you're voting for a wolf. She has this noncommittal attitude when she shares feels and votes, and I'm not sure if it's more noob-MOOSE or wolf-MOOSE.
 
MOOSE seems to be the woman of the hour today, so here are my thoughts on her posts thus far.
There were 106 when I isolated them. Holy.

Her D1 vote was interesting because she votes for someone she doesn't actually want to see lynched. If she thought Mixy was village, why not put her vote somewhere where it might save Mixy? Voting for Elf accomplished nothing but checking that "congrats you voted!" box.



The following interaction between MOOSE and AM begins with MOOSE's reads, where she mentions SAR seems suspicious (which is vague) but she's voting for Elf.






She's backtracking on her initial feels for Elf now that's she's been called on it. Originally she said she was voting for Elf because she didn't think Elf would be lynched, and she needed to vote for someone. She literally said nothing about having feels for Elf (beyond saying it's a good strategy to play the noob card - which is funny, because most of the Elf votes stemmed from her doing just that). Once she identifies SAR as sketchy she has to justify her Elf vote, and suddenly her feels for Elf are stronger than for SAR.

And continuation of the "I'm getting feels" without articulating why.


So wishy-washy. SAR was suspicious but oh that was a misreading, but she's still suspicious, but I don't have enough info. What info are you waiting for to figure out your feels?


Her response to Coffee? was strange, where she almost defends Red but then tried to negate it with her second bold comment




I don't like how often she's used D1 as an excuse (?) for the reads she posted.


This is kind of adorable, actually:


Bold can kind of explain MOOSE, too. She's posting A LOT (over 100 messages so far) but most of it is conversational. Her reads and feels have all been pretty vague.

The second bold sentence above: what? The magical things about votes is that you can change them. You don't have to believe 100% that you're voting for a wolf. She has this noncommittal attitude when she shares feels and votes, and I'm not sure if it's more noob-MOOSE or wolf-MOOSE.
I originally voted for Elfy, and stated, that I didn't like the bandwagoning comment. It was a vote because that set of my sketchdar however, I was willing to acknowledge that noobs make mistakes and was not on board with the mixy vote or anyone else with more votes. I gave reads because I was trying to be honest, maybe a bit too much as it was D1 (sorry, had to say it again). I have a better read on SAR now and I'm leaning more village on her. Kara won't always be messaging her, sometimes Red will have to make statements on her own and it was a possibility that this was one of those times (I was simply acknowledging that). I'm not 100% on Jboo and I've ALWAYS gotten sketch feels from her in every game we've played so I'm starting to second guess myself on her a bit and was willing to give her a shot.
 
Could be persuaded to go there. Particular reason for the switch?
If genny doesn't like MOOSE as a lynch candidate, then I don't either :shrug:
as for why PBC, see earlier in the day. and add in the fact that she just did the same thing again with MOOSE and still not vote planted.
 
Lol. If anyone should be called out for tunneling moose, it should be us

So why call out jboo but not us?

I had more issues with how Jboo was posting, that in combination with with going after Moose for multiple reads on D1 is what got me on Jboo.
 
Have you ever seen it as a wolf ability? Bc I haven’t. Discussion and talking to others inherently helps the village.
Not in the limited handful of games I've played but could easily be a wolf role. Ex role seer is usually wolfy in nature but was given to a villager. So doesn't really make anything as far as that goes.
 
Re: my feels for PBC, her post about Paws kinda struck me because she posted it when no suspicion was being thrown her way and then that train of thought just kinda disappeared from hers and everyone else’s minds.
 
Lynch pbc

Willing to keep jboo arou d after reveal, I'm reading moose as more villagery, and I'm neutral to slight village on dubz. Based on going back and rereading a little bit, I don't like how pbc has been really wishy washy and hedging on votes. Mostly feels, but I'm playing a terrible game and some feels are better than none
 
Re: my feels for PBC, her post about Paws kinda struck me because she posted it when no suspicion was being thrown her way and then that train of thought just kinda disappeared from hers and everyone else’s minds.
I'm willing to switch to PBC because I am village and there is a possibility that you are village as well. Are you willing to switch?
 
Others seem to think jboo not a good idea so I'm willing to budge for now. Still not seeing the moose lynch personally. PBC is still bugging me. Can't articulate my reasons why exactly. Seems to pick one person and then be stuck on them. Hmm. Will think more on this for now.
###unlynch jboo###
 
It has definitely been a wolf ability though I think it’s more often village.

Unlynch boo

Lynch moose
This was a mistake. Sorry.
Re: my feels for PBC, her post about Paws kinda struck me because she posted it when no suspicion was being thrown her way and then that train of thought just kinda disappeared from hers and everyone else’s minds.

Why havent you mentioned pbc before??
Why arent you pushing the dubz lynch as genny invited you to do, when you've consistently mentioned being suspicious of her?
 
I'll go with it for now ###lynch pbc###
@johnnaboo I'm with skimble that it probably is more likely to be village than wolf part of reason I'm backing off for now. On other hand what about after WZ?
Also not sure I like moose asking jboo to switch with her. It gives me feels of when WM and I tied lynch vote with AMs help as a wolf...
 
I'll go with it for now ###lynch pbc###
@johnnaboo I'm with skimble that it probably is more likely to be village than wolf part of reason I'm backing off for now. On other hand what about after WZ?
Also not sure I like moose asking jboo to switch with her. It gives me feels of when WM and I tied lynch vote with AMs help as a wolf...
I know I'm village and I'm starting to second guess myself (maybe I'm tunnel Jboo?). Remember Bake it and they Wwill come? I read Jboo as wolf almost instantly and was wrong. I think I'm wrong so I'm willing to work with her to save both of us.
 
I know I'm village and I'm starting to second guess myself (maybe I'm tunnel Jboo?). Remember Bake it and they Wwill come? I read Jboo as wolf almost instantly and was wrong. I think I'm wrong so I'm willing to work with her to save both of us.
This gives me more feels. I like the pbc lynch better though so you're safe for now but my eyes be on you
 
oooooooooh my goooooooooood I feel like a broken record

Dubz bc gameplay is drastically different than I’m used to

I don't see where you've really made a case for this though. You've mentioned her a few times, sure.

I’m just adding to my laundry list of weird things Dubz has been up to this game. Could easily switch my vote there.

Your laundry list:

1.) Dubz is being mean to me.
2.) Fluff (which she pointed out as well)
3.) Sass (which you agree is normal to some extent)

See following quotes for citations:
Dubz has been far more sassy than usual so my votes going there for now

Lynch Dubz

Also could got for MOOSE, as those early reads were kinda overkill for D1.
Let me clarify--you are sassier earlier that usual. Usually sassydubz doesn't appear until mid-game.
I am apparently a master of interesting timing

The only reason I cast shade at jboo first was because I quoted her posts first. Honestly by the time it got around to where I decided I wanted to change my vote, so much had happened I didn't even remember that I had found anything sketch in jboo's posts previously. Blame the lack of sleep I guess. But I did remember feeling weird about some things cray had said, and I felt better about the other people on her lynch than I did about the people on jboo's.

Fluffy posts don't bother me, by the way. I look at the posts that have content. If they don't exist, and it's someone who is like "Ah I'm too busy to actually play!" but is posting fluff all the time, then sure. But otherwise...who am I to call someone out for being fluffy? Pretty sure half my posts are fluff.
Bolded the part that stuck out to me. I agree with that self-assessment, but you’ve been posting way less fluff than normal imo
Another thing to add to the Dubz list of “odd things” is that she was quick to throw shade onto me. Typically she’s a little nicer to me because I’m her grandmanatee.


Jboo was pretty intent on calling out MOOSE's D1 reads. The following convo, we have MOOSE insisting her reads can be vague because it's D1. We have Jboo insisting it's too many read to have D1, even though they're vague and unsubstantiated in her post. We have Bryn thinking the whole thing is weird, and Jboo insisting it's sketchy.

I didn't have a problem with the number of people MOOSE commented on, I had a problem with the wishy-washy disclaimers she seems to tack on to everything.

Jboo, why are you on Moose for posting so many reads? Would you rather have her keep them to herself? Do you have any other reason for voting WZ?
Because it was freakin D1
Can I mention that I pointed out it was D1 multiple times when I was making my reads.
I don't see how that means she can't have a handful of reads. I have a hard time on D1 as well, but that doesn't mean everyone else does.
It was a large handful. Also her play is pretty defensive like last game when I wolfed with her.
Doesn’t make it any less sketchy to me, sorry.

This interaction:
From general rapid reading of day 1

Lynch Moose

Before anybody gets too excited, know I read through most of the day as a lone spectator and was not paying too much attention. I am aware this will bite me in the ass.

Can I ask why you chose me so I can defend myself?

Sent from my SM-G900T using SDN mobile
And this post is not helping my feels for MOOSE. More popping in only when trying to defend herself
MOOSE has over 100 posts in this game so far. Jboo's claim that she only pops in to defend herself is laughably unfounded.
 
Last edited:
I don't see where you've really made a case for this though. You've mentioned her a few times, sure.



You're laundry list:

1.) Dubz is being mean to me.
2.) Fluff (which she pointed out as well)
3.) Sass (which you agree is normal to some extent)

See following quotes for citations:







Jboo was pretty intent on calling out MOOSE's D1 reads. The following convo, we have MOOSE insisting her reads can be vague because it's D1. We have Jboo insisting it's too many read to have D1, even though they're vague and unsubstantiated in her post. We have Bryn thinking the whole thing is weird, and Jboo insisting it's sketchy.

I didn't have a problem with the number of people MOOSE commented on, I had a problem with the wishy-washy disclaimers she seems to tack on to everything.








This interaction:




MOOSE has over 100 posts in this game so far. Jboo's claim that she only pops in to defend herself is laughably unfounded.
What's your point here, Peebs
 
On the other hand, perhaps DVMD saw how slowly I was catching up and thought to take advantage by accusing someone she thought wouldn't be around. I am debating moving my lynch this way because of that.

Nein, ich habe versucht, das zu sagen, basierend darauf, wie du über den Schalldämpfer gesprochen hast. Ich hatte das Gefühl, dass du der Schalldämpfer sein könntest.

Ich stimme zu, dass der Schalldämpfer Wolf oder Dorfbewohner sein kann und dass Schalldämpfer allein nichts mit der Zugehörigkeit zu tun hat.
 
Nein, ich habe versucht, das zu sagen, basierend darauf, wie du über den Schalldämpfer gesprochen hast. Ich hatte das Gefühl, dass du der Schalldämpfer sein könntest.

Ich stimme zu, dass der Schalldämpfer Wolf oder Dorfbewohner sein kann und dass Schalldämpfer allein nichts mit der Zugehörigkeit zu tun hat.
I liked the French better.
 
Top