StardeWW 2: Ginger Island - GAME THREAD

[lucy.]

---

Members do not see this ad.

@JaggedJimmyJay since i won't be cleared mechanically as i'm vt and i was a d1 cw isn't it optimal that i get chopped eventually here because more accurate wagon analysis when 2 wolves were chopped will clear villas and narrow down poe significantly?

 

[samac]

Yes it is. I wouldn’t make that assumption. I’ve made games where only some actions are loud

Especially if there was going to be a quiet one makes sense it would be a hider

 

[potentialsheltervet]

@JaggedJimmyJay since i won't be cleared mechanically as i'm vt and i was a d1 cw isn't it optimal that i get chopped eventually here because more accurate wagon analysis when 2 wolves were chopped will clear villas and narrow down poe significantly?

You... Want to get misyoten?

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

The whole concept of “loud actions” is fascinating to me, because I have played almost exclusively in games with nothing loud

 

[genny]

I would assume all actions are loud but that's a big assumption for a game where the mechanics are behind a curtain so... Eh. If you cannot confirm that is concerning.

imagine giving wolves an ability reveal when the hider accidentally targets a wolf. still think that should be loud?

 

[samac]

Also who in the sign up threads said designated day 1 samac killer? Santy *nod nod*

 

[potentialsheltervet]

imagine giving wolves an ability reveal when the hider accidentally targets a wolf. still think that should be loud?

I said nothing about should be. All I mean is JJJ cannot verify Santy's PR claim.

 

[lucy.]

You... Want to get misyoten?

no but it might be correct so i'm just gonna resign myself/not ate if i am wagoned

and i do believe pretty strongly that santy is villa

 

[samac]

imagine giving wolves an ability reveal when the hider accidentally targets a wolf. still think that should be loud?

eh “Someone hid behind you“ isn’t much different from “someone doctored you” or “someone protected your if they targeted a wolf

 

[Zenge142]

The whole concept of “loud actions” is fascinating to me, because I have played almost exclusively in games with nothing loud

We’ve got creaky floors over here.

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay since i won't be cleared mechanically as i'm vt and i was a d1 cw isn't it optimal that i get chopped eventually here because more accurate wagon analysis when 2 wolves were chopped will clear villas and narrow down poe significantly?

I’m not sure I understand the question, but I don’t care for “wagon analysis” in general and will rarely promote eliminations on that basis. Do you think your demise would clear people?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

i do believe pretty strongly that santy is villa

Weren't you yeeting him for a while?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Also @lucy. Idk where you are in ketchup but you should probably get off alley.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Catch... Up.

 

[genny]

eh “Someone hid behind you“ isn’t much different from “someone doctored you” or “someone protected your if they targeted a wolf

yeah but i feel like protector is more of an expected role.

 

[WildZoo]

I thought a hider dies if they hide behind a wolf anyway

 

[genny]

Also @lucy. Idk where you are in ketchup but you should probably get off alley.

lucy in the skkyyyyyyy with ketchup

 

[WildZoo]

Or is that technically a weak modifier and it's just the one that gets used commonly...

I've read too many role wikis, everything gets all jumbled

 

[potentialsheltervet]

shorty "hmm"ing any mechanics post

 

[samac]

Or is that technically a weak modifier and it's just the one that gets used commonly...

I've read too many role wikis, everything gets all jumbled

i was looking earlier. Apparently that’s weak but not always used

 

[potentialsheltervet]

"You plebs will never understand the depths of my plans."

 

[Barkley13]

Or is that technically a weak modifier and it's just the one that gets used commonly...

I've read too many role wikis, everything gets all jumbled

I just looked back because I remember being a hider and dying if I hid behind a wolf but it was one of your games lol

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Might have to incorporate some loudness in the crossover game @WildZoo. The locals will be baffled.

Oh yeah you're all invited and wanted, pls play, mmkay

 

[genny]

Or is that technically a weak modifier and it's just the one that gets used commonly...

I've read too many role wikis, everything gets all jumbled

whatever game i was recently a hider in.. i asked about that, and apparently wouldn't die if hiding behind a wolf.

 

[WildZoo]

I just looked back because I remember being a hider and dying if I hid behind a wolf but it was one of your games lol

I didn't make that one up lol
from mafia scum wiki

A Weak Hider is the original form of the Hider. This modified role is the most common version of this role (to the extent that many people will just say "Hider" to mean the role that has been standardised as "Weak Hider". A Weak role will die upon targeting a scum player, in addition to the other aspects of their role.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Might have to incorporate some loudness in the crossover game @WildZoo. The locals will be baffled.

Oh yeah you're all invited and wanted, pls play, mmkay

2spoopy4me

 

[lucy.]

I’m not sure I understand the question, but I don’t care for “wagon analysis” in general and will rarely promote eliminations on that basis. Do you think your demise would clear people?

seeing as how two wolves are left me dying would probably clear people, i just dunno if they're already consensus villa

 

[WildZoo]

whatever game i was recently a hider in.. i asked about that, and apparently wouldn't die if hiding behind a wolf.

Mods do what they want, as per usual lol

 

[Lawpy]

shorty "hmm"ing any mechanics post

What pls

 

[WildZoo]

Might have to incorporate some loudness in the crossover game @WildZoo. The locals will be baffled.

Oh yeah you're all invited and wanted, pls play, mmkay

Semi-loud is my favorite tbh

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

seeing as how two wolves are left me dying would probably clear people, i just dunno if they're already consensus villa

Is there anyone in particular you have in mind?

 

[Lawpy]

Might have to incorporate some loudness in the crossover game @WildZoo. The locals will be baffled.

Oh yeah you're all invited and wanted, pls play, mmkay

Sub pls ty

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Semi-loud is my favorite tbh

That probably means only having some things be loud and other things not, but I choose to interpret it as everything being whispered.

"you were tracked"

 

[alleycat03]

I just looked back because I remember being a hider and dying if I hid behind a wolf but it was one of your games lol

I think this was the last time I played with a hider because that was my thought process too after Santy's reveal

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

2spoopy4me

but you're one of my most favorites

 

[potentialsheltervet]

but you're one of my most favorites

 

[supershorty]

me feeling like a con artist because I got all these fun champs friends to come play on SDN, meanwhile not playing, myself, since finale

 

[Lawpy]

me feeling like a con artist because I got all these fun champs friends to come play on SDN, meanwhile not playing, myself, since finale

Play pls 🥺

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

me feeling like a con artist because I got all these fun champs friends to come play on SDN, meanwhile not playing, myself, since finale

why would anyone play Mafia when they can just watch Mafia and judge everyone from an ivory tower

 

[SARdoghandler]

me feeling like a con artist because I got all these fun champs friends to come play on SDN, meanwhile not playing, myself, since finale

This is the way

 

[supershorty]

why would anyone play Mafia when they can just watch Mafia and judge everyone from an ivory tower

Well, the funny thing is that I truthfully said that my playstyle is just really exhausting and burns me out, which it does, and then I proceeded to lie to myself and say that I don't threadcamp when I'm modding the way I do when I'm playing, and I think anyone who has ever played one of my games knows that I am completely and entirely full of **** on that point.

 

[Lawpy]

Hold pls

 

[Santygrass]

DONT DO THIS TO ME PANICK.

Im not a great read of sanity but his responses here do feel wayyyy different from when I pushed him in Hannibal to be fair

Different in a good or bad way ?

And also ofc they going to be different, in Hannibal I had the control, here I do not.

I am a pretty adaptable player pls

 

[Lawpy]

The affairs of mundane folk matter little to me... - Day 2 Tally

Santy (10) - samac, Dubz, Stagg, alley, Clem, PSV, Lawpy, JJJ, miranda, SAR
PSV (2) - Barky, genny
alley (1) - lucy.
Lawpy ()
Nate (1) - santy
lucy (1) - Zenge
Barky (1) - Nate

@Santygrass you are in the lead!

16/16 voting
Missing: none

Vote closes TODAY, 3/19, at 10 PM CDT (~2 hours).

Ok this is the most recent tally i found

 

[supershorty]

Ok this is the most recent tally i found

Yes, no one has voted since then.

 

[Santygrass]

Also who in the sign up threads said designated day 1 samac killer? Santy *nod nod*

And you didn't die, so I'm not a wolf gg easy thanks for proving my point Samac

 

[samac]

And you didn't die, so I'm not a wolf gg easy thanks for proving my point Samac

Hahahah

 

[Santygrass]

I thought a hider dies if they hide behind a wolf anyway

I also thought that! But apparently not me ehehe. Me sneaky

 

[supershorty]

I also thought that! But apparently not me ehehe. Me sneaky

Sneakygoose

 

[samac]

Sneakygoose

Samac self destructs