I liked True's timing of his cancel so he's my strongest village read atm. The rest is a blob.
In that scenario, I wouldn’t expect it to backfire because it wasn’t a fake claim
That's part of why I'm stuck.
well, my eel pool is basically just alley, barks, and AM at this point.
Day 1: That's Impossible Vote Tally
PSV (3) - AM, alley, Barks
Zenge ()
True ()
AM ()
alley (4) - PSV, True, Vissy, alissa
alissa (1) - genny
Barks (1) - Zenge
9/9
Winning: @alleycat03
Missing: No one!
Vote closes at 10pm EDT (~4 minutes)
What's got you excluding Vis?
she doesn't like to swim in scummy water.
I can’t rule it out unfortunately as the numbers are such that it doesn’t give an extra cycle
I have no idea what that means.
I mean in the context of this game. You obviously aren't wolfreading Vis but I want to what specifically she's done to make you feel that way.
no thank you. we can discuss whom i'm wolfreading, not interested in discussing vis or true.
I'm just curious because this could be the last chance we get and I'll take anything that will help me refine my POE. It's almost tight as-is. Being able to take out Vis would leave me with three options instead of four.
if i'm one of the four, how is anything i say going to remove vis from your POE but keep me in it?
Because whiteknighting is a thing. Regardless, if you're village you'd have to know one of your three is village, so it's in your best interests to try and work with that villager to form a bloc unless you want wolves to have control over the wagons.
I don’t get how I was “egging on” Alissa. I completely thought you were wolfy until you did the night cancel. Alissa brought up a lot of your posts that seemed pretty wolfy, but I was actually way more concerned with you twisting words and trying to change perceptions (like when you said you were “barely scum” in the last game). That seems incredibly wolfy to me and I voted as such. I don’t agree with the way you’ve painted me as wolfy for egging Alissa on. We both had valid critiques of how you seemed suspicious, and I wasn’t egging her on at all.
Yes, only IC is 100% not a wolf ability. But wolf protector seems like negative utility.
Seems very ballsy for her to come up with that ability on the fly and hope that nobody counter-claimed her. A wolf protector also seems like a very weak wolf ability tbh, though I know it’s possible.
It's really not. Sometimes it's even necessary to protect partners.
What wasn’t logical?
I'm confused why someone who's mechanically clear in your eyes is below two others including someone who's been on two misyeets.
All she did was compile quotes mentioning me and add in a few comments. That shouldn’t be clearing her as a wolf at all.
Why? You still haven’t given a solid argument since my comments to PSV on D1. I don’t get why you’re so confident that I’m scummy.
Why are you refusing to discuss them?
Because literally everything else he’s done this game has seemed wolfy except for the night cancel. I’m begrudgingly accepting that him canceling the night is a pro-village move and would be stupid for a wolf to do.
But what makes genny more villagey than him?
if you think i'm hat-eatingly village, you're just going to have to accept that i want them in my bloc.
Because she’s been actually acting village this entire game. I admit that’s a logical flaw because true is probably village and there’s mechanical evidence to suggest he’s village. I don’t want him to be village because I don’t want my read on him to be so completely wrong.
Again, all abilities but one are NAI. No exceptions. I don't know if a wolf has ever had the ability, but I've seen them cancel night intentionally through an item for cred. The key then was that the cancel was used with weird timing. I do wish True had used it N1, but this is the second best time he could have done it. I'm not village reading him off of the ability. I'm village reading him for the usage of said ability.
I wouldn’t say “egging on” personally but when I was catching up the other day I was getting strong vibes of you and alissa teaming up
Idk about your question but I also find it interesting you’re discussing wolf vs. village abilities so much
Wow, that looks nothing like alley. Curious.
good thing i didn't etch it in stone
idk you both look a little furry to me.....
That response doesn't make sense. I'm only compatible with alley so by voting me, you're saying the team is exactly me/alley.
Too bad you've never given a reason for wolfreading me, huh?
I'm just having a hard time picturing wolf!Vis, she's still very much an option I'm considering. It's the nature of the game that I'm going to have a harder time seeing people as scum when I agree with most of what they say, and when they're putting in a solid amount of effort towards increasing clarity.
To give full clarity, it was my intention to hold the ability until we caught our first wolf, and then use the momentum to close out the game with no more villager deaths. (Part of the reason I was flustered after the fake PSV reveal on N1 is because I had already gone to my role PM to use my night cancel and was writing up a post to hint that it was me when Dubz stepped in to let me know that I had missed the real update.)
That's why it's second best to me. If you didn't use it tonight, and Barks didn't successfully protect someone, we'd be in yolo. (Thus borderline disabling your ability altogether.)
barks has claimed protector, so that leaves you and alley. would you like to tell me why i should go alley/barks over you?
how does that affect your vote?
Ignoring everything, if there's more than one wolf on the board, village loses. If there's a villager voting another villager we lose. You splitting the vote is fostering those environments.
How is getting off Barks with less than five minutes to spare a quick backtrack?
genny this crypticness is unnecessary. I'm not asking for your social security number. I just want to know about one (1) read.
you haven't answered my question
