-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
Supernatural WW 2019 Edition Sign Ups & Game Thread
Started by WildZoo
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
What's it mean?From pippy in response to all:
Unofficial D2 Lynch Tally
Paws (1) - SAR
mpm (1) - AM
kras (1) - FTF
MsP (1) - Barks
4/21
lynch close in ~8 hours
Paws (1) - SAR
mpm (1) - AM
kras (1) - FTF
MsP (1) - Barks
4/21
lynch close in ~8 hours
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Because you are on the same wolf team this game?
ftfy because it's a Supernatural game
Me and MsP or me and miz? Because I’m voting for MsP now
Responses to nothing game related:
My grandpa is blind in one eye and half blind in the other and still drives
Sorry to tell you, but you are on a med/vet forum playing werewolf with the them Supernatural.. I think you qualify for nerd-status already.
That is how I felt yesterday
My grandpa is blind in one eye and half blind in the other and still drives
Sorry to tell you, but you are on a med/vet forum playing werewolf with the them Supernatural.. I think you qualify for nerd-status already.
That is how I felt yesterday
Page 8 and AM is sounding reg village. Sporty and genny are wolf-leaning. So is Barks maybe (but she always lands slightly wolfy to me). I would put petmoose village. FTF and pips are neutral. nav/mel/miz/msP leaning more village but they are sneaky so I sleep with one eye open around them. Everyone else isn't memorable rn.
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
How does pippy feel about coffee? How do you feel about coffee?
Do you think pippy is a wolf? Does her silence today change anything for you?
He actually had posted a fair amount (be it fluff but still). He's neutral to me.
AM bringing all the salt this game
The write up made me think that there might be more than one wolf pack?
Point 2 was about pippy’s thoughts on coffee. I’m not leaning either way yet
Haii, ur obnoxious 😛
Glad you're playing now haha
MOD' NOT FOLLOWING HER OWN RULES
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Gotcha, so does pippy have anything to say about being silenced besides that whoever did that is a wolf? Does she think wolf Coffee would do that? I think that getting silenced almost protects you from lynch which may have worked in your favor if Coffee was planning on pushing it. But I also struggle with seeing why Coffee would silence someone she wants to lynch...I obviously agree with you that with the silencing placement puts village at a disadvantage, making me lean the silencer wolf
How experienced in ww is FTF? I wouldn't expect a noob wolf to pull that last min vote with all the people who hadn't voted yesterday. But an experienced wolf could have.
Did she ever answer? I know in the introduction it sounded like people might end up with hidden votes.
I feel like cubs always sounds like a wolf. Maybe he has wolfed a lot in the games I've played with him or he just sounds like a wolf.
*edit* oh I forgot cubs died.
Sorry forgot to include I think wz and coop are leaning slightly to the mod side..
This makes me feel good about you. With sporty Nkd I don’t see a wolf bringing her up.
I know roles aren't indicative of affiliation but if I had to choose then deanmon, mark of cain dean, lucifer possessed sam, soulless sam and demon blood drinking sam would definitely make my list of wolves
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
I don't have to follow rules, no one can modkill me 😛
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Don't be silly, we're always wolves
Vegan sam would also make my list
Final list for right now:
Wolfy: pips, genny
Neutral: barks, paws, DrFlush, MJ, SAR
Village: am, mel, coffee, miz, capri, moosey
Who? (I don't know who they are or if they have posted yet): acan, FTF (whoops, I've been using this acronym for Dr.Flush - if my posts have been confusing), kras, mutts, SOV, kc
Okay so I don't have a lot of strong wolf feelz right now. I'll come back to this but for now
lynch genny
Wolfy: pips, genny
Neutral: barks, paws, DrFlush, MJ, SAR
Village: am, mel, coffee, miz, capri, moosey
Who? (I don't know who they are or if they have posted yet): acan, FTF (whoops, I've been using this acronym for Dr.Flush - if my posts have been confusing), kras, mutts, SOV, kc
Okay so I don't have a lot of strong wolf feelz right now. I'll come back to this but for now
lynch genny
Yesterday's lynch was disappointing to say the least. It seems like guys were just cool with...whatever.
Why didn't you vote and change things then?
The first day in this universe was a bit of a panic for a lot of people. Accusations were thrown around, @Dr. ForgotToFlush was almost speared in the head when things got violent. Voices were raised for most of the day. Ultimately they decided that the one guy scratching at his ears and sniffing people's butts had to be the bad guy. Who does that?
Dead is @Navilly who wasDog Dean a villager who could track someone every night with his almost dog nose.
You monsters!
It is now Night 1. Deadline is 9AM EST tomorrow but preferably ASAP.
24 players remain
Dead
- @PippyPony
- @Barkley13
- @cubsrule4e
- @StayingPositive2017
- @Animal Midwife
- @acanthuroidei
- @Melchizedek
- @fromthebox
- @kraskadva
- @CoffeeQuestionMark
- @mizchiefmanaged
- @SportPonies
- @Dr. ForgotToFlush
- @muttmanager
- @Mad Jack
- @capri1722
- @SnowshoeDog143
- @Dinashadow
- @genny
- @Ms Procrastinator
- @StartingoverVet
- @SARdoghandler
- @mypetmoose
- @kcoughli
REMINDER @SnowshoeDog143 @StartingoverVet @Ms Procrastinator @fromthebox @SARdoghandler to get your votes in. There won't be a second warning
- @Navilly - Dog Dean - tracker
I don't think this would happen if she could vote secretly
I just want to point out to not dig too deeply into (abilities to affiliation)
Reference: Colorado game, jboo was a wolf post restricter but restricted herself
There have been other games where silencer/restricter was village
Also, does pippy being silenced impact your read of her at all? And why genny? Can you elaborate?
I will say I always get nervous when Pippy doesn’t try to go after me in the first few days. In my experience the less she goes after me the more likely she is a wolf 🤣
How many games have you played with wolf!Pippy?
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Good point about restricting yourself. Yeah, its one of those things where I wouldn't lynch someone based on that alone, but I like to consider it anyways because along with other factors it can give someone a lean. So why do you think Pippy would be so sure its a wolf then?
There were votes all over the place when I left the game and when I came back I saw nav and flushy tied up. I certainly wasn't gonna throw in a vote after that. You guys seemed fine with the lynch going either way.
Several. The same holds true for chaos Pip.
Who's 'you guys'? And you did realize how close all the votes were right?
Which ones were they? Chaos isn't important because it's just as much wolf as village is.
Chaos pip gives me the
You guys all of you.
Exactly my point. Pippy wouldn't know any more than we do. A village player might be more inclined to silence somebody who isn't going to say much (like MJ) so it doesn't impact discussion too much - but that doesn't guarantee that they wouldn't silence somebody else. So one can say it was being used in a wolfish manner, but that doesn't mean it's a wolf.
Every single player in the game, including FTF, Nav, and yourself was cool with either of the two tied being lynched?
Dude I don’t remember lol. One of them was Nav’s long game. I do count chaos since it isn’t strictly village. Neutral I’m kinda meh about but chaos tends to act differently towards village in a similar way that wolves do, at least to me.
smh then you haven't played enough
But like, I need you to remember if this is a real meta argument and not a misconception.
There were so many ties throughout the game I feel like people didn't really argue much for each player. It was day 1 though so there wasn't much to say.
I don't know. I'm used to lynches, especially D1s, being sort of a waffle fest. It felt too quiet towards the end
. Don't know how to describe it.I’ve played plenty. My thoughts on that just happen to differ from yours.
I’ve had that thought the last several games I’ve played. Let me see if I can dig back. It might take a while.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
N1 write up has been updated from the more creative Mod God
Okay, then why didn't you say anything? Or attempt to start a waffle?I don't know. I'm used to lynches, especially D1s, being sort of a waffle fest. It felt too quiet towards the end
First off, my bad. I had a really long commute home yesterday and my kid has been fussy and not sleeping well and basically I just forgot I was playing a WW game. But also, did we really need 13 pages for me to catch up on in one missed day?? Seems excessive... been trying to catch up since this morning. I added a bunch of quotes as I was reading through so lets just see if I remember why I added each of them.
3. I didn't notice that.
But I am a little surprised her and SOV haven't participated much yet (pot, kettle).
Otherwise AM sounds like herself, FTF was annoying and weird with his posts (which may be normal for him but IDK) - very AM focused posts, did he mention her in every post??, Pippy didn't point out how quiet and non-participatory I was which makes me feel forgotten but also curious from her, and I don't remember what other thoughts I may or may not have had during the day trying to catch up on this beast of a thread.
This post was weird to me, basically saying she has 100% wolf read on him? Or she just always thinks he's a wolf but sometimes she's right? Idk that whole back and forth went on far too long and wasn't very helpful. Sporty also tried to deflect off the topic which felt genuine and more helpful so I think it was v/v but the post still stands out to me as weirdness.
Your reasons for lynching me are weird AF. I get lynching an absent player. I get lynching someone who's around at lynch close and sitting on a joke vote. I don't get lynching someone for making a joke vote and then not being around to evaluate and make a change at lynch close.
Wasn't he leading with like, 2 votes vs 1 vote for most of the day? From my understanding of how yesterday went, there wasn't a lot of straight up accusations or real lynch leaders. This post felt off.
I think I quoted this for the underlined portion which I addressed above with the sporty quote.
1. It's already been addressed but Pippy is a liar liar pants on fire. I too can only PM one person (and I haven't even opened the PM yet because I kind of forgot I am playing - sorry future PM buddy, will check roster and open shortly).
3. I didn't notice that.
But I am a little surprised her and SOV haven't participated much yet (pot, kettle).
The last minute self pres FTF vote felt snarky to me rather than wolf or village indicative. Like "look mom, see what I can do?" I guess I'm trying to say it felt like an experienced player move rather than a noob move but NAI either way. Not sure why but I feel like Snowy is not sounding like Snowy this game - more snark than I remember (though I appreciated the last line there)
Otherwise AM sounds like herself, FTF was annoying and weird with his posts (which may be normal for him but IDK) - very AM focused posts, did he mention her in every post??, Pippy didn't point out how quiet and non-participatory I was which makes me feel forgotten but also curious from her, and I don't remember what other thoughts I may or may not have had during the day trying to catch up on this beast of a thread.
I mean, the perspective on chaos/neutral doesn't do much for me. I already know just from this year, that chaos has village-sided while neutral has wolf-sided in all games. Still more, neither are wolves and lynching them doesn't help anybody but wolves. I'm just curious about the wolf!Pippy since it actually affects this game.
oh em gee me too
Similar threads
